Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Scott Morrison didn’t say anything wrong?

158 replies

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 21:28

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-61171449.amp

I heard this being discussed on Shelagh Fogarty this afternoon. I don’t think he’s said anything wrong. What do you think?

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 08:32

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 08:29

Perhaps if you can't you are totally unsuited to being an elected representative in high office.

Most of us get through life perfectly comfortably without offending people simply by engaging in conversation. There are some who can't, and I don't think they should be anywhere near politics quite frankly.

I don’t think anyone can hence virtually every politician making some kind of ‘gaffe’ at some stage. Your standards are too exactly and unrealistic of anybody. How do you know you haven’t offended anyone? Do you check with every person you have an interaction with?

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 08:29

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 08:26

SM, as a PM, should really give more consideration to the language he uses and whether or not his responses are relevant and/or actually add anything to the discussion.

but you can’t be this precise and planned with spontaneous natural speech. It’s getting ridiculous.

Perhaps if you can't you are totally unsuited to being an elected representative in high office.

Most of us get through life perfectly comfortably without offending people simply by engaging in conversation. There are some who can't, and I don't think they should be anywhere near politics quite frankly.

Flickflak · 22/04/2022 08:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 08:26

SM, as a PM, should really give more consideration to the language he uses and whether or not his responses are relevant and/or actually add anything to the discussion.

but you can’t be this precise and planned with spontaneous natural speech. It’s getting ridiculous.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 08:20

@Innocenta

I'm not suggesting disability is a blessing, merely that SM, as a PM, should really give more consideration to the language he uses and whether or not his responses are relevant and/or actually add anything to the discussion. In this particular instance he's not only made his point in a particularly clumsy and tone-deaf way, but he was busy putting his foot in his mouth bringing up something that had no relevance to the question he was asked in any case.

In terms of how disability is described - I think that's a matter for the individual. I have no issue with people who do have a disability describing it in any way they see fit, but where I do take exception is when someone with no disability uses clumsy and ill-considered language in an attempt to make some ill-conceived point that does have implications for disabled people. I don't consider my own condition to be either a blessing or a curse, it has it's plus points and a whole load of negatives, but I totally reject the notion that I'm in any way less a desirable member of humanity than someone with no disability because of it. My disability simply 'is'. It's a part of who and what I am, and I wouldn't be rid of it given the option, because then a significant part of who and what I am would go with it and I'd cease to be 'me'. I can understand though why other people, with other conditions, might take a totally different view and wish with every fibre of their being to be rid of their disability, but again, I think it's totally unacceptable to suggest that those people are somehow 'less than' because of their condition. A senior elected official really ought to know better and be held to a higher standard.

"Wheelchair user" is an interesting one. It's had a lot of discussion where I am, and the reason I said 'going the same way' is because that discussion is very much about whether it is a stigmatising term or not, and whether people believe there is something more apt that could or should replace it. Personally, I don't like it, purely because of the semantics of the term, but I've discussed it with plenty of others who, like yourself, prefer it to older and outdated terms and have no particular issue with it. Generally speaking, I'm not keen on any term that centres a diagnosis or a piece of equipment rather than the individual or the person who uses it, but that's just my view and I totally accept others see things differently.

WhatNoRaisins · 22/04/2022 08:08

This neutral/differences language just seems fake and potentially gaslighting to me.

That said I do think lucky might have sounded better than blessed.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 08:03

@XDownwiththissortofthingX the term 'wheelchair user' is not preferred for that reason. Speaking as a wheelchair user 😉

It primarily replaces 'wheelchair bound' which is not favoured because it focuses on limitation and doesn't acknowledge that for most of us, the chair is a tool of greater enablement.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 08:01

@XDownwiththissortofthingX but disability isn't a blessing. I'm not saying an individual child is not a blessing to their parents and their family; of course they are, no matter what additional needs they have. They are a blessing as a person. But it feels like you're trying to say that disability should only be spoken of in a neutral way? And to acknowledge that the absence of disability is easier, more pleasant, literally entails (usually) less pain and expense and stress, etc ... that's just the reality. It is a blessing not to face all those things. That's what abled privilege is.

I see plenty of disabled people in this thread saying similar things.

Clymene · 22/04/2022 07:59

I think it's very clear what he meant. That he feels fortunate to have neurotypical children.

It's a shitty thing to say but I think every single person with NT children thinks the same way. Few of them are crass enough to say it to our faces though.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:58

WhatNoRaisins · 22/04/2022 07:43

Genuine question, does this sort of enforced positivity actually help those with disabilities and their carers? For example referring to Downs syndrome as a "chromosomal difference" doesn't make the symptoms associated with the condition any different.

Changing terms and language is an important part of destigmatisation campaigns. Whether you refer to Downs Syndrome or "chromosomal difference" makes no material difference to the actual condition as it is experienced, but 'chromosomal difference' doesn't carry anything like the number of associations with stigma, prejudice, ignorance, deliberately cruel language, or misguided and preconceived notions that 'Downs Syndrome' does, so changing terms can be an important part of dispensing with or minimising societal stigma, and can therefore lead to a small but significant improvement in the lives of people living with the condition or the relatives and carers thereof.

Society doesn't commonly describe people as 'Schizophrenics', 'lunatics', 'hysterics' and such any more because those terms are outdated, carry a stigma, and centre the condition rather than the individual. It's going the same way with 'wheelchair user' and such, where the emphasis is again on the wheelchair and not the person. It's slightly different with terms that describe a condition or diagnosis, but the likes of 'Downs' has long been used in a pejorative way, so I can totally understand why people might believe there's a need to move on from it. We don't diagnose people as 'morons', 'cretins', or 'idiots' any longer, but those terms also have their origin in the medical model, albeit an archaic and flawed one.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 07:55

@WhatNoRaisins In my opinion, forced positivity is just annoying and detracts from honesty about the real difficulties of living with disability / chronic illness (esp at the more severe end).

(But at the same time I think the onus was on him to be careful of his wording when the topic related to children, as there's clearly more potential for offence and hurt there.)

WhatNoRaisins · 22/04/2022 07:43

Genuine question, does this sort of enforced positivity actually help those with disabilities and their carers? For example referring to Downs syndrome as a "chromosomal difference" doesn't make the symptoms associated with the condition any different.

Maverick101 · 22/04/2022 07:37

His government have made huge efforts to cut the National Disability Insurance Scheme. He is not a friend of the vulnerable.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:36

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:28

explain to me how the assertion that only parents of NT or able bodied children are 'blessed' is not offensive, given that it demands by inference that parents of children who are ND or disabled are not also 'blessed'?

He didn’t say that. That’s your interpretation.

Here's exactly what he said -

"Jenny and I have been blessed, we've got two children that don't - that haven't had to go through that."

Clearly the sentiment is that he and his wife are 'blessed', thanks to the fact they have had two children that "don't -that haven't had to go through that"

So what possible interpretation could there be other than the parents of children who 'have had to go through that' not being similarly blessed?

It's pretty unequivocal. Even if that's not what SM intended to suggest, that's what his actual choice of language does suggest, hence why people are offended and angry.

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:28

explain to me how the assertion that only parents of NT or able bodied children are 'blessed' is not offensive, given that it demands by inference that parents of children who are ND or disabled are not also 'blessed'?

He didn’t say that. That’s your interpretation.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:24

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:16

🙄

Stunning comeback there.

So, again, explain to me how the assertion that only parents of NT or able bodied children are 'blessed' is not offensive, given that it demands by inference that parents of children who are ND or disabled are not also 'blessed'?

If he had paused and thought for a moment, he'd have surely seen how utterly tactless his choice of language was, and the fact that the able bodied status of his children is irrelevant and didn't even need mentioned anyway.

Intent is important. He may not have intended to offend people, and may have thought he was merely making a comment that would engender some sort of feeling of mutual understanding between parents, but he made a complete mess of it, and chose some ill-advised language to talk about something that added nothing to the exchange anyway. At best, all you can say about it is that he's inadvertently and not deliberately offended, but that's not exactly anything new for SM.

Getoff · 22/04/2022 07:21

To me, in effect he said he was lucky not to have to cope with disabilities in his children. He was acknowledging that other people have harder lives. Assuming disabilities are never a good thing, what he said is what everyone would say.

Onionpatch · 22/04/2022 07:19

What are his actions rather than his words. I dont know Australian politics. Is he improving care for disabled children or removing/underfunding it.

ScaldedBy · 22/04/2022 07:18

Agree. He didn't. Nobody wants for their kids to be born with a disability. And most people wish others a happy healthy baby... But people look into everything he says lately to find offence and most who are offended are those with children with a disability. There is nothing wrong with them having children with a disability but I'm sure that wasn't the goal when they grew up jisy a hand they're dealt and dealing with it amazingly... But... He didn't say anything wrong to the rest.

Maverick101 · 22/04/2022 07:17

Context is everything. While those of you in the UK can probably take this incident on its own it's impossible for anyone in Australia to ignore the context of him being one of the most tone deaf politicians in our history. The man is truly vile. He's a Pentecostalist who likes to lay his hands on unsuspecting members of the public and pray for them.

He runs from controversy and is remarkably loose with the truth.

This was two years ago and he hasn't covered himself in glory since

He's got a bit of history with Australians of the Year too 😉

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:16

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:15

But it wasn’t ‘outright offensive’ was it?

Yes, it was.

🙄

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:15

But it wasn’t ‘outright offensive’ was it?

Yes, it was.

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 07:14

GADDay · 22/04/2022 07:14

As an Australian. Context is key here. Scott Morrison has form for being completely tone deaf. I watched the debate - he totally deserves the arse kicking he received. He is honestly the worst PM I have ever encountered.

He was wrong, thoughtless and totally out of touch with his comments.

bear in mind we have Boris Johnson!

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 07:14

I’m not even sure they are, it seems to just be people taking offence on their behalf

Christ, it's like a game of ableist bingo.

So far we've had 'going out looking for offense', and now 'being offended on other people's behalf'.

It's evident from this thread alone, if nothing else, that plenty people have found it offensive, and given that a good number of those are of the specific demographic that his poor choice of language implied were somewhat inferior or undesirable, I'd suggest that's a pretty clear indication he's pissed specific individuals with a stake in this off, and it's not just people with an agenda kicking up a stink on the behalf of others, whether that's merited or not.

GADDay · 22/04/2022 07:14

As an Australian. Context is key here. Scott Morrison has form for being completely tone deaf. I watched the debate - he totally deserves the arse kicking he received. He is honestly the worst PM I have ever encountered.

He was wrong, thoughtless and totally out of touch with his comments.