Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Scott Morrison didn’t say anything wrong?

158 replies

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 21:28

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-61171449.amp

I heard this being discussed on Shelagh Fogarty this afternoon. I don’t think he’s said anything wrong. What do you think?

OP posts:
TalkingCat · 22/04/2022 10:18

I'm Australian. I am voting Labor BUT I genuinely don't see that Morrison, as much as I loathe him, said anything wrong. To say you've been "blessed with good health" or blessed with healthy children is now somehow wrong?? It used to be that when you were asked if you knew what you were having (boy or girl) it would be "we don't care either way as long as it's healthy". I suppose we can no longer say that any more, either?

And what of when you are describing a just born baby when you say it "has 10 fingers, 10 toes and is healthy". Can we no longer say that, either, it case it offends someone who has a child with 11 toes? Or only 9 fingers?

Even my Labor member mother who HATES Morrison with a passion I haven't seen her hate anyone with before, said she really didn't say anything wrong.

Though, admittedly, if it helps Albo get elected, I'm quite happy to run with it. I guess that makes me a hypocrite.

WildCoasts · 22/04/2022 10:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

GADDay · 22/04/2022 09:52

Our liberal/national coalition:

Has sat back whilst women have been raped and abused in parliament.
Stood against the legalisation of LGBTQ marriage.
Would sell their grandma's for a lump of coal - flood, fire, devastated reef, extinct koalas ARE our reality.
They endorse continued decimation of first nations culture, rights, representation. The Uluru Statement has been renewed upon.
Horrific treatment of refugees. Imagine being locked in a dingy facility for 9 years all because you were fleeing persecution.

So pretty much - if you are brown, poor, disabled, can't speak for yourself or you don't make a buck you are marginalised /fucked in Australia.

We are tired of this. So the comments in isolation probably seem innocuous. It's the sum of the parts.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 09:50

So do you use a wheelchair yourself? As you clearly think the commonly preferred term that most people who do use them want, is problematic. What term do you want to use instead?

Ok, I'll answer this as truthfully as I can, and I apologise in advance if any of it sounds like a cop-out, but I can only talk within the terms of reference that I encounter it.

Firstly, no, I am not a wheelchair user myself, which is why when I do encounter this phrase being discussed I will offer input if I'm asked, but I take a back seat because it's not something that is directly relevant to me as an individual. Why I am still required to participate in that discussion though, is that I have partial executive oversight of an organisation that provides a service to a specific demographic within the general public, and many of those individuals are wheelchair users, so it is important for us to have some agreed, preferred terminology that we use in our organisations publications, both external and internal.

I note that you use a generic 'we' when referring to a preference for the term 'wheelchair user'. What is interesting about this to me is that as an organisation we have used that term before now as that is commonly agreed to be the preferred language throughout our discipline, however, what actually prompted the discussion was our own service users questioning the term themselves. We have more than one 'regular' who believes it is possibly outdated, and since we continually review all of our publications, we felt that it was necessary to include that specific term in the group that we discussed.

As of yet, nothing has actually changed, but it probably will be included in the terms we put to consultation of our service users. What will happen in practice is that if a majority of our service users express a preference for that term above any other suggestion, then that's the term we will continue to use.

My personal thoughts on it won't come into consideration, and as for my suggestions about alternatives, I don't really have any viable ones that aren't a total mouthful, but again my personal dislike of the term is purely because the dominant word in the phrase is 'wheelchair' and the only reference to an actual human is in 'user'. We've gone through similar consultations with other terms, some of which are still in use despite being objected to by some people. "Service User" is one that isn't universally popular, and I completely understand the arguments against it, but when we consult the actual people that term refers to, they invariably come back with a majority favouring 'Service User' over any of the other proposals. When the time comes, if the same happens with 'wheelchair user' then it will stay, and as I said, my personal thoughts about it are irrelevant and I'll continue to use it myself in the appropriate setting.

DetMcNulty · 22/04/2022 09:46

@WildCoasts - his policies are pretty awful too.

And his comments to Grace after her very moving and inspirational speech were in such unbelievably bad taste, nothing he says could surprise me. How he made it to PM is beyond me, I wouldn't even employ him in a marketing role, he's even bad at that considering that is his background.

GADDay · 22/04/2022 09:43

GADDay · 22/04/2022 09:42

Dylan Alcott is the Australian of the Year. He is an amazing tennis player and advocate. As a wheelchair user he WAS offended by this weak, unliveable, dishonest man. Google Grace Tame - an autistic sexualising abuse survivor. She was Dylan's predecessor and has very strong opinions on our PM. His policies and personal politics are offensive, so it is unsurprising his comments are given short shrift.

Australians are pissed off. It's bubbling and boiling - these comments are the tip of the iceberg.

Sorry autocorrect is having a field day.

GADDay · 22/04/2022 09:42

Dylan Alcott is the Australian of the Year. He is an amazing tennis player and advocate. As a wheelchair user he WAS offended by this weak, unliveable, dishonest man. Google Grace Tame - an autistic sexualising abuse survivor. She was Dylan's predecessor and has very strong opinions on our PM. His policies and personal politics are offensive, so it is unsurprising his comments are given short shrift.

Australians are pissed off. It's bubbling and boiling - these comments are the tip of the iceberg.

WildCoasts · 22/04/2022 09:37

Harridan1981 · 22/04/2022 09:31

Well exactly! So why would he find it so hard to understand them?

I suspect he spoke badly. I understand the sentiment of being glad your child doesn't have extra challenges in life (it's challenging enough already). None of us want that for our children. The way he put it is such that I would prefer my disabled child not to hear it it in case they think they are a burden on me, which they're not.

I wouldn't be basing a vote on this one gaffe though. I'd look at overall policy.

Harridan1981 · 22/04/2022 09:31

Well exactly! So why would he find it so hard to understand them?

Harridan1981 · 22/04/2022 09:30

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 09:24

Oh please. It’s getting silly now.

Dude, you literally started this thread asking opinions. Yet those which are different are silly? If someone with a disabled child, tells you that his opinion on having a disabled child is offensive to them, who on earth are you to say that it isn't? And that they are being silly?

WildCoasts · 22/04/2022 09:25

Harridan1981 · 22/04/2022 09:21

"And so, for parents with children who are disabled, I can only try and understand your aspirations for those children."

This is the bit that makes me uncomfortable tbh. Possibly the use of the word aspirations. As if he can't understand having aspirations for 'those' children.

Same as every parent, isn't it? Aspirations for them to have a happy and fulfilling life, whatever that is for them.

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 09:24

Harridan1981 · 22/04/2022 09:21

"And so, for parents with children who are disabled, I can only try and understand your aspirations for those children."

This is the bit that makes me uncomfortable tbh. Possibly the use of the word aspirations. As if he can't understand having aspirations for 'those' children.

Oh please. It’s getting silly now.

OP posts:
Innocenta · 22/04/2022 09:24

@XDownwiththissortofthingX I think it's really unhelpful to frame this discussion in terms of ableism bingo. Many of the people disagreeing with you are disabled.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 09:23

@XDownwiththissortofthingX So do you use a wheelchair yourself? As you clearly think the commonly preferred term that most people who do use them want, is problematic. What term do you want to use instead?

Fwiw, I certainly have no problem whatsoever with other individuals feeling or describing their own disability or condition as neutral (as you did in your post) or even as positive, which sometimes, some people do. But I think there is a very real risk of that bleeding over into a 'this is how we should talk about disability' kind of attitude (because it seems more positive, and because, ironically, it's an easier narrative for able bodied people to reckon with!) which then leads to policing people who realistically are in medical situations that just. are not neutral. and cannot ever be.

Harridan1981 · 22/04/2022 09:21

"And so, for parents with children who are disabled, I can only try and understand your aspirations for those children."

This is the bit that makes me uncomfortable tbh. Possibly the use of the word aspirations. As if he can't understand having aspirations for 'those' children.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 09:20

He has said nothing to cause offence. Not to most rationally minded people anyway

Another tick on the bingo card, this time 'you're all mad'. Suppose I should just cross off 'gaslighting' while we're at it and claim four corners.

Here's a hint - the very fact so many people are offended by what he said is a pretty big give away that it was offensive. I've no idea how you are having such a hard time grasping this.

You'll have a difficult time finding anyone more 'rationally minded' than some of the disabled people with one specific condition (if you know, you know) that SM has offended, so not only is your comment completely crass and offensive, it's also demonstrable nonsense.

Clymene · 22/04/2022 09:15

I'm not sure why you've asked what people think in your OP. You're clearly not remotely interested in what anyone else thinks Confused

Samcro · 22/04/2022 09:13

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 09:09

He didn’t say he’s blessed because he doesn’t think disabled children are joys.

he said he’s blessed because his children haven’t had to go through the process for national disability insurance.

so why even mention it? why bring his non disabled children into it?

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 09:09

Samcro · 22/04/2022 09:07

this
so am i not "blessed" as my dd is severely disabled....she is a joy to be around. is kind and never nasty unlike many nt people.
horrid comment.

He didn’t say he’s blessed because he doesn’t think disabled children are joys.

he said he’s blessed because his children haven’t had to go through the process for national disability insurance.

OP posts:
Samcro · 22/04/2022 09:07

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/04/2022 21:53

Great, so myself, and all the other ND people around are both undesirable, and abnormal.

Beggars belief that it's 2022 and there are apparently sentient humans who still use this sort of language. Have a word with yourself.

this
so am i not "blessed" as my dd is severely disabled....she is a joy to be around. is kind and never nasty unlike many nt people.
horrid comment.

WildCoasts · 22/04/2022 08:59

As a parent of a child with a disability, it's offensive. I understand feeling blessed not to have to deal with the challenges of a disability. If I could take away my child's disability I would - not because I value them less, find them a burden, don't feel blessed to have them, but because their life would be easier without having to deal with the extra challenges, some quite large. I accept them as they are and we take a positive approach to the issues. I think it is offensive as something I don't want my child with disability to hear themselves. Fortunately, they almost certainly won't hear it. My child hearing that would hear that a child with a disability is a burden on their parents and it's luckier not to have them. That's not a message I want them to hear.

So I get that yes, it's easier and fortunate not to have a child with these challenges as none of us want our children to have it harder in life than they have to. I think the wording is poor and sends a potentially bad message to children with additional needs.

tigger2022 · 22/04/2022 08:56

He actually said he was blessed that his children "haven't had to go through that" which is a bit different to saying he's blessed he doesn't have disabled children IMO

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/04/2022 08:50

He was just acknowledging that ableism is something he hasn’t had to face as a parent of abled children imho. Not that he believes himself they are lesser. You’re stretching to reach that conclusion by simply one word of “blessed” in place of “that” which would have made it all ok to you.

But language is important and one word can very often make all the difference.

For example, If he was talking about racism and had said he was "blessed" to have white children I very much doubt anyone would interpret that as an acknowledgement that racism isn't something they've had to face as a family. You'd think "wow, what a racist pig, did he really just say that?"

Acknowledging parents of children who are ND/disabled (and the children themselves) face many barriers to participating in society can be done without making sound like you're somehow lesser for having to deal with them. The fact that so many on this thread don't get that shows just how far we still have to go to be an inclusive society.

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 08:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 08:35

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 08:32

I don’t think anyone can hence virtually every politician making some kind of ‘gaffe’ at some stage. Your standards are too exactly and unrealistic of anybody. How do you know you haven’t offended anyone? Do you check with every person you have an interaction with?

I tend to know because they usually tell me, kind of like the people telling SM he's an objectionable arse.

But again, I'm not an elected official or PM of an entire country, so I don't think I actually need to match up to the standards that should be expected of SM.