Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Scott Morrison didn’t say anything wrong?

158 replies

Organictangerine · 21/04/2022 21:28

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-61171449.amp

I heard this being discussed on Shelagh Fogarty this afternoon. I don’t think he’s said anything wrong. What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Minimalme · 22/04/2022 18:47

He's a twonk. The woman wanted to know what legislation his party would make to support disabled people. He should have stuck to the brief.

It was a doddle to answer without over-sharing and using a word which suggests he feels favoured by God.

I bet his press people don't favour him quite so highly now...

ISeeALittleSiIhouettoOfAMan · 22/04/2022 15:01

As to the blessing/disablist debate itself...it is also important to note there are many parents out there who hate the Welcome to Holland mantra. Certainly, when I was being headbutted and bitten on a daily basis, I felt more cursed than blessed. Again, anyone who has not been in my shoes cannot judge. They were dark days.

ISeeALittleSiIhouettoOfAMan · 22/04/2022 14:58

The phrasing was poor, the context important - he was counting his blessings that he has not had to go through the hoops in sorting funding for his own kids/having the same worries about their future that this parent has and will continue to jump through.

OctopusSay · 22/04/2022 14:49

I can see why people have reacted the way they have. People often say they're lucky/grateful that DC are healthy, but blessed implies something else.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 14:46

@Unblessed We certainly don't have to discuss it, but please bear in mind that you are not the only one hurt by ableism, and while obviously you are 100% entitled to your own view, seeking to police others' responses is sadly only likely to cause more hurt.

However, I'm happy to leave it at that.

Unblessed · 22/04/2022 14:30

@Innocenta

with respect, I’d rather not engage with you on this matter. I am not here to justify my own personal hurt to anyone.

LetitiaLeghorn · 22/04/2022 14:26

@Discovereads

I agree. That's exactly how I understood what he meant. He wasn't insulting anyone with children with disabilities. Intent is different ftom inference. But these days people look for offence anywhere and I guess the opposition are going to seize on anything.

Discovereads · 22/04/2022 14:16

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/04/2022 13:16

I think he'd have been better to use the term "lucky" but actually I don't really see that what he said was that bad. I have come across a heck of a lot worse from people who have foot in mouth.

You don't see it as that bad because the othering of people with a disability is so ingrained into society.

Ask yourself the following, which of these would you not have an issue with being said, or saying yourself:

I'm blessed/lucky not to have black children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have homosexual children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have female children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have children with disabilities.

I bet (or rather hope) you wouldn't dream of saying the first three but apparently there are no qualms with the fourth. Why?

A child with a disability doesn't make a choice about it, just like they don't chose their race, sexuality, or the sex they are born as (please for the love of the donkey don't jump on that as a signal to start the trans debate here)

But he did not say “I’m blessed to not have children with disabilities” you are misquoting him. The transcript reads
”Catherine - asked about funding for a disability support scheme.
"I've been told, to give my son the best future, I need to vote Labor. Can you please tell me what the future of the [National Disability Insurance Scheme] looks like under your government?"
The prime minister began by asking Catherine for her son's name. After she replied it was Ethan, Mr Morrison said: "Jenny and I have been blessed, we've got two children that don't - that haven't had to go through that."
"And so, for parents with children who are disabled, I can only try and understand your aspirations for those children."

He stated that they are “blessed because they have got two children that don’t, haven’t had to go through that”. THAT is referring back to the pain in navigating the national disability insurance scheme. I can see in the U.K. THAT referring back to say our DLA or PIP (16+) process to get disability benefits which everyone knows is a shitshow designed to deny the help that these parents are entitled to receive. Or perhaps even the process of fighting with school SENCOs for accommodation? Or any number of government run disability “help”.

when met with the outrage, he said he was only acknowledging his privilege and I believe him:

“i was just simply trying to say... I haven't walked in your shoes, Catherine. I'm not going to pretend to say that I understand it as well as you do."

RantyAunty · 22/04/2022 14:13

Worst leader.
He never answers a question. He just waffles on changing the topic.
I don't think he tries that hard to hide his contempt for certain groups.

WhatNoRaisins · 22/04/2022 14:07

I don't think with the luck or blessed it's so much the children in of themselves but the life you have as a family that makes you feel lucky. With race it's more a case of I'm lucky my children don't face racial discrimination than I'm lucky they're white for example. No one would want extra difficulty for their children.

Many individuals with disabilities and their families do have more difficult lives because of disability and not all of this is due to wider society, the symptoms and effects are very real. I'm not convinced we can pretend otherwise.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 14:02

@Unblessed What if someone finds forced positivity hurtful? That isn't just a thought experiment, there are plenty of people (including me) who do.

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 13:27

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/04/2022 13:16

I think he'd have been better to use the term "lucky" but actually I don't really see that what he said was that bad. I have come across a heck of a lot worse from people who have foot in mouth.

You don't see it as that bad because the othering of people with a disability is so ingrained into society.

Ask yourself the following, which of these would you not have an issue with being said, or saying yourself:

I'm blessed/lucky not to have black children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have homosexual children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have female children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have children with disabilities.

I bet (or rather hope) you wouldn't dream of saying the first three but apparently there are no qualms with the fourth. Why?

A child with a disability doesn't make a choice about it, just like they don't chose their race, sexuality, or the sex they are born as (please for the love of the donkey don't jump on that as a signal to start the trans debate here)

Because being black, gay or female isn’t physically painful, life limiting or restrictive in terms of basic day to day life

surely that’s obvious?

OP posts:
Unblessed · 22/04/2022 13:26

I was born with only 9 fingers. I was teased/bullied throughout school because of it. Maybe my parents didn’t feel blessed with me and had to wait until my physically perfect sibling was born a couple of years later?

But suspect my parents may disagree. I think they liked and loved me and - I hope - felt
blessed. I was capable in other ways.

So maybe be aware - whilst eye rolling and saying “you can’t say anything these days without offending someone” - that you can actually be causing hurt. I suspect many of you are fine with this, as your comments suggest - but please just be aware that there are real humans reading this - who have been made to feel imperfect all their lives. It’s not nice.

QuebecBagnet · 22/04/2022 13:22

I’m on the fence about this. Dd is disabled. I love her to bits and am glad for her every day. But do I wish she wasn’t disabled? Of course I do. Not really for me but more for her. I am worried sick about her future, I’m not sure she will hold down a job, move out of home, etc.

Her life would be so much better and easier for her if she wasn’t disabled. And her disabilities are minor compared to others. But I think she would consider herself to be more “lucky” if she wasn’t disabled.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/04/2022 13:16

I think he'd have been better to use the term "lucky" but actually I don't really see that what he said was that bad. I have come across a heck of a lot worse from people who have foot in mouth.

You don't see it as that bad because the othering of people with a disability is so ingrained into society.

Ask yourself the following, which of these would you not have an issue with being said, or saying yourself:

I'm blessed/lucky not to have black children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have homosexual children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have female children.

I'm blessed/lucky not to have children with disabilities.

I bet (or rather hope) you wouldn't dream of saying the first three but apparently there are no qualms with the fourth. Why?

A child with a disability doesn't make a choice about it, just like they don't chose their race, sexuality, or the sex they are born as (please for the love of the donkey don't jump on that as a signal to start the trans debate here)

MargaretThursday · 22/04/2022 12:58

@TalkingCat
And what of when you are describing a just born baby when you say it "has 10 fingers, 10 toes and is healthy". Can we no longer say that, either, it case it offends someone who has a child with 11 toes? Or only 9 fingers?

My dd (#2) was born without a hand, so I think I am allowed to comment on this. Yes, it is a phrase that is still extensively used, including on greetings cards for new babies and things like that. It's been said to me with all three of my children.
The only time it did upset me was when I was pregnant with #3 and someone I know very well asked if I was having a boy or girl (I didn't) and responded with "well as long as they have all their fingers and toes". They may have gone away and kicked themselves, but they showed no sign of realising that was inappropriate.
But in that case it felt personal. Because it was a specific case. I totally understand that people in general (as I and as dd would also agree) would prefer their child to be born with all their fingers and toes.

I think he'd have been better to use the term "lucky" but actually I don't really see that what he said was that bad. I have come across a heck of a lot worse from people who have foot in mouth.

Discovereads · 22/04/2022 11:54

Good points @Organictangerine
The obsession with terminology is ultra performative. No one can speak ad hoc perfectly all the time. They’re going to say things in a clumsy fashion now and then. It’s sad that the focus is all on how he said things, not on what are his campaign promises regarding meeting the needs of disabled children.

Organictangerine · 22/04/2022 11:11

Samcro · 22/04/2022 10:55

i have been a parent of a disabled child for more than 20 years. I think having lived it I am "silly" for being offended by crap like this.
people like my dd are othered enough.

All you are going to do is alienate well-meaning potential disability allies, not create a world in which very subtle nuance is free from even the most tenuous association with abelism. The in-fighting and obsession with terminology is taking up so much public conscience that the actual needs of disabled people, like me, are pushed to the back in favour of ‘getting the exact terminology right’. Which is impossible anyway as it’s subjective. I would be offended if somebody told me my disability ‘made me, me’ and ‘enriched my life’ in any way. Every day I wake up wishing I was healthy.

OP posts:
Samcro · 22/04/2022 10:55

Harridan1981 · 22/04/2022 09:30

Dude, you literally started this thread asking opinions. Yet those which are different are silly? If someone with a disabled child, tells you that his opinion on having a disabled child is offensive to them, who on earth are you to say that it isn't? And that they are being silly?

i have been a parent of a disabled child for more than 20 years. I think having lived it I am "silly" for being offended by crap like this.
people like my dd are othered enough.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 10:54

@XDownwiththissortofthingX sure! Please do

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 22/04/2022 10:34

@Innocenta

Do you mind if I PM you a response to your last post? I'm happy to continue discussing with you, but there are certain things I can't really get into on here because of confidentiality concerns and such.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 10:31

Sorry, that was for @XDownwiththissortofthingX :)

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 10:30

As a follow up (and I'm aware this is very much getting into specifics, and off topic), I know this probably isn't something you can disclose, but I am so curious as to what term the person who thinks 'wheelchair user' is inappropriate would prefer! Because at least here in the UK, 'wheelchair bound' is still very commonly used in many informal and colloquial contexts; my experience with many PWD here is that we do largely agree that getting away from that is a decent shared priority.

Side note: in my own informal writings about the topic in social media settings, I tend to say 'wheelchair user' initially as it's the most specific and preferred term, but I do very frequently then go on to use 'chair user'. Of course in itself, that phrase would be confusing (able bodied people use chairs too!), but in context of a paragraph about wheelchair users, it is clear what I mean. This diction reflects my actual language about my chair irl / verbally, and is less clinical and medical. I don't have any problem with alluding to myself as a user of my chair, because...I do use my chair! My chair is a tool for me.

I am actually not self pushing as I don't have enough strength (which would also incline others to see me as 'bound', perhaps), but I still feel that the role of the chair in my life is clearly one if enablement and expansivity. I would be 100% housebound without my chair, and leaving aside the latest period of Covid restrictions as a CEV individual, it is entirely down to using my chair that I've been able to: travel abroad, present at conferences, go to restaurants, go to the theatre/concerts, visit museums and other places of interest, meet friends anywhere other than at my own house, be at family weddings... The benefit to me is so huge and undeniable that it feels completely...askew from reality to take issue with the idea that I am using my chair, and therefore am a user of it.

(I'm not saying you aren't entitled to your own emotions, just trying to explain a bit more as your response was so thoughtful!)

WildCoasts · 22/04/2022 10:26

TalkingCat · 22/04/2022 10:18

I'm Australian. I am voting Labor BUT I genuinely don't see that Morrison, as much as I loathe him, said anything wrong. To say you've been "blessed with good health" or blessed with healthy children is now somehow wrong?? It used to be that when you were asked if you knew what you were having (boy or girl) it would be "we don't care either way as long as it's healthy". I suppose we can no longer say that any more, either?

And what of when you are describing a just born baby when you say it "has 10 fingers, 10 toes and is healthy". Can we no longer say that, either, it case it offends someone who has a child with 11 toes? Or only 9 fingers?

Even my Labor member mother who HATES Morrison with a passion I haven't seen her hate anyone with before, said she really didn't say anything wrong.

Though, admittedly, if it helps Albo get elected, I'm quite happy to run with it. I guess that makes me a hypocrite.

Do you have any disabled children? If not, try to imagine them hearing someone say how fortunate they were not have disabled children. Like their parents are unfortunate to have them because they have some additional challenges. It doesn't bother me personally but I don't want my child to hear it.

Innocenta · 22/04/2022 10:18

@XDownwiththissortofthingX I do very much appreciate that you answered me on a difficult topic, thank you. Many people choose simply not to respond on issues like this, and I respect the fact that you did no matter what we disagree on when it comes to specifics. :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread