Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Architect Error - Anyone got any advice?

35 replies

marmite14 · 21/04/2022 20:29

Just started some renovations on our house, it's all internal work - few walls coming down to make an open plan kitchen diner. We commissioned an architect to provide a current floor plan and design layouts. She advised that one of the walls would need to be checked with a structural engineer but all others were plasterboard and easy to pull down. That was the extent of the work she did as it's not a huge job. We used a structural engineer to look at the wall she suggested and he provided details for the steel that is required. Roll forward to this week, most of the walls are down, kitchen has been ripped out and we have found that one of the wall isn't made of plasterboard and is supporting wall that requires a huge steel with an estimated cost £15K. This is going to blow the budget and there is no way around it.

Has anyone experienced issues with architects making error ? Does anyone have advise on whether I have any recourse with the architect?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FinallyHere · 22/04/2022 11:06

I would have asked the structural engineer to confirm the other walls weren't load bearing.

This ^

But it does highlight the trouble when you instruct people separately rather than having someone do that project management for you. Not having an overall saves a lot of cost but these 'falling between the cracks' are what goes wrong.

PinkPlantCase · 22/04/2022 09:16

I think some people are confused by the relationship between the architect and the structural engineer.

In domestic jobs like this it is very unlikely that the structural engineer is a sub contractor of the architect.

In this instance I would expect the homeowner to have directly appointed the structural engineer and so will pay their fee direct to them.

The architect may have got the quotes/made the recommendations but the appointment contract will be between the client and the engineer not the architect and the engineer.

Either way the architect shouldn’t have made assumptions especially without any caveats. Though it is surprising for a structural engineer to look at things in such isolation.

As stated up thread the best thing to do really is to get in touch with the architect and the engineer and get them to fix it. There may be another, better solution to the one you’ve been quoted for.

CornishGem1975 · 22/04/2022 09:01

Structural Engineer is a subbie and will have only looked at what he was instructed to look at it. The architect made a (wrong) judgement without checking for accuracy.

Fulmine · 22/04/2022 08:24

It rather depends on what you would have done if you had been told at the time that it was a load bearing wall that needed also to be checked by the Structural Engineer. The SE would presumably have told you that you would need a steel for that wall and presumably the cost would have been the same. So the question is - what would have happened then? Would you have abandoned the whole idea, would you have gone ahead anyway, would you have done the work in a way that left the load bearing wall in place? If the latter, is there any reason why you can't do that anyway?

Lunar27 · 22/04/2022 08:24

@NewHouseNewMe

Who acquired the services of the structural engineer?

Lunar27 · 22/04/2022 08:22

@starlingdarling

This. It's poor from all parties TBH. An architect shouldn't have assumed and ultimately is in the wrong for asking the structural engineer to look at only one wall.

Architects aren't structural engineers but will have an appreciation of the physics and importantly house construction. If not, it wasn't her business stipulating that the other two walls were plasterboard. Total schoolgirl error.

The structural engineer could've been more diligent but may not have been aware of the entire job as they won't need to. If they've only been told about one wall and to size the beam (about £300), they're not going to look at additional walls.

People suggesting it was the engineers fault are perhaps not understanding how subcontracting works.

NewHouseNewMe · 22/04/2022 08:19

If helpful I paid for:


  • official site drawings with elevations, room sizes etc. This was done by a surveyor but some architects offer the service. Only visible supports or beams noted

  • Architects plans for the design using above

  • Structural engineer’s report including structural plans with supports and full calcs needed for building control.

NewHouseNewMe · 22/04/2022 08:13

I’d be looking closely at the terms of the contract with the structural engineer. They won’t normally give calcs is isolation - professionally their insurance may not cover it - so I wonder if this was informal advice or an engagement to work out load bearing calcs.

starlingdarling · 22/04/2022 08:07

I would have asked the structural engineer to confirm the other walls weren't load bearing. It's not a huge job to check and they're far more likely to know what they're looking at than an architect. Were they aware that you were planning to take other walls down or did you just direct him to the one wall?

DinoWoman · 22/04/2022 07:58

I agree with those that have said it is the structural engineer at fault.

Pegasushaswings · 22/04/2022 07:41

workingmomlife · 21/04/2022 20:40

Why can't you just work around the wall in question? As soon as you stripped the plasterboard off it would have become obvious it was a block wall and therefore load bearing. Highly doubt the steel cost is £15k Someone is having you on over that unless it's holding up the entire rear of the house in which case only an idiot would have said it wasn't load bearing in the first place?

I agree, it’s pretty obvious which walls are load bearing if you know what you are looking for. It sounds to me that the architect doesn’t have much practical knowledge and the structural surveyor would surely have known that the wall in question would be load bearing, even if they weren’t there to check that particular wall, as I would have expected a good builder to also know, you don’t have to knock down a whole wall to check it.

custardbear · 22/04/2022 07:33

That price is huge, we did a almost total rebuild with 15 steels,
Some huge, and all together they weren't anything close to £15k, probably about £3k but that was about 3 years ago and costs have gone up ... but not that much!

NewHouseNewMe · 22/04/2022 07:29

On costs, it Is possible that the extra steel needs to have reinforced foundations and side steels which could be £15K all in.

SolasAnla · 22/04/2022 07:18

workingmomlife · 22/04/2022 05:31

@CorsicaDreaming

I work in construction and a steel for a domestic house definitely doesn't cost £15k unless her House is a mansion or it's holding up more than 2 floors above

I expect that the builder is adding a large premium on the change of plans, if its kicking the agreed work schedule out by a few weeks.
If the architect and engineer got it wrong it' going to get messy.

Redcherries · 22/04/2022 06:46

Also in construction, 15k is a rather large sum for installing a steel. I’d be looking into that personally.

Soontobe60 · 22/04/2022 06:28

The question you need to ask yourself is, had either the architect or structural engineer noted that the wall in question needed a steel right from the beginning, what would you have done? Would you have cancelled the building work entirely? Revisited the plans to keep the wall in place? Or found the extra costs?

workingmomlife · 22/04/2022 05:31

@CorsicaDreaming

I work in construction and a steel for a domestic house definitely doesn't cost £15k unless her House is a mansion or it's holding up more than 2 floors above

CorsicaDreaming · 21/04/2022 23:47

@workingmomlife

Why can't you just work around the wall in question? As soon as you stripped the plasterboard off it would have become obvious it was a block wall and therefore load bearing. Highly doubt the steel cost is £15k Someone is having you on over that unless it's holding up the entire rear of the house in which case only an idiot would have said it wasn't load bearing in the first place?
:.

I think it's likely it could cost that. Steels have gone up massively in price in last twelve months. It's also more technically involved if you need to deal with load bearing walls.

OatSprout · 21/04/2022 23:30

They are possibly both at fault.

The architect if she directed the surveyor to only look at certain walls from the plan of works and not check the whole, and possibly the surveyor if he knew other walls were being taken down and didn’t point out to you that they should also be inspected not assumed to be non-load bearing. I would have thought he’d have a duty of care to make sure you knew nothing should be assumed.

If the architect felt she was certain they didn’t need checking then the responsibility is her’s.

Lunar27 · 21/04/2022 23:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Lunar27 · 21/04/2022 23:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

NewHouseNewMe · 21/04/2022 23:07

It would be the structural engineers responsibility but it doesn’t sound like you got the full calculations or drawings from him/her. There’s no way an engineer would only work on calcs for one wall in isolation. How did you pass building control (not planning) without full structural drawings?

Gingernaut · 21/04/2022 22:53

Fourmagpies · 21/04/2022 20:39

I don't think that is the responsibility of the architect unless they completed a full survey. Surely checking load bearing walls would be the structural engineers job?

This

justforthisnow · 21/04/2022 22:41

This is absolutely the responsibility of the engineer. Architects can suggest what might be looked at in a survey but it's the engineers responsibility to do a full survey to ensure all aspects are covered. The most basic of all checks in an existing building is assessing what is and isnt a load bearing wall. It's the medical equivalant of taking blood pressure and pulse, the most basic of measures.

BoredZelda · 21/04/2022 22:35

This was the structural engineer’s mistake. They had the plans and should have checked all walls being removed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread