Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That her words about the UK really depressed me?

316 replies

NaturalScone · 21/04/2022 20:29

Talking to a Swedish colleague this afternoon, not had much of a chance to in the past and we ended up discussing the news.
She mentioned how peculiar our politics were, how we have such a massive wealth divide (as we all know) with little encouragement for people from all walks of life and backgrounds to have equal opportunities. By this she meant how Uni education is funded over there so nobody is in debt, which means many more young people are able to chase professional careers, without massive debt.
Also, the work ethic, how people in Northern Europe are encouraged to prioritise health and wellbeing as well as work, and how well housing, health, etc work over there.

I stupidly mentioned Boris J and she said he would likely already be sacked or various offences. I also didn't know that many European monarchs had to either self fund (?) or had most of their palaces belonging to the public.

Are we going backwards here? It left me feeling pretty depressed. I see people on here all the time saying we are so lucky here, but I think the bar is set really low compared to much of Europe. And now we are less connected to Europe, many people here only judge our standards by the US, as if the EU is somehow 'foreign'.
It all sounds a bit scary if I think about it, we do seem so easily led by a one-party representational media/press (right). And whilst I am not generally partisan, I do feel weirdly uncomfortable. She even said the tories were set to abolish channel 4 and soon the BBC because they were too neutral. I find that fairly terrifying and wonder where we re headed. I previously considered Brexit an issue of immigration, but to be honest I now wonder if that was a red herring and the true motivation was to get us clear of having to take on EU worker's rights and values.

I usually look for the positives in what we've got, because it feels better than admitting things are that bad, but now I just don't know. And not much I can do about it either!
Something does feel harsher and more divided nowadays, and politicians are able to do anything without fear of reprisal. The UK press is incredibly dire! Do other people see this?

OP posts:
giggbig · 22/04/2022 05:01

how could they expect the economy not to be fucked when millions have sat on their arse being paid 80 percent of their wages. Incredibly short sighted there's going to be a lot of pain.

Do you think people shouldn't have been paid if their jobs were stopped? Or did you think mass redundancies & business closures wouldn't damage the economy?

giggbig · 22/04/2022 04:58

Also don't people the UK is now a high tax economy too? 😆

giggbig · 22/04/2022 04:51

There is inequality but this is a growing universal problem and the UK has things like inheritance tax to work against this.

It doesn't though as income is very unequal & wealth even more so.

garlictwist · 22/04/2022 04:49

Agree with this. I live in Scotland and find it generally a very depressing place to be.

sjxoxo · 22/04/2022 04:36

I’m surprised you are shocked by this op.. to me it’s a bit obvious that’s the reality of life in the UK. And Brexit being an excuse to move away from decent worker rights in the UK- you know we have a Tory government right?! What do you think they care about more? Immigration (cheap labour?) or keeping workers rights nice and comfortable for the working people?? You seem a tad naive to me sorry Xox

sst1234 · 22/04/2022 04:28

SpaceyCake · 21/04/2022 23:26

I'm from a Nordic country but have lived in the UK for 15 years now and I tend to agree with your friend. The way this country is run is pretty backwards, and in some aspects quite shocking too. If I ever mention it to anyone here I'm often asked why I don't go back to my "promised land" if it's so much better, but I have a family here and I know we wouldn't be able to get decent jobs back home due to language issues. Also DC was born here and I don't want to uproot them at this stage.

I like the diversity in the UK though and I have learnt a lot about other cultures during my time here.

Right, so the UK is crap - except that it’s so much better to live in than your other alternative. It’s crap but it’s better for being multicultural and because of the small matter of being able to provide a decent job. The case is well and truly rested on this thread.

allsorts1 · 22/04/2022 04:21

For me, while she makes good points, and the channel 4 moves make me pretty sad, there are lots of great things about the UK. For one, we are making great moves on climate and the environment, lots of regulation here especially for banks to follow, which trickles down to all suppliers and customers in the economy. In my area we have fantastic restaurants and shops opening up all the time. In my area they’ve also clearly done a huge tree planting drive, new trees down every street and every park - these will be beautiful in many years to come. Our local council has been immensely supportive protecting us from a pretty evil faceless owner of a park nearby who keeps trying to close it, the council steps in immediately and keeps it open for residents and is on our side — they aren’t corrupt. This is fantastic.

There is inequality but this is a growing universal problem and the UK has things like inheritance tax to work against this. Looking at even the Tories, they are really diverse - we have had female prime ministers and the ethnic diversity even in the Tory party is something to be really proud of! Women here get 52 weeks mat leave - not the best in Europe but far from the worst in Europe and much much better than the global average!

I moved to the UK for my career and to find more opportunities! I didn’t move to Sweden!

The press in the UK is also excellent compared to many many places (in fact I’m actually struggling to think of anywhere with better press??).

LegMeChicken · 22/04/2022 04:19

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 22/04/2022 04:11

But it's not 'better' in any real sense.
Of course people want to gontonplaces thah they've seen in films and whose language they may speak some of....

So unless someone is fluent in another European language... Naturally they will gravitate to the country they have some knowledge of... If only from films!

Also... Pekole want to go to places where family & friends are

B.S… have you seen in the interviews most of them barely speak any English… and the family/friends thing is nonsense too.
Its really because disappearing into the black economy is easier in the U.K. we don’t have national ID.

OP while what your ‘friend’ said is true I wouldn’t go so far to be depressed by it. What’s the point of being depressed. Fight for what you believe in.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 22/04/2022 04:11

sst1234 · 21/04/2022 22:00

I think the bar you missed was ‘better than France, Germany, Italy’, since they likely crossed those countries to get here.

But it's not 'better' in any real sense.
Of course people want to gontonplaces thah they've seen in films and whose language they may speak some of....

So unless someone is fluent in another European language... Naturally they will gravitate to the country they have some knowledge of... If only from films!

Also... Pekole want to go to places where family & friends are

DownNative · 22/04/2022 03:20

Poppetlove · 21/04/2022 21:02

University is funded in Scotland for anyone who wishes to go and it has been for a long time.

Misleading as university is CAPPED in Scotland as the Scottish Government aka SNP cannot afford to pay for it properly. Over 15,000 students in Scotland cannot get a uni place. Students from privileged backgrounds go to uni in Scotland at TWICE the rate of disadvantaged students.

England, Wales and Northern Ireland all send more students from disadvantaged backgrounds to university proportionately than Scotland as a result.

Martin Lewis is correct that student loans is really a graduate contribution most never repay in full. And a good proportion never actually repay a penny.

MyCatIsAJerk · 22/04/2022 03:10

Perfectlystill · 21/04/2022 21:05

And yet thousands risk their lives every year to come and live here. Weird.

Exactly, @Perfectlystill — same with the U.S. People will give you a long list of all the evils and imperfections while discounting the multitudes trying desperately to move there.
It can’t be that bad.
I’d choose either country over a vast many others, even with their foibles.

Sawadeekaka · 22/04/2022 03:03

That said, I do think the OP's friend has pointed to some of the good things about the Scandi countries and the bad ones about the UK and is right about those issues. Just that there is more when comparing countries and, for many many reasons, I would choose living in the UK over Scandi despite everything.

Sawadeekaka · 22/04/2022 02:54

I've lived in a Scandi country and know very well the 'We do everything so well here'.
I must admit, I do admire the society they have built and there's certainly plenty to learn from them plus I don't like the way the UK is going socially.
That said, I could never live there long term. It's a closed society, quite racist and provincial in so many ways. As a foreigner, you don't fit it - it's like you're a guest at a party and you can enjoy the party but they don't want you to stay. And if you're a non-white foreigner, even less so. Compared to Scandi, the UK is so tolerant and multicultural and accepting.
There's a lot of pressure for everyone to do things in the same way, especially in the schools. In a way, I liked it but it's not for me really.
And it's not some socialist paradise. We were renting but had no social protections. There isn't a deposit protection scheme like in the UK , for example, and we had to fight our landlord to get our deposit back (with deductions).

So, yeah, while I think we can learn a lot from Scandi countries - there is a lot they do right - the UK has some pretty awesome stuff going for it too and it's not like it's some kind of hellhole!

Andouillette · 22/04/2022 02:13

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/04/2022 02:00

And the figures for independence don't add up.

Always find it interesting when unionists say that. The UK's national debt is something like €2.2 trillion and growing, so it's not like we are a shining example of fiscal responsibility.

I know some also like to throw about the "deficit" issue but that's really an irrelevance as 1) most countries run a deficit, the UK has had one for 44 of the laat 50 years and 2) no one knows for sure that whether Scotland would run a deficit (more than likely would would) or, more importantly, what it would look like. The GERS figures used by the union have been widely discredited as they just make random assumptions and fail to account for numerous revenue streams.

It's very odd that in the eyes of unionists Scotland, with 1/10th the population of the UK, a vast abundance of natural resources (not only oil and gas before someone chucks that about as per), and several thriving industries would automatucally become the next Somalia if it were to go independent.

Makes you wonder how places like Norway, Iceland, Finland, New Zealand, Netherlands, and Sweden all manage to survive (and often thrive) without a overpopulated neighbour hoovering up all their resources........👀

Surprise surprise, all the usual crap about vast natural resources. What will we do, nationalise everything? The countries you mention don't have, and never have had some of the problems we have up here, endemic poverty, drugs, a failing education system, a health service that creaks along while politicians pat themselves on the back and ignore reality, all helped by a complicit media. A judicial system up to its neck in crap, corruption in high places, you name it, we've got it. But no, indymince will fix all that. Not! Name me one time in history when Scotland, as a separate country, was peaceful apart from about 10 minutes when Kenneth MacAlpin was king of most of it. Bet you can't. Scotland, one of the loveliest places on earth was and in some respects still is riven by infighting, clan warfare, sectarianism, bloodshed, petty rivalries, north v south, east v west, sectarianism etc. Can you honestly say we have changed? Sadly I don't think we have.

Zotter · 22/04/2022 02:10

I previously considered Brexit an issue of immigration, but to be honest I now wonder if that was a red herring and the true motivation was to get us clear of having to take on EU worker's rights and values.

The think tanks and wealthy who supported Brexit were libertarians - the small Lexit (left wingers for Brexit) movement had different motivations - and this heavily suggests their motivation for wanting to leave EU was precisely because they wanted an economy with v little regulations, the Singapore on the Thames that people referred to.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/04/2022 02:00

And the figures for independence don't add up.

Always find it interesting when unionists say that. The UK's national debt is something like €2.2 trillion and growing, so it's not like we are a shining example of fiscal responsibility.

I know some also like to throw about the "deficit" issue but that's really an irrelevance as 1) most countries run a deficit, the UK has had one for 44 of the laat 50 years and 2) no one knows for sure that whether Scotland would run a deficit (more than likely would would) or, more importantly, what it would look like. The GERS figures used by the union have been widely discredited as they just make random assumptions and fail to account for numerous revenue streams.

It's very odd that in the eyes of unionists Scotland, with 1/10th the population of the UK, a vast abundance of natural resources (not only oil and gas before someone chucks that about as per), and several thriving industries would automatucally become the next Somalia if it were to go independent.

Makes you wonder how places like Norway, Iceland, Finland, New Zealand, Netherlands, and Sweden all manage to survive (and often thrive) without a overpopulated neighbour hoovering up all their resources........👀

Zotter · 22/04/2022 01:54

The U.K. does have wider inequality than many other European countries. We do have an inflated housing market that means less under 40s are managing to own homes. Public services have been decimated since 2010. I want the U.K. to improve for its citizens and acknowledging the problems is important.

silentpool · 22/04/2022 01:54

Given the state of my country of birth (South Africa), I don't believe the grass is greener anywhere really.

I tend to roll my eyes when people not living somewhere, go on about the virtues of that place. If it's so great, live there. If it's so shit in the UK, you also have options?

lameasahorse · 22/04/2022 01:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/04/2022 01:18

A Swedish friend told me that (despite relatively high taxes) everybody pays something for prescriptions ( inc. her dad, who was over 90 at the time), with an annual cap for those who need a lot, plus something for visits to GP and A&E, and ditto towards the ‘board’ element of hospital stays.
Just saying.

Yet I’m sure there would be outrage if any political party proposed any such measures here, even though the NHS is on its knees for want of cash - ‘free at the point of use’ is such a sacred cow. I dare say there’d be outrage on MN.

I don’t suppose any political party would ever dare to suggest it - too afraid of it costing them millions of votes.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/04/2022 00:53

imswedish · 21/04/2022 23:52

Okay, so to start with - I'm not exactly impressed by the current UK government and its leaders. However, I'd never in a million years listen to a moaning Swede. Many Swedes, even Swedes abroad have this view of Sweden and the "Swedish way" being superior to everyone else. And it's tiring and also inaccurate. In fact, the "Swedish way" is often utterly boring with no room for individuality. Sweden is also the OECD country with the fastest growth (albeit from a low level) in income inequality, and so on.

Oh, and I'm a Swede in the UK who wouldn't dream of moving to Sweden for two reasons - state education and public health care. So much better here.

Fair point, but in no way mitigates the current awfulness of UK politics.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/04/2022 00:51

I previously considered Brexit an issue of immigration, but to be honest I now wonder if that was a red herring and the true motivation was to get us clear of having to take on EU worker's rights and values.

You reckon?
What - Johnson & co LIED about immigration?
You'll be telling us they painted lies on a bus next ...

It is about 50% based on exactly what you surmise OP.
The other 50% being to avoid the then upcoming EU legislation affecting how the uber-rich use offshore tax havens.

So in effect exactly what your Swedish pal surmises - creating a vehicle to make the rich richer, & the poor ever more disadvantaged.
Leading us inexorably to the desired outcome - an asset-stripped UK where the few remaining publicly owned services are hanging on by their teeth (remember dentists, old-timers?!), ordinary workers including those who were comfortably-off but are now joining the ranks of the "just getting by & 3 months with no income will see us on the homeless" masses, & Britain becomes an offshore facility to foreign-owned business. Just like we outsourced to India etc.

This time around, it will be John & Jane working the night shifts, cold calling people in China/Oz/USA, who will be annoyed that the callers are obviously Brits, but are passing themselves off as Jing/Bruce/Chuck ... what nuisances!

Welcome to New Britain, soon to be a renowned banana republic ...

Andouillette · 22/04/2022 00:47

Blinky21 · 21/04/2022 23:28

I thought it was universally acknowledged that the UK had much lower living standards than Europe, worse health outcomes etc etc. What is depressing is that the UK is regressing still further. I would love to be in a position to leave the UK, my plan is to move to Scotland when it devolves, assuming they will have me

I live in Scotland and there is much to love about it but please don't assume it is some magical place compared to England. It is not. Poverty is terrible, alcoholism is rife, drug deaths are the highest in Europe, all but the very lowest paid pay more tax (for no discernable benefit) and educational choices can be very lacking outwith the biggest cities. There is corruption aplenty. Nothing bad that has happened in England politically hasn't also happened here under successive administrations, none of them Tory! All that being said we also have more space, lots of beautiful countryside, less busy roads, miles of incredible beaches, fascinating wildlife, and the majority of the population consists of decent people doing their best.

Foreignmumof2 · 22/04/2022 00:45

I grew up in a North West European country and will say this:

The UK definitely has its issues and in terms of quality of life in general might not do so well in comparison with some European countries. For one I did have to get used to the wealth divide, the old houses, pot holes and the filth on the streets.

Having said that though, the country I grew up in was impossibly bureaucratic for no good reason. I also think the UK generally has a much better community spirit as a whole, but especially towards minorities and the disabled. And of course the NHS. I’d rather stay here for those reasons alone.

AmberLynn1536 · 22/04/2022 00:42

sst1234 · 21/04/2022 22:21

The manic depressives who despair at the state of this country are likely the ones that contribute to the problems they complain about. Where to start?
lockdown enthusiasts complaining that inflation is running away with itself when they were curtain twitching and talking on this very forum about reporting neighbours. As well as idiotically banging pots and pans outside their houses on Thursday evenings rather than wondering why healthy adults were sat at home while the economy was being destroyed.
Nimbys turning up with placards to protest about commercial and residential developments in their area and then complaining that there no houses or jobs for their kids locally.
Even harder nimbys moaning about nuclear power stations and then in the same breath complaining that energy bills have gone through the roof. There is a protest group blocking the building of an onshore wind farm on Shetland isles which is deemed the best place in Europe for such an initiative. Let’s stop and think about that for a second - this is a green initiative at a time when we have an energy crisis. You couldn’t make this s up.
Complaining about the NI increase and then protesting that you might not get an inheritance because your parents have to sell their home to pay for their care.

The list goes on….

Absolutely spot on.