Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That her words about the UK really depressed me?

316 replies

NaturalScone · 21/04/2022 20:29

Talking to a Swedish colleague this afternoon, not had much of a chance to in the past and we ended up discussing the news.
She mentioned how peculiar our politics were, how we have such a massive wealth divide (as we all know) with little encouragement for people from all walks of life and backgrounds to have equal opportunities. By this she meant how Uni education is funded over there so nobody is in debt, which means many more young people are able to chase professional careers, without massive debt.
Also, the work ethic, how people in Northern Europe are encouraged to prioritise health and wellbeing as well as work, and how well housing, health, etc work over there.

I stupidly mentioned Boris J and she said he would likely already be sacked or various offences. I also didn't know that many European monarchs had to either self fund (?) or had most of their palaces belonging to the public.

Are we going backwards here? It left me feeling pretty depressed. I see people on here all the time saying we are so lucky here, but I think the bar is set really low compared to much of Europe. And now we are less connected to Europe, many people here only judge our standards by the US, as if the EU is somehow 'foreign'.
It all sounds a bit scary if I think about it, we do seem so easily led by a one-party representational media/press (right). And whilst I am not generally partisan, I do feel weirdly uncomfortable. She even said the tories were set to abolish channel 4 and soon the BBC because they were too neutral. I find that fairly terrifying and wonder where we re headed. I previously considered Brexit an issue of immigration, but to be honest I now wonder if that was a red herring and the true motivation was to get us clear of having to take on EU worker's rights and values.

I usually look for the positives in what we've got, because it feels better than admitting things are that bad, but now I just don't know. And not much I can do about it either!
Something does feel harsher and more divided nowadays, and politicians are able to do anything without fear of reprisal. The UK press is incredibly dire! Do other people see this?

OP posts:
Blaggertyjibbet · 22/04/2022 07:19

YANBU. We moved to a European country for DH’s job just before Brexit and now we just thank our lucky stars we got out before freedom of movement ended. Every time we go back to the UK to visit, it seems increasingly run down and depressed. Our quality of life and long term prospects here are far better here than they were back in the UK.

Alexandra2001 · 22/04/2022 07:17

@sst1234
Where to start?
lockdown enthusiasts complaining that inflation is running away with itself when they were curtain twitching and talking on this very forum about reporting neighbours. As well as idiotically banging pots and pans outside their houses on Thursday evenings rather than wondering why healthy adults were sat at home while the economy was being destroyed

I thought it was Boris that introduced the LD's and it was Boris that got us to clap etc for the NHS?

Nimbys turning up with placards to protest about commercial and residential developments in their area and then complaining that there no houses or jobs for their kids locally

No point building houses locals cannot afford is there? Boris isn't building social ones but ones that are bought by private landlords

Even harder nimbys moaning about nuclear power stations and then in the same breath complaining that energy bills have gone through the roof

Unless the energy market is altered, doesn't matter how many power stations we have, energy is a global commodity, as is oil & gas and priced accordingly, so despite 50% ish being produced by renewables or north sea - we pay more than our european counterparts.
Plus Nuclear is extremely expensive, look at the amounts we will be paying for Hinkley C.

Complaining about the NI increase and then protesting that you might not get an inheritance because your parents have to sell their home to pay for their care

The money isn't going to social care for several years or for extra staff... hence the discharge issues & the staffing issues won't be fixed, sticking plaster politics.

Anyone who agrees with with what you wrote is just another blue rinse Tory, whose voting choices have contributed to wrecking the country.

GettinPiggyWithIt · 22/04/2022 07:11

She’s correct.

High AND UNAVOIDABLE levels of tax generate enough cash to pay for university fees healthcare and generous benefits. It’s the most equal society I’ve ever seen. The mentality is different.

For example in Denmark, you can take two years off after university until you find your perfect job

Perfectlystill · 22/04/2022 07:10

@sst1234

I think the bar you missed was ‘better than France, Germany, Italy’, since they likely crossed those countries to get here.
Quite @MrsTerryPratchett
Getoff · 22/04/2022 07:07

Wait, I think I did something wrong. Google tells me 30K GBP is 371,261 Swedish Kroner, and the total deductions on that as an annual salary in are 47.8%.

That sounds too high, so maybe I'm still doing something wrong.

SScoobiedoo · 22/04/2022 07:06

I don't know if it's our ruthless interfering media but unfortunately no one wants to be an MP let alone a PM. And now it involves even putting your life at risk.

Hence we get bad politicians. Boris got in because we Brexitted then floundered in a sea of arguments for 2 years when our development and investment in the UK stopped. Boris said he would get brexit done so got voted in as JC, TM were the more useless alternatives.

Not - as seems to be believed by the present parliament and right wing press because the people loved him - no - we had no other alternatives.
I can't understand Labour trying to oust him as they have a much bigger chance of being voted in if BJ is still in office than if he leaves or is (hopefully) chucked out.

The US politicians are pretty bad too - but what normal person would take that job?

I imagine in smaller non english speaking countries (so possibly not so much at the mercy of Twiitter etc) politicians are still given some respect - so you get better politicians.

ParisNoir · 22/04/2022 07:05

One of my best friends is Swedish and she will tell you that they have had more than their fair share of rubbish politicians themselves. Sure, she might have criticisms of the UK, but she also has plenty of criticisms of her own country. UK isnt perfect by any means but I know for a fact that my friend would live here in a heartbeat if her job accommodated it. Ive been to visit her in Sweden and I can tell you now- it was very average, the streets werent paved with gold.

MarshaBradyo · 22/04/2022 07:03

AmberLynn1536 · 22/04/2022 00:42

Absolutely spot on.

Agree too and generally with your pp

Getoff · 22/04/2022 07:03

LampLighter414 · 21/04/2022 22:50

Well it's 20% income tax + 13.25% NICs here. A quick Google and I gather the Swedish tax deduction is inclusive of social security etc. So it's higher here...

My first thought was the same as yours, but I found salary calculators for the UK and Sweden, and someone with a 30K salary would have total deductions of 20% in the UK and 35% in Sweden.

(Although from what other posters say, Sweden is a 50% richer country, and salaries would be higher there for the same person.)

SleeplessInEngland · 22/04/2022 06:56

It’s certainly not controversial to say a country that deigns to elect Boris Johnson (whatever the state of the opposition was at the time) is in a very bad way.

Sweden has its own problems though. Racism is a huge issue over there.

aramox1 · 22/04/2022 06:47

I agree with all of her points. But Scandinavians generally are raised to be pretty loyal and conformist to their largely trustworthy governments, so it's partly that you're hearing. I'd love to have faith in a decent govt.

MarshmallowSwede · 22/04/2022 06:45

Of course Swedish people think Sweden is better. Because in our mind it is better. Sweden is better at everything than anyone else.

There is a way to do things and there is the Swedish way of doing things.. and our way is the right way. I don’t think we can help but think this way. I’ve yet to see anyone do things better than us.

I think it’s the default of Swedish people to believe we do things better and that Sweden is better than anywhere else. Even if we are living abroad we probably are thinking in our head “this would never happen in Sweden” or “Sweden does it this way and it’s much better”.

But again.. no country is doing everything 100% right all the time.

One thing I will say is that the UK government is the most atrocious, poorly run, peanut gallery I’ve ever seen in my adult life. Due to this it’s a poorly run nation.. you can’t be led by idiots and think you’re going to get things done as they should. Boris has absolutely no respect for the people of the nation he governs.

And yes.. Swedish people do take great interest in the politics of our land as well. We are not at all apathetic as some would have you believe. Hence why we throw politicians out on their asses when they do something we don’t like.

It’s shocking to me that Boris is still in office. At this point what would he have to do? Kill a baby on live tv to be thrown out? Even then I’m not sure he would go. We wouldn’t have a politician like this blatantly flouting rules and disrespectful like this here. He would be voted out in no confidence. Which we have done before to politicians.

GetThatHelmetOn · 22/04/2022 06:42

I think the main problem with us is that we do not question enough. The UK system is based in honour and trust, which is commendable but also very susceptible to abuse.

We trust those in positions of power far too much, from the police to the government. We asume we are better off than other countries, which is true in some aspects but the fact other countries are doing worse shouldn’t be an obstacle for us to check what is happening in our own country and how to improve the situation.

We also overvalue apologies, whether it is a child being a bully in the school ground or Boris lying to Parliament, we all are happy to close the case if an apology is produced, when the apology should be only the start of reparations.

It is not good enough to keep pointing what other countries do worse, when we should be concentrating on what we could be doing better.

Nothappyatwork · 22/04/2022 06:42

CharityShopChic · 21/04/2022 20:34

Did she also say that Swedes pay one of the highest levels of tax in the world? 32% basic rate income tax?

So do we national insurance is a tax !

SScoobiedoo · 22/04/2022 06:42

Yes, it could be free healthcare which attracts many to the UK.
I have a Greek tenant in my let apartment. I understood she would return to Greece once she retired but now it seems she is keeping a foot in the uk as the health care is so much better.

workwoes123 · 22/04/2022 06:23

I’m from Scotland originally, but have moved a lot and lived in various countries including in Europe. We live in France just now.

firstly, the whole “ah but you choose to live here!” gotcha is nothing but. People move for a huge number of reasons. One place being “better” than another is very subjective. I agree wholeheartedly with the pps who point out that the UK is very attractive to immigrants for many reasons that have nothing to do with quality of life - it’s English speaking, no ID cards, no residence checks when accessing healthcare, huge cash-in-hand black economy to work in. France, by comparison, has excellent healthcare but you have to prove that you are eligible to access it: easy enough for anyone in a ‘regular’ situation, much harder if you don’t have ID / visa / work permit, are working on the black etc. But my point is that people don’t generally just move on a whim because they decide one place is “better” than another. DH and I are ready to move on from France now, but the kids are established in good schools with important exams coming up, I’ve got a job that would be tricky to replicate elsewhere… it’s not just a straightforward assessment that somewhere else is “better” than another, it’s a decision that takes a whole range of personal and external factors into account - and the quality of life available is only one of them.

SScoobiedoo · 22/04/2022 06:09

No UK Gov can do anything about the NHS until it is failing so badly that they will not be immediately voted out of office by the 'cradle to grave' believers.
So I would guess we have maybe another 5 years at least of shit service then some charges will be introduced, then another 5 years while that money filters through to making any improvements.

falloutcheer · 22/04/2022 05:59

As an aside
i adore GB (well England, never been to wales, Scotland or Ireland!)

falloutcheer · 22/04/2022 05:58

A Swede talking politics?! That’s a first. My father’s side of the family is Swedish and my impression of Sweden and it’s citizens are that they have very little interest in the politics of their own country let alone other countries

notwhatineednow · 22/04/2022 05:55

sst1234 · 21/04/2022 22:00

I think the bar you missed was ‘better than France, Germany, Italy’, since they likely crossed those countries to get here.

Do you really believe this nonsense?

People risk everything to come here for reasons like they have family or other connections here or because they can speak English, not because the UK is so much better than other countries.

MarshmallowSwede · 22/04/2022 05:50

Swede here. We moved back to Stockholm from London after living in the UK for a couple of years.

We came because you have better weather. And just for the experience of working in London for a couple of years.

We perhaps would have stayed had I not gotten pregnant. The thought of having to use medical care (even private) in the UK filled me with dread and there was no way I was going to give birth there.

My husband and I are both white swedes, but the amount of causal racism thrown around in conversation was shocking so you’re not as open as you like to think.

Economically we are better off in Sweden and the quality of life of London left a lot to be desired. I do feel you’re at a race to the bottom and your standards on what makes a “good life” is so low it’s ridiculous.

Of course Sweden is not a utopia as we also have issues, but I know the UK isn’t a well run or governed nation and your quality of life is in my opinion extremely low and getting worse.

we lived in the “wealthy part of london” and your wealthy areas are pretty standard normal Stockholm area. So I wasn’t impressed at all.

Also, the anti immigrant sentiment is pretty vile in the UK. Sweden is known for being anti Muslim in ways… but we certainly aren’t anti immigrant. I just think the UK overall isn’t welcoming to foreigners. Of course I’m one Swedish person so take it as a grain of salt.

As the standard response is to any criticism of the UK, yes I’ve gone back to where I come from. I’m happily back in Stockholm and can no longer muck up the place with my Swedish smugness and telliNg you how filthy London is and how terrible your healthcare is.

Wheretheskyisblue · 22/04/2022 05:43

'The press in the UK is also excellent compared to many many places (in fact I’m actually struggling to think of anywhere with better press??).'

Really? This index measures press freedom by country. Sweden ranks 3rd. The UK 33rd. This is a 2020 ranking and I suspect things have got worse since.
rsf.org/en/united-kingdom

This is also interesting as you can compare any 2 countries on a variety of indices
www.mylifeelsewhere.com/compare/sweden/united-kingdom
Stats which stood out to me....
In UK 75% more likely to die in childbirth in UK compared to Sweden, 35% more obese, 58% more likely to die in infancy, spend 29% less on education, pay 59% more for housing, pay 6.2x more for childcare.

SScoobiedoo · 22/04/2022 05:41

Population of Denmark 1970 - 5 million
Population of Denmark 2020 - 5,700,000

Population U.K. 1970 - 55 million
Population of U.K. 2020 - 67 million

Pop of Sweden 1970 - 8 mill
Pop of Sweden 2020 - 10 million

Just looked this up for interests sake. We have a much bigger population so hard to compare.

Alaimo · 22/04/2022 05:17

I've moved back and forth between the UK and parts of Northern/Western Europe a couple of times, and each have their pros and cons.

I do think at many levels Scandinavian societies function better. Just a small example: A couple of months ago a pothole appeared in the street in front of our house. The council fixed it within days. The last place I lived in the UK it would take months for a pothole to get fixed. On the other hand, I find civic society in Scandinavia in many ways non-existent. There is often an assumption that the council should do/fix/organise things. Sure, there's lots of sports clubs, or hobby groups, but I found there were very few that were generally concerned with just having a nice neighbourhood.

I don't agree with having to pay to see a GP and much prefer the NHS. On the other hand, in the last Scandinavian country where I lived I could have online therapy/counseling for £10 per session with basically no waiting list. After 10-ish sessions, it'd be free for the remaineder of the year.

The high taxation rate in Scandinavia is really not that different than tax in the UK though. 32% in Sweden, but no NI and no council tax either (and no TV license). On the other hand, almost no tax free allowance either. In the end it works out pretty similar in my experience. The much bigger difference is that the spread of salaries is much lower in Sweden: low-paid jobs pay better than in the UK while well-paid jobs pay less than in the UK.

sst1234 · 22/04/2022 05:07

giggbig · 22/04/2022 05:01

how could they expect the economy not to be fucked when millions have sat on their arse being paid 80 percent of their wages. Incredibly short sighted there's going to be a lot of pain.

Do you think people shouldn't have been paid if their jobs were stopped? Or did you think mass redundancies & business closures wouldn't damage the economy?

Strange that you should think these two to be the only two choices. How about not locking down healthy people. I know that seems like a novel idea to so many but it really shouldn’t be. Healthy adults did not need to stay home and watch Netflix and banana bread. And that way the economy would not have been shut down. The rampant inflation and energy crisis today is because the economy shut down and supply chains ceased. This should not be be some big revelation, this was the obvious consequence of the hysterical madness that people happily took part in. And even advocated for more lockdowns. It’s hurting now though, isn’t it?