Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That her words about the UK really depressed me?

316 replies

NaturalScone · 21/04/2022 20:29

Talking to a Swedish colleague this afternoon, not had much of a chance to in the past and we ended up discussing the news.
She mentioned how peculiar our politics were, how we have such a massive wealth divide (as we all know) with little encouragement for people from all walks of life and backgrounds to have equal opportunities. By this she meant how Uni education is funded over there so nobody is in debt, which means many more young people are able to chase professional careers, without massive debt.
Also, the work ethic, how people in Northern Europe are encouraged to prioritise health and wellbeing as well as work, and how well housing, health, etc work over there.

I stupidly mentioned Boris J and she said he would likely already be sacked or various offences. I also didn't know that many European monarchs had to either self fund (?) or had most of their palaces belonging to the public.

Are we going backwards here? It left me feeling pretty depressed. I see people on here all the time saying we are so lucky here, but I think the bar is set really low compared to much of Europe. And now we are less connected to Europe, many people here only judge our standards by the US, as if the EU is somehow 'foreign'.
It all sounds a bit scary if I think about it, we do seem so easily led by a one-party representational media/press (right). And whilst I am not generally partisan, I do feel weirdly uncomfortable. She even said the tories were set to abolish channel 4 and soon the BBC because they were too neutral. I find that fairly terrifying and wonder where we re headed. I previously considered Brexit an issue of immigration, but to be honest I now wonder if that was a red herring and the true motivation was to get us clear of having to take on EU worker's rights and values.

I usually look for the positives in what we've got, because it feels better than admitting things are that bad, but now I just don't know. And not much I can do about it either!
Something does feel harsher and more divided nowadays, and politicians are able to do anything without fear of reprisal. The UK press is incredibly dire! Do other people see this?

OP posts:
giggbig · 22/04/2022 10:10

Read caveats on interpreting data but you have to look at bonuses as part of total pay, not on their own.

True & its job/industry/firm specific.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 22/04/2022 10:07

Would you rather see another decade of Torys rule? Seriously?!!

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 10:03

@giggbig both higher and highest taxpayers here too. Think my new beef will definitely be all the people not paying enough NI!!

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 10:01

Again the lower earners won't see generally see increases but for some eg bankers this year bonuses have been at record levels

That’s not entirely true - www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/bulletins/averageweeklyearningsingreatbritain/march2022

Average total pay growth for the private sector was 5.3% in November 2021 to January 2022, and for the public sector was 2.4% in the same time period.

All industry sectors saw pay growth in November 2021 to January 2022, with the finance and business services sector seeing the largest growth rate at 8.6% as well as strong bonus payments.

And in real terms:

In real terms (adjusted for inflation), in November 2021 to January 2022, growth in total pay (inc bonuses) was 0.1% and regular pay (ex bonuses) fell on the year at negative 1.0%.

Read caveats on interpreting data but you have to look at bonuses as part of total pay, not on their own.

Fimofriend · 22/04/2022 09:57

Ih right. I should add that in the Scandinavian countries people actually abide by the health and safety rules.

Fimofriend · 22/04/2022 09:55

@Crikeyalmighty You see less people on mobility scooters in the Scandinavian countries than in Britain because they have a smaller percentage of disabled and morbidly obese people. A lot smaller percentage.
There are various reasons for this: Better health care, better health and safety rules, less traffic accidents and people eat better.

Kendodd · 22/04/2022 09:50

God why do people keep going on about how much tax they pay, don't you see its doesn't matter, what matters is standard of living.
Let's say you work full time and have two kids. In country A you pay 50% of your income in tax, in country B you pay 25% of your income in tax.
Country A you have a comfortable warm house, good cheap public transport, childcare and healthcare, with money left over for treats.
Country B you have a cold damp, massively expensive home, expensive public transport and childcare and no money left over for treats.
But poor fools in country A letting the government take 50% of their income, the people in country B would never do that, too smart!

giggbig · 22/04/2022 09:22

… everyone will vote for a government where SOMEONE ELSE has to foot the bill for the extra taxes.

We pay higher taxes as a household anyway which I'm happy to do. I just want better services.

giggbig · 22/04/2022 09:20

@SonicWomb agreed

I do however think we need to redefine what “rich” means.

definitely, my neighbour thinks her doctor neighbour is rich because she is a retired nurse. However she has a BTL, holiday home & no mortgage. Who is richer?

BoE this year has asked for employers to be cautious about wage increases because it also FUELS inflation… vicious circle.

Again the lower earners won't see generally see increases but for some eg bankers this year bonuses have been at record levels

Schulte · 22/04/2022 09:20

There are quite a few posters here asking why so many Europeans live in the UK so as I’m one of them, let me try to answer that!

Firstly, there used to be lots of exchange programmes and pre Brexit there was a steady flow of continental Europeans coming to the UK for a while to improve their language skills. Everyone learns English at school so doing a school or university year in an English speaking country is a no brainer. Of the people I still know from my Erasmus university exchange programme, a good handful ended up either staying in the UK, or coming back to the UK after they’d completed their degree in their home country. It was either for career opportunities or because they’d met someone and fallen in love.

Twenty years ago the UK was also a very different place. It felt a lot more open, better connected to the rest of the world outside Europe than other EU countries, it seemed to offer exciting possibilities. London in particular of course. For lots of people from the continent, a stint in the UK was a smart career move.

And then they ended up marrying a Brit or another expat, carving out good job roles for themselves, having children, buying a house… Putting up with things like inflated property prices and the NHS, which was always crap.

It’s not a one way thing either. I know lots of Brits who have settled in my home country for various reasons - often also career related or for love. Brexit may stop people from moving countries in that way now but it used to be quite normal to make a different country your home. And once you’re settled and have a family, you can’t just leave. Although some families have, and many are thinking about it now.

I’ve wondered many times whether I should move back to the continent, but DH is British and doesn’t speak other languages. The kids are British. They have their school, their clubs, their friends. It would take a huge amount of energy to pack up our lives here and start again somewhere else, and in many ways it could cause more unhappiness than we feel now. So we’re kind of stuck. And of course there are plenty of things we love here, too.

So to the posters saying ‘why don’t you just go home’: it’s not that simple.

And it’s true that things aren’t all rosy elsewhere, either. My home country has also changed a lot over the past 20 years.

I do worry about where the UK is headed. It’s not the place I came to live in many years ago and I probably wouldn’t move here now. I’m amazed at how many people I know can’t see all the things that are going wrong, or perhaps they choose not to see them. I just hope it’s only a phase, we will get a new government eventually…

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 09:19

Very good points @sodermalm … yes personal allowance makes a big difference overall. I personally agree with it, as it’s set broadly at or around the minimum income standard but that’s another argument

sodermalm · 22/04/2022 09:16

Dual Swedish/UK citizen currently in SE.
For anyone with a modest income the tax is far higher in SE. No one seems to have mentioned the personal allowance. In the UK you will be paying zero up to about 12k whereas in SE the deductions are minor so many pensioners and people on benefits will lose almost 30% with a similar income.
They also pay VAT at 25%, with a reduced 12% on food.

And as for privacy I can easily search your age, marital status, who you live with, what car is registered to you, what pets are registered to you and for a small fee your tax return.

And then there is the use of digital ID everywhere …

giggbig · 22/04/2022 09:15

you can go on & on about whether we should have locked down or not but the fact is we did so in that context I think support was necessary.

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 09:15

Problem is no government is brave enough to say this because…. Shock horror…

… everyone will vote for a government where SOMEONE ELSE has to foot the bill for the extra taxes.

And we wonder why nothing changes.

giggbig · 22/04/2022 09:14

It’s not a separate point. It is THE point. Starting a fire in your own home and then complaining that you had no choice but to leave is what happened here.

No it's not, the gov chose lockdown therefore the only choices was support or no support in that context.

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 09:14

*and they should be paying it on ALL their income.

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 09:13

By the way I think that NI and Income Tax should be combined. Absolutely ridiculous that someone can earn income through non PAYE means (eg property, pensions, dividends, capital gains) and NOT pay NI. Every single person in the country with any income at all should be paying it.

So that’s another area where we aren’t “all in it together” either.

giggbig · 22/04/2022 09:12

If we had better provision for everyone we would all feel more wealthy, we need to remember that wealth isn’t just about what we have in the bank.

completely agree

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 09:10

@giggbig you’re making the same point as me - close the loopholes, that’s different to “taxing the rich more” it’s just making sure they pay their fair share. And by the way, making sure people pay their fair share also applies to the self employed and huge numbers of people who don’t declare all their income (although after realising that furlough was based on their tax returns I wonder how many will magically be earning more this year). It happens at every level across society not just “the rich”. Basically the only people who are generally paying the full amount of tax that they are due to are the ones whose income comes through PAYE where it can’t be avoided. Hence the reason I say we need to change the system for everything else.

I do however think we need to redefine what “rich” means. Everyone wants to think it means someone else, not them. Many of us are far far richer than we’d acknowledge, one of the reasons being that we don’t feel rich because as you say, so much money tied up in mortgages and rent, and cost of living sky rocketing. BoE this year has asked for employers to be cautious about wage increases because it also FUELS inflation… vicious circle.

sst1234 · 22/04/2022 09:10

giggbig · 22/04/2022 08:54

Strange that you should think these two to be the only two choices.

@sst1234 not strange at all. In the situation we were in there was only two choices. In a lockdown you either support businesses or you don't.

Whether we should have locked down or not is a separate point. The route the gov chose was lockdown & my point was referring to what actually happened.

It’s not a separate point. It is THE point. Starting a fire in your own home and then complaining that you had no choice but to leave is what happened here.

giggbig · 22/04/2022 09:02

“The rich” already pay almost 2/3 of their income in taxes, made up of 45% + NI. You can’t really go much height than that without bringing that thresholds down and redefining “rich”.

They are not all it together though.

"Using anonymised data from personal tax returns, we show that in 2015-16 the average rate of tax paid by people who received one million pounds in taxable income and gains was just 35 per cent: the same as someone earning £100,000. But one in four of these paid 45 per cent – close to the top rate – whilst another quarter paid less than 30 per cent overall. One in ten paid just 11 per cent—the same as someone earning £15,000. The rich, it seems, are not all in it together."
LSE

giggbig · 22/04/2022 08:57

We need to tax differently. Target wealth similar to income, so increase CGT, the new house for your care should be a % not an amount. I would also favour more aggressive levies on multiple home/foreign ownership. We need much less money tied up in mortgages/rent.

giggbig · 22/04/2022 08:54

Strange that you should think these two to be the only two choices.

@sst1234 not strange at all. In the situation we were in there was only two choices. In a lockdown you either support businesses or you don't.

Whether we should have locked down or not is a separate point. The route the gov chose was lockdown & my point was referring to what actually happened.

SonicWomb · 22/04/2022 08:52

I want the rich taxed more

@Directorlevelmaybe I’m in agreement with your politically but I think this statement is overused and is the perfect way for everyone to say that someone else should be taxed more than them because there’s generally someone who is richer than them.

I think everyone needs to be taxed differently . “The rich” already pay almost 2/3 of their income in taxes, made up of 45% + NI. You can’t really go much height than that without bringing that thresholds down and redefining “rich”. It just doesn’t raise enough.

Differently means taxing capital gains on homes, or at least taxing homes differently, having higher inheritance tax… I know in the past that wouldn’t have worked but the baby boomer generation will be the wealthiest generation that has ever lived and it’s unlikely any generation will be so relatively wealthy again. We need to close loopholes available to the rich, for example my 80 year old neighbour has just put his £4 million house in trust for his middle aged kids in order to minimise paying inheritance tax on that and whatever else he has.Demographic structures are changing and the system needs to change accordingly. Corporation taxes have to play a huge part in this too, it’s not just about individuals. Companies need to live their ESG values more and actually recognise their contribution to society in terms of jobs, investment, wages and services … rather than just writing shiny brochures about it for their investors.

As for Jeremy Corbyn. He was just a bitter socialist full of hatred for anyone who has any kind of aspiration or success in life. We need a modern approach for a modern, fair, inclusive and aspirational society, not more dinosaurs who are living out their parents’ wet dreams (yes you too JRM).

SleeplessInEngland · 22/04/2022 08:51

"Sweden has its own problems."

Nice bit of anti-immigrant propganda you're posting there (see the link on the pic).