Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people need to stop suggesting marriage is just a piece of paper

106 replies

afizzysweet · 21/04/2022 16:16

if they're in a relationship with joint outgoings and children?

I got married when I was young and married 'for love' and not for any other reason, because I was ignorant to the other reasons. As I've got older, I've realised that with marriage brings a lot of security for women.
Typically when you have children, it is a woman's career and ability to earn money that is impacted rather than a man's. Doesn't have to be, but usually is.

I know many women that have 2 or 3 children with their DP. They want to get married but DPs are saying "we need the prioritise the money for xxxx instead" or just sort of tell them that it's not a priority for other reasons and that marriage is only a piece of paper. These women have had years of working part time because of providing childcare, dropping their career progression for several years because it's not really possible for them with children. In the event of them splitting up they aren't entitled to as much.

I think they've been talked in to an idea that marriage is just a part of the patriarchy by their DPs so don't want to bother now. If that is your feeling and at your core do not want to get married, absolutely fine, but put something else in place so that should yourself and your partner split up, you've got some security and won't be left up a creek without a paddle, and you get your fair share of things - taking in to account things like staying at home to look after the kids whilst your partner has been out furthering his career for years.

AIBU to think this? I have spoken to some of my friends about this when they bring it up, especially a couple whose DPs manage all of their money and not in joint accounts (which I find really worrying). At the end of the day it's their life, but am I the only one who finds this quite bad?

OP posts:
GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 21/04/2022 16:42

YABU. My friend's partner died when they had 3 kids age 8 and under. Because the weren't married his parents (as official next of kin) organised his funeral in his home country following religious beliefs he no longer held and my friend had no say. An awful time for her anyway was made even worse.

afizzysweet · 21/04/2022 16:41

Men can opt out of parenthood completely, and do so all the time- so having children isn’t really a huge commitment to someone.

The children themselves might not be (sadly) but women who stay at home for several years raising the kids while the dads go out and get promotions, only to swan off later on, are screwed.

the waters are muddied by the uk govt treating couples “as if they were married” when it suits them to do so! Mainly benefits claims BUT when it doesn’t suit them eg inheritance tax, bereavement payouts they don’t!

Yes this is true!

I’m firmly in the cohabiting camp, don’t want or need to get married and DP and I have things in place in case of problems; joint ownership of assets and wills.

This is sensible - so many people don't. I know one person who isn't married and have nothing in place, and all of their assets and finances are in her DPs name!

OP posts:
Suprima · 21/04/2022 16:26

YANBU- but it’s a sensitive subject as many women have settled for and had children with men who don’t want to marry them and aren’t really that into them.

Men can opt out of parenthood completely, and do so all the time- so having children isn’t really a huge commitment to someone. Women tend to pay 50/50 for the running of the home and the mortgage these days too. It’s no wonder men set home with women who they like having sex with, will have their babies for them and split the bills with them- usually for the woman to do 90% of the housework as well.

Whatsthestoryboringglory · 21/04/2022 16:24

I’m firmly in the cohabiting camp, don’t want or need to get married and DP and I have things in place in case of problems; joint ownership of assets and wills.

having said that, if I had kids and had to take time out of my career or become a SAHP, I would absolutely insist on marriage. I’ve seen too many people left financially ruined by a partner who refused to marry and left them with no job, no savings and no house with kids to look after.

Graphista · 21/04/2022 16:24

as I always say on threads on this topic it’s not just in the event of a split it’s an issue it’s also if the higher/only earner becomes incapacitated or even dies.

I’ve seen a relative deal with such a situation and it was a total shit show!

i think the main problem is that we (as a population) aren’t taught about the clear differences between living together and marriage in the uk

uk laws vary by internal country but generally speaking on this they are very similar. If you’re not married you’re simply much less protected

the waters are muddied by the uk govt treating couples “as if they were married” when it suits them to do so! Mainly benefits claims BUT when it doesn’t suit them eg inheritance tax, bereavement payouts they don’t!

they have it all ways

as for patriarchy being an argument against marriage, as you say op the majority of the time it is women - and by extension children - that are most disadvantaged by a lack of marital contract. Because that is what it is a contract

and as you rightly say it’s not just a piece of paper it’s an important piece of legislation.

SemperIdem · 21/04/2022 16:19

It irritates me too. It is not just a “piece of paper” - it is a legal contract that offers protections and benefits merely cohabiting does not.