Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset about SIL comments?

37 replies

SILhelp · 21/04/2022 12:50

...about children and me?

SIL has three lovely little ones and we've know eachother a long time. I've never mentioned an interest in having kids myself but I take an interest in hers and am always supportive and positive. But the comments are every time I see her, she seems to have decided for me I'm going to have kids and talk like it's a given. It making me a bit down about seeing her and making our relationship hard though I don't know she's noticed. Pressure from my parents and society generally in women to have kids is already such a weight when not sure (the idea of a child seems nice but the realities I see day to day seem overwhelming and do not fill me personally with excitement, nothing meant to people who chose to have them its everyone's personal choice and I positively support people who make that choice). While I can tune out a lot of that when I see her SILs comments make me feel like im a disappointment or silently judged or looked down on because I don't have kids or am not v maternal.

Comments like 'its so sad realising our children won't grow up together', 'You'll need to consider properties that are good for children', 'Hope mine don't put you off when you're having children', " when you have kids..." 'You can tell you don't have children!' (at non kid friendly furnishings in my new home), infantilizing my hobbies as if they're a children's hobby, referring to me as if I'm a maternal figure to my partner, and getting irritated with me if I'm not watching her kids when SIL wanders off as I'm expected to help with care.

Other family and friends with children dont constantly make comments, so I'm in no way saying this is the reason but I don't know what is. Every time she says something like this I brush it off, change subject or generally make it clear I'm not interested in this chat but its been years and she wont take the hint. Any advice from the wisdom of mumsnet on how to deal with this? Any insight on why she would do this so I can understand better? I want to have a positive relationship with her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wheniruletheworld · 21/04/2022 21:22

Tell your SIL that you like kids, but couldn't eat a whole one..
Then on a serious note, tell her ypu don't want kids and that you don't have to explain why to anyone

Mooshering · 21/04/2022 21:06

@Itshothothot

I don’t understand why people think children are desirable to have.

there is so much more to life than having kids

This.

It infuriates me when people assume that all women want or should want children, or that we're missing out if we don't.

My cousins all have children and have made comments to me like this in the past. I've told them straight that I do not want children. They seem enormously insulted by this, and I then have to sit through an interrogation about why I wouldn't etc.

One of them is very pushy with me on the subject. I'm always tempted to point out to get that she constantly complains about being exhausted/stressed/skint/never getting a break or a holiday.

JudgeJ · 21/04/2022 21:02

Any advice from the wisdom of mumsnet on how to deal with this? Any insight on why she would do this so I can understand better? I want to have a positive relationship with her.

'Dear SIL, I do feel sorry for those who made the decision to have children without realising until it's too late how restricting, draining and career ruining they are. It's such a joy to be able to have a lovely home, knowing it won't be destroyed by grimey fingers!'
Smile, head tilt and walk away.

jytdtysrht · 21/04/2022 19:41

I think just tell her straight out that you love her kids but kids are not for you full time. Tell her you have thought long and hard and won’t change your mind ever.

thebeespyjamas · 21/04/2022 19:29

Also it sounds as though she would then go onto 'no you must have children/who will take care of you when you're old?' and things.

To that you should say 'that makes me feel really sad when you say those things'

She really should rethink her choices after that to be honest and if not, she sounds not all there.

thebeespyjamas · 21/04/2022 19:27

Simply tell her you do not plan to have any children. That should stop the comments assuming you are having them?

And then if you do it's a nice surprise for her.

ThreeLittleDots · 21/04/2022 19:23

*not that you do, but it's extremely presumptuous and rude of her to keep making these comments.

I wonder if she sees your child-free status as a sort of attack on her own choices

ThreeLittleDots · 21/04/2022 19:22

Tell her that actually you hate children and you're expecting to be child-free for life. That'll shut her up.

Maydaysoonenough · 21/04/2022 17:13

Next time just whisper you used to be a man so no dc any time soon..
She is extremely rude imo.

supersop60 · 21/04/2022 16:59

It sounds like your SIL is just assuming that you will one day have kids.
I think you will have to be blunt (not rude) and say the words, because changing the subject isn't working.
I don't want children
I don't intend to have children
I like my life the way it is
etc etc

Hankunamatata · 21/04/2022 16:56

Urgh my dh used to do this to one of our friends. I told him repeatedly not everyone has kids. Friend then told him she couldn't have kids infront of a huge group of people- he was mortified and finally saw the light. Friend later confided that she didnt know as she hadnt tried for children but wanted to shut him up. He has been more wiser since

Moochio · 21/04/2022 16:43

SILhelp · 21/04/2022 14:33

Thank you everybody for the messages, I wondered if I was maybe being too sensitive. to respond to some questions, we're in our 30s, we spend time just us two when these comments tend to be made. I honestly thought my way of handling it by never answering and obviously switching to something else repeatedly would have got the message across. If I'm outright they may then want to discuss it in detail, which i really wouldnt want to. I just dont know what makes them want to make the comments.

That's fine, just say you don't want to discuss it. It may be blunt but I don't think it's rude.

Moochio · 21/04/2022 16:42

I would spell it out to her. Ask her not to assume you're having kids. If you want tell her it upsets you to keep talking about it.

whenwilliwillibefamous · 21/04/2022 16:19

I think, "How can you?!" and bursting into tears might be a very effective technique, but sadly not one you should use deliberately.

Take her aside somewhere private the next time you see her and she's once again ignored the "change subject/deflection/not answer" technique, and say, look, this is not a subject I want to discuss with anyone for very private, personal reasons, please don't assume we're going to have children from this point on, I know you just want us to be as happy as you and don't mean ANY harm but I'd be very grateful if you could do this.
Possibly with damp eyes and a hug.

She's not malicious so make sure she knows you don't think that - no point in having a rift or a row.

Unsureaboutit9 · 21/04/2022 15:58

I think if it is bothering you you need to be direct, how is she suppose to no you don’t want kids if you’ve never said?

forrestgreen · 21/04/2022 15:32

Dear dsil, I just wanted to send a quick text to reply to a few comments that have been made recently y about mine and dp plans for children. I don't think we've ever discussed that we don't want children. We'd be really grateful if you'd stop bringing it up. We of course love your dc but have no plans for our own. Thanks, see you soon x

YouAreNotBatman · 21/04/2022 15:25

Your SIL is an asshole and a bitch.
That is all.
Nothing else to add.
Except that she’s also a cu……..

sayanythingelse · 21/04/2022 15:24

You need to be straight with her because she's obviously not getting the hint.

DH and I are secretly gutted that we'll probably never have nieces or nephews. My brother has ASD and will never live independently and BIL isn't keen on having his own kids. I'm sad for my DD that she'll never have cousins to play with but I would never say anything to BIL. It's not my decision. Your SIL obviously doesn't have the same tact.

ForeverSingle881 · 21/04/2022 15:18

Just say you're not interested in having kids at all. You can't expect people to be mind readers. If she reacts badly or still goes on about it then you know she's a bitch and you can distance yourself from her. If you've never said you don't want kids, you hang around hers a lot and are married to her brother, it's really not a big assumption to make. Her kids are probably her whole world right now so she.might just be a bit self absorbed.

Courante · 21/04/2022 14:57

She either lacks awareness of how she is coming across and genuinely doesn't realise how draining and hurtful she's being or she is isn't a particularly nice person IMO.
I think it is time you found out which one it is by telling her how it makes you feel to be in the receiving end of this all the time, not by challenging her the next time she does it but by specifically picking a time to talk about this with her (in person or on the phone) - just you and her. You decide how much you want to share - they is absolutely no need to justify your position. She may ask you personal questions, as she doesn't really seem to understand boundaries - so go prepared with how you will gently steer her in the direction of understanding how inappropriate she is being.
Flowers

billy1966 · 21/04/2022 14:48

Why are you tolerating such rudeness for years?

She sounds absolutely ghastly and thick as shit with it.

You need to nip this in the bud and not be diplomatic about it.

I would be actively avoiding her company.

What a tedious bore.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 21/04/2022 14:42

jealousgirl · 21/04/2022 13:33

I would say "I'd prefer not to talk about my fertility and medical history if that's ok?"

I had an aunt who went on and on and ON about when I was going to have my first, until I managed, just the once, to say, "How can you?" and burst into tears and had to be consoled about not being able to have a baby. The subject was not mentioned again even when I did get pregnant a few years later, I suppose because she was afraid I might miscarry.

Itshothothot · 21/04/2022 14:37

I don’t understand why people think children are desirable to have.

there is so much more to life than having kids

SILhelp · 21/04/2022 14:33

Thank you everybody for the messages, I wondered if I was maybe being too sensitive. to respond to some questions, we're in our 30s, we spend time just us two when these comments tend to be made. I honestly thought my way of handling it by never answering and obviously switching to something else repeatedly would have got the message across. If I'm outright they may then want to discuss it in detail, which i really wouldnt want to. I just dont know what makes them want to make the comments.

OP posts:
jealousgirl · 21/04/2022 13:33

I would say "I'd prefer not to talk about my fertility and medical history if that's ok?"