Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I too available at work?

80 replies

JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 11:16

Prompted by DH asking why I’m answering emails in bed this morning.

I am a manager in a hospitality setting. It’s a full on job, often 50-60hr weeks. I love my job. I work alongside another manager but we have specific roles each and don’t really get involved in the other’s unless absolutely necessary.

I have work emails, booking system, WhatsApp etc on my phone and laptop. Invariably, things will crop up that need my attention while I’m at home. I get phone calls/messages from the team when I’m not there with queries that I can’t just ignore. Or emails from customers that are time critical.

DH works in a completely different sector earning 4x what I do and when he’s not at work (9-5) he doesn’t think about work at all.

I think it’s just a totally different world and comes with the job. I sometimes have to message my own manager when they’re not actually working and they will always reply.

I did leave my phone at home at DHs request over Christmas when we were horrendously short staffed and I was under a lot of stress, it was my first day off for 12 days and we went out for a family dinner but tbh I spent the whole time panicking that they needed me and I did get home to several messages (and yes, it had all gone to shit unnecessarily which I could have sorted).

I am working on building up the team to be more self sufficient but it’s hell out there in hospitality land and I have a very young team who aren’t always confident to make decisions without me.

How available are other people outside their working hours? It’s pretty normal in a lot of sectors I’d have thought?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Keladrythesaviour · 21/04/2022 23:47

I haven't rtft so sorry if things have moved on. I worked in a similar sector and I think there definitely is an expectation as a manager to be available. I certainly was responsible for dealing with cover and absences even on my days off (and if I couldn't get cover I was expected to go in unless I had a verifiable reason why I couldn't like a wedding). But if I was on annual leave I could usually allocate an area manager or other venue manager as the person to call if there was a problem.

It wasn't an issue I had but another manager was struggling with being called a million times a day by her team. She was told to say to her team on her off days they could only contact her twice. So to think very carefully before calling and if it was worth using one of their 'phone a friend' tokens as it were. It worked really well as her team had got into the habit of calling her about any little thing, they now had to consider each time they did so, and over time built up their confidence, and her confidence in them.

You've said you're working on giving your team strength and that's so important. I only felt I'd achieved as a manager when the shift could run as smoothly when I wasn't there as when I was. After each day off have a full debrief with your team. Before a day off make sure everyone knows their roles and your expectations. You certainly shouldn't be answering customer emails - you should have a process in place that covers that whilst youre off. Contact should be emergency only.

Starseeking · 21/04/2022 23:43

If you don't own the business, as in have 100% of the shares, you are making yourself too available. If staff know you will respond out of hours, and solve the problems for them, they will keep ringing you!

I'd ask for a work phone, and turn it off as I was leaving for the day.

kokoalemon · 21/04/2022 23:37

Earlier in my career I made myself too available, learned from that and figured out what my boundaries are. I’m currently public sector, £55k. I work flexibly, so sometimes I could finish at 4pm, other days at 7pm, but crucially I don’t often go beyond my contracted hours (38/week) and if I do, I take them back as leave.

It sounds like you care a bit too much about controlling things, it also sounds like you put a lot into your work which is a nice ethic in some ways but unfortunately you won’t get the same in return. Which is why you are carrying so much. As much as you like your job, it really could lead to health problems (it did for me, hence learning my boundaries!).

You will serve your team, your business and your customers best by enabling them to work well without your constant input. You will benefit from this in your career and any next steps you take, and in your personal life by regaining some semblance of balance.

I hope this comes across nicely as it is meant nicely! You sound like you care, and just need to learn to lead, to delegate, to be comfortable with that, and to know what your personal priorities are.

Womencanlift · 21/04/2022 23:28

Sounds like your colleague has boundaries by not having work emails on their phone, maybe you should consider this too. By answering/being available all you are doing is hiding an issue that you are understaffed

I am reasonably senior and have a team reporting into me and I still don’t check emails on phone and I actively encourage my team to do the same as their well-being and family life is more important than a deadline.

If I see that they have been online over the weekend or late at night (because emails are sent or notice their last online time on our chat system) then I will challenge them in it. Because if it’s due to them being stretched as they have too much work that’s my issue to sort.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 21/04/2022 23:03

I promise I’m not a micromanager either, it’s not like I’m breathing down their necks and not delegating, just that I’ve been put in the position of being the perceived font of all knowledge and don’t like to leave messages unanswered.

But the more you take on extra work and the more you keep picking up jobs in your free time, the more people will come to rely on you and then it's a viscous cycle.

You should have a colleague on every shift when you're not there who is capable of stepping up and doing the vital parts of your role that can't wait until you're next back in the business.

So a deputy manager, or someone in a supervisory capacity who knows it's their job to check/action emails when you're not on the rota etc.

As the manager, it's your responsibility to make sure you have someone who is trained up to step in when you're away, else how do you ever get a proper day off or break?

Iliketeaagain · 21/04/2022 22:33

I manage a big team and do more overtime than I should (NHS). But when I'm off, I'm off. The only reason I check email if I'm on leave is the night before i'm back at work, just so I can delete all the rubbish as it saves me time my first morning back.

Plenty of people have my personal number and can call me if there is something that can't wait that I haven't handed over BUT they rarely do - I think maybe once in the last 2 years, even in the midst of the covid chaos.

You are far too available. If they need someone at your level or above always on call to make decisions, then they should have an on-call system, not rely on you answering your phone or queries when you are frequently not at work. Also, people should be respecting your time off unless it's a major emergency - even then, we ask people if they are happy to be contacted when not at work in case of crisis (E.g contact to ask if they will work if a whole team was off with covid for example) and if the answer was no, then that's made clear in our emergency folder.

JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 22:19

ImBurtMacklin · 21/04/2022 19:38

I’m pushed off it’s lost us actual money.

I bet you don’t see a penny of this money yourself do you?

My bonus is dependant on sales.

I promise I’m not a micromanager either, it’s not like I’m breathing down their necks and not delegating, just that I’ve been put in the position of being the perceived font of all knowledge and don’t like to leave messages unanswered.

My opposite colleague isn’t bothered about promotion or even a long term career so he gives far fewer fucks about things than me, tbh. It’s not ideal.

OP posts:
ImBurtMacklin · 21/04/2022 19:38

I’m pushed off it’s lost us actual money.

I bet you don’t see a penny of this money yourself do you?

thecatsthecats · 21/04/2022 19:27

I was young and inexperienced once. In a team of similar people.

And we learned fuck all except to rely on our manager because he was a micromanager.

Funnily enough years later, I ended up managing the whole team, and said manager phoned me to ask if he should order loo paper because they were running out. My silence spoke volumes, and he said, "I should just get some, shouldn't I?".

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/04/2022 19:13

My colleague doesn’t have emails on his phone

So if he's "your equal" and yet doesn't have email on his phone, why do you?

Unless he's avoiding having the facility because that means you'll do it instead, in which case I'd suggest you've brought this on yourself

Etinoxaurus · 21/04/2022 18:04

You must get a work phone.
Read this book.
Turn the Ship Around!
A True Story of Turning Followers into Leaders
Flowers

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 21/04/2022 18:00

OP you are being taken advantage of big time.

Additional responsibilities, sole gatekeeper of vital processes and procedures, chief decision maker, and always on call all for no additional pay or benefits (not even the basic equipment needed to do the job).

You've said it yourself hospitality businesses are struggling to recruit and it's an employees market.

If I were you I'd be reevaluating my worth and asking for a pay rise or, more likely, looking for a new role as your current company clearly do not value you enough.

balalake · 21/04/2022 17:27

You should have set boundaries a long time ago. Not just out of consideration for your family.

Things should not need your attention whilst at home.

I don't know if he went through with it, but Monsieur Macron proposed a legal right not to have to answer emails or other messages outside working hours. An idea I 100% supported.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 21/04/2022 16:17

JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 15:56

My colleague doesn’t have emails on his phone so doesn’t see them in real time, he has to physically be at the office pc.

usual process is whoever the duty manager is should have read the email and done the (30 second) action.

My instinct was to message him and make sure he’d seen it but I was trying to take a step back. Ultimately this doesn’t blow back on me, it’s not my responsibility, but I’m pushed off it’s lost us actual money.

So why didn't the duty manager check the e-mails and respond appropriately?

LookItsMeAgain · 21/04/2022 16:14

I was just about to type this when I saw that @falloutcheer did - your direct equal manager doesn't have email on their phone so can't check emails in the same way you do?
Do you see what we're driving at here??

You are more available.

What is shocking to read is that the General Manager defers to you (but I'm guessing you're not the CEO/owner/director of the company, which would be, in my opinion the only level or role that would top being a GM). They shouldn't be doing that. They are the GM. They should be taking on the queries about sick leave cover etc. but because they know you will do it, they couldn't be arsed in learning to do it in good time.

You clearly don't value your own time very much because you've been effectively gifting that time for no compensation (i.e. no overtime wages) to your company/employer.

Value your time more.

falloutcheer · 21/04/2022 15:59

So your direct equal can only check emails when in the office?

sounds sensible

SleeplessInEngland · 21/04/2022 15:58

It's good you like your job because 60 hours a week for under 30k seems absurd to me. I think your DH has a point if it's demanding that much time from you.

Robin233 · 21/04/2022 15:58

You sound like me Op.
your company is lucky to have you.
And if you love your job , which I think you do - you're very lucky too.

JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 15:56

My colleague doesn’t have emails on his phone so doesn’t see them in real time, he has to physically be at the office pc.

usual process is whoever the duty manager is should have read the email and done the (30 second) action.

My instinct was to message him and make sure he’d seen it but I was trying to take a step back. Ultimately this doesn’t blow back on me, it’s not my responsibility, but I’m pushed off it’s lost us actual money.

OP posts:
JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 15:54

I don’t manage my colleague, he is my equal. We both report to the same LM. I have asked that emails be checked first thing and then before we open as a priority. This shouldn’t have happened.

I will raise it at our next manager meeting as well in general terms.

I’ve had pretty much constant management training due to the studying I’m doing alongside my job. But I have only been a manager for less than a year and I am still learning.

OP posts:
Jalepenojello · 21/04/2022 15:50

What is the usual process there OP? Was is assigned to anyone specific? If they are used to you always chasing them and being on call, were your team not waiting for your instructions? You need to take a step back but you actually need to manage your team first, confirm processes, assign x person a day for urgent queries in your absence and raise with that individual if they don’t follow through.

Switching up your expectations after months of being on call and telling no one isn’t going to work…..

Itshonestlynotthathard · 21/04/2022 15:47

Op

habe you been on any management training courses that may assist you?

Itshonestlynotthathard · 21/04/2022 15:46

JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 15:16

Well I’ve just arrived at work to find absolutely no one has actioned the time critical email I ignored earlier, which means the business has lost money.

I really wanted to message to make sure it had been seen but refrained. 🤦🏻‍♀️

So… as a manager, how are you now going to address this?

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 21/04/2022 15:32

JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 15:16

Well I’ve just arrived at work to find absolutely no one has actioned the time critical email I ignored earlier, which means the business has lost money.

I really wanted to message to make sure it had been seen but refrained. 🤦🏻‍♀️

As a manager, surely it's your job to deputise someone to action these things on your behalf, though?

So - who is that person and why didn't they do it? If you don't have a person you can deputise to, why on earth not?!

OctopusSay · 21/04/2022 15:20

JanetPluchinsky · 21/04/2022 15:16

Well I’ve just arrived at work to find absolutely no one has actioned the time critical email I ignored earlier, which means the business has lost money.

I really wanted to message to make sure it had been seen but refrained. 🤦🏻‍♀️

The business needs to alter it's working practices so time critical things are seen by someone who's working.