Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To talk about what happened?

67 replies

theblabber · 21/04/2022 07:41

I just went through a break-up which has a bit of a crazy and shocking story attached.

It was actually very traumatic but I have told the story to anyone who’ll listen because I find it therapeutic. I’d rather share the story with people (and dare I say, receive the validation that it was insane and I am better off without him), than bury it and relive the trauma of it in my head.

I’m doing all the healthy stuff too - journaling, seeing a therapist, exercise etc.

My best friend just read me the riot act because I’m telling people what happened. She’s had a couple of people approach her to say they heard what happened and were shocked and is apparently very very annoyed at that. She isn’t defending him or anything (she hates him) but she keeps telling me it’s unhealthy and I shouldn’t be sharing so much with people.

I can’t really work out why she has such an issue with it. I find it therapeutic to share the story. It turns it from a traumatic event, into an anecdote, and I find that useful.

IABU to tell people what happened? I really can’t see the harm in it.

OP posts:
thebeespyjamas · 21/04/2022 14:19

I think it's your story to tell or not to tell.

You can gently suggest things to your friends but ultimately can't tell them how to behave.

Does the story involve her at all? Why are people mentioning it to her?

UnsuitableHat · 21/04/2022 11:56

I don’t think you’re doing anything wrong, unless you’re really forcing your ‘stuff’ on people who don’t want to listen. Sometimes we need to talk things through.

Squirrelblanket · 21/04/2022 09:44

As others have said, it depends on the story and how close you are to the people you are telling. For a very close friend I wouldn't be surprised to hear the full details. For someone I'm not close too might say, 'Oh no, poor you, what happened?' But I would be expecting more of a 'he dumped me/I dumped him' kind of thing rather than all the details. Honestly that would just make me feel awkward and uncomfortable. It sounds like this is what has been happening and that other people have asked your friend to have a word.

whenwilliwillibefamous · 21/04/2022 09:30

So, here's the thing, OP.
Right now it's a relief to talk about it and helps you get over the shock.
But, if you were my friend, I would also gently suggest you keep that to close friends, who would expect to know these details.

People who aren't close - they'll now think of you always as "woman who found her boyfriend dressing up the hamster in rubber gear" (or whatever). Not "woman who is quite funny", "woman who works at the council", "woman who was having trouble with her Ford Focus". It'll colour their view of you, following you round, and just imagine if you go for a job interview three years from now and they're on the other side of the desk...!

Your close friends know all about who you are anyway, so this won't skew their opinion of you. They know that this is just an isolated experience. But people who don't know you will wonder, "is she the sort of person who is always ending up in drama?", and who wants to give that as a first impression?

I think that's where she's coming from.

BeautifulWar · 21/04/2022 09:24

Also last time I put a shocking story on here, the Daily Mail picked it up.

Blimey, how many shocking stories do to have?!

Brefugee · 21/04/2022 09:21

I think the best thing is to let them lead the conversation if you're talking to someone about your break-up. So let them ask and you can then give them a chance to say "do you just want me to listen or are you asking for advice/feedback?" (lots of people don't ask this, but it is really useful as a listener to know what's expected)

I hadn't heard "trauma dumping" before but that is a great way of putting it. It isn't fair to dump things on people who might not want it but don't know how to stop you from doing it.

x2boys · 21/04/2022 09:18

I went through a really traumatic experience a few years ago i also felt the need to talk about it ,I self referred for counseling,and was able to talk the whole experience through ,and how I felt sad and also angry with some people,it helped me just having some one listening to me.

queenMab99 · 21/04/2022 09:08

I had not discussed the way my marriage was disintegrating and my ex was having an affair, for 4 years, as I was told by him that I was mentally ill for thinking such a thing and by the OW, that I was mistaken, it was not until I had proof, had made him leave, and seen a solicitor about a divorce, that I told friends and colleagues. It was like an explosion, I told everybody, and they were all very interested, I didn't care who knew, it was such a relief to know that I wasn't a mad, menopausal, paranoid old bitch. I don't think I upset anyone except him and her. It might not have been the right thing to do but it made me feel so much better. 'The shit hit the fan' describes it perfectly.

sst1234 · 21/04/2022 08:55

OP putting the friend aside for the moment. It’s great that you have a way to manage things which otherwise may be difficult to manage. Overhearing personal stuff can hurt your credibility though. People start to see other peoples trauma as drama after a while. It may be harsh but it’s also true. Humans are wired to have limits to empathy. Some boundaries and keeping certain things personal is important to maintaining relationships without people eye rolling about your personal life. Talking to a professional is better idea.

the80sweregreat · 21/04/2022 08:49

I knew someone who tended to ' overshare' a bit
It made me feel uncomfortable as I know that some people are just keen on the gossip and not on how they are dealing with the situation
I don't trust most people , very few in fact , but I think that's an age thing , you do learn who you can trust and who you can't and you find out it's a very small number of people most of the time.
Just chose wisely who you chose to confide in.
I'm sorry you had such a bad break up.

AllOverIt · 21/04/2022 08:47

I agree with your friend, sorry.

Itshonestlynotthathard · 21/04/2022 08:42

And unless a close friend
i take any “break up stories” with a pinch of salt.

Itshonestlynotthathard · 21/04/2022 08:42

He fact you’re even starting a thread about your BF giving you some advice and whether you are right to overshare…… indicates to me that you thrive on bringing others in to issues in to your life.

Pause, reflect, talk to very close friends if you wish, but sharing with multiples is, in a word, gossiping.

Itshonestlynotthathard · 21/04/2022 08:38

I’m with your friend

Thehop · 21/04/2022 08:35

Your friend could have been kinder but I actually agree. I’m not a sharers so could be wrong but it sounds like you’re trauma dumping and should maybe stick to talking about it with your therapist?

good luck moving forward.

Momicrone · 21/04/2022 08:28

There are no rules, if it helps you, crack on, it would not annoy me at all. We're all human and have to find our way through these things.

Winederlust · 21/04/2022 08:23

It's not an all or nothing game though succulent; of course sharing with close friends and family can be helpful of course. Telling the whole story to anyone who asks (often because they're just interested in a bit of gossip, not in actually helping the OP) can be detrimental rather than helpful.

FourTeaFallOut · 21/04/2022 08:19

If this is someone whose judgement you usually trust and you think she is speaking in good faith, then I think she might have good reason to think you need to be more selective about how and who you are telling and you should ask her.

SucculentChalice · 21/04/2022 08:17

Telling close friends isn't trauma dumping, its what friends are for.

I assume your ex behaved quite badly?

This idea that people shouldn't discuss things that happened to them is something I find quite old fashioned, it comes from a time when women were meant to put up and shut up, and its very convenient for men who want to cheat and be secretive. As a society, we inform others on reputations of people we know, and its one of the primary defences we have in warning people against "bad sorts" and saving them from future trauma, should they choose to acknowledge it.

I don't believe in a code of silence around bad behaviour, because it generally protects men and its this notion that women have to be compliant and good little uncomplaining girls, just in case they put another man off.

RealBecca · 21/04/2022 08:17

You're not unreasonable to share your story but you sound very reactive - telling everyone proactively is oversharing, as it is giving the full details to people you dont really know at ladies night. Telling close family and friends is healthy. Acquantainces you just say its finished and that's the end of discussion.

I say this with love, other people arent there to be your therapy. They have their own stuff going on X

Winederlust · 21/04/2022 08:13

I agree with PP that you should be careful who you're sharing things like this with. If it's getting back to your friend it's obviously being gossiped about. Stories tend to get distorted through gossiping which never turns out well.
I think if it's getting to the point where you're sharing this with anyone and everyone then that's just too much and is probably an indication that you're not getting over it, rather than it helping you.

ZenNudist · 21/04/2022 08:11

Your friend is right I'm sorry. You need to have some reserve about this or you come across crazy. It's OK to tell the people who love you but don't overshare.

I found myself in a conversation at the park with a mum who used to be at my dc school. She was telling me all these awful stories about her life and I found myself first wanting to pray for her but also exhausted by it. I remembered she's done this to me before when she was still at school but I thought that was pandemic crazy rather than just what she's like.

theblabber · 21/04/2022 08:10

DownUdderer · 21/04/2022 08:03

Actually maybe I mean trauma dumping. Oversharing can be too much for most people.

A quick google has informed me that this is exactly what I’m doing. Wow…

I feel super embarrassed now.

OP posts:
RonObvious · 21/04/2022 08:09

Fuck me. This is why I find people so complicated (am neurodiverse) - where exactly is this "over-sharing" boundary? Most of my friends and colleagues know almost nothing about me, because I have no idea where the line is, and I don't want to step over it. It's kind of a lonely feeling though, as it means that most of the people in my life don't really know who I am.

OP: what you are talking about doesn't sound like over-sharing to me - people are asking you, and you are answering them. I hate this whole second guessing thing, where if people ask you a simple question, you are supposed to answer in some kind of predefined, socially acceptable manner, rather than just telling the simple truth!

oliviastwisted · 21/04/2022 08:09

I think there may be something to what your friend is saying. I went through hell a couple of years back and it was definitely one for therapy. At the start I ended up dumping on people in a way that probably wasn’t fair on them in hindsight. I was pretty maniac from the trauma of it so it really wasn’t me behaving in my right mind. But others have done the same to me about various issues over the years so it is human nature. I mean what did humans do before therapy drink away their feelings, take there trauma out on someone else, not the healthiest.