Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that the Spice Girls were absolute rubbish?

115 replies

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 20/04/2022 22:13

Just that really. I think some of them could sing, one better than all of them, but their songs and persona, just no. I was about 16 when they appeared on the scene, so I was too old to be their target audience, I suppose. But I've always thought they were very Emperor's New Clothes.

OP posts:
the80sweregreat · 21/04/2022 10:29

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Lots of rubbish things are a success though - just look at Boris, the tool.
Yep, life is strange !
the80sweregreat · 21/04/2022 10:28

They made millions out of it , at least Mel C admits it was fun and more about the exposure than the actual singing!
They were huge in the states too , more so than Robbie Williams who flopped badly over there

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 21/04/2022 10:25

FairyCakeWings · 20/04/2022 22:20

Yabu because even if you didn’t like them, you can’t argue with the success they had. They can’t have been that rubbish!

Lots of rubbish things are a success though - just look at Boris, the tool.

Gowithme · 21/04/2022 10:25

I think they were fun and all appeared to be having a fantastic time, knew who they were, were just being themselves, all best friends and were really living their best lives, I think that's what appealed about them - even if it was all completely fake. It's like the show 'Friends', I think its popularity is a lot down to people wishing they were like the characters and wishing they had friends that were like the other characters.

nearlyspringyay · 21/04/2022 10:23

I was 14 when they appeared, it was something for teen girls to idolise, as was always this. Not great singers, but look at most of the manufactured pop bands, there are always crap singers. It is the 'x' factor and marketability that makes their success. Only Gary in TT could sing properly, and he was always ridiculed as the ugly one. He's grown into himself now.

Take a 'proper' band, eg Foo Fighters, they're musicians first but also marketable. There are bands all over the place and singers who are brilliant but they don't have it.

mycatisannoying · 21/04/2022 10:17

YABU!

GoFishandChips · 21/04/2022 10:14

*Not Girl Talk but Girl Thing

GoFishandChips · 21/04/2022 10:11

They were of their time and I don't think there has been a group like them before or since. They were of kind of cartoon group with the individual personalities (which were arguably stereotypical male fantasies but also appealed to young girls) They were loud and in your face, brash and colorful. I wouldn't choose to listen to their music now but I do think of them with fond nostalgia.

I think their management tried to replicate the success with a group called Girl Talk (if i'm remembering correctly) they were heavily marketed, given a Smash Hits cover (which was a big deal at the time and unheard of for a new band) and they were a complete flop, so there was more to it than marketing with the Spice Girls.

SVRT19674 · 21/04/2022 10:09

YANBU. They were shite. But then, I was over 20 when they came out, so not the target market. I remember little 6 year olds would show you their choreography and sing along. Pretty harmless really. I preferred All Saints.😎

CharSiu · 21/04/2022 09:58

I was too old to be in the demographic that was targeted as in my late twenties. At that time I was partying in London and having a whale of a time. I knew quite a few people, that worked in glam professions. They were very sneery about The Spice girls. It was of it’s time and when I hear them on the radio now as a very late middle aged woman it reminds me of a more carefree fun time when my bones didn’t ache.

crackingreward · 21/04/2022 09:41

@Ifailed

What did they stand for?

Doing as they were told.

.

Haha, yes.

crackingreward · 21/04/2022 09:40

What a lot of people miss when criticising artists or bands is that popularity is so much more than an ability to sing or dance. It's a mix of charisma, appeal, being right for the times, capturing the mood of a nation.

I actually think that it's the nation missing the fact that artists should be able to sing. It's the basics of their model.

DeclineandFall · 21/04/2022 09:17

I hated the fact they pretended they'd invented girlpower in pop. Did no-one remember Banarama? But then every generation thinks they've invented the wheel.

itsgoodtobehome · 21/04/2022 09:09

I saw them in concert once. They were dreadful. Their voices weren't powerful enough to project to the audience, and they had no stage presence whatsoever. I forgot what I was doing there after a while!!

the80sweregreat · 21/04/2022 09:04

They didn't really stand for anything , but at least they didn't feel the need to flash their knickers every five minutes and mostly covered up ( I know Geri's dresses could be a bit short , but not all the time)
I loved how they played up to their characters too, Emma could wear a baby spice t shirt and jeans and still look great.

veronicagoldberg · 21/04/2022 09:02

They were brilliant. They really captured the zeitgeist.

What a lot of people miss when criticising artists or bands is that popularity is so much more than an ability to sing or dance. It's a mix of charisma, appeal, being right for the times, capturing the mood of a nation.

IncompleteSenten · 21/04/2022 09:00

Yes they were. Most of these groups put together by execs are.
Find some good looking young people, exploit the fuck out of them, chuck them on the rubbish heap and autotune the next lot. 🤷‍♀️

RichardsGear · 21/04/2022 08:58

I never liked them but I was about 20 and madly into Britpop when they popped up. My 15 yr old DD is into the TikTok fuelled 90s revival and played Wannabe the other day in the car saying how much she loves it. It was shite at the time and is still shite now 😆.

sst1234 · 21/04/2022 08:58

They were a great brand for their time: a great business move. Like others said, it wasn’t about the singing. Well done Simon Fuller.

Ifailed · 21/04/2022 08:55

What did they stand for?

Doing as they were told.

crackingreward · 21/04/2022 08:51

@Barneysma2

Yes they weren't the best singers but it wasn't so much about that but more about what they stood for and their entertainment value and they did have some great songs. For example out of Gary Barlow and Robbie Williams, Gary has the better voice but who would I rather see in concert? Robbie for sure as he would be so entertaining to watch.
.

What did they stand for?

PuppyMonkey · 21/04/2022 08:50

I remember them quite fondly now as a fun part of the era, but I do recall at the time I was getting seriously bored of them - long before Gerry left etc.

JassyRadlett · 21/04/2022 08:49

The 'hot take/controversial opinion' that the Spice Girls aren't all that has been around since about 10 minutes after Wannabe was released.

I think some of the freshness may have worn off now.

Barneysma2 · 21/04/2022 08:44

Yes they weren't the best singers but it wasn't so much about that but more about what they stood for and their entertainment value and they did have some great songs. For example out of Gary Barlow and Robbie Williams, Gary has the better voice but who would I rather see in concert? Robbie for sure as he would be so entertaining to watch.

the80sweregreat · 21/04/2022 08:42

It made a change seeing a new British girl group instead of Take that or Boy-zone all the time on top of the pops!