Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that the Spice Girls were absolute rubbish?

115 replies

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 20/04/2022 22:13

Just that really. I think some of them could sing, one better than all of them, but their songs and persona, just no. I was about 16 when they appeared on the scene, so I was too old to be their target audience, I suppose. But I've always thought they were very Emperor's New Clothes.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ambereeree · 21/04/2022 19:01

I remember thinking they were awful and embarrassing at the time- I was a teen listening to "cool" britpop mid 90s but I secretly liked when two become one.
All Saints were too try hard alternative with their cargo pants.

balalake · 21/04/2022 18:41

They were awful, what was worse was some of the others who followed in their slipstream, so to speak. Bewitched, Westlife (who I called Pondlife until I realised I was being offensive to frogs, fish and other pond residents), Atomic Kitten, to name three.

Agree about the comments about Shaznay of All Saints, perhaps the only one with talent.

Rosehugger · 21/04/2022 15:18

LetHimHaveIt · 21/04/2022 13:15

At least they had five distinctive personalities, even if they were essentially caricatures. The Appleton sisters were to 'All Saints' what John and Terry were to E17, while Blatt was an unpleasant bully. It was really only Shaznay who had anything approaching talent; and I'm not really sure how much of that. 'I Know Where It's At' was pretty catchy, but I never got the appeal of 'Pure Shores'. Everyone behaving like they were 'Fleetwood Mac', or something - they were fractionally cooler and edgier than The Spice Girls, but they were still a load of Italia Conti 'Mels' at the end of the day. Without the record sales

Absolutely. All Saints took themselves far too seriously in a way that the Spice Girls never did.

Rosehugger · 21/04/2022 15:15

They were not amazing singers, but they were good performers and could put a song across. I think they all knew that they had been lucky and in the right place at the right time, and had a good sense of humour, and were about having a good time. They had a lovely energy about them. Plus I am about the same age and was a in a group of five friends (still friends now) and it felt like we had a lot in common.

the80sweregreat · 21/04/2022 14:03

There were plenty of good girl groups around pre The Spice Girls, why they thought the public wouldn't like another one I've no idea.
Playing up to their own cartoon characters was genius , say ' ginger spice ' or ' baby spice' to most people and they know who they are , even if they were only small when they were really famous.
I did like All saints too, but not as much as the spices who had the best catchy pop songs at that time.
I admit that ' spiceworld, the movie ' was dire though. They couldn't act very well , but it all added the 'Brit pop ' agenda well I suppose with lots of Union jacks and so on.

DrManhattan · 21/04/2022 14:03

Total rubbish, no idea why they were so popular at the time.

Whitewolf2 · 21/04/2022 13:58

Spice Girls was the first album I owned, I was the core target market and I loved them! Now of course I can look back see that the songs and singing were not exactly the ‘best’ however you want to measure that, but they were so fun and different at the time. The marketing certainly worked on me!

UhtredsLatestPaganHussy · 21/04/2022 13:31

I'd be shook if someone compared me to John or Tezza from E17 Grin

Tabitha005 · 21/04/2022 13:29

@LetHimHaveIt - 'Italia Conti Mels' had me in stitches!

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/04/2022 13:27

EinsteinaGogo · 20/04/2022 22:24

Of course they weren't rubbish.

They were different.
They were entertaining,
Their songs were mainly catchy.
They sold millions.
They made a sell out movie,
Most of them are still wealthy
Some of them are still very famous

What's your definition of rubbish?

Something I don't like. Spice Girls may have been successful, but tbh lots of crap (imo) groups are successful.

However, I do remember reading that their record label wasn't particularly keen on promoting them because they didn't think girl groups would sell. That annoyed me.

Tabitha005 · 21/04/2022 13:27

I was on the fence re: Spice Girls - neither liked nor loathed them, but at least they had some level of identifiable personalities and looked different to one another and gave as good as they got in interviews, whereas most girl groups never really seemed to have much to say. Musically, I always preferred girl groups like The Sugababes and All Saints, but I do think Spice Girls caught a zeitgeist with the 'girl power' thing and rode that wave for all it was worth.

For my money, the 'most crap' girl group of recent times is Little Mix - truly risible 'music' and styling. I accidentally caught one of their videos whilst flicking through the music channels the other night - can't recall the name of the song, but the video is (unintentionally, I'm sure) hilarious! They're in a warehouse, all decked out in some mash-up of bondage/fetish/goth gear. DH and I were pissing ourselves laughing. The faces they're pulling and the 'punching yourself through a wall', over-the-top contrived dance moves (which none of them can pull off with any aplomb whatsoever) had me suspecting their management, stylist, choreographer, producer and director alike were all in it together to ensure Little Mix's career hit the skids thereafter. If you need a laugh, I recommend finding it on You Tube.

UhtredsLatestPaganHussy · 21/04/2022 13:26

they were still a load of Italia Conti 'Mels' at the end of the day

Grin absolutely

I liked Never Ever, mostly just the intro tbh, but think their being 'cooler' than the Spice Girls was so over-egged.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 21/04/2022 13:19

GoFishandChips · 21/04/2022 10:14

*Not Girl Talk but Girl Thing

One of them was in Hollyoaks I think, and married one of Westlife (or Boyzone!)

OP posts:
LetHimHaveIt · 21/04/2022 13:15

At least they had five distinctive personalities, even if they were essentially caricatures. The Appleton sisters were to 'All Saints' what John and Terry were to E17, while Blatt was an unpleasant bully. It was really only Shaznay who had anything approaching talent; and I'm not really sure how much of that. 'I Know Where It's At' was pretty catchy, but I never got the appeal of 'Pure Shores'. Everyone behaving like they were 'Fleetwood Mac', or something - they were fractionally cooler and edgier than The Spice Girls, but they were still a load of Italia Conti 'Mels' at the end of the day. Without the record sales

Badger1970 · 21/04/2022 13:14

Our DD's loved them, and we had the horror of seeing them live in concert once. I can't tell you how bad their singing was, even Mel C was struggling.

As for girl power, what a heap of shit. Prancing around half naked isn't girl power. Nor is getting involved with men in relationships and newborn babies, is it Geri...............

Bananarama21 · 21/04/2022 13:09

Very much the era of the time in the 90s pop music many of those girl bands and boy bands were rubbish..the only decent music of that time was the clubland. If spice girls came out now I don't think they would be any where near successful.

CurlyBurley · 21/04/2022 13:05

Utter rubbish and the girl power stuff was just embarrassing. I always cringed when Geri or Mel B spoke, they both came across as utter idiots. Rest of them less offensive.

Goodyetalso · 21/04/2022 12:56

I was about 18 when they appeared and very into indie/rock so not their demographic. I remember thinking they were shit but in a funny way and quite liking them for it.

I never understood why they were seen as such empowered women though as they were very clearly managed and marketed to the last second of their time. Yes, they all supposedly had different styles and personalities, but these were massively played upon as a marketing strategy too to the point where it was difficult for any of them to change if they wanted to.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 21/04/2022 12:48

Kite22 · 20/04/2022 23:30

This ^

As had been said, the band was put together as a 'product' and, lets be honest, it was an extremely successful business model which plenty of others have gone on to try and copy with far less success.

Whether their songs are to your taste or not doesn't make them rubbish, it probably means you aren't a teenage girl.

I was a teenage girl when they appeared but was more interested in Oasis and Blur.

OP posts:
Fidodidit · 21/04/2022 10:53

Ultimate “zeitgeist” band. The production value of the songs wasn’t great and I think that shows up now - something like “Pure Shores” by All Saints still sounds good but the SG songs sound like they are tied together with string.

BogRollBOGOF · 21/04/2022 10:46

They had a freshness, energy and personality that was very of the moment, but actually stands up in a retro, nostalgia way. I was 15 when they came out and not deeply impressed but I remember them fondly and think their music holds its place compared to more recent but similar acts.

Was "Girl Power" a revolution in feminism, not really, but as a teenage girl that being "equal to boys" message was empowering in its own way-better than the messages my mother was getting 20 years earlier. You could choose to be sexy or sporty. Sporty Spice was my least favourite of the time, but was actually the most positive charicature presented.

Musically they do have a distinctive sound across different styles. They are recognisable where many girl groups merge together and they've had enough talent to hold successful solo careers. They weren't one-hit wonders or faded into obscurity.

10 years or so earlier and the charts were very male-led. I've got Now2 from 83-84 and 24 of the 30 acts were male/ male dominated, I've not counted the mixed bands with female lead vocalist like the Eurythmics. Many of the female artists on there weren't British either with an American bias.

They still play well as fun pop records, were part of the zeitgeist and are part of a positive legacy in female pop music.

Trulyweird1 · 21/04/2022 10:37

I have great memories of my nieces, nephews and various friends children, singing along, doing the dance moves , having fun.
They helped change the way young women were perceived , with their focus on fun and friendship. ( yes I seriously believe that)
They were of the moment. They were not All Saints however…

avamiah · 21/04/2022 10:37

I think they came out at the right time and got Lucky but they had a Great Manager and they were actually put together and basically moulded into something that over time became very successful and made a lot of people very wealthy including themselves.

Indicatrice · 21/04/2022 10:31

YANBU, they were crap but hypnotic, like most girl and boy bands.

I remember watching ‘wannabe’ when it came out on The Box like a zombie, knowing it was crap but couldn’t look away.

MadameCholetsDirtySecret · 21/04/2022 10:29

Managed and marketed pop is always the same. Banal, anodine and formulaic. There are so many ‘bands’ over the decades who fall into this bracket. It isn’t good music but it fills a need in pre teens/teens who like safe idols.
i can’t be that upset by it. Ffs I liked Donny Osmand back in the day. 🤣