Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's so great about having two kids?

56 replies

anatomyoftiredness · 20/04/2022 21:20

There's been lots of threads about having a third child recently.

I would love to have a third but for a number of reasons, and with a very very heavy heart, will be sticking with my two.

Tell me all the reasons why two is the magic number and that I definitely won't be full of regret on my death bed.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CoffeePlease89 · 26/04/2022 20:46

Ha, I'm quite glad to come across this post!

I'm 32, have a DD 6 and a DS 3 (nearly 4) and all I've been thinking about for the last few months is the possibility of a third.
No idea why, never imagined I'd consider another, but my youngest is at full time nursery now as he's starting reception in september and as I work Part Time I find I'm twiddling my thumbs sometimes and think it would be nice to have a bigger family.

But then my anxiety hits and I think how my DS and DD are the absolute best of friends, and why would I change that?
Something awful could happen to me during childbirth, how selfish to leave my two kids? The new baby could be born with disabilities and again I'd feel selfish to change the dynamic. I hate the newborn stage, mine woke every hour or so and it was hell, so why do I have urges to do it all again.

I realise, it's because I'm 32, and my youngest is about to become a boy instead of a toddler, some of my friends are only just starting to have babies... and I feel a bit lost. Kinda wish I was TTC my second again because it was so exciting and a no brainer. Its weird without a pram. I see others with 3 kids and feel a bit jealous. What do I do with myself now?

But I know really, deep down, it's better for me to stick with 2, we can afford 2, we cherish our 2, we have a girl and a boy, they are both healthy, I'm so lucky. I can't risk ruining that. I'm also fat, and I need to concentrate on my own health, for the kids I've got. 🙃

I love this thread, makes me realise there are so many people with just 2 because atm everywhere I look I feel like I'm one of the only women with "just" 2!!

Ahgoonyegirlye · 25/04/2022 07:30

money and logistics! lots of things are hearted towards a family of 4 when it come to tickets, holidays, cars, travel.
2 means you aren’t outnumbered as parents.
2 means no middle child!
2 means having more time and attention for the 2 you have for sports, homework, friendships etc…
I know 2 families who went for no. 3 and had twins…

honeylulu · 25/04/2022 06:59

When they reach teenage years and you have to deal with uni, driving lessons, keeping check on mental health, being an emotional support that balances respect for their privacy with concern for their wellbeing, new trainers (and adult sized clothes), social media worries, skateboard accidents, hours talking about career choices and work experience, giving lifts late at night, first trips abroad without parents, being able to pay for private counselling/medical care if they need it and the waiting list on NHS is soooo long, then they pass the driving test and you start thinking about getting an old banger or putting them on your insurance (omg), needing extra space in your house for a separate gaming/TV room (can't recommend enough), phones, phone contracts, laptopsfor college, adult sized clothes (and you can't get away with nipping too Primark any more), school/ college residential trips including abroad, allowance/spending money, wondering if you should start a LISA to help with first house deposit ... honestly you'll be so glad you stopped at two.

My two are nearly 10 years apart which wasn't planned but I'm even glad about because I've got time to save up for the second round and (most importantly) enough time and emotional and mental energy to dedicate to them.

That!

Mybobowler · 25/04/2022 06:11

Fairislefandango · 20/04/2022 21:35

One of the things that has made me most happy in my life is the relationship between my two children. They wouldn't openly admit it to anyone else but they are best friends, which is pretty amazing since they are an only just 14yo boy and a nearly 17yo girl.

We recently had the possibility of a complex relocation which might have involved me and dd staying put for a year and dh and ds relocating ahead of us. The brief anguished look that passed between ds and dd when we mentioned that possibility brought tears to my eyes (and I'm quite a hard nut!). I couldn't imagine them having quite that bond if there were a 3rd sibling in the mix.

This is so lovely to read. I have a daughter and a son with the same age gap and I hardly dare imagine that they'll be this close growing up.

Some very helpful tips here. I feel a bit bereft that we've agreed to stop at two, and this thread is helping me to keep some perspective!

For me, in addition to all the above, I have a feeling of not wanting to push my luck. I have two healthy children in a happy, healthy marriage and I think it would be best to quit while we're ahead. My youngest is still only a baby so I've informed my husband that we'll be getting a dog when I inevitably get broody for another baby in a few years' time.

RowanAlong · 25/04/2022 06:08

Attention and money - more to go round if you stick with two.

TheDug4 · 25/04/2022 05:54

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 20/04/2022 21:31

The third might be twins. Or triplets.

Yes! This happened to someone I know of. She went from 2 to 5 kids.

WindyKnickers · 25/04/2022 04:59

As someone who found herself unexpectedly a single parent I think 3 kids would have been too much for me to manage- money, house size, my time and energy. Being outnumbered 3 to 1. Plus my children are good friends with each other and I think I third could have upset that dynamic.

violetbunny · 25/04/2022 04:43

You have an heir and a spare?

NurseBernard · 24/04/2022 22:33

I know much of this depends on the personalities of the children and the environment we create for them, but I think because I don't have any real life examples of that close relationship in adulthood, I feel like it doesn't exist - though I'm sure it must!

My experience is the exact opposite - all the close adult sibling relationships I know, are brother / sister.

I planned my DC’s age gap to be the same as the gap between me and my DB, because of a). how close we were growing up, and b). how good friends we are now as adults. And my DS and DD are the best of friends.

My oldest friend is really close to her brother. My cousins (male and female) are close, and my second oldest friend is closer to her brother than either of her sisters. By close, I mean, actual good friends who spend a lot of time together - are very much in one another’s lives.

And I know it’s not real life - but even TV shows depict close brother-sister relationships, where they’re actual friends as well as siblings (Friends, Modern Family, etc).

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 24/04/2022 22:23

I won't lie, I Iove having three but it is definitely easier with two although I can't tell you really why one child tips it over the edge! Practical reasons never bothered me but a friend once said if you're going to have three you may as well have 4 simply because most family things come in 4s or 6s! Definitely true. I don't have the middle sibling thing as I have twins.
Sometimes it bothers me that we can't do the same stuff as friends because x3 it becomes financially unviable but I wouldn't change my decision.

dangermouseisace · 24/04/2022 22:22

I have 3. Maybe I wouldn’t be divorced with just 2? Who knows?
I constantly feel like I’ve failed them all. Like I could have given 2 a better quality of life. Housing has been an issue. Not enough space!
Of course, I love all 3 and they are all fabulous, I wouldn’t change my situation. But there are definite benefits to only having 2.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 24/04/2022 22:19

I would love to have a third so much, and if money were no object I definitely would.

But I grew up quite poor. Not in poverty - I was always fed and clothed and warm. But money was always an issue and a constant worry in our family - it overshadowed everything and we often had to do without.

With two children we’re fairly comfortable. With three I’m sure we could probably manage, but I don’t think it would be comfortable. And my parents spent my childhood ‘managing’ and it really wasn’t fun, for them or me.

anatomyoftiredness · 24/04/2022 22:05

Thanks all for your replies.

The practical reasons for sticking with two never really carry much weight for me, as I feel like for us they would be mostly surmountable.

But @Fairislefandango that's lovely to hear that your son and daughter are so close.

It's the dynamic of two that sometimes worries me.

I have a son and daughter and worry that they won't be close.

With all my friends and cousins etc. there are no brother-sister sibling sets that are close.

I know much of this depends on the personalities of the children and the environment we create for them, but I think because I don't have any real life examples of that close relationship in adulthood, I feel like it doesn't exist - though I'm sure it must!

OP posts:
Springandsummerarecoming · 23/04/2022 11:46

We nearly went for 3 but changed our minds. I’m so glad we did. As the children have got older they are getting way more expensive! Growing out of clothes so quickly I can’t believe what fit with room at Xmas is now too small. Of course they also like brands like Nike etc which aren’t cheap either. They eat sooo much too. Want lifts out and about etc etc.

LuaDipa · 23/04/2022 11:10

I have two because I knew that I could cope with them whatever the circumstances. I really wanted more but I worried about dh or I having to raise that many alone in the event of something bad happening so we stuck with our two and they are lovely.

Sausagerollfiend · 23/04/2022 10:12

When kids are young they're physically draining. But once they're teens, it's mentally exhausting. I've got 2 and I just don't think my mental health could have coped with another one! The worries, the exams, their mental health, their friendship problems.... the list goes on. Stick to two!!

thebookeatinggirl · 23/04/2022 10:09

Time for each child, money (child care costs especially) space (house, cars, hotels) and for me sanity - I know people do brilliantly with large families and lots of children, but for me, two saw me at parenting capacity.

Pixies74 · 23/04/2022 10:03

There's no extra benefit from having more than two children (two has the extra benefit over one of the children having a sibling).

There's just more financial expense, more emotional expenditure, less time and energy for each child, less time amd energy for yourself, prolonging the sleep deprivation and the extreme dependence stage.. For no extra benefit...

Needless to say, I can't comprehend how anyone rationally decides to have more than two children, seems to me like it's a more physical broodiness.

cigarettesNalcohol · 23/04/2022 09:56

3 makes it even harder to connect and have quality time with your partner.
Less time for socialising with your friends, less time for progressing in your career, less time for a hobby or sport. Less time to read books, less time to look after your mental health.

Refrosty · 23/04/2022 09:34

Every time we holiday with the whole family, issues always arise from the family member with three kids (the couple earn a very good wage but it's more spread out between them all, especially as all kids are now older so costs increased and it's usually an extra £1-2k for travel and accommodation). For this family, it's more expensive to do anything worth doing and the parents have to scale down the kids expectations (especially regarding shopping for stuff on holiday, tickets etc). What ends up happening is other family members will chip in or else it's near impossible for that family to join us on most holidays, plus there's guilt from adults around buying for/doing stuff with our kids and not anything for these 3 (which is not good for any child to experience, plus we are all family, so it's more like a gift from aunt to nephew etc).

Children are expensive. I'm stopping at two because right now, we can give enough to both and a third would completely disrupt that. I'd then feel guilty.

TheUsualChaos · 23/04/2022 08:32

If money was no object and I didn't have to work, maybe I'd have 3 even 4 children. (Although I still think I'd probably stick at two as would also consider environmental impact of a larger family).
But in my circumstances of being an low middle income household and working 30 hours a week, DH fulltime, 2 children feels the max we can manage without being completely overstretched both financially and emotionally.

Everything would change significantly with one more child. We would need a bigger car, a bigger house, our time would be even more stretched between juggling work, school and activities. Holidays and staying away with family would become a lot more expensive and difficult especially as children got older. The grandparents can just about manage to look after two on the odd occasion for us. Not sure they would do it if there was one more! The list could go on and on!

user1506328491 · 23/04/2022 08:21

You can give them more time and attention than if you had 3.

LuckyAmy1986 · 23/04/2022 08:20

In this day and age I can’t fathom why on earth you would want to bring another baby into the world, especially when you already have two. It’s not just about you and your want for a baby. think about the child you will have who will then become an adult who has to live in this world and try to make the best of it. Then look at the state of the world and where things are going. Then really think about if it’s a good idea or if you should just concentrate on providing a hopefully nice life for the two you have had. I know what I would do.

PurplePinecone · 23/04/2022 08:13

Made the decision to stick with two. Since, I have been relieved as the costs just seem to go up and up. Beyond the preschool childcare costs, once they get to a certain age then it's swimming lessons, music lessons, any other clubs they want to do... Then once that's over its affording to help them with university costs if they choose to go. Now a days parents are expected to contribute. Then beyond that, helping with house deposit, wedding costs etc. And that's not even factoring in holidays which is the primary reason we decided to stop at two at the time!.... So glad we stopped at two! Also so glad there is nearly a 5 year gap meaning university won't be at the same time for both! Two is expensive enough!

withacherryonthetop · 23/04/2022 08:13

What I’m realising is that as they get older, although more independent, everything takes so much time. Mine are 9 and 6 and soo many play dates, parties, clubs, homework, reading etc etc that I just don’t think I’d keep track of everything if there was a third in the mix too! Every day feels quite manic at the moment!