Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

3 months post separation too early for daughters to meet ex's new girlfriend?

34 replies

MilitantMandy · 20/04/2022 21:11

My husband and I separated in January - he left me with the children. I had previously asked him to leave several times due to drinking and obnoxious behaviour. Ostensibly he left due to his own "unhappiness" but it soon emerged he had an emotional relationship for two years with a woman he had met online. A week later he was visiting her abroad and he has been over there since - he is "in love" with her and they are "a couple." She is now coming over to visit him as well.

There are loads of issues, financial and otherwise, and obviously the whole thing is miserable and humiliating for me, but luckily he isn't physically violent or anything very scary. He is very insistent however that my children meet his girlfriend and I have said that IF I've met her first AND I feel I can trust her (I mean hahahahaha in the circumstances but anyway) the children can meet her, but not until next year. This has driven my husband to distraction and he is sending long nasty messages about "custody" and me not having the right to determine that. They are also insisting on going to pubs etc less than 5 minutes' walk from my house, so I feel a little terrorised as I don't want the girls to see them together. And he doesn't even live in the area any more - and London is a big place ffs.

So what i would like to know is whether iabu in saying it's too early for them to see children as a couple, for the following reasons:

  1. I can't trust her as she was a factor in breakdown of marriage
  2. Girls are young (12 and 10) and easily manipulated
  3. They may split up
  4. Worried about them taking girls abroad
  5. Effect on me - girls see me more upset
  6. Girls still processing what has happened - just seems to early to me
  7. Worried it's being used as a stick to beat me with, and to prove seriousness to girlfriend
  8. Just too bloody early and raw for all of us
  9. Safeguarding issue around drinking if he has them for weekends away etc (currently under control) - now agitating for whole weekends

Please tell me : AIBU to say girls don't meet her until early 2023, once I've met her myself?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Itsallchange · 22/04/2022 10:44

I totally understand how you are feeling however as has been said you don’t have a say on when to make that call, he effectively can do what he likes with them during his time…..unless it becomes a safeguarding issue, in which case you have to take photos, keep a written record and then report it to social services for advice. All the family court will care is that the children are having a relationship with their father however hard that is for you. Be the bigger parent (not to sound patronising so apologies if it does) gather your thoughts and feelings and keep them away from the children, encourage the relationship (they will see him for what he is!) be there for them and comfort them, show them that you love them and will keep them safe and in the long run they will know who really cares about their welfare. Good luck sweetheart

PicaK · 22/04/2022 07:31

Understand your pain but you can't lay down the law in this way.

AntarcticTern · 22/04/2022 07:19

I agree with you that three months is early, but next year is completely unrealistic! As others have said, you just have to suck it up and concentrate on co-parenting amicably. That's the main aim here.

AchillesPoirot · 22/04/2022 07:18

I understand why you feel as you do. However you can't insist on anything

If he's a fit person to have access to the DC without supervision you can't dictate what he does while he has them and this includes introducing them to whom ever he likes

I have never met my ex's now wife - never wanted to and never will. She's been at two events I've been at and I've just nodded in passing to her. Whether I approve of her or not is irrelevant - he's picked her, she's in their lives regardless.

Kiiiiiiik · 22/04/2022 07:13

this is one of those things where *as much as people demand...

Stupid phone.

Kiiiiiiik · 22/04/2022 07:12

And agree with PP. You're never going to know whether you trust someone after one brief meeting.

You don't want them to meet her, for their sakes but I also think because you just don't like it either, and this is your way of trying to control that situation. But it's not up to you.

Kiiiiiiik · 22/04/2022 07:11

I really don't disagree with you that it's too soon but I still voted YABU.

and I have said that IF I've met her first AND I feel I can trust her (I mean hahahahaha in the circumstances but anyway) the children can meet her, but not until next year

You can't demand stuff like this. It isn't for you to tell him what he can and can't do or who he can and can't introduce his children to. They are just as much his as yours and he can do what he likes with them during his time (safeguarding concerns aside which this is not).

This is one of those things where we much as people remand you have a right as the childrens mother to know X Y or Z, you actually don't have any right to veto the people your children's dad wants them to meet on his time. Not legally or even morally really imo.

By all means tell him you're uncomfortable with it but no you cannot tell him he can't do something.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 22/04/2022 06:50

Echoing PP, it really isn't up to you. I understand as I'm divorced myself but you can't make those kind of demands.

Presumably you trust your ex husband with the children, so you also have to trust his decisions when they are in his care.

Asking to meet her first to see if you "trust" her is ridiculous, how could you achieve that in one meeting? Do you usually decide that you can or can't trust someone after meeting them once?

Unfortunately this is one of those situations where you don't really get a say.

AuntieStella · 22/04/2022 06:34

I agree with you that it's far too soon.

I also agree with all the posters pointing out that you can't do a damned thing about it

You cannot insist on meeting her first, and your approval isn't required (just as he doesn't get a right of veto on your future friends). And you can't lay down a timetable for him - I think an attempt to do that is also bad tactics, as its just a random time and it would be easy to make you look like a capricious control freak if he needs to argue for contact/holidays in court

He is their DDad, and unless you think he is planning on abducting then to live abroad, of course he can take them on holiday.

As a pp said, this is the nasty reality of separate parenting. Don't make it hard for the DDs to see their DDad, don't leave them feeling bad if they enjoy his company. Don't mention the new woman and don't ask any questions about her.

Do tell him that you think its far too soon, that it's been only three monnhs and you think everyone needs to have settled into the new pattern of coparenting for a little longer.

One big worry is that she will be the first of a parade of new girlfriends, but there's no way you're going to make him doubt for one second that she's not the great love of his life. So even though its a very good point, it won't work as a tactic right now.

This is tough, but I think your best bet is to wave them off and tell them to have a nice time and to enjoy seeing their father. And to continue to be the rock they can always come home to

jealousgirl · 22/04/2022 05:53

I'd say 3m is a bit quicker I'd want to leave it a couple of months longer. You meeting her first is a a great idea in theory (if it's more about getting to know each other than interviewing her) but their may not be keen.

HoppingPavlova · 22/04/2022 04:22

You just can’t dictate this stuff. He can do what he likes in this regard. It sucks when someone lacks decent judgement but nothing you can do about it.

BadNomad · 22/04/2022 02:34

Like others have said, you can't actually stop him from introducing his children to anyone. Nor can you insist on meeting her ever. In fact, you will be the one to get into bother if you withhold contact because of this. Be reasonable about holidays too because if you refuse he can take you to court to make it happen. Unfortunately, this is the reality of separate parenting.

Starseeking · 21/04/2022 21:19

Of course 3 months is far too soon for your DC to meet your EX's new girlfriend, however what your EX does in his time with your DC has nothing to do with you (assuming no safeguarding issues).

Your reasons 1-9 bear absolutely no relevance to anything that should dictate who your EX introduces your shared DC to. He is their equal parent.

So YABVVU, and I wouldn't be surprised if he introduces her to them on their next visit.

Pinkyxx · 21/04/2022 20:36

While I can understand and agree with all the points you make, the fact is you have no say whatsoever in whether your ex introduces his girlfriend or not. I asked my ex to wait to introduce our 3 year old to his girlfriend. He didn't wait, and felt it wise to introduce her as ''your new mummy'' - can you imagine the confusion in a 3 year old? The courts criticized him for the confusion he unnecessarily caused an infant who was already struggling but beyond that nothing more was said of it. Had she been 10 or 12 they wouldn't have batted an eyelid.

Yes it sucks, yes it's in poor taste, yes it's inconsiderate, yes it's very cliché but when it comes to children of divorce none of this matters. You'll need to work on separating how you feel about how he has treated you from what is in your children's best interest - which per the family court is to see their Father regularly. How he parents is really neither here or there. The most important thing is how you respond to this, if you make an issue out of it it will become an issue for your children. It's like asking your kids to pick a side and that is what creates loyalty binds and messes kids up massively in divorce. It's hard, I still remember how awful it was when my ex did this with the woman he'd been having an affair with for god knows how long.. It took ever inch of self control I had to never let is show and I'm glad I didn't. About 8 years after we'd separated I was out with my daughter and she out of the blue thanked me for never having made it difficult or about me when it came to her Dad / step Mother.

Children eventually see their parents for who they are. Be the parent that puts them first here, they'll thank you one day.

Whatever00 · 21/04/2022 20:20

Personally, I think waiting a year for a new partner to meet the kids is sensible. However, unfortunately it really isn't up to you. You can ask to meet her but you can't insist and you aren't in control of the time frame. On his time he can do what he wants as long as it isn't a risk to the children.

toastofthetown · 21/04/2022 20:09

While I don't think it's ideal, you have no control over who sees is children when it's his contact. If there are safeguarding concerns then supervised contact might be warranted, but not for introducing your children to someone you don;'t want your children to meet.

GreenClock · 21/04/2022 19:57

I’d take legal advice and formalise access through the divorce courts OP. I appreciate how difficult all this is and I am sorry that you’re going through it.

Re: point 5 “effect on me” - I think it’s very important that you keep your kids out of any arguments, dramas etc. The effect of the divorce on you should not be made into their problem. They need to see you coping.

NameChanged2022 · 21/04/2022 19:47

Sorry @MilitantMandy, you wouldn't have a leg to stand on in a family court room.

  1. I can't trust her as she was a factor in breakdown of marriage - family court won't care
  2. Girls are young (12 and 10) and easily manipulated - family court won't care
  3. They may split up - family court won't care
  4. Worried about them taking girls abroad - court sees holidays as beneficial to children where there are no proven safeguarding risks, so you wouldn't be able to prevent this in time
  5. Effect on me - girls see me more upset - family court won't care
  6. Girls still processing what has happened - just seems to early to me - family court won't care
  7. Worried it's being used as a stick to beat me with, and to prove seriousness to girlfriend - family court won't care
  8. Just too bloody early and raw for all of us - family court won't care
  9. Safeguarding issue around drinking if he has them for weekends away etc (currently under control) - now agitating for whole weekends - is his drinking an actual recognised issue?

Please tell me : AIBU to say girls don't meet her until early 2023, once I've met her myself? - yes you are being unreasonable with this time scale and with regards meeting her yourself? That's just weird.

What he chooses to do on his time with the girls is his choice - you can't control that.

worraliberty · 20/04/2022 22:44

Sorry this has happened OP but yes you are being unreasonable.

Also with regards to your DDs, kids are pretty resilient and tend to accept changes like this far more easily than the 'wronged' parent.

What normally fucks kids up isn't the break-up, it's how the adults act afterwards.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/04/2022 22:37

I think it's a bit odd to want to meet her first, but I also think it's way too soon to introduce boyfriends and girlfriends to your children.

He is clearly a twat though, and they are usually difficult to reason with.

Maydaysoonenough · 20/04/2022 22:34

Nowt like 2 sullen dc to dampen a new relationship op....
Out of your control sadly.

Keepitonthedownlow · 20/04/2022 22:32

Can you hide their passports somewhere? That's the worst case scenario obviously. Everything else is poor form on your exes part but not something that would be easy to control. How long is she over for? The fact they are planning on staying local is a good thing in a way as you will be nearby. Make sure it's just an afternoon or lunch and no more to start with. Also you could say to your DDs that your ex hasn't been seeing this woman that long so to just treat her as a new friend and not expect more.

What you're going through sounds very hard however.

Hospedia · 20/04/2022 22:22

As difficult as it is, you don't get to dictate whether he introduces the children to a new partner or not and you don't get to insist on meeting her first - would you accept him doing this to you and any future partners you have?

You need to be calm about the issue for the sake of your DC as you being stressed and uset will make them stressed and upset. Take the power play out of it too by not giving the dickhead the reaction he so obviously wants.

It could also be worth considering applying to the family court to formalise contact arrangements, particularly if you have safeguarding concerns or are worried he might take them abroad and not return them. This would also mean he can't make vague threats to you about "custody".

BlueOverYellow · 20/04/2022 22:22

You're not going to get to make this decision, unfortunately. You're not wrong, but he can introduce them to anybody he likes on his time with them unless there's a court order involved.

Good luck.

WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 20/04/2022 22:20

TinksBilly · 20/04/2022 22:12

Ummmmm I don’t know why everyone is being so reasonable at all. Not acceptable for him to introduce them to a girlfriend he’s basically just met, and of course you have the right to place rules on who they can be around and the situations they might be put in if those situations are potentially dangerous emotionally or physically

Morally unacceptable, unfortunately it's legally perfectly acceptable.

Ops list of reasons are basically a list of what ifs that a court wouldn't be interested in, and, if it did go as far as court the op would be seen as being obstructive.