Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Oh do piss off, Harry

543 replies

HettySunshine · 20/04/2022 11:34

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/apr/20/prince-harry-says-queen-on-great-form-during-visit?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

The Queen has coped for most of her life without you. I don't think she needs you 'protecting her' now.

I'm usually entire ambivalent to the royals but this has really bruised my cherry!

AIBU?

OP posts:
VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:55

IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 20:46

My mistake, I said group. But a conversation with even 1 person that has ‘concerns’ is unacceptable. Or is it ok if its just 1 person that’s racist? I prefer a zero tolerance policy.

And I prefer not to automatically believe a rather muddled and contradictory story from two individuals who have shown themselves to be unreliable narrators, to say the least.

Which version of the story do you 'choose' to believe?

I believe there were various conversations as Meghan said but one in particular that Harry was very offended by. I don’t believe that they would make up racism claims, but if you do that’s fine. We were not there after all.

VladmirsPoutine · 21/04/2022 20:53

Thank goodness there isn't a nonce running around in the royal family. There's only a half black woman who appears to not know her station being protected by her 'controlled' husband - what a wench!

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:53

Butfirstcoffees · 21/04/2022 20:35

The Royal Family isn't just any family though. And actually as a mixed race woman I absolutely expected my white grandparents to not accept racisim directed towards me in their home. By their own children or their staff (if they had them).

I don't believe it was a racist comment. However, I don't believe in that family you can claim that many of them were racist but then also pretend it's nothing to do with the Queen.

He also was angry and hurt that, as they saw it, no protected them against the press.

I dont think they should blame the Queen. I dont think you can say 'we were the victims of the RF.....but the Queen is great and is lovely and always supported us'

I agree that if this was my family, it would be everyone’s argument. In fact it was, some of my nieces and nephews have an Indian dad. There were some racist comments made many years ago about him and the kids. Those people making them were firmly told that it won’t be tolerated. Many of us stopped seeing the racist relatives when the comments continued.

Did it happen in the Queens home? I guess we don’t know if anyone in the family spoke up, it’s very bad if they didn’t. For me, not being racist isn’t enough, you would have to speak up. But we don’t know who said what.

Blossomtoes · 21/04/2022 20:50

IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 20:46

My mistake, I said group. But a conversation with even 1 person that has ‘concerns’ is unacceptable. Or is it ok if its just 1 person that’s racist? I prefer a zero tolerance policy.

And I prefer not to automatically believe a rather muddled and contradictory story from two individuals who have shown themselves to be unreliable narrators, to say the least.

Which version of the story do you 'choose' to believe?

I haven’t even chosen not to believe it. It lacks credibility as far as I’m concerned. Harry looked really shifty when he was asked about it. If they said who it was I might question that it could possibly be the truth.

MissPolliezDolly · 21/04/2022 20:49

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:17

But then Meghan wasn’t part of the conversation was she? Nor can they decide between themselves when it was - early stages of relationship, during pregnancy. Who knows.

I don’t thing Oprah’s main concern was pinpointing exactly when it was, the important thing is that it was said at all. If you choose to believe it didn’t happen, that’s one thing, none of us were there so can’t prove it. But anyone on here stating ‘concerns’ over skin colour are ok, normal and not racist are very wrong.

I agree that these conversations can be ugly. But I honestly don’t believe that in this instance it was. I think Meghan knew exactly what she was doing when she made her claim and the more time goes on the more Harry and Meghan will discredit themselves.

I was very much for them when they got together but not anymore.

IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 20:46

My mistake, I said group. But a conversation with even 1 person that has ‘concerns’ is unacceptable. Or is it ok if its just 1 person that’s racist? I prefer a zero tolerance policy.

And I prefer not to automatically believe a rather muddled and contradictory story from two individuals who have shown themselves to be unreliable narrators, to say the least.

Which version of the story do you 'choose' to believe?

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:42

IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 20:29

And maybe you wouldn’t have been offended and sad and felt awkward at a group of white people having those ‘concerns’ but Meghan and Harry did.

So it's a 'group' of people now?

And, depending on which version of the story you choose to believe, Harry can't have been all that offended, since he didn't bother to tell his wife for months or even years.

My mistake, I said group. But a conversation with even 1 person that has ‘concerns’ is unacceptable. Or is it ok if its just 1 person that’s racist? I prefer a zero tolerance policy.

x2boys · 21/04/2022 20:41

Soffit · 21/04/2022 20:20

The only member of the current royal family to have done anything racist in living memory is Harry himself when he dressed up as a Nazi. It never just happened on a whim. Some planning would have gone into it. He must have had the right sort of 'attitude' to pull it off among his friends. He probably wishes that it had never got out but he has never apologized for it. Probably induced by the trauma inflicted upon him by his birth family 😁

I think you will find Prince Philip wasent averse to a bit of casual racism
Didn't he once say something about "slitty eyes"?

Butfirstcoffees · 21/04/2022 20:35

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 19:12

Confused Just because someone else in the family made a racist comment, doesn’t mean the Queen is racist. Does that really need explaining?

The Royal Family isn't just any family though. And actually as a mixed race woman I absolutely expected my white grandparents to not accept racisim directed towards me in their home. By their own children or their staff (if they had them).

I don't believe it was a racist comment. However, I don't believe in that family you can claim that many of them were racist but then also pretend it's nothing to do with the Queen.

He also was angry and hurt that, as they saw it, no protected them against the press.

I dont think they should blame the Queen. I dont think you can say 'we were the victims of the RF.....but the Queen is great and is lovely and always supported us'

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:33

Fine to say it didn’t happen, none of us know. I choose to believe them, others don’t have to.

Blossomtoes · 21/04/2022 20:30

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:24

We’re a mixed race family and we comment on the possible colour of everything about any baby we’re waiting on.

Very different to a group of white people discussing their ‘concerns’ over skin colour. Do you feel ‘concerned’ that these babies will be too dark or too light skinned? Is there a skin colour that could in some way be wrong and ‘concerning’ to you on a baby you’re going to love. And maybe you wouldn’t have been offended and sad and felt awkward at a group of white people having those ‘concerns’ but Meghan and Harry did.

Or just made the whole thing up. If it was true they’d say who it was. Odd that the only time they exhibit any discretion is about something one of them didn’t even hear.

IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 20:29

And maybe you wouldn’t have been offended and sad and felt awkward at a group of white people having those ‘concerns’ but Meghan and Harry did.

So it's a 'group' of people now?

And, depending on which version of the story you choose to believe, Harry can't have been all that offended, since he didn't bother to tell his wife for months or even years.

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:24

We’re a mixed race family and we comment on the possible colour of everything about any baby we’re waiting on.

Very different to a group of white people discussing their ‘concerns’ over skin colour. Do you feel ‘concerned’ that these babies will be too dark or too light skinned? Is there a skin colour that could in some way be wrong and ‘concerning’ to you on a baby you’re going to love. And maybe you wouldn’t have been offended and sad and felt awkward at a group of white people having those ‘concerns’ but Meghan and Harry did.

wordler · 21/04/2022 20:23

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/04/2022 18:10

He wanted to stay a working royal, just not do the bits he didn't fancy and make money on the side

That's the fly in the ointment that's always conveniently ignored isn't it? Especially when Harry himself said that what they'd wanted "hadn't been possible"

Had they said "Look, we simply can't live his life so we're going" that might have been one thing, but I've yet to see anyone explain why they were so keen to stay half in/half out if the situation was as appalling and racist as they've since tried to paint it

Exactly - the media ran with this weird 'privacy' line which everyone now keeps repeating as if that meant they didn't want any publicity at all. The website they launched in Jan 2020 when they announced they were stepping down as working royals in the BRF laid out that they wanted a half-in half out option where they would work for themselves making money with commercial ventures for part of the time and then for part of the year they would support the Queen by doing royal duties such as international visits and tours etc and any patronage work. They explained that they were giving up the royal grant money which comes from the government which funded 5% of their current budget.

Based on Harry's anger on the Oprah interview about his father 'cutting him off'
he fully expected to continue to receive the remaining 95% he was currently getting from Charles' Duchy of Cornwall funds. We don't know exactly how much that was because Charles' accounts lumped Harry and William's households together but assuming William got a little more at that time because he had three kids vs Harry's one it was probably around the 2 million pound mark.

But with their original plan there was no intention to step away from the limelight - they just wanted to be able to control more of who was doing the interview / filming etc. Their commercial plans would always have relied on a lot of publicity etc.

Soffit · 21/04/2022 20:20

The only member of the current royal family to have done anything racist in living memory is Harry himself when he dressed up as a Nazi. It never just happened on a whim. Some planning would have gone into it. He must have had the right sort of 'attitude' to pull it off among his friends. He probably wishes that it had never got out but he has never apologized for it. Probably induced by the trauma inflicted upon him by his birth family 😁

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 20:17

But then Meghan wasn’t part of the conversation was she? Nor can they decide between themselves when it was - early stages of relationship, during pregnancy. Who knows.

I don’t thing Oprah’s main concern was pinpointing exactly when it was, the important thing is that it was said at all. If you choose to believe it didn’t happen, that’s one thing, none of us were there so can’t prove it. But anyone on here stating ‘concerns’ over skin colour are ok, normal and not racist are very wrong.

MissPolliezDolly · 21/04/2022 20:16

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 19:41

Speculating on the skin colour of a child with one black and one white parent is not the same as speculating on hair colour. No doubt you’ll have a black ‘friend’ who is fine with it. 🙄 😡

And Meghan said there were ‘concerns’ about how dark his skin would be. Having concerns is a negative thing, not excitedly discussing what he’ll look like.

We’re a mixed race family and we comment on the possible colour of everything about any baby we’re waiting on.

And if Meghan told me today is Thursday I’d check to see if it is. Not that I’ve always thought she’s a liar. But I now do and I don’t believe for a minute that anyone had concern over how dark the baby would be.

wordler · 21/04/2022 20:14

JudgeJ · 20/04/2022 23:04

And the Guardian isn't the same as the gutter press? Maybe they're in the right gutter so it's OK, or rather in the left gutter. The Guardian is as reliable as the Mail, their rhetoric just suits more people's agenda.

Off piste, but I don't like the new layout, I can't load 100 messages in one go and it's annoying!

The Guardian and The Independent are pro-republican papers so they often report on the royal family from an anti-monarchy place.

Aspiringmatriarch · 21/04/2022 20:06

Agree to disagree then Smile

IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 20:04

Also, I can't really think of anything equivalent to growing up in the public eye as a member of the (famously dysfunctional) royal family, and then having a 'professional' role within a rigid hierarchy made up of your closest family, whose most elderly member is also the head of state. If he's got something to say about it then I think that's fair enough and potentially of legitimate public interest.

I'm not sure how private family matters, or rather, one somewhat embittered individual's personal perception of such matters, are of 'legitimate public interest'. It's essentially tittle tattle. Isn't everyone entitled to a private life, no matter what their official position might be?

Harry most certainly wouldn't want to be at the receiving end of the same, and I'm sure there's lots that could be said about him that he wouldn't want made public.

LittleBearPad · 21/04/2022 19:53

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 19:41

Speculating on the skin colour of a child with one black and one white parent is not the same as speculating on hair colour. No doubt you’ll have a black ‘friend’ who is fine with it. 🙄 😡

And Meghan said there were ‘concerns’ about how dark his skin would be. Having concerns is a negative thing, not excitedly discussing what he’ll look like.

But then Meghan wasn’t part of the conversation was she? Nor can they decide between themselves when it was - early stages of relationship, during pregnancy. Who knows.

Presumably it will be brought up again when they feel they need some publicity.

Aspiringmatriarch · 21/04/2022 19:53

IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 18:40

I actually feel quite sorry for him although I think his comments are openly trolling Meghan and Harry and have been for some time

And what is the point of Harry repeatedly criticising his family in front of the world? What constructive purpose does this serve? What is his motivation?

Not really comparing like with like

Why not?

No two situations are identical, of course, but your "feeling is that it's better risk to ruffling feathers than stay quiet about things that are potentially damaging or have caused hurt to you or others" applies to Thomas Markle as much as it does to Harry or Meghan.

If, as you seem to think, it's OK to publicly criticise people regardless of the effect it might have on those people, then surely that is true for everyone, not just people you approve of?

I don't think their behaviour is quite as similar you're suggesting, but in general I believe it's ok to speak about one's own experiences, yes.

Also, I can't really think of anything equivalent to growing up in the public eye as a member of the (famously dysfunctional) royal family, and then having a 'professional' role within a rigid hierarchy made up of your closest family, whose most elderly member is also the head of state. If he's got something to say about it then I think that's fair enough and potentially of legitimate public interest. You can't just cover a multitude of sins behind being a private family while also functioning as an employer, head of the church, head of the commonwealth etc.

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 19:41

Speculating on the skin colour of a child with one black and one white parent is not the same as speculating on hair colour. No doubt you’ll have a black ‘friend’ who is fine with it. 🙄 😡

And Meghan said there were ‘concerns’ about how dark his skin would be. Having concerns is a negative thing, not excitedly discussing what he’ll look like.

A580Hojas · 21/04/2022 19:28

I don't really have a finger on the pulse about current public opinion of Harry but I get the feeling it's not great.

There's probably a greater proportion of people on Mumsnet who are fine with it all than there are in the wider public, iyswim. As in, he's probably less unpopular on Mumsnet than he is in general.

There's no getting away from the fact that he's caused a ruckus.

PlasticineMeg · 21/04/2022 19:27

VeganGod · 21/04/2022 08:53

They said they wanted to be financially independent and that the British press was an issue and affecting mental health. So they moved away but never said they would be silent. I think people have misunderstood, deliberately.

The issue is that, for 2 people who as you say just want to be financially independent and left alone, what they’re not being silent about includes:

  • prince Charles l having cut him off financially. He sat in a $11million mansion, an almost 40 year old man who is a millionaire in his own right, and moaned about daddy ‘cutting him off’
  • things that attract huge press attention, like little digs at his family and interviews where he says provocative things
Their fundamental problem is they want to have their cake and eat it as well
Swipe left for the next trending thread