Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Oh do piss off, Harry

543 replies

HettySunshine · 20/04/2022 11:34

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/apr/20/prince-harry-says-queen-on-great-form-during-visit?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

The Queen has coped for most of her life without you. I don't think she needs you 'protecting her' now.

I'm usually entire ambivalent to the royals but this has really bruised my cherry!

AIBU?

OP posts:
Wheniruletheworld · 23/04/2022 01:43

VeganGod · 20/04/2022 13:32

The queen has a shedload of advisors and at least two further adults in line to the throne who are more than capable of protecting if needed. This looks like interference to me.

Maybe she’s not happy with what they call protection though. Maybe she is pushed into things she doesn’t want to do and controlled and has no choice. We don’t know. I think it’s likely. I also think that a woman, even the Queen would be more vulnerable to others as she ages, during periods of isolation (covid) and afternoon losing her husband, even one that wasn’t exactly a good one in many ways.

Theres always the assumption on these threads that the Queen doesn’t like what Harry has done with no real evidence of that. Just because he’s not with her a lot now doesn’t mean that he isn’t trying to protect her from people. The same as just because people are with her, it doesn’t mean they are looking out for her. Protection isn’t always given by those physically closest to you unfortunately.

There will be so much going on in the Royal family that we aren’t aware of. I don’t think Harry is the enemy here and I think most of us would be appalled if we knew the details of many things that gave happened over the years. No doubt accepting it would be too hard for many so instead they’ll just say anyone that reveals any of it is lying and turn them into a hate figure as we’ve seen with Harry.

The Queen certainly made bad decisions lately, regarding Andrew. Someone failed to protect her there.

Shes too bloody old for any of it. She’s likely not even aware of much of it and spends most of her time sleeping.

What utter bloody tosh.

Andouillette · 23/04/2022 01:01

Arucanafeather · 22/04/2022 21:02

I totally agree that if is not for anyone on this thread to state whether anyone else is suicidal or not. We simply do not know. We do know that the Duchess of Sussex said she felt suicidal. That is all we know. Anything on top of that from the believers or disbelievers is opinion and not knowledge or fact.

You are right. My assumption was that she had PND and felt unsuported. Having been through that myself I felt sorry for her. Those feelings are horrible and it is not exactly unusual for the 'nearest and dearest'(!) to be completely bloody useless.

UniversalAunt · 22/04/2022 22:31

Should be a meme: "if you visited your grandmother and didn't post it on Instagram, did you even go?"

Unless you went three days before you went.

Rinoachicken · 22/04/2022 21:57

LittleBearPad · 22/04/2022 21:01

No it’s not.

Actually it is. Suicidality is used as a term when determining the risk of someone actually taking their life.

suicide = the act of taking one’s own life
suicidal ideation = having distressing, intrusive and recurring thoughts about taking ones own life, but without having plans or desire to follow through with the act itself.
suicidality = the risk factor of someone attempting to take their life, when considering all such things as past history, mental illness, protective factors etc

examples:

“study into the risk markers of suicidality in adults with xyz”

“Future suicidality is greatly increased in those with a past history of severe mental illness”

It’s not a commonly used term outside of clinical and research fields but it is a legitimate term.

Arucanafeather · 22/04/2022 21:02

I totally agree that if is not for anyone on this thread to state whether anyone else is suicidal or not. We simply do not know. We do know that the Duchess of Sussex said she felt suicidal. That is all we know. Anything on top of that from the believers or disbelievers is opinion and not knowledge or fact.

LittleBearPad · 22/04/2022 21:01

ajandjjmum · 22/04/2022 20:50

Suicidality?

Is this a word? Genuine question.

No it’s not.

VladmirsPoutine · 22/04/2022 21:00

This is not about supporting Harry at all. I mean my position. Because frankly I think once Liz pops it they all need to update their CVs and I'm not even necessarily in support of Meghan - she said it herself! Had they been open and welcoming to her she too would have been happy to basically spend her life cutting ribbons and smiling at babies.

This is about the establishment and their antimony towards anyone they don't see fit be part of it. That it was actually Kate who made her cry and the papers ren with 'evil Meg makes Kate cry' and not one of them said a single word about it!

The royals do have control. Do you think an entire Prince - the Queen's actual son would have paid someone he claims to have never met £12million just to get her to go away???? If there was a grain of doubt the Royals have the resources and power to take her to court and ridicule the whole thing. Do you really think they have no power??

The point is about the establishment and the way they've made so many people believe we are eachother's enemies and anyone they don't deem fit to sit in that circle is out. There's a reason why you never see Black tories being disgraced in the same manner you see Diane Abbott and co being disgraced by not only their peers but by just about everyone else.

ajandjjmum · 22/04/2022 20:50

Suicidality?

Is this a word? Genuine question.

RaleighDurham · 22/04/2022 20:28

I suspect that the "concern" allegedly expressed about the baby's skin colour might well have been in the context of the media's coverage of it, and that the "concern" was whether Harry was ready for how it might be portrayed.
If Harry relayed this to Meghan without laying out the context of the conversation, then yes, I can see how Meghan would have been upset by it. But it might well have been coming from a different place than racism.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/04/2022 20:05

AmberLynn1536 · 22/04/2022 19:08

I do think it's impressive that someone who has white privilege, rich privilege, titled privilege, male privilege and celebrity privilege has managed to make himself appear as a marginalised victim.

Agree with the above, maybe he is brighter than we think.

That’s a lot of privilege. I hadn’t realised how many ways he is privileged! I would like to add royal privilege. It’s different from titled privilege.

RonaldMcDonald · 22/04/2022 19:45

Swayingpalmtrees · 22/04/2022 16:11

arcu Is spot on threatening suicide can be considered a form of cohesive control, and would be very triggering for someone like Harry who lost his mother at such a young age.

This is nonsense.

Anyone who feels suicidal can and should speak to those around them who love them and can form a safety net of support. They should not feel the burden of worrying about who they tell. They simply must reach out and get the care they need. The person offering it will place boundaries in place for this own safety.
They should also seek medical support and ideally therapy.

Anyone whose partner is experiencing feelings of suicidality is in a horribly difficult situation to deal with. Often they support their partner through their most difficult times. They can feel on edge 100% of the time. It is terribly hard to witness.
Suggesting that the Duchess’s feelings of suicidality are coercive in nature, is utterly baseless.

Suggesting this may be triggering for Prince Harry is spot on. He has lost a woman he loves in a situation that could have been prevented. To lose another one in a preventable way or to face the fears of losing another one to suicide due to lack of support may have brought all manner of thoughts, feelings or behaviours to the fore in Prince Harry.
I think he has clearly stated something similar.

This should make you feel empathy for this couple who are after all people, parents of small children.
The spiteful way in which things are written here is horrendous

RonaldMcDonald · 22/04/2022 19:32

Arucanafeather · 22/04/2022 15:59

Without commenting on the specific people being discussed on this thread (as I certainly feel l don’t know enough about these individuals and also am not in any way qualified to make a judgment) & in reference to your last paragraph: whilst it is important that anyone asking for help with their mental health is support and encouraged to get the help they need, is it not also recognised that threat of suicide can also be used as part of abusive cohesive control?

Yes, threats of suicide can be used and are seen in relationships where there is coercive control and patterns of domestic violence and abuse.
Suggesting that their relationship involves The Duchess of Sussex coercively controlling Prince Harry by threatening suicide, is quite a reach.

On each occasion where someone states they feel like ending their life for one of many reasons, are you suggesting our thinking should first be drawn toward - oooo could this be a manipulation as part of coercive control?

I think Women’s Aid, Refuge and every other mental health charity and practitioners would suggest this is really unhelpful.

I think you are suggesting this is in order to make people on this board belittling and questioning the Duchess’s suicidality with the use of quotations acceptable, yet it is far from helpful.

Querying the Duchess’s suicidality at all, impacts on many other people who have faced suicidal ideation, attempted suicide or lived with intrusive thinking around suicide. Often they face nasty commentary about attention seeking, not making a ‘real’ attempt etc. This ruins lives and prevents people asking for help.

Even in the pursuit of whatever fact free gutter press regurgitation the worst offenders on here use, this dangerous action of querying a person’s feelings of suicide seems a little more than a little off.
It should be against @mumsnet guidelines.

AmberLynn1536 · 22/04/2022 19:08

I do think it's impressive that someone who has white privilege, rich privilege, titled privilege, male privilege and celebrity privilege has managed to make himself appear as a marginalised victim.

Agree with the above, maybe he is brighter than we think.

Blossomtoes · 22/04/2022 18:30

peaceanddove · 22/04/2022 17:55

Utterly sick to the back teeth of Harry whining that his diamond cod-piece is too tight.

😂

peaceanddove · 22/04/2022 17:55

Utterly sick to the back teeth of Harry whining that his diamond cod-piece is too tight.

Bjarnum · 22/04/2022 17:40

Interesting that they never seem to give interviews to anyone who challenges their narrative ... wonder if Netflix will eventually try to insist that they do. Because that would really be a money spinner

Soffit · 22/04/2022 17:02

If you use Netflix or Spotify (among others) then you are indirectly paying their way because they have merched themselves to the maximum and named their inflated price upon the basis of what they have argued that their brand is worth in relation to YOUR interest in them. Just like any other brand, they positively deserve to be scrutinized.

Bluerose77 · 22/04/2022 16:42

People do seem to get over invested over people who live in a completely different world to us mere mortals. The royals live lives of extreme wealth and privilege. Why should we care about any of them. I'm sure they don't care about us, even if they knew us.

GladAllOver · 22/04/2022 16:27

I do find it odd that the same pp spend all day every day for days on end posting about a subject that has already passed, and immediately jump on every post that expresses even the merest hint of discontent with the Sussexes.

It is very strange why anyone would care THAT much about two people they have never met, will never met and have no idea what is truly going on. Why are some so so so invested.

This 100 times. And change to a more responsible news source that reports on more important issues.

Swayingpalmtrees · 22/04/2022 16:11

arcu Is spot on threatening suicide can be considered a form of cohesive control, and would be very triggering for someone like Harry who lost his mother at such a young age.

Swayingpalmtrees · 22/04/2022 16:09

I do find it odd that the same pp spend all day every day for days on end posting about a subject that has already passed, and immediately jump on every post that expresses even the merest hint of discontent with the Sussexes.

It is very strange why anyone would care THAT much about two people they have never met, will never met and have no idea what is truly going on. Why are some so so so invested. Hmm

Arucanafeather · 22/04/2022 15:59

RonaldMcDonald · 22/04/2022 14:07

I’m unsure if they needed sign off, as it were, to hire a counsellor or therapist.
Part of the wider explanation that they, whilst a family, are also a firm.
Given the mess left behind by Diana’s more shady support mechanisms I would expect there to be strict rules.
This hiring would have required extensive vetting and it wasn’t green lighted - apparently. An in-patient stay would have likely been easier.

His mother’s friend being a therapist makes little odds. She may have been able to recommend someone but then the vetting etc would have still have needed to take place.

This all sounded like nonsense to me. If my partner was facing suicidal ideation or indeed simply not coping I would have demanded they get the support they needed and if it was not agreed to be provided I would have arranged support myself, as an emergency action.
Ditto taking them to hospital.
But, I am not a Royal and I can have no understanding of the processes they feel they must have agreement around before acting.

I think it is unsafe to put quotation marks around anyone’s claims to be suicidal. If someone states they need or have needed help with their mental health I have no reason to do anything other believe them and encourage they get the support they need.

Without commenting on the specific people being discussed on this thread (as I certainly feel l don’t know enough about these individuals and also am not in any way qualified to make a judgment) & in reference to your last paragraph: whilst it is important that anyone asking for help with their mental health is support and encouraged to get the help they need, is it not also recognised that threat of suicide can also be used as part of abusive cohesive control?

RonaldMcDonald · 22/04/2022 14:07

Blossomtoes · 22/04/2022 12:31

Never mind Harry claiming to be unable to help, despite the vast resources available to them and his own known counselling experience

And one of his mother’s closest friends, who just happens to be a therapist, reported in the engagement interview to love Meghan. All he needed to do was dial her number.

I’m unsure if they needed sign off, as it were, to hire a counsellor or therapist.
Part of the wider explanation that they, whilst a family, are also a firm.
Given the mess left behind by Diana’s more shady support mechanisms I would expect there to be strict rules.
This hiring would have required extensive vetting and it wasn’t green lighted - apparently. An in-patient stay would have likely been easier.

His mother’s friend being a therapist makes little odds. She may have been able to recommend someone but then the vetting etc would have still have needed to take place.

This all sounded like nonsense to me. If my partner was facing suicidal ideation or indeed simply not coping I would have demanded they get the support they needed and if it was not agreed to be provided I would have arranged support myself, as an emergency action.
Ditto taking them to hospital.
But, I am not a Royal and I can have no understanding of the processes they feel they must have agreement around before acting.

I think it is unsafe to put quotation marks around anyone’s claims to be suicidal. If someone states they need or have needed help with their mental health I have no reason to do anything other believe them and encourage they get the support they need.

RonaldMcDonald · 22/04/2022 13:54

@EdithWeston yes agreed and great point. I’ve never really understood why she doesn’t receive more support and publicity for the work she does backing the BG and UN in these objectives.

InTheDogDen · 22/04/2022 13:33

Between you, you know the grand total of nothing and have created page after page of fiction. Excellent work. 🕵️‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread