Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a boundary one!

170 replies

Toomuchtooyoung01 · 19/04/2022 20:34

Moved house 3 months ago. Next door neighbours seem fine, however about a month ago the lady collared me as I was setting off on the school run to ask about popping into the front garden to access something. I had my 2yr old kicking off as standard and was quite distracted so (also wanting to be an amenable neighbour) said yes fine and set off on my way. A week or so later, I came home to find her sitting on my driveway weeding. Before I had a chance to ask what she was doing, my 4yr old innocently asked why she was sitting in our garden to which she replied “well this bit is actually my garden” 😳
I asked what she meant and she began waffling about how the boundary goes beyond the fence they erected and this strip of land is actually hers, she just hasn’t been able to access the garden to weed it for some time. Confused and again distracted by the kids, I went inside and relayed the conversation to OH who was NOT happy, especially after getting the title deeds out which shows the boundary line as being in line with the brickwork of our garage. Since viewing the property, a single bit of fencing has been erected attached to our garage, and a wire fence has been added by next door which is in line with this. Where she was weeding and where she claims is her land is on the other side of this (in our garden).
Yesterday, without asking if they could come into the garden to do so, they have now put down weed matting along this strip.
OH is raging, mainly at me for allowing them to come into the garden the first time when they asked to and for not setting them straight when they began weeding etc, he has said I have to sort this with them and tell them clearly they have to remove the matting and that we recognise the boundary as being where the title deeds depict it and that as a fence has been put in line with that prior to us moving in, they cannot now change the narrative to “actually that strip of land on the other side of the fence is ours and always has been”, despite the title deeds showing the boundary to be in line with the brickwork of my garage and the fence being in line with this too.
I HATE confrontation, even when I’m in the right feel guilty and uncomfortable like I’m doing something terribly wrong in asserting myself or opposing something, and usually end up getting shouted down and back down.
Dreading this conversation. Has everything I’ve said made sense? Have they got a leg to stand on if I say take the matting away and stay on your side of the fence? Am I about to make a dick of myself and an enemy in my new neighbours?

OP posts:
lottiegarbanzo · 22/04/2022 06:57

At least they asked for access first.

All you need to tell them is that you were distracted, didn't hear her properly and you wouldn't have given her permission if you had. They do not have your permission to enter your garden.

Then it's up to them to prove their rights, if they wish to try.

Pinzotti · 22/04/2022 06:06

Why are you worried about falling out with them?? Were you bosom buddies before??

TigerLilyTail · 22/04/2022 05:47

You could make enquires from your planning office about boundaries and if your neighbour still is in dispute replay the information from the planners/council. If you make it more official and from a third party without it being threatening or confrontational then they can’t get angry with you as it’s not your opinion but legally binding facts.

You see, I couldn't be arsed with all this. It has obviously been going on for years. Just deny them access and if they want to waste their time and money on it, they can, but why should the OP put herself out when she obviously has her hands full at the moment? Put the onus on them. It's your land unless they can prove otherwise.

Stilsmiling · 22/04/2022 00:21

The key here is for you not to anticipate confrontation. Approach it simply as a fact finding mission.

If your neighbours aren’t listening or agreeing to what you tell them is on the title deeds then it important to tell them that “we need to find out which boundary location is accurate” (said with a smile) so that the sim is to help both families resolve the puzzle. Keep it about “we” rather than “you” and “us”.

You could make enquires from your planning office about boundaries and if your neighbour still is in dispute replay the information from the planners/council. If you make it more official and from a third party without it being threatening or confrontational then they can’t get angry with you as it’s not your opinion but legally binding facts.

Its also worth mentioning that where you believe the boundary to be is where it was described when buying the house so it’s important that it’s established for any future sale of either house ie. for the benefit of both of you.

Just keep focusing on how both houses can benefit from getting help or advice to find out where the boundary lies.

TutiFrutti · 21/04/2022 23:50

OP, if you can't resolve this amicably then check your home insurance. We had a similar situation a few years back and realised we have free legal cover on our hone insurance. They helped us draft a letter which shut down our neighbours nonsense straight away.

Sswhinesthebest · 21/04/2022 23:42

I think you need to battle this one out, however much you want to avoid confrontation.

TigerLilyTail · 21/04/2022 23:33

Also, unfortunately, media outlets do often take stories from Mumsnet, so you don’t have to upload a diagram if you don’t want to. It sounds like logically they wouldn’t own the land in front of your garage, so remember “You can’t argue with crazy”

TigerLilyTail · 21/04/2022 23:30

Thinking2022 · 21/04/2022 21:13

As a number of others said, try not to see this as a confrontation. Just pop over with a copy of the deeds and explain they will need to move the matting as it is in fact in your boundary. Smile and ask if they would like some cake and tea

Did you even read the OP’s posts?

Unfortunately, boundary disputes are notoriously hard to resolve. My advice is to be firm with them, which it seems the previous neighbor was. Personally, I’d erect my own fence for the back garden. Whenever they put anything on to your land, remove it without damaging it and place it in their garden with a firm and clear this isn’t your land. Don’t enter into discussions or arguments with them, just keep saying “This isn’t your land” like a broken record.

aveline161 · 21/04/2022 23:01

TLDR but everyone stops needing to talk about DEEDS you aren’t looking at your deeds you’re looking at your entry on the land registry and the title plan, which is nothing but a snapshot of the current ordnance survey map at the time the property was registered or last sold. If you can get the actual ‘deeds’ fro. Your mortgage provider you might get exact boundary measurements but you might not. A piece of ‘our’ land was ‘given away’ by a previous wonder and it enrages me- the title plan shows the ridiculous boundary line that was adopted after this point but they are to quote Geoffrey Rush ‘more what you’d call guidelines’

Hippee · 21/04/2022 22:52

Read this today, so hope they don't pursue it www.thetimes.co.uk/article/couple-left-30-000-in-debt-over-boundary-dispute-hzdhr7lw8

LampLighter414 · 21/04/2022 22:12

This makes no sense. Need a diagram.

lottiegarbanzo · 21/04/2022 22:10

The neighbour is weeding on OP's side of the fence. The neighbour would not have placed the fence where it is, they'd have placed it at the edge of what they believe to be their property - not in the middle of it.

OP's seller's must have put it there. Which implies a prior dispute.

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/04/2022 21:26

Do you know it was them that put up the boundary marking fence at the front?

I am wondering if it was the sellers of your property, who won the argument about whose land it was and put this up before selling... with neighbours simmering with rage but biding their time.. then you move in and neighbours start it up again, thinking their claim will work on you!

Boundaries should be marked but this can be with a fence, a line of wire, a string, painted line down the flagstones... whatever.

Deeds as some people still don't seem to realise, won't be accurate to the inch!

I'd fence the buggers out with good 6ft solid panels at the back, and whatever is the tallest you are permitted at the front!

Thinking2022 · 21/04/2022 21:13

As a number of others said, try not to see this as a confrontation. Just pop over with a copy of the deeds and explain they will need to move the matting as it is in fact in your boundary. Smile and ask if they would like some cake and tea

TurquoiseSwirl · 21/04/2022 20:57

No one is obligated to put fencing up or even mark the boundary.

but the front garden sounds like they wanted to take it from previous neighbours and are tsk the opportunity now to do so. Talk to the solicitor who did the sale for you.

IceandIndigo · 21/04/2022 20:56

If it were me I think I would be more bothered about the neighbour coming on to my property to weed ‘her’ garden rather than the technical issue of who owns a piece of land that’s apparently just filled with weeds anyway. I wouldn’t assume they have bad motives, it honestly sounds like the neighbours genuinely believe that’s their land and they have an obligation to keep it tidy. I’m not sure it’s really worth falling out over. I would just politely explain that you had assumed the fence line was the boundary and suggest that for simplicity you take over responsibility for that piece of land, given that it can only be accessed from your property, and irrespective of who it technically belongs to. Make it clear that if the current situation were to continue you would want them to seek permission each time they need access and that you would expect this to be very occasional - you won’t be routinely granting access via your property. In the meantime, perhaps quietly talk to some of the other neighbours to see if the husband’s explanation holds any water.

JudgeJ · 21/04/2022 20:48

Toomuchtooyoung01 · 19/04/2022 22:55

Thanks everyone for your messages! I know I’ll sound really wimpy here (sorry) but I’m worried she’s going to be annoyed and have a go after she spent an afternoon weeding quite a big patch. What should my response be if she kicks off about it?

I would wait until she's weeded all of it before going round to tell her she's wrong!

JudgeJ · 21/04/2022 20:46

munner · 21/04/2022 19:43

Tell OH to grow a pair and sort her out with a copy of the deeds to hand.

Oh yes, let's all be weak little girls and expect a Man to sort out a problem we've created!

TheChurchOfEli · 21/04/2022 20:45

Are they obligated to put up actual fencing?
No. All they need to do is mark the boundary. You can erect a fence your side though, as long as it’s in front of the boundary line.

It is very odd behaviour. It’s not as if that extra teeny little bit of land is going to add value to the house, and I imagine if they sold in future most people aren’t going to even want to deal with a random strip of grass in front of someone else’s property. I suspect this is more about control than the land.

lottiegarbanzo · 21/04/2022 20:44

Since viewing the property, a single bit of fencing has been erected attached to our garage, and a wire fence has been added by next door which is in line with this. Where she was weeding and where she claims is her land is on the other side of this (in our garden).

You need to talk to your conveyancing solicitor about this.

This happened after you viewed but before you purchased the house? Look at your conveyancing documents. There will be a question about neighbour disputes. What was the previous owner's answer? Either there was a dispute that they didn't declare, or they had ceded this strip to the neighbour and hadn't declared it.

Either way you won't get anywhere by pursuing the previous owner but your solicitor will be able to advise on the boundary of the property they conveyanced and advise on next steps.

ElsieMc · 21/04/2022 20:41

They are trying it on because you have just moved in. We had a neighbour who when we showed them the title deeds and plan said they must be wrong because it did not accord with his wishes. He also effectively took a strip of land adjoining our property. We agreed to let it go because there were numerous huge trees on this strip as we did not wish to maintain them. But nor did they and for years no work has been done.

Please do download his deeds. It is £3 and you get them from HM Land Registry straightaway. Once you have these, he cannot argue with you. I think by saying he has maintained the land, ie mowed the lawn or whatever, he is trying to establish ownership via long user or similar.

You are not obligated to put up fencing but in these circumstances I think you need to establish very firm boundaries.

LannieDuck · 21/04/2022 20:37

Has he said why he thinks the curb is the boundary?

Toomuchtooyoung01 · 21/04/2022 20:33

Thanks everyone for your messages and good advice. It’s bloody ridiculous, title plans show the boundary to be in line with the garage, I asked if his title deeds said different and he said no “but these aren’t zoomed in enough” and just kept repeating the kerb is the boundary. Over and over again. It seems obvious that there’s been a dispute about it over the years and presumably if they thought they had a strong case they would have already had all these conversations and got it sorted legally and it would have been done and dusted years before we ever moved in, so I kind of feel the fact they haven’t says everything. It unnerves me how they genuinely seem appalled that we don’t agree. Also find it borderline weirdo behaviour to be so adamant you own a strip of land that sits in front of someone else’s garage, they themselves erected fencing that prevented them from accessing this strip without coming onto our driveway anyway. How does any of this make sense?!
The back garden is a bit of a jungle to put it mildly that we are wading our way through and we can now see after cutting back literally over a metre’s width of bamboo that they also have just trellis in the back garden to serve as fencing? Are they obligated to put up actual fencing?

OP posts:
thelowcarbsweats · 21/04/2022 20:23

It doesn't make sense to me that front gardens would be designed to overhang the neighbours garage by a few inches. I think maybe someone else in the street tried to claim that at some point (because some people are obsessed with claiming every inch of land that they possibly can) and the other neighbour was a pushover. I bet they have no written proof.

JonSnowIsALoser · 21/04/2022 20:21

How weird. If the neighbour insists that the boundary is where the "kerb stone" is, and not where the deed says it is, ask him politely to provide legal evidence of that in writing. An old photo of him mowing the grass doesn't qualify as evidence I'm afraid. Can you ask the estate agent who sold you the house what's going on? Or a solicitor?

I hope your husband becomes more co-operative too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread