Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my big birthday holiday to be a family holiday?

412 replies

Haaaaliday · 19/04/2022 19:06

I've got a big birthday coming up next year and my best friend is turning the same age around the same time.

We've been talking for a while about booking a big, once in a lifetime style holiday with our children. Our DC won't be school age by then so we wouldn't be going in the school holidays which saves a lot on what is already an expensive trip. Both our husbands welcome too but we don't mind going just together with kids either.

My husband has an older DC from previous relationship who is 9, nearly 10 (would be at least 11 by the time we went). My friend has never met DHs son and he is much older than both her children and our joint child. DH initially said he felt unable to come as wouldn't want DSS to miss out which I understood and accepted that decision.

He is now making sounds about why it can't be a whole family holiday. He is offering to pay the difference.

AIBU to say no?

-My reasons really are this is a holiday for my birthday and not only mine, but my friends too. So I think what we want to do should take precedence. She nor her children have ever met my husband's son, she is very close to our child and I am with her's too.

  • I do not want to have to go in the summer holidays. It's one thing me and my friend have said makes this the perfect time to do this type of holiday when our DC are little so no school holiday times required.
  • I just want to focus on our DC and me and my friend. They are all similar ages so we can focus activities etc.. around their age.

I've accepted it may mean DH doesn't come but this was mine and my friends idea, I intended to pay for this myself and with some money my parents have offered toward it for my birthday.

AIBU to tell DH he can come or not but I'm not asking my friend to change plans to go in school holidays and with DSS?

OP posts:
Tereseta · 21/04/2022 08:33

This thread is nuts! Some of the comments on here must be people projecting their own step family experience.
Nothing wrong with having a holiday with a friend during term time and not taking step children or partner 🙄why should her friend suffer having to pay over the odds for a school holiday break. Get it booked! You can always have a family holiday in the summer holidays.

Threetulips · 21/04/2022 08:32

Maybe she just wants to celebrate her birthday with a long time friend how she wants to celebrate!

Doesn’t diminish her relationship with her husband. He was invited. His DS wasn’t - it was rude to ask OP to then include the DS and change the dates to suit him.

can you imagine if this was some one else?

hi, we’re going on a cruise for a week, fancy coming? ‘Well only if I can invite someone else, not we need to change the dates to suit them and pay the extra’

it would be an instant NO! And a quick label of CF!

newname12345 · 21/04/2022 06:50

Moochio · 21/04/2022 06:18

Then couples counselling might be a better option.

Possibly, to help the OP with why she values her friendship with her friend over her DH's relationship with all of his children.

Moochio · 21/04/2022 06:18

newname12345 · 21/04/2022 05:44

Doesn't that depend on whether his feelings are normal or not? I am not in his position but I can understand why he is feeling that way. Don't couples in a relationship consider the other person's feelings anyway regardless of whether they are normal or not?

Then couples counselling might be a better option.

newname12345 · 21/04/2022 05:44

Moochio · 20/04/2022 21:34

Which works for you, but in this case the OP's DH does want to go, but feels he can't unless his DS is able to come as well. that's his feelings. OP is not responsible for this. Maybe he can seek therapy if these feelings are causing issues in his relationship so he can better handle them.

Doesn't that depend on whether his feelings are normal or not? I am not in his position but I can understand why he is feeling that way. Don't couples in a relationship consider the other person's feelings anyway regardless of whether they are normal or not?

Moochio · 20/04/2022 21:34

Which works for you, but in this case the OP's DH does want to go, but feels he can't unless his DS is able to come as well. that's his feelings. OP is not responsible for this. Maybe he can seek therapy if these feelings are causing issues in his relationship so he can better handle them.

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2022 21:31

Which works for you, but in this case the OP's DH does want to go, but feels he can't unless his DS is able to come as well. So it's not really the same situation.

It's his choice to feel that way, though. He doesn't have to.

Rewis · 20/04/2022 21:24

I was merely commenting on the comment that was saying that husband going on once in a lifetime holiday without their wife it would potentially be marriage ending. It wasn't to OP and her situation specifically.

I think I've taken enough space in Op's thread. Hope you get everything sorted where its a friend trip or a family trip!

budgiegirl · 20/04/2022 20:03

I actively don't want my partner on my once in a lifetime dream holiday. Paying a lot of money for him to join me on a glacier hike that he wouldn't enjoy? No thanks, Lake District hike was an experience enough for him. If he wants me to join him in would cup final in Qatar, fine but I'd rather have him go with his friend who would share his once in a lifetime excitement of seeing England win the World Cup

Which works for you, but in this case the OP's DH does want to go, but feels he can't unless his DS is able to come as well. So it's not really the same situation.

Rewis · 20/04/2022 19:16

newname12345 · 20/04/2022 18:56

So where does a once in a lifetime Disney Cruise with DC fit? With partner, with friend, or alone? I know where it fits to me, and if I wasn't included I probably wouldn't see it as a relationship ending dealbreaker, but DP would know I wasn't at all happy.

Personal hell and being grateful that my partner takes the kids and I don't have to go? 😁

newname12345 · 20/04/2022 18:56

Rewis · 20/04/2022 18:43

I get the lifetime dream,

I'll edit the response to once in a lifetime. There are once jn a lifetime trips I'd rather do with my partner and once in a lifetime trips I'd rather do with my family and some that I'd rather do with my friend and some I'd like to do alone 😀 just saying that to me it's not a relationship ending dealbreker. But obviously it's fine if it is to some.

So where does a once in a lifetime Disney Cruise with DC fit? With partner, with friend, or alone? I know where it fits to me, and if I wasn't included I probably wouldn't see it as a relationship ending dealbreaker, but DP would know I wasn't at all happy.

Rewis · 20/04/2022 18:43

I get the lifetime dream,

I'll edit the response to once in a lifetime. There are once jn a lifetime trips I'd rather do with my partner and once in a lifetime trips I'd rather do with my family and some that I'd rather do with my friend and some I'd like to do alone 😀 just saying that to me it's not a relationship ending dealbreker. But obviously it's fine if it is to some.

newname12345 · 20/04/2022 18:37

Rewis · 20/04/2022 18:20

But if my DH said he was going on a once-in-a-lifetime holiday without me, I'd think I also might be considering the future of my marriage.

I wouldn't unless it was a joint dream that we had both talked about and the he decided to do with someone else. I actively don't want my partner on my once in a lifetime dream holiday. Paying a lot of money for him to join me on a glacier hike that he wouldn't enjoy? No thanks, Lake District hike was an experience enough for him. If he wants me to join him in would cup final in Qatar, fine but I'd rather have him go with his friend who would share his once in a lifetime excitement of seeing England win the World Cup.

I get the lifetime dream, but the OP hasn't even hinted she has been dreaming of going on a Disney Cruise. In her words "this was mine and my friends idea" and "wanted to do something fun together with our kids".

Threetulips · 20/04/2022 18:20

I have to say my DH would have wanted to have joined in with seeing our DS enjoying Disney or anything big like this. It would definitely be a family thing

DSS mother may fee the same!

does DH go on all if DSS holidays? Just so he doesn’t miss his excitement?

Rewis · 20/04/2022 18:20

But if my DH said he was going on a once-in-a-lifetime holiday without me, I'd think I also might be considering the future of my marriage.

I wouldn't unless it was a joint dream that we had both talked about and the he decided to do with someone else. I actively don't want my partner on my once in a lifetime dream holiday. Paying a lot of money for him to join me on a glacier hike that he wouldn't enjoy? No thanks, Lake District hike was an experience enough for him. If he wants me to join him in would cup final in Qatar, fine but I'd rather have him go with his friend who would share his once in a lifetime excitement of seeing England win the World Cup.

toomuchlaundry · 20/04/2022 17:21

The OP also describes it as OIAL trip so assume something similar will never happen again

personally for OIAL trip I would go when all DC will appreciate it. Think pre-schoolers won’t fully appreciate it which would be a shame and partly waste of money in respect of them

newname12345 · 20/04/2022 17:12

SleepingStandingUp · 20/04/2022 16:18

But if my DH said he was going on a once-in-a-lifetime holiday without me, I'd think I also might be considering the future of my marriage. Because I'd never do that to him. I wouldn't prioritise friends over family.
But this is a OIAL trip for op, not her DH. She's nothing to suggest that her DP also considers this an amazing holiday and is desperate to go. Disney Cruise? I'd imagine the total opposite for lots of men. I'm going on a OIAL trip for three nights in Europe to a concert. It isn't so much the money that makes it OIAL but its something I don't see myself redoing because it will never be as good as that first time. He's staying home with the kids. For him it would be a holiday to put up with. If he could come (can't, we have three kids) he'd enjoy the bit in the middle, abhor the travel and be fine about the concert. It's OPS OIAL trip, and her mates

IMO for it to be a OIAL trip it has to a something more special then your normal trips that you are unlikely to be able to do again (maybe because of money, time, or maybe because it is a point in time). Its definitely not a normal trip that you don't want to repeat (I've been to Grimsby once, don't plan to go back there but that didn't make it a OIAL trip!).

In her DH's case he might be seeing this as a OIAL trip. Not though directly for himself, but because he's never going to be ever able to take all his kids on a Disney Cruise at the same time where they are still at an age where they will really appreciate it.

budgiegirl · 20/04/2022 16:40

It isn't so much the money that makes it OIAL but its something I don't see myself redoing because it will never be as good as that first time

Fair enough, I suppose it depends on your definition of a OIAL trip. For me, I guess it would be something that's expensive, meaning that it would be difficult to do it again. And the OP has said that this is expensive, so a family holiday will not be in the same league. It doesn't sound fair to me, to prioritise my own trip over a family trip, but I guess we're all different. I know that my DH would feel the same. We've both been away on holidays without each other, but never at the expense of the main family holiday.

DH initially said he felt unable to come as wouldn't want DSS to miss out which I understood and accepted that decision

The OP's DH said that he felt unable to come, not that he didn't want to. It may be his idea of a wonderful holiday, but he just felt he couldn't go without his son.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/04/2022 16:18

But if my DH said he was going on a once-in-a-lifetime holiday without me, I'd think I also might be considering the future of my marriage. Because I'd never do that to him. I wouldn't prioritise friends over family.
But this is a OIAL trip for op, not her DH. She's nothing to suggest that her DP also considers this an amazing holiday and is desperate to go. Disney Cruise? I'd imagine the total opposite for lots of men. I'm going on a OIAL trip for three nights in Europe to a concert. It isn't so much the money that makes it OIAL but its something I don't see myself redoing because it will never be as good as that first time. He's staying home with the kids. For him it would be a holiday to put up with. If he could come (can't, we have three kids) he'd enjoy the bit in the middle, abhor the travel and be fine about the concert. It's OPS OIAL trip, and her mates

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2022 16:15

@toomuchlaundry

@aSofaNearYou you could argue it the other way that OP has married someone with a child and there are times when DSS should be considered.

DH had a stepdad and he fitted in with his step kids. Does seem to be different rules for step mums

I know, people often do, but it's bogus tbh. Step parents lives do not revolve around their step children, they will always want to and be entitled to do things without them as well as with, and if you seek out a relationship post splitting with your child's other parent you need to be able to accept that.

Step dad's often live with their step children full time from the get go which is quite a different dynamic and usually does involve being fully involved through necessity.

toomuchlaundry · 20/04/2022 16:10

@aSofaNearYou you could argue it the other way that OP has married someone with a child and there are times when DSS should be considered.

DH had a stepdad and he fitted in with his step kids. Does seem to be different rules for step mums

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2022 16:02

@toomuchlaundry

I have to say my DH would have wanted to have joined in with seeing our DS enjoying Disney or anything big like this. It would definitely be a family thing. If Disney was a every 3 months type thing, then maybe not, but certainly a family thing (which a Disney cruise is) I would have felt odd not including him. Then if he was coming it would be be bad if DSS couldn't come either.
This is something he'd need to accept as someone with a child from a former relationship, though. His new partner will do things and he will need to either be happy to go along without his DS sometimes, or cope with missing out himself. Life doesn't stand still because of his situation.
budgiegirl · 20/04/2022 15:44

yellowsuninthesky · 20/04/2022 11:51

I can’t get over that you would prioritise your friend and her children over your husband and his child. If my husband did that to me, I would consider my marriage over

For a one-off trip? Are people not allowed to do things with friends? I don't have any friends I am close enough to, to go on holiday with them, but if I did, I'd be annoyed if DH got the hump every time I wanted to do things with them and not him. I know lots of people who go away with friends.

Of course people are allowed to do things with friends. But if my DH said he was going on a once-in-a-lifetime holiday without me, I'd think I also might be considering the future of my marriage. Because I'd never do that to him. I wouldn't prioritise friends over family.

OP, it's fine to go away with your friend and the kids for a birthday trip. But I don't think its fine to for it to be a once-in-a-lifetime style trip. If you could afford (between you and DH) to do a similar holiday next year for your whole family, then that might be different, but you've already said you can't afford it.

toomuchlaundry · 20/04/2022 15:44

I have to say my DH would have wanted to have joined in with seeing our DS enjoying Disney or anything big like this. It would definitely be a family thing. If Disney was a every 3 months type thing, then maybe not, but certainly a family thing (which a Disney cruise is) I would have felt odd not including him. Then if he was coming it would be be bad if DSS couldn't come either.

AryaStarkWolf · 20/04/2022 14:49

thatweirdhippygirl · 20/04/2022 13:54

Is OP meant to just ditch her friend and their plans they’ve had for months? That would be mean.

I go on holiday without DH all the time. Big once in a lifetime holidays too. He stays home with the kids. Highly recommend. You don’t need to be joined at the hip when you marry someone.

Well yeah, I think if she isn't going to take SS then she should also not take DH because leaving 1 person out of the holiday like that (especially one that probably feels less a part of the family as it is) is a really shitty thing to do.

It has a different vibe if she goes with her friend and her friends young children