Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my big birthday holiday to be a family holiday?

412 replies

Haaaaliday · 19/04/2022 19:06

I've got a big birthday coming up next year and my best friend is turning the same age around the same time.

We've been talking for a while about booking a big, once in a lifetime style holiday with our children. Our DC won't be school age by then so we wouldn't be going in the school holidays which saves a lot on what is already an expensive trip. Both our husbands welcome too but we don't mind going just together with kids either.

My husband has an older DC from previous relationship who is 9, nearly 10 (would be at least 11 by the time we went). My friend has never met DHs son and he is much older than both her children and our joint child. DH initially said he felt unable to come as wouldn't want DSS to miss out which I understood and accepted that decision.

He is now making sounds about why it can't be a whole family holiday. He is offering to pay the difference.

AIBU to say no?

-My reasons really are this is a holiday for my birthday and not only mine, but my friends too. So I think what we want to do should take precedence. She nor her children have ever met my husband's son, she is very close to our child and I am with her's too.

  • I do not want to have to go in the summer holidays. It's one thing me and my friend have said makes this the perfect time to do this type of holiday when our DC are little so no school holiday times required.
  • I just want to focus on our DC and me and my friend. They are all similar ages so we can focus activities etc.. around their age.

I've accepted it may mean DH doesn't come but this was mine and my friends idea, I intended to pay for this myself and with some money my parents have offered toward it for my birthday.

AIBU to tell DH he can come or not but I'm not asking my friend to change plans to go in school holidays and with DSS?

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 19/04/2022 20:50

I’d happily let Dh go on a lads holiday but to take my dc and leave me at home I’d be right pissed off

And some of us would be happy as a clam to have a house to ourselves while our spouses took the kids somewhere else.

Bagadverts · 19/04/2022 20:49

I have no experience of step family to comment on that dynamic.

this is a trip of a lifetime with memories of your children doing something special. They will not remember. it is a shame that your husband will not have those memories or be able to discuss with you or the children in the future. You may or may not remain close to your friend (not falling out but moving house, circumstances changing such as a disability or death in one of your families. Yes it is possible that you will split from your husband but he will always be their father.)

If your husband is ok with that that’s fine.

MangshorJhol · 19/04/2022 20:45

But if you are willing to take a husband and a small child then it IS a family holiday. The only person being excluded is a ten year old. Whom you don’t want to take (the school holidays aside) because he’s…ten.
I have a 10 and a 5 year old and they get in great and we have just been on holiday and it’s been absolutely fine.

So what a family holiday means here is ‘my’ family which doesn’t include DH’s child? (Aka even if the mum agreed and he could come it would be awkward because he’s ten…and your mate doesn’t know him even though most of the people on holiday, aka you, your son and DH do…).

Eddielizzard · 19/04/2022 20:43

What SimonedeBeauvoirscat said

konasana · 19/04/2022 20:42

YANBU! Go on your girls trip, it sounds amazing. Some of these responses are baffling!

Bikeybikeface · 19/04/2022 20:41

Oh god, give me a 10yo over preschool children anytime, I think I’d take 20 10yo over 1 toddler!
I think you’ve already made your mind up so I’m not sure why you posted in AIBU. You don’t want to take him, that’s the be all and end all of it. You don’t have to take him, that’s your prerogative, that’s the kind of person you want to be and that’s fine. It’s not the kind of person I can relate to but we are all different.

LuaDipa · 19/04/2022 20:40

@MichelleScarn

Are people really insisting the op and her friend organise their big birthday fun around the DSS?
This.

It’s not like they actually care if the dh’s are there or not so doesn’t have to be a family holiday. They can do that another time.

I’m also curious why dh even wants to come along when he’s apparently usually so blasé about birthdays. Could it be that he’s not happy about having to entertain his dc himself?

It’s your birthday, just book the holiday for you, friend and the kids while the husband’s stay home and enjoy.

TheGirlWhoLived · 19/04/2022 20:38

Yeah @WindyKnickers I agree, you’re right it’s not fair to ‘blame’ the mum - I wasn’t thinking about it from her angle

Watapalava · 19/04/2022 20:36

This is an odd set up

I’d happily let Dh go on a lads holiday but to take my dc and leave me at home I’d be right pissed off

Going with your friend is fine

Going with friends and kids and no Dh is weird in itself

Very odd op

WindyKnickers · 19/04/2022 20:36

[quote TheGirlWhoLived]@WindyKnickers Maybe the difference is that I have taken an older child out in term time. The holiday is planned in term time, if dss cannot attend the planned holiday then they should do something else with him at a different time when he can attend 🤷🏼‍♀️[/quote]
I agree. I wouldn't take my older children out of school in term time for more than a day or 2 and would feel pretty aggrieved at being made out to be the arsehole by protesting if their dad wanted to. If it really was the only opportunity for a once in a lifetime holiday I would be more open to the idea, but not so they could tag along to disney with some pre-schoolers. The dad should arrange a family holiday that includes DSS from the get go and let the OP go off on her jollies as she would prefer anyway. Win win.

phoenixrosehere · 19/04/2022 20:33

Why does the DSS even need to know? It has nothing to do with him and he is going to be in school. OP and her best friend’s children aren’t even going to be in reception, so who is to say that they are going to tell their older sibling where they went or even understand themselves where they are going. The only person who would be telling DSS is his dad and his dad is the one who is making this awkward when he could use the time to spend it with his son.

Curious OP, how much time does your DH actually spend with his son alone?

SimonedeBeauvoirscat · 19/04/2022 20:30

Gosh marriage is so stifling for some people. It is possible to live (laugh love 🤮) without having your husband there for every second of it. Not judging those who prefer to live in each other’s pockets, just saying there are other ways to have a relationship.

I’d do what suits you, OP. A hol with your friend, partners optional, sounds fine to me. If your H doesn’t ‘do’ birthdays then I don’t see how he could object as presumably he wasn’t planning to make a fuss of you anyway?

C152 · 19/04/2022 20:28

YANBU at all. This is a special birthday trip and your DH is trying to piggy back onto it. It's totally reasonable to say you would be happy to have family holidays at another time, but this is a special event for your birthday. No need to explain further or apologise; he's the one being unreasonable.

Daqqe · 19/04/2022 20:27

Does the 10 year old want to come? Or would he rather be at home with his mates?

We’ve refused family holidays twice now because my SIL wouldn’t pull her kids out of school (fair enough) & we refused to pay school holiday prices when we had pre-schoolers. It caused a bit of fuss when we initially refused but hey ho. I’m not wasting my money on a shittier hotel in crap location when I can spend the same amount on afar nicer holiday in term time! My eldest is now at school, so my time has come to pay horrendous holiday prices 🥴

Lollypop701 · 19/04/2022 20:27

I get you want a girls trip to remember and for you, this is it. The age difference of kids is also a factor . But it just feels off, although I find it hard to explain why. Disney is held up as THE best holiday so dss is going to be hurt, whether that’s reasonable or not. if he was going with his mum your child would be too young to understand but would probably be jealous if it ages were reversed. If my child were the older child I’d want to do something special with them separately albeit doesn’t have to cost so much. but I wouldn’t want to miss trip of lifetime with younger dc… I agree they might not remember but I would . It’s a difficult one op but it sounds like you’ve made your mind up and want reasons to explain what you are going to do, rather than opinions on Wethersfield you should do it.

Herejustforthisone · 19/04/2022 20:27

@Neverreturntoathread

If it’s a once in a lifetime holiday then yabvu to take the DC you had with DH but exclude your DSS. Either all the children go or none do.

Honestly the post comes across as a bit spoilt: ‘it’s my birthday so I want it all my way’ Imagine how DSS would feel about his siblings going on the holiday of a lifetime without him. He’d hate you forever and rightly so. Good luck with the teen years if that’s your attitude!! When you married DH this big came to: he is your son too now. So stop being so spoilt and work out a way to treat all of the children fairly.

Kerrrrrrrrist almighty. 😂

OP, have a lovely holiday with your friend and your child. Your H, who doesn’t do birthdays, can arrange the usual family holiday for everyone together. By virtue of being a stepmother, you’ll be rinsed here whatever you do but know that most reasonable posters agree with you.

Chickychoccyegg · 19/04/2022 20:26

You and your friend should go with your dc, when you want to, your dss wouldn't expect to go on a holiday with you and your friend, he can do something separate with his dad.
Some people are so dramatic about including sc even when it's not needed.

rookiemere · 19/04/2022 20:24

Just go with your friend and the two young DCs and book another holiday which includes DH and DSS for a different occasion.

doggiescats · 19/04/2022 20:24

Is it the kind of holiday that DSS would have absolutely dreamed of ie Disney or is it just a bucket and spade type of destination?
I think that will make a big difference to how he will feel about being excluded!

TheGirlWhoLived · 19/04/2022 20:21

@WindyKnickers Maybe the difference is that I have taken an older child out in term time. The holiday is planned in term time, if dss cannot attend the planned holiday then they should do something else with him at a different time when he can attend 🤷🏼‍♀️

TheOriginalEmu · 19/04/2022 20:20

@Clymene

If her husband went too, then as far as that child is concerned they’re all going without him. Kids notice this stuff and feel it.

Dontbeme · 19/04/2022 20:19

He is now making sounds about why it can't be a whole family holiday. He is offering to pay the difference

Is he offering to pay the difference for your friend and her DC also if the break is rebooked out of term time? Does he really want to go and bring DSS or does he feel put out that you and friend are off on a break when he feels that your place is at home with him?

toomuchlaundry · 19/04/2022 20:17

If it is Disney it might be wasted on the DC if they are quite young. We took DS when he was school age and we saw so many younger children being scared of the characters when they got up close to them.

WindyKnickers · 19/04/2022 20:17

@TheGirlWhoLived

I think if dss mum will let him come out of school time then offer to take him, if she doesn’t then the onus is on her. I think it would be mean to discount him coming on the basis that he is 10, unless there are other underlying things (very hard work/special needs/you don’t get on) as they can often just entertain themselves mostly- particularly in this instance if your DH would then come too as he would help with the childcare part for DSS.

I can’t imagine being in a blended family situation and then saying actually you aren’t important enough to be invited to my birthday. If his mum won’t let him attend then that’s not your problem, but to not invite is very rude imo

I think inviting a school age child on holiday in term time, knowing his mum will (rightly) disapprove is bloody mean. Why turn her into the bad guy just so you don't look bad? Either plan a holiday including DSS or don't, but own the decision.
phoenixrosehere · 19/04/2022 20:16

So you don't want a family holiday but you do want your DC and DH to come?

Did you even read OP’s posts?

She said neither her or her best friend were fussed with their husbands going and more than happy to just take their young children.