Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To update about The Family Sex Show

716 replies

theDudesmummy · 19/04/2022 16:36

There are active two threads on this in Feminism but I feel I just have to update here for traffic. Although protests appear to have, for now, stopped the theatre production going ahead, new and highly disturbing material has today appeared on their webpage, clearly aimed at children. It (cheerily and breezily) suggests, among other things, that children search for images of masturbating animals on the internet and then draw what they see. I am not going to Google that term, I really don't want that in my history, but first, can you imagine what children will be exposed to if they search that, and second, this is pure and simple grooming of children into being abused. Masturbating animals? What larks! Lets have an arts and crafts session about it! Next steps: Masturbating with Uncle Jim? Why not? Masturbating Uncle Jim? Of course!

I have now made a complaint to CEOP. Others may wish to as well.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
HairyBum · 27/04/2022 19:56

This bill is quite interesting also

bills.parliament.uk/bills/3137/publications

Snugglepumpkin · 27/04/2022 19:01

I hate quotes, that wasn't the post I was quoting

Snugglepumpkin · 27/04/2022 19:01

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:24

But yes, it is tricky because of the way society has gone in recent years and changes in attitudes in some parts of society with regard to what is and is not accaptable. No way they will ever be prosecuted, as I have said. But that didn't stop me reporting them as groomers to CEOP and the police. Because I believed it to be the right thing to do regardless.

This show/website does encourage children to make a communication that is sexual as they are prompted to consider & voice what gives them sexual pleasure etc...
It is not a show about bodies as they would be shown in a biology lesson, it is a show specifically created to encourage children to see their bodies as sexual & to explore WITH OTHERS as some of the language refers to a childs reactions to other people touching in a sexual manner etc...

(b)the communication is sexual or is intended to encourage B to make (whether to A or to another) a communication that is sexual

PonyPatter44 · 27/04/2022 19:00

Meaningful change WAS effected, though, Lockheart. The crappy show was cancelled, and the most unsavoury sections of the website were pulled. That seems like a satisfactory result to me.

Lockheart · 27/04/2022 18:45

Daisycrown · 27/04/2022 18:38

Someone should definitely become a Criminal defence lawyer... if they're not already one. It takes a certain kind of person to defend the undefendable when it comes to these types of matters.

I didn't realise pointing out the law meant you were defending something. I would argue it's quite crucial to understand the legal issues at play if you want to effect any meaningful change.

Daisycrown · 27/04/2022 18:38

Someone should definitely become a Criminal defence lawyer... if they're not already one. It takes a certain kind of person to defend the undefendable when it comes to these types of matters.

Lockheart · 27/04/2022 18:24

PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 18:20

Without further clarification from you on the question, I will continue to believe that you hold the opinion I stated earlier and which you bizarrely called "an attack". Anyone who agreed that situation is patently inappropriate would not have any trouble in saying so.

You can believe whatever you want, I hope it makes you happy.

Lockheart · 27/04/2022 18:22

PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 18:18

Regardless of any show that may or may not exist, are you able to state that you do, or don't, believe an adult exposing their genitals and talking about sexual pleasure, to be age-appropriate when the child is 5? If not, what age child do you think that would be appropriate for?

I asked this exact question before and you still did not say you thought it was not appropriate.

I am asking specifically about the situation I have described and not any other situation that you or anyone else may imagine.

I am not talking about showing you anything. I am not talking about whether the adult is sitting down or not. I am not talking about crimes or the law or the police. The question is as I worded it.

I am sure you will handwave the question away again.

It was you that said "it's fine to talk to children about sexual pleasure as long as it's done in an age appropriate way".

Yet you are utterly unable to state what situations your own "as long as" does and doesn't apply to.

I'm not going to repeat a mantra off the back off a fabricated scenario just to please or win the approval of a stranger on the internet.

PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 18:20

Without further clarification from you on the question, I will continue to believe that you hold the opinion I stated earlier and which you bizarrely called "an attack". Anyone who agreed that situation is patently inappropriate would not have any trouble in saying so.

PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 18:18

Regardless of any show that may or may not exist, are you able to state that you do, or don't, believe an adult exposing their genitals and talking about sexual pleasure, to be age-appropriate when the child is 5? If not, what age child do you think that would be appropriate for?

I asked this exact question before and you still did not say you thought it was not appropriate.

I am asking specifically about the situation I have described and not any other situation that you or anyone else may imagine.

I am not talking about showing you anything. I am not talking about whether the adult is sitting down or not. I am not talking about crimes or the law or the police. The question is as I worded it.

I am sure you will handwave the question away again.

It was you that said "it's fine to talk to children about sexual pleasure as long as it's done in an age appropriate way".

Yet you are utterly unable to state what situations your own "as long as" does and doesn't apply to.

Lockheart · 27/04/2022 17:44

PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 17:37

I'm not going to respond to the ad hominem attack.

I don't understand why you think it's an 'attack' - I believe this to be a statement of your views - certainly when you posted on the original thread discussing this specific behaviour you said along the lines of "it's fine to talk to children about sexual pleasure as long as it's done in an age appropriate way". You then couldn't or wouldn't answer whether you considered this specific behaviour (a naked adult talking about it to a 5-year-old) to be age-appropriate or not.

I therefore concluded you believe it is age-appropriate, as you spent quite a lot of time defending it and refusing to give a clear answer.

If you now do actually agree with me that an adult exposing their genitals to a child and talking about sexual pleasure is not appropriate for primary-age children, feel free to state that clearly and unequivocally.

You also said you would laugh at anyone who called the police.

I still believe it is fine to educate children about their bodies and all the elements of sex as long as it is done in an age appropriate way.

If you can show me where a naked adult talks to children about sexual pleasure, I'll happily address that point, but given none of us have seen the show and you've put two and two together and arrived at purple, I'm going to continue to ignore it. It seemed to me the naked section was about bodies, not sexual pleasure, but again, I haven't seen the show.

And as should be clear from my recent posts, I continue to believe this is not (based on the information available) a criminal offence.

PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 17:37

I'm not going to respond to the ad hominem attack.

I don't understand why you think it's an 'attack' - I believe this to be a statement of your views - certainly when you posted on the original thread discussing this specific behaviour you said along the lines of "it's fine to talk to children about sexual pleasure as long as it's done in an age appropriate way". You then couldn't or wouldn't answer whether you considered this specific behaviour (a naked adult talking about it to a 5-year-old) to be age-appropriate or not.

I therefore concluded you believe it is age-appropriate, as you spent quite a lot of time defending it and refusing to give a clear answer.

If you now do actually agree with me that an adult exposing their genitals to a child and talking about sexual pleasure is not appropriate for primary-age children, feel free to state that clearly and unequivocally.

You also said you would laugh at anyone who called the police.

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:35

Well @Lockheart I do at least agree with your last point.

OP posts:
theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:35

The stipulation that communication must be for personal sexual gratification is outdated in this context for example. It's almost impossible to prove in an online context. It also fails to capture the online sexual grooming of children for other reasons, including for the facilitation of the sexual gratification of others, or for the eroding of societal norms for political or other social reasons. This case is a prime example of this. The fact that the person producing the online grooming might not in that moment be sitting at the keyboard with an erection does not in any way decrease the actual eventual harm to the child.

OP posts:
Lockheart · 27/04/2022 17:34

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:28

It may also be that the 2003 Act is not fit for purpose where we are, nearly 20 years later, especially with regard to online offending. The internet and the power of the internet is very different now from what it was in 2003.

True. Updates do get brought in (for example the sexual communication with a child bit was added in 2017(?) I think), but the advent of social media and its huge expansion could be something that requires more of a sea-change.

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:28

It may also be that the 2003 Act is not fit for purpose where we are, nearly 20 years later, especially with regard to online offending. The internet and the power of the internet is very different now from what it was in 2003.

OP posts:
Lockheart · 27/04/2022 17:27

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:21

Sexual communication with a child is Sec 15A of SOA.

It includes communication intended to encourage B (the under 16) to make (whether to A (the person over 18) or to another) a communication that is sexual. I would argue this to be precisely the case when the website encourages mastubation-googling, making toy vulvas, drawing penises etc etc. Because realistically the younger chidren are not going to do that all by themselves, they will do it with an "interested adult".

But again, in order for the offence of sexual communication to have taken place, you would need to prove it was done for sexual gratification, and I don't think that could be successfully argued in this context.

F115ASexual communication with a child
(1)A person aged 18 or over (A) commits an offence if—
(a)for the purpose of obtaining sexual gratification, A intentionally communicates with another person (B),
(b)the communication is sexual or is intended to encourage B to make (whether to A or to another) a communication that is sexual, and
(c)B is under 16 and A does not reasonably believe that B is 16 or over.
(2)For the purposes of this section, a communication is sexual if—
(a)any part of it relates to sexual activity, or
(b)a reasonable person would, in all the circumstances but regardless of any person's purpose, consider any part of the communication to be sexual;

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:24

But yes, it is tricky because of the way society has gone in recent years and changes in attitudes in some parts of society with regard to what is and is not accaptable. No way they will ever be prosecuted, as I have said. But that didn't stop me reporting them as groomers to CEOP and the police. Because I believed it to be the right thing to do regardless.

OP posts:
Lockheart · 27/04/2022 17:22

PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 17:11

You're asking me why CEOP - part of the police - are explicitly asking people to report grooming behaviour?

I'd assume it comes under sexual communication with a child, or other parts of the sexual offences act.
You're also mistaken if you think the police can only be contacted if a crime can be proven to have taken place - we've had numerous discussions on here about what the police record, including coverage of various court cases.

Sonia has updated that the A&S PCC has suggested a letter to the Chief Constable. Perhaps someone should let them know that Lockheart thinks it's all fine and that adults exposing their genitals to 5-year-olds while telling them their ideas of sexual pleasure is age-appropriate?

I didn't ask you anything of the sort. The CEOP have said report it to the police, the police have apparently said it's not a police matter, so I'm contemplating the relevant laws.

It wouldn't come under sexual communication with a child or as far as I can see under the child sex offences sections of the SOA.

I'm not going to respond to the ad hominem attack.

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:21

Sexual communication with a child is Sec 15A of SOA.

It includes communication intended to encourage B (the under 16) to make (whether to A (the person over 18) or to another) a communication that is sexual. I would argue this to be precisely the case when the website encourages mastubation-googling, making toy vulvas, drawing penises etc etc. Because realistically the younger chidren are not going to do that all by themselves, they will do it with an "interested adult".

OP posts:
Lockheart · 27/04/2022 17:16

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:07

Just for starters, I would argue that these offences could be considered relevent:

causing a child to watch a sexual act (telling them to google masturbation, whether in animals or humans, would qualify)
inciting a child to engage in sexual activity
sexual communication with a child

But as I have said repeatedly on this thread I am also very very concerened about the grooming aspect. The wider grooming of society to normalise sexual activity by and with children, and the specific instructions on the webpage for children to engage in sexualised activities with interested adults, which would fall under facilitation of an offence.

I know full well they are not going to be prosecuted but the point is that they should be under the existing law.

s.12 (causing a child to watch a sexual act) would not apply unless you could prove a specific individual did this for the purposes of sexual gratification.

s.10 (causing or inciting a child to engage in sexual activity) I think is the closest you would get to a breach of the law, but I think this would be a stretch in the context of a website which caters to a wide age range.

Sexual communication with a child (not under the SOA, this is under a different act) would only apply if a specific individual over 18 was talking to another specific individual under 16. Not likely in the context of an open website and a theatre show.

They should only be prosecuted under the existing law if the law can be proven to have been broken.

The conversation about a wider landscape of sexualising children is a different issue.

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:16

(Sorry re typos. If only the new MN update had included an edit button!)

OP posts:
theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:15

And the definition of "sexual" is at Sec 78. Which says:

There are two alternative limbs to the definition of “sexual”. Paragraph (a) covers activity that the reasonable person would always consider to be sexual because of its nature, such as sexual intercourse. Paragraph (b) covers activity that the reasonable person would consider, because of its nature, may or may not be sexual depending on the circumstances or the intentions of the person carrying it out.

So the "reasonable person" test is relevent here, and I would imagine, if any of this was ever to be prosecuted, that would be a possible line of defence (ie that a reasonable person would not consider their actions sexual, or alternatively would not consier their intentions to cause it to be sexual). In today's world, given the aforementioned societal grooming, that defence moght well succeeed.

OP posts:
PrelateChuckles · 27/04/2022 17:11

You're asking me why CEOP - part of the police - are explicitly asking people to report grooming behaviour?

I'd assume it comes under sexual communication with a child, or other parts of the sexual offences act.
You're also mistaken if you think the police can only be contacted if a crime can be proven to have taken place - we've had numerous discussions on here about what the police record, including coverage of various court cases.

Sonia has updated that the A&S PCC has suggested a letter to the Chief Constable. Perhaps someone should let them know that Lockheart thinks it's all fine and that adults exposing their genitals to 5-year-olds while telling them their ideas of sexual pleasure is age-appropriate?

theDudesmummy · 27/04/2022 17:07

Just for starters, I would argue that these offences could be considered relevent:

causing a child to watch a sexual act (telling them to google masturbation, whether in animals or humans, would qualify)
inciting a child to engage in sexual activity
sexual communication with a child

But as I have said repeatedly on this thread I am also very very concerened about the grooming aspect. The wider grooming of society to normalise sexual activity by and with children, and the specific instructions on the webpage for children to engage in sexualised activities with interested adults, which would fall under facilitation of an offence.

I know full well they are not going to be prosecuted but the point is that they should be under the existing law.

OP posts: