Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that this is legal

30 replies

TibetanTerrah · 19/04/2022 14:18

I had to call a plumber out yesterday and while he was here he checked my immersion tank.

I live in a block of 4 rented flats. It seems we all share the same tank. I laughed dryly and said "how does that work with hot water bills then?" And he said there's no way to track who is using what so the bill is divided between you. If someone happens to be a high user then the others effectively subsidise their bills.

Especially now with cost of living rising, I'm surprised that this can be a "thing" and that they can get away with not telling you when viewing and applying. I've lived here three years but have had periods when I haven't lived here (six months over lockdown when I only popped back to get post etc for example), and I was surprised when my electric bill was the same as usual after that time. Now i know why! Angry

There's nothing I can do, but this week has been really shit already and we're only on Tuesday so this revelation has pissed me off even more than it would normally.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
chesirecat99 · 19/04/2022 20:02

A communal meter is common, @burnoutbabe, but OP states it is connected to 4 meters, which is why I and (presumably for the same reason) Apileofballyhoo are questioning it... and who told her that. I have 2 water meters (for inside and outside) and they are shown separately on the bill. She also said she is being charged for it through the electricity supplier, not a building service charge.

If the electricity company is billing her for both her meter and a share of a communal meter, her bill should have 2 separate meter numbers (so that the person being billed can check the reading is correct on each meter). Otherwise, if they just added it onto her reading, her meter reading and the number of units used wouldn't tally up, her bill would be for more kWh than the difference between the 2 meter readings. Unless she is right and the immersion heater is somehow connected to 4 meters. I don't think that is possible with a conventional dial/digital meter though (as they measure the electricity flowing through them where the supply enters the building, they can't identify what appliance is using it after it has left the meter and then charge a different rate for different appliances). Unless OP has some uber smart meter that "talks" to the communal meter but I'm not sure that exists and whose wifi would it use?

I think I would be checking that I am not paying the entire bill myself if I were OP.

burnoutbabe · 19/04/2022 17:34

@Apileofballyhoo

I can't see how the hot water tank is hooked up to 4 separate meters.
or possibly hooked up to 1 and the cost just divided by 4 and then what

added to each meter?
the meter reading company adds it on top of the normal readings.

a communal meter is common -our block has that which covers the lights in the hallways and the cleaners using a hoover. We then get rebillled that as a share of our annual management charge we pay.

Apileofballyhoo · 19/04/2022 17:25

I can't see how the hot water tank is hooked up to 4 separate meters.

mamabr · 19/04/2022 16:57

Where I used to live, it was a conversion and I had the same issue too..
can't believe this wasn't disclosed to you before moving in

LeftFootForward · 19/04/2022 16:34

I can well believe this OP.
About 20 odd years ago I rented a room in a shared conversion in London. It was originally a house that had been split into 2 flats, one upstairs, one downstairs. The upstairs flat had never to the knowledge of anyone living there, ever had an electricity bill. This information was passed down from tenants to tenants on the assumption that the downstairs flat paid the whole wack. I don't know if they did though because no one ever asked them.

catndogslife · 19/04/2022 16:16

Are you in England OP and were you given the EPC rating for your rental property?
The minimum rating for a rental property is grade E at the moment and it is illegal to rent out a property below this value.

chesirecat99 · 19/04/2022 16:07

As the water is used and reheated again, all four meters are charged for the electric used equally. but theres no way of tracking which flat the water went into and calculating the cost to replace it in the tank iyswim.

Who told you that? The electricity supplier? I'm not sure that is possible with an ordinary meter... Are you sure you aren't paying for it?

kgap · 19/04/2022 15:59

Yep. There you are:
Energy Efficiency Directive 2012/27/EU (EED) on Heat Metering
• Art 9(3): multi-apartment or multi-purpose buildings supplied with heating or cooling or hot water from external sources, meters had to be installed at the heat exchanger or the point of delivery to the building before 5 June 2014. No exceptions are foreseen.
• Art 9(3): individual meters for each apartment or unit in such building had to be installed by 31 December 2016 where technically feasible and cost-efficient.
• If the installation of individual heat meters is not technically feasible or not cost-efficient, accurate heat cost allocators had to be installed for each radiator, unless it was shown by the Member State that this would not be cost-efficient

10HailMarys · 19/04/2022 15:58

I used to live in a house converted into four (tiny) flats and we had card meters for electricity but our gas bill was split in the same way that yours is, OP. Also ... the thermostat, boiler and heating controls were in one of the flats, so the other three flats had no control over when the heating was on or what temperature it was set at. Luckily, the couple who had the magic gift of heating control were great and agreed what times they'd put it on ... but only after they were actually made aware by the landlord that they were only ones who could set it. He didn't actually tell them when they moved in, so for the first few months the rest of us would occasionally be freezing for an entire weekend because they'd gone away or something.

kgap · 19/04/2022 15:56

I remember looking into this ages ago and there was some EU regulation/directive that required each flat in a rental building to have a meter for their heat usage. It’s worth you researching it a bit. There may be something similar that we inherited from our good old EU days that you can point your landlord to.

ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 15:48

I live in a massive block of flats and share my hot water tank with nearly 1,000 other people. Beat that!

TibetanTerrah · 19/04/2022 15:40

@Jossbow

So who has the control switch? An immersion heater you switch on and off.
Its in a cupboard in the communal hall.
OP posts:
irishfarmer · 19/04/2022 15:38

I lived in a converted old Edwardian house. 4 flats in the one house. I know we shared one oil tank and the cost was just added to our rent. We had electric meters for our own flats though. How is the electricity cost split between the 4 flats? Surely it can only be read by one meter, probably the same meter the the communal lights etc are connected to.

I'd be asking your LL

OneTC · 19/04/2022 15:37

You're just talking about unmetered water aren't you?

You're actually heating the water yourself

Unmetered water is becoming more unusual but our block of 57 flats has only just had individual meters installed.

Jossbow · 19/04/2022 15:33

So who has the control switch? An immersion heater you switch on and off.

TibetanTerrah · 19/04/2022 15:29

@Lochroy

I can see why this is shocking, but it's not actually that unlike the way water is billed for house which don't have a meter, just a different scale.
Yes that makes sense. Its just disheartening as I'm trying to reduce my usage to save money and this is something out of my control Sad
OP posts:
Lochroy · 19/04/2022 15:11

I can see why this is shocking, but it's not actually that unlike the way water is billed for house which don't have a meter, just a different scale.

SmileyClare · 19/04/2022 15:07

It depends on the other tenants and the size of the other flats. If they're all for single professionals or couples, I would imagine your usage would be fairly equal and it may actually be more cost effective to share a communal tank.

I think it's unlikely any of the tenants will "realise how it works and take advantage" Confused what do you mean? They'll start offering baths to anyone visiting or something?!

It should be in your tenancy agreement and definitely worth checking the contract you signed.

TibetanTerrah · 19/04/2022 14:58

@Pinzotti we don't have gas, so all the flats equally share the cost of electric to heat the tank, regardless of who actually uses the hot water and how much they use.

OP posts:
Pinzotti · 19/04/2022 14:48

I don't understand. How does this affect your HOT water and electricity bills?

TibetanTerrah · 19/04/2022 14:46

@burnoutbabe

How can the elec bill be shared like that?

The hot water must be attached to one meter. Now that maybe a communal meter which the landlord is billed and charges you all 1/4. But it can't be that the elec company adds 1/4 of another meter to your bill. (If they did I'd expect it to be very obvious on the bill anyway)

So I'd double check how it's billed.

As the water is used and reheated again, all four meters are charged for the electric used equally. but theres no way of tracking which flat the water went into and calculating the cost to replace it in the tank iyswim.

@springtimeishereagain I was disappointed, but as I'm a low user anyway and my standing charge has always been quite high, I just sucked it up and didn't think there might be a shared tank. This is my first rental alone and it never occurred to me.

@SmileyClare I'm not paying for the plumber. The emergency guy at the letting agent told me he wouldn't come out as he was ill and to call someone myself and they'd reimburse me. As it happens the plumber was lovely and I didn't have to pay anything upfront anyway.

OP posts:
burnoutbabe · 19/04/2022 14:39

How can the elec bill be shared like that?

The hot water must be attached to one meter. Now that maybe a communal meter which the landlord is billed and charges you all 1/4. But it can't be that the elec company adds 1/4 of another meter to your bill. (If they did I'd expect it to be very obvious on the bill anyway)

So I'd double check how it's billed.

springtimeishereagain · 19/04/2022 14:37

I can understand having a shared water tank, but how can they justify shared electricity bills?? That's insane. Why didn't you do anything about it after you moved out for 6 months and noticed that your bill hadn't gone down? Think I would have...

I wonder if that is legal.

SmileyClare · 19/04/2022 14:31

There are some benefits to a communal tank. It's larger and more cost effective than heating a smaller one for a single person. The cost for repairs or replacements are presumably divided between you (?) and if any of the tenants are away or a flat is empty, you will benefit from the lower usage.

It's worth checking with your landlord before calling out and paying for a plumber. I'm not sure you should have to foot that bill?

AHungryCaterpillar · 19/04/2022 14:29

Yes I live in a gf maisonette and seem to have this as well! The people from upstairs sent someone into mine once because they needed to do something with the hot water in their flat. I had no idea it was shared until then Confused