Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

powerful, potentially life-threatening dogs

139 replies

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 12:14

AIBU to think people who own such breeds which then go on to kill/maim a child / pet/adult should automatically be prosecuted? With so many smaller weaker breed available ( which may well be snappy but who would struggle to inflict the ghastly injuries seen lately) WHY would you pick a dog so heavy and powerful that if they turn they would be unstoppable? Another child in the paper today maimed by his "best friend".

OP posts:
Suzi888 · 19/04/2022 14:19

YANBU

As a dog owner, the owner should carry a license and be prosecuted. Not that it really helps if you’ve had your face ripped off…. Hmm
I’m not sure why anyone would want to own a dog that is capable of a full blown, unstoppable and fatal attack.

People who train these dogs sell the dogs upwards of £20k, they are family dogs (some of them) but will give their life to protect you.

Joe Bloggs from down the road, in his Nike tracksuit should not own a dog of this type. For people saying a chihuahua can cause injury- these massive, muscle bound dogs say- hold my beer! They are a different league.

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 14:18

@OldTinHat I'd have though the content would be obvious from the title? I can appreciate you may find it tedious so although I am sure many find your comment relevant, and a meaningful contribution to the debate, can I suggest for your own mental equilibrium that in future you simply scroll on past and ignore?

OP posts:
Thisismynamenow · 19/04/2022 14:16

ANY dog can cause serious damage to a child or adult, regardless of the breed.

Any parent neglectful enough to leave their child in a room with any dog and the dog attacks should be prosecuted for manslaughter.

Its fully down to training, upbringing and respect that their an ANIMAL.

I write this as my 8 stone Staffy snuggles into my baby bump, and whilst I'm looking at the scars a Mini Jack Russel gave me as a child

Horst · 19/04/2022 14:14

A lot of these attacks do seem to be with brand new “family pets” and yes it’s always a bull type and it’s always family buying then with young children/babies as second hand dogs. Then shocked when they leave baby/child alone and baby/child gets hurts.

It’s more about the owners in these cases these are not accidents due to the breed they are poor ownership not looking after their dogs or children good enough. Neglect all round basically. The breed is only at fault due to the type of people buying them in these circumstances.

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 14:10

@Spacedebret

My kids grew up with large breed dogs. They were well trained in how to behave so never rode or pulled at or sat on the dogs. They didn’t touch them if they were asleep. They were not their ‘best friend’ or sleep buddy. I despair if so many of the photos that turn up of toddlers grabbing at dogs or big dogs next to babies or dogs enduring forced hugs off bigger kids. So often that dog is already showing stress but the owners are clueless. We need to understand our animals better to prevent many of these accidents.
Yes !! This ^^. I have 3 dogs - all gentle creatures, but I never leave them alone with a child and I always make sure the children behave and understand not to pull them about, mess with them when they are eating, put their faces into theirs.
OP posts:
OldTinHat · 19/04/2022 14:06

Uh not this thread again!!!

powershowerforanhour · 19/04/2022 14:04

Every time we have this thread- almost always sparked by one of the large breeds or types of dogs historically used for fighting, guarding or gripping having killed somebody- a surprising number of people fall over themselves to talk about all the hordes of frenzied Chihuahuas, teacup Yorkies and tiny mini maltipoos rampaging around ripping out the throats of children and grown men alike and having to be shot by SWAT teams.

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 14:00

@Maydaysoonenough Were these the 7 dogs, mixed dachshunds x breeds and a collie in Oaklahoma?

OP posts:
Spacedebret · 19/04/2022 13:59

My kids grew up with large breed dogs. They were well trained in how to behave so never rode or pulled at or sat on the dogs. They didn’t touch them if they were asleep. They were not their ‘best friend’ or sleep buddy. I despair if so many of the photos that turn up of toddlers grabbing at dogs or big dogs next to babies or dogs enduring forced hugs off bigger kids. So often that dog is already showing stress but the owners are clueless. We need to understand our animals better to prevent many of these accidents.

PlasticineMeg · 19/04/2022 13:57

I agree people who have dangerous dogs round children are fucking stupid. I don’t care for the ‘oh he’s a softie’ - yeah until he’s not!

However I don’t see the value in prosecuting people whose children have been killed. They have been through enough.

Maydaysoonenough · 19/04/2022 13:55

The article about the 17 mo girl mentions family pet. They had owned it a week. It wasn't a family pet. It was a strange ddog in a strange environment allowed access to a baby. I hope the owners are prosecuted for neglect.
I had a rotty for 11 years. She wasn't allowed near unknown dc...

Leonberger · 19/04/2022 13:51

I agree with what your trying to say to a point however I don’t know how the line would be drawn.

I mean labradors and golden retrievers are large and powerful. Newfoundland’s and other giants are typically slow, calm, gentle and often used as service or rescue animals.
Then you have the likes of wolfhounds, greyhounds and the like which are typically calm and gentle. So large does not necessarily mean nasty.

What I would agree with is looking at the breeds that pop up time and time again repeating the same behaviour and look at the reasons why. It’s almost always a repeat of the same pattern…bull breed type, newly acquired or unknown history, more often than not uncastrated male, history of aggression previously, no formal training completed, not enough stimulation or exercise, no background on dam and sire genetics or temperament, owned by dare I say a certain type of person. Maybe that’s the sort of thing that should be focused on rather than the size of the animal.

The vast majority of people with larger dogs are sensible. I for one spend so much time training, socialising and exercising my dogs mentally and physically. I am very strict with the rules around my dogs and children (or adults for that matter!) because a dogs a dog but I don’t think it’s fair to say because mine are large I am an irresponsible person. There are so many more factors at play than that.

I do 100% agree that owners should be prosecuted for irresponsible dog ownership though!!

Nidan2Sandan · 19/04/2022 13:49

My sil looked after a staffy for an ex boyfriend for a while and fuck me that dog was HUGE! It was all chest and muscle and scared the beejesus out of me. It jumped up at me as I entered her house and sent me flying, i mean, I'm not a tiny woman and this thing floored me without trying.

Luckily it was a big softie and proceeded to lick me to death, but I couldnt get it off me and it took my large strong husband and his sister to pull it off.

She refused to look after it after that.

So, I think these dogs bred for power and muscle should be licensed and not allowed in homes with children under the age of 16.

I think all dog owners should have to pass a test and get a licence anyway. Reduce the number of dog owners, the cash cow that dog breeding has become and bring a bit more respect and understanding to an animal which is deadly in the wrong hands

FizzyTango · 19/04/2022 13:49

The situation reported on today is awful, I feel so sorry for the dog. Totally the parents fault. The dog was bloody asleep!

TheWayTheLightFalls · 19/04/2022 13:48

(Bias warning - I love Rotties and staffs.)

I think the average larger dog can do more damage than the average smaller dog, but there’s also this thing where the “tough guy dog du jour” - which let’s be honest is not ever going to be a Chihuahua - becomes popular with people who bring out the worst in it/fail to train it/fly drones around it while it sleeps/lets their kids chew its tail. And then we all talk about banning the dog.

Maydaysoonenough · 19/04/2022 13:45

A lady was killed by a pack of dachshunds..
Imo it is all about circumstances and owners than the breed...
Recent deaths were ddogs that has recently been acquired from unknown sources and thrown into a new life with dc in it. Is the ddog really responsible for that?

Bagelsandbrie · 19/04/2022 13:44

@AntiHop

That poor little boy.

Of course larger breeds are a higher risk. They are stronger. Doesn't mean other dogs aren't a risk too. I don't know why some people are so keen to deny this.

Because they think it justifies their own selfishness to keep these types of dogs as pets.
AntiHop · 19/04/2022 13:43

That poor little boy.

Of course larger breeds are a higher risk. They are stronger. Doesn't mean other dogs aren't a risk too. I don't know why some people are so keen to deny this.

Eddielizzard · 19/04/2022 13:43

Yes, I think if you have a dog that has a history of aggression, you absolutely should be prosecuted.

capricorn12 · 19/04/2022 13:41

I was at a local park last week with DD and we were queuing for ice cream when a woman appeared with a huge English bulldog. The woman was about 7 stone and was clearly struggling to keep hold of the dog which looked like it weighed more than she did. At one point she tried to tie it to a table but it just walked off and took the table with it!
Luckily it wasn't an aggressive dog but it highlighted to me that the owner would have no chance of controlling it if it had been.
I agree that some smaller breeds can be more aggressive but like a previous poster said, their size make them easier to control.

Bagelsandbrie · 19/04/2022 13:38

I agree with you op.

And yet here we already have people saying “but what about xxxxx tiny breed of dog” blah blah- come on, yeah if you’re stupid enough to let them get near your face it won’t be good but they’re unlikely to kill a child. If my 9 year old was attacked by any breed of dog I think they’d stand a pretty good chance of getting away from a Yorkshire terrier or a chihuahua…! Hmm

People need to stop buying big powerful dogs as pets.

Iheartmysmart · 19/04/2022 13:31

One of my friends was horrifically bitten by a Jack Russell when I was a child. We were sat on the kerb playing and the dog ran over and went for both of us. This was back in the 70s where people would just let their dogs out in the morning and take them in at night.

I was ‘fortunate’ and only had a few bites on my hands, arms and legs and one on my face. She was practically ripped to shreds and had to have extensive surgery to repair the damage. It’s not just big and powerful dogs that can cause dreadful injuries.

Limegreentangerine · 19/04/2022 13:27

It's much easier to get out of a chihuahuas jaws than a pit bull ....

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 13:21

@SharpLily

Children have been killed and maimed by all sorts of different dog breeds, including Chihuahuas. YABVU.
Just done a Googol search and can't find anything about Chihuahuas killing or maiming a child. I'd not heard of this - perhaps you could give me a link, please? I have seen the adult who was bitten by her own dog though. It's more about people outside the family - or any child. So, whilst I agree all owners need to take responsibility for their dogs I still think those that own the larger, stronger breeds which statistics suggest do the most damage need to be particularly called to account. Maybe then I should amend my aibu to say that any dog who attacks a child/pet/adult causing death or serious injury should be prosecuted? (Unless of course, the injured party is the owner alone )
OP posts:
Lbnc2021 · 19/04/2022 12:54

I agree with you OP

I’ve said it before, anything that can’t be trusted to be left alone with my children for a minute, whether it’s human or animal, doesn’t get past my front door.