Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

powerful, potentially life-threatening dogs

139 replies

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 12:14

AIBU to think people who own such breeds which then go on to kill/maim a child / pet/adult should automatically be prosecuted? With so many smaller weaker breed available ( which may well be snappy but who would struggle to inflict the ghastly injuries seen lately) WHY would you pick a dog so heavy and powerful that if they turn they would be unstoppable? Another child in the paper today maimed by his "best friend".

OP posts:
Horst · 19/04/2022 15:10

The helicopter dog was put down.

“'The ownership of the dog was transferred to police. Following a thorough assessment it was established the dog could never be rehomed due to the violent act and they were humanely destroyed.'”

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 19/04/2022 15:10

It's not always down to size though.

Littler dogs can often be more snappy and could still kill or seriously maim if they bit into a main artery. A little baby was killed by a Jack Russell about 10 years ago. He was only about a week old. Imagine how haunted these families are. It doesn't help you saying "people should be prosecuted"
Like when a child hits another child it's hardly the parents fault is it. Therefore when a dog attacks it's not the owners fault. Unless of course the owner was telling the dog to "fetch"

I also remember reading an article about a women who was minding her mums dog He was as daft as brush (as they say)and one day for no reason he just turned and had her terrified trapped in the bathroom.

VickyEadieofThigh · 19/04/2022 15:05

@TempName01

It’s sickening. And this type of attack can easily happen while the parent or responsible adult is in the room so it’s no good saying ‘I don’t leave the dog alone with the child’.
Indeed. But reading the article about the child badly bitten by the family pet when he and siblings were flying toy helicopters indoors, I wonder how many kids and how many helicopters - because the family has 8 children. Parents need to exercise close supervision in such instances.
Stirrupp · 19/04/2022 15:04

I cannot believe that the dog in that recent attack is not being PTS. Unbelievable. There are more than enough dogs in the world, we don't need dogs like that in society full stop. 😡

Agrudge · 19/04/2022 14:59

Yabu . As I've said on other posts the problems start at the other end of the lead.

I've not seen a dog attack from a decent home/owners

TempName01 · 19/04/2022 14:59

It’s sickening. And this type of attack can easily happen while the parent or responsible adult is in the room so it’s no good saying ‘I don’t leave the dog alone with the child’.

RollerGirl7 · 19/04/2022 14:58

I agree with you OP

A Yorkie or sausage dog or westie, etc might yap (although I've had several and none where yappy) but I know it they attached someone I could wrestle them /kick them off.

That being said all dogs can cause damage with teeth and claws but obviously smaller dogs cause less damage and are easier to overpower.

Not popular but I believe big dogs should be reserved for over 16s and if you have a big dog then have children the dog should be rehomed.

EdithStourton · 19/04/2022 14:56

@Maydaysoonenough

A lady was killed by a pack of dachshunds.. Imo it is all about circumstances and owners than the breed... Recent deaths were ddogs that has recently been acquired from unknown sources and thrown into a new life with dc in it. Is the ddog really responsible for that?
They weren't entirely dachshund: they was veery obviously a sizeable % - at least 50% - of something else. And some of the dogs involved don't look like dachshunds at all.

Post-mortem photo of the dogs here:
blog.dogsbite.org/2018/05/dog-bite-fatality-ardmore-woman-killed-by-dogs.html

PaintAndPirouettes · 19/04/2022 14:54

@yellowsuninthesky

I think a strict liability offence for dogs that injure other animals, whether other dogs, farm animals or humans would probably concentrate some owners' minds.
How would that work?

For instance, snappy Jack Russell has a crack at an otherwise lovely staffie. A scuffle ensues. Staffie bites Jack Russell - bad enough to need a few stitches but not badly enough to maim. Staffie is uninjured. If I were the Jack Russell's owner I'd take the view that my dog deserved what it got and I wouldn't dream of asking the staffie owner to pay. Your proposal would have the staffie owner liable.

Likewise, child walks up to dog and kicks it (happened to a relative's dog years ago; the dog was never the same again). Dog retaliates in kind, leaves some puncture marks and draws a bit of blood. Frankly the child deserves to be bitten in those circumstances, and the dog owner shouldn't be held liable.

Context is everything.

toastfiend · 19/04/2022 14:54

I've got large breed, powerful dogs (although HPR types, not the "tough guy" image dogs that are often talked about on here in this context). We've had them since puppies, they're very well trained and soft as butter and DS has grown up with very clear guidance on how you do and do not treat dogs, but I'd still never leave them alone together. I've met more nasty terriers than large breeds, though, so I don't think banning big dogs is the answer. My PILs' Jack Russell has absolutely no qualms about going for someone's face if she's mildly displeased. She is NEVER in the same room as DS and is muzzled at all times when we are at their house.

Ultimately, I think there needs to be more regulation around dog ownership, a reduction in the ability for people to pass dogs around through FB/gumtree/any other source that doesn't carry out any proper checks on the dog or its future home and people need to be less complacent about their beloved pets and not allow their children to climb all over them/take part in activities around the dog that are likely to be scaring or confusing to it, no matter how trustworthy they think they are.

Suzi888 · 19/04/2022 14:54

Have just viewed the photo of that poor child.

I’m quite surprised, well shocked to read that the dog has been rehomed as the incident was classed as an accident.

Stirrupp · 19/04/2022 14:53

I always love these threads..you always get some saying a chihuahua can do just as much damage as an XL Bully/Pitbull etc 😂😂😂😂😂😂

We have 2 Jack Russells, 3 Miniature Dachshunds, 2 Cockers, a Rottweiler and a bull/mastiff cross. I know which ones I'd rather be bitten by!!!!!!

Idiocy thinking there's as much risk with any breed. Absolute ignorant idiocy. Big strong powerful breeds should not be owned by just anyone.

Philisophigal · 19/04/2022 14:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

PaintAndPirouettes · 19/04/2022 14:47

@BemoreDerek

If it's the story I'm thinking of it was entirely avoidable, the family were flying toy helicopters round the living room while the dog slept. The supervising parent left the room and the dog obviously woke up and was freaked out by the helicopters, sadly the child face was the nearest thing to the dog and the inevitable happened. I have 'powerful' dogs and they are never alone with any DC let alone when there are things going on around them which may frighten or excite them, surely that's dog 101?
I too assume it was that story.

There's a reason why there's a saying of "let sleeping dogs lie". It's common for even very placid dogs to snap when startled awake, before they realise where they are, what is happening or who is around them.

Letting small children play around a sleeping dog, even if supervised, is asking for trouble.

ComDummings · 19/04/2022 14:43

@yellowsuninthesky

I think a strict liability offence for dogs that injure other animals, whether other dogs, farm animals or humans would probably concentrate some owners' minds.
I agree
BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 19/04/2022 14:42

I have large breed working dogs (GSDs) some larger and more powerful than the others. I also have a small mixed breed thing which is about 10kg wet. I know which one I would rather be attacked by.

Anyone who does not accept that a large powerful breed can do more damage than a small breed is just being silly. That being said a small dog can easily maim / kill a small child / baby and anyone who doesn't think any dog can be a danger to children is also being silly.

In my opinion a large part of this problem comes from people allowing their kids to climb all over their "best friend", invade its space and very often clearly make it feel uncomfortable. Social media is full of it. A kid with its arms hugged tightly round the dogs neck, and the dog body posture, eyes, mouth and whole demeanour screaming get it off me and the caption will always be something idiotic like aww best friends. When that dog finally snaps and bites it will always be ... came out of nowhere, he's always been so good. Bollocks. Supervise your kids with dogs. Don't allow your kids to climb all over your dogs.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 19/04/2022 14:40

OP sorry I know this is anecdotal but I've personally received injury and know people who have been attacked by smaller breeds of dog.

I grew up with large breeds who have all been so incredible gentle and far easier to train than some smaller breeds. The main issue with larger breeds (IME) is the accidental knocking over they do or bashing into people when excited.

A smaller, mixed breed dog (size of a Springer Spaniel) attacked me and my dog. Left me with scars on my legs and (I'm ashamed to admit this) but I ended up having to kick it to get it off my dog. No amount of dragging my dog away, shouting, or trying to prise the dog off would help.

Suprima · 19/04/2022 14:37

So many disingenuous posters on here.

Of course large, muscled, athletic, strong jawed dog is going to be more dangerous.

I have a toy breed. He might nip and take off a bit of my face, or a finger- sure. It can happen.

A pitbull could rip your throat out.

I find the obsession with purchasing and breeding dogs that can be actual killing machines abhorrent. Especially seeing as they have no utility and tend to be kept in flats or with small gardens.

I don’t know any sensible dog owner which owns a bully type. I follow a few people on Instagram who have rescued these dogs and are good owners- but the people who illegally breed them and purchase them tend to be thugs who want the scariest dog possible.

Laiste · 19/04/2022 14:35

I mean are you after the total ban of all breeds bigger than a certain weight?

Or would you hope that lots of prosecutions alone will deter people from owning the larger/more dangerous breeds in the first place?

Laiste · 19/04/2022 14:32

What are you asking for exactly OP?

For the owner of any (?) dog which does any (?) damage to anyone (?) anywhere (?) to be prosecuted?

Not being goady. Genuine question. I'm confused about what you are calling for. What laws do you want changed/bought in?

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 19/04/2022 14:31

I have two dogs one of which is a massive Labrador cross. He's a rescue dog but has the sweetest nature and loves people, plus he's pretty well trained. That said, I would never leave him alone with young children - he's an animal, after all. Children provoke animals without meaning to and if never want him or a child to be put in that position. If there are children round, he is supervised, and that's it.

OldTinHat · 19/04/2022 14:30

@Bjarnum I certainly don't scroll past. My friend had to have her shihzu put down after it attacked a toddler, police ordered.

Not exactly your perceived big breed killer dog.

I've been mauled by a daschund.

I think maybe direct your dislike to dogs in general??

If you're a cat person, however, I've been hospitalised thanks to a cat. Just saying.

gogohm · 19/04/2022 14:27

All dogs can be dangerous. Untrained dogs however are particularly risky, this includes toy sized dogs whose owners didn't think training was necessary because they are tiny (my collie was badly bitten by a teacup pincer I think they are called, Doberman in miniature, he could have killed it if he wasn't trained not to bite).

The gentlest dog I know is also the largest, a Newfoundland, gorgeous gentle giant who seems to like live music!

yellowsuninthesky · 19/04/2022 14:25

I think a strict liability offence for dogs that injure other animals, whether other dogs, farm animals or humans would probably concentrate some owners' minds.

NightOwl101 · 19/04/2022 14:21

I have giant breed dogs and DC but i am a responsible dog owner, they have had training (DDogs not DC which I would if I could 😂) and they are never alone with my DC, they have plenty of space to get away from DC that is just their space and I make sure that they aren't in situations that can potentially cause any horrible situations.