Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

powerful, potentially life-threatening dogs

139 replies

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 12:14

AIBU to think people who own such breeds which then go on to kill/maim a child / pet/adult should automatically be prosecuted? With so many smaller weaker breed available ( which may well be snappy but who would struggle to inflict the ghastly injuries seen lately) WHY would you pick a dog so heavy and powerful that if they turn they would be unstoppable? Another child in the paper today maimed by his "best friend".

OP posts:
Kathers92 · 19/04/2022 16:47

I have a Rottie and a toddler and have no issues the dog is well trained the toddler is very good around dogs. I also have a smaller poodle/ Lab cross. It has now got to the stage now where I keep the Rottweiler on a long line when going out for a walk because the amount of times he has been attacked by other smaller dogs who's owners have no clue.
I have also had issues of peoples dogs coming into my land and attacking my dogs/ horses, A few weeks ago it look about five minutes to get a staffys teeth out of my dogs neck while the owner stood other aide of the hedge on the footpath telling me its not my fault she cant call her dog back.

I live on a small holding and have previously had outbuildings burgled. As well as being a family pet he has been a fantastic deterrent which a smaller dog would be no substitute for. But yes the fact of the matter is a 60kg dog can do a lot of damage and should only be owned by responsible people.

WeAllHaveWings · 19/04/2022 16:36

Unfortunately domestic dog ownership has too few rules and the ones that are there are way out of line now with powerful breeds that are being breed to be larger and stronger than ever before, or powerful working breeds are being introduced to domestic homes, and anyone can just go out and buy one.

Agrudge · 19/04/2022 16:26

[quote HorseGallopingOnATomato]@Agrudge I read that as a typo “with shitty owners” and not white shitty owners! Grin[/quote]
Let's hope so

HorseGallopingOnATomato · 19/04/2022 16:23

@Agrudge I read that as a typo “with shitty owners” and not white shitty owners! Grin

Leonberger · 19/04/2022 16:22

@afizzysweet personally if my arthritic old dog bit someone I would be kicking myself into next week for putting a dog into the situation where it can be touched by someone and have to escalate its behaviour to that extent without me advocating for it first. I would then very sadly have it put to sleep if I couldn’t ensure 1000% that it wouldn’t happen again, although like I say I wouldn’t have put it in that position in the first place.
There’s no way on earth I would pass it on to someone else as so many people seem to do.

People are unpredictable (more so than dogs!) and behave like entitled idiots but I don’t think they deserve to be bitten for it.
My dogs are stupid human magnets. It’s a pain when children or even adults on occasion run up to them but the responsibility is mine to make sure nobody is insured as they are my pets under my control.

I love dogs, I work with dogs, they are my hobby and my passion however I understand that not all dogs have a place around other people and other animals.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 16:14

Banning breeds doesn't work. We've already banned four breeds of dog in the UK and we still get numerous fatal dog attacks (from perfectly legal breeds) each year.

The law around selling and owning dogs is what needs to change. At the moment, anyone can go online, pick a dog, buy it and take it home with their newborn baby. That's the problem. Not the fact that some people own certain breeds.

Any breed can do damage. There was a 9yo girl in this country who needed 200+ stitches because she was bitten by the family Labrador - yet Labs are constantly rated as being amazing, friendly, biddable family pets. There are also cases where Jack Russells have killed babies.

Yes, size and breed matters to an extent but it's not the sole thing that dogs should be judged by. Temperament, health, breeding and socialisation are all much more important factors than breed.

afizzysweet · 19/04/2022 16:04

Probably unpopular opinion but I don’t think anything with a bite history of any kind should ever be rehomed, so I would introduce a law if you can’t keep it and commit to making sure it’s cared for properly and become responsible for its behaviour for the rest of its life then it must be destroyed.

What about a dog that is in undiagnosed, unmedicated pain because of the "I would know if my dog was in pain" crew, somebody is hassling the dog and corners it, so the dog bites?
Or an arthritic dog with limited vision that's been taken by a surprise by a loud person running over saying "I LOVE DOGS" and shoves their hands on them before the dog knows they're there?

Should those dogs be PTS or were humans (both owner and others) being hugely inappropriate?

lljkk · 19/04/2022 16:04

"powerful, potentially life-threatening dogs"

how would that (PPltD) be defined -- anyone?

10 kg? I chose that because it's about the minimum for a Staffsh terrier. The net would also therefore take in greyhounds, labradors, French Bulldogs, daschunds....

or defined by breed -- but then what do you do about cross breeds?

And then, how is regulation to be managed and funded? Out of general taxation or a special dog-owners' tax?

If 10kg is threshold, is it reasonable if a smaller dog maims someone, that the owner doesn't get prosecuted?

If you extend the prosecution law to all dogs, then why not extend law to physical harm from all pets or all owned animals? Plus what is the threshold for maimed... assuming we don't just mean death, would a scratch from the cat count as maiming? One dog bite where just one of the dog's teeth drew blood? What about a nip from a pet rat that drew blood?

And why stop at physical harm? On MN I often read about people who were scared by a dog that "jumped up" in the park? Why stop at fear caused to people, what about "my dog was terrified by another dog that jumped at it in the park!" ?

I quite like my cats so hope these crazy laws don't come in before my cat's natural lifespans end.

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 19/04/2022 16:02

For me the problem is that (some) people don't really want a dog: they want some kind of human baby/teddy bear hybrid in a dog's body.

They want it to magically know what they want and behave accordingly. They want the dog to give all, and for them to be barely inconvienced. They don't want to bother learning about the species they are keeping, it's wants and needs, its communication methods.

There are far too many myths and fairy tales about dogs - and too few people who can be arsed to look past them and SEE the animal they have.

Dogs don't turn for no reason (with the rare exception of idopathic medical issues, in which case there is still a reason but no one knows what it is) and they don't turn without warning. It's just too few people bother to learn the warnings.

I could type in "dog and child cute" to Google images and guess that around 50% of the first 100 or so photos that come back, include a dog displaying some form of communication that it is not comformatble. And most of those are 'professional' photos. It's actually shocking how few people with dogs and children could recognise a dog trying to communicate that they are unhappy with what the child is doing.

I don't know whether I'd agree with banning specific breeds - because we tried that and it didn't work - but I'd sure support mandatory training in canine needs and behaviour.

Leonberger · 19/04/2022 15:57

Probably unpopular opinion but I don’t think anything with a bite history of any kind should ever be rehomed, so I would introduce a law if you can’t keep it and commit to making sure it’s cared for properly and become responsible for its behaviour for the rest of its life then it must be destroyed. Regardless of whether it’s fearful or the reason. There’s just no need for that level of risk. I honestly would ban all this rehoming dogs that have only bitten a child to child free homes etc- complete madness.

I also would support prosecutions for dogs that attack other animals. It might make people more careful about who and what they allow their dogs off lead around.

Disclaimer: I don’t let my dogs off lead around any livestock, animals, dogs, children or strangers regardless of how lovely my animals are.

Agrudge · 19/04/2022 15:52

The problem is white shitty owners

Erm what!!!

MyWinterRose · 19/04/2022 15:50

I completely agree that dog owners should be prosecuted if their dog causes harm to a human or another animal.

I think we have reached a stage where this is needed for people to wake up and take responsibility for an animal they choose to have, it may make people think twice before buying cheap dogs over the internet with no history of their behaviour.

I also think dog licences should be brought back and people only able to buy from registered breeders, adverts for previously owned dogs banned and if people no longer want their dog they either need to take it to a adoption centre or have it put to sleep. In my opinion making dog ownership more difficult is the only way forward.

PaintAndPirouettes · 19/04/2022 15:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MaryFerguson · 19/04/2022 15:39

"Much like children some dogs have additional needs, and the owners really are doing all they can."

What an idiotic comparison. If a dog has "additional needs" such that it's dangerous there's simple solution - put it down!

PaintAndPirouettes · 19/04/2022 15:39

True, and not a particularly welcome thought, either. If an animal has the potential to seriously injure or even kill you, why would you keep one in the house? Especially when there are children in the family. Tragedy after tragedy, and still people never learn.

As a woman the person most likely to kill me is my male partner - and yet still I keep letting him into the house.

We all take calculated risks in life.

afizzysweet · 19/04/2022 15:38

Also, I'm a big believer that people shouldn't be able to just go out and get a dog. I haven't seen the article you've mentioned but from rtft it looks like a dog had been in the home a week and a toddler bothered it whilst it was sleeping.

  1. A dog that is that new to the home is going to be stressed
  2. The parents shouldn't let children approach a sleeping dog
  3. They could have not known this dog well at that point and the dog and child should not have access to each other even if supervised

Why do people let their children hassle sleeping dogs, crawl up to them whilst they're eating, hug them, climb on them, hit the dog, etc?

I can't imagine what the family are going through and the pain they're experiencing but questions need to be asked about what was going on between child and dog, and also where they got the dog from.

blacksax · 19/04/2022 15:35

@GooglyEyeballs

Even small dogs have capacity to tear your throat out if they felt like it. It's not just big dogs.
True, and not a particularly welcome thought, either. If an animal has the potential to seriously injure or even kill you, why would you keep one in the house? Especially when there are children in the family. Tragedy after tragedy, and still people never learn.
XelaM · 19/04/2022 15:35

Agree OP. Unfortunately there continue to be many "Staffy/Rottweiler the nanny dogs" fans on mumsnet and there is no reasoning with them. I love dogs, but chose a toy companion breed because I wanted a friendly family dog and one who can't overpower an adult

afizzysweet · 19/04/2022 15:26

I work with dogs professionally and the majority of dogs that I see that have bitten people are breeds that you probably wouldn't even blink twice at.

The issue is a huge lack of education amongst people about dog behaviour, dog communication, the right environments for different dog breeds & personalities. There is also a lack of education amongst other dog professionals, because the industry is not regulated, so half of the trainers out there don't have qualifications or any up to date understanding. They then pass this misguided understanding to others.

However, if people have a big powerful breed, they do have to be able to manage them. Even a friendly, large dog, has the potential to injure somebody badly if they run over to them and knock them down. This does involve an amount of self-acceptance (e.g. I am in my 80s and may not be able to hang on to an enthusiastic 40kg dog).

wetotter · 19/04/2022 15:25

Like when a child hits another child it's hardly the parents fault is it

It would be if the child had been raised to be aggressive, acts of aggression praised, training to bite hit strongkymincluded in daily activities etc.

I agree with pp that there are many components to temperament and behaviour, but good owners keep their dogs, and the people they know are interacting with them, safe and happy (phrased like that because you still do get twerps who encourage DC to 'go and pat the doggie' without checking with the human first)

wetotter · 19/04/2022 15:20

Breed based legislation just doesn't work.

Because there will always be a newly fashionabje 'hard' breed/cross, and any larger dog can inflict life-changing injuries, and even small ones can do extensive damage.

The problem is white shitty owners who have under socialised socialised and poorly supervised dogs. It doesn't matter what breed they own, because the problem starts with the human

A (proper) Staffy weighs no more than about 35 lbs - a Labrador goes up to 80lbs. So if you ban by size/power, then Labs would be gone long before Staffies. But you don't mean that do you? You are wishing for a solution that doesn't exist - something that is based on something measureable, rather than the real problem of shitty owners

PaintAndPirouettes · 19/04/2022 15:18

@Agrudge

Yabu . As I've said on other posts the problems start at the other end of the lead.

I've not seen a dog attack from a decent home/owners

There's a lot of factors that affect a dog's personality and behaviour, including
  • parents temperament (like humans, some dogs are just have atypical personalities, which they can pass on)
  • breed - for instance dachshunds are often a bit nervous, collies love to herd things and can be a bit neurotic, terriers will chase small furry things
  • experiences in utero - for instance, was mum stressed?
  • experiences in the first 8 weeks of life before going to new homes - a puppy raised in a filthy dark shed isn't going to have such a good start as one reared in a family home

Plus, for rescue dogs, there's the impact of the experiences they had in their first home. The first 16 weeks of life are really critical for socialisation, and you can never get that time back. Lots of rehomed dogs come from homes where they meant well but inadvertently didn't meet all their dogs needs.

Please remember that the person holding the lead isn't solely responsible for a dog's temperament. There's plenty of respectable, decent people doing their absolute best with a dog that was poorly bred and had some substandard experiences in their early life.

I choose to judge dog owners on what they're doing for their dog (training methods, adequate exercise, keeping them on a lead if necessary) not what their dog is doing at that moment in time. Much like children some dogs have additional needs, and the owners really are doing all they can.

AryaStarkWolf · 19/04/2022 15:16

@Maydaysoonenough

A lady was killed by a pack of dachshunds.. Imo it is all about circumstances and owners than the breed... Recent deaths were ddogs that has recently been acquired from unknown sources and thrown into a new life with dc in it. Is the ddog really responsible for that?
Yes a "pack" not 1. Also, they were 6 Dachshund-mixes(they were bigger than pure bred Dachshunds) and a Border Collie
Agrudge · 19/04/2022 15:12

@Nidan2Sandan

Are you that gullible to think a licence would solve the issue?

All it would is penalise the responsible owners . All the people that want them for the wrong reasons wouldnt bother

MrsWinters · 19/04/2022 15:10

The dog was PTS. It was taken away, ASSESSED for rehoming and judged unsafe and put down.