Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

powerful, potentially life-threatening dogs

139 replies

Bjarnum · 19/04/2022 12:14

AIBU to think people who own such breeds which then go on to kill/maim a child / pet/adult should automatically be prosecuted? With so many smaller weaker breed available ( which may well be snappy but who would struggle to inflict the ghastly injuries seen lately) WHY would you pick a dog so heavy and powerful that if they turn they would be unstoppable? Another child in the paper today maimed by his "best friend".

OP posts:
Suprima · 19/04/2022 19:24

@XenoBitch

If you had to leave your child in a room with either a small, toy dog or an American bulldog which would you chose?

It depends on more than the breed.
If the American bulldog was already established in the home as the family pet.. then I would pick them over a toy breed that was a total unknown and belonged to a visitor.

That’s not what pp is asking Confused of course the established family pet with a sensible child who has been trained well around animals would be safer!

Imagine they are both strange dogs.

It’s fairly clear what one would do the most damage.

XenoBitch · 19/04/2022 19:21

If you had to leave your child in a room with either a small, toy dog or an American bulldog which would you chose?

It depends on more than the breed.
If the American bulldog was already established in the home as the family pet.. then I would pick them over a toy breed that was a total unknown and belonged to a visitor.

ChairCareOh · 19/04/2022 19:06

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 19:01

@PegsandBags

Only properly trained working dogs and service dogs should be allowed and licensed. That is their job, dogs were not made to be domesticated as pets.

There is hardly room for humans let alone dogs in urban areas now. At least humans use a toilet and flush their poo away.

Dogs have been domesticated for thousands of years.

You can hardly turn back the clocks now.

XenoBitch · 19/04/2022 18:58

@IncompleteSenten

I think people should be made to have training on how to manage any animal capable of causing harm before being allowed to have that animal.

It'd never happen of course, but it would really help.

And also education on how to read warning signs. I know I will get flamed into oblivion for this, but teach your kids how to act around dogs too. No climbing over them, pulling ears etc.
IncompleteSenten · 19/04/2022 18:53

I think people should be made to have training on how to manage any animal capable of causing harm before being allowed to have that animal.

It'd never happen of course, but it would really help.

XenoBitch · 19/04/2022 18:52

@Laiste

What IS the answer? Realistically?

I mean, we need one [an answer] but it's so easy to say ban this and ban that - but putting it into practice ... what does that look like?

Will we round up the dogs which are already in existence and take them away?
We could enforce castration ect. but again, how?
Dog licences - the decent owners get them, the dodgy ones wont. How do you enforce that?

Rescues do what they can by not allowing potential adopters with children to apply for dogs. But then you get people moaning about that too. It is backyard breeders, and people selling their dogs on Gumtree etc with no homecheck/vetting that is the issue.
PegsandBags · 19/04/2022 18:50

Edith,

What about their shit everywhere though? It really is so disgusting. Even the Romans had sophisticated latrines for the humans.

Laiste · 19/04/2022 18:49

@FourChimneys

The only dog I have been bitten by was a West Highland terrier in a totally unprovoked attack on my brother and me.

No dog can be considered safe however much their apologists like to think so.

Yes this.

I've only been bitten once and that was a Seyleam (sp?) terrier. My own mother's bloody dog!

Laiste · 19/04/2022 18:47

What IS the answer? Realistically?

I mean, we need one [an answer] but it's so easy to say ban this and ban that - but putting it into practice ... what does that look like?

Will we round up the dogs which are already in existence and take them away?
We could enforce castration ect. but again, how?
Dog licences - the decent owners get them, the dodgy ones wont. How do you enforce that?

XenoBitch · 19/04/2022 18:45

@PegsandBags

Xeno,

What is done with other working and trained animals who no longer make the grade?

Same for working dogs.

Which is what?

Put to sleep?

I would not want to live in a world where that is an acceptable way to treat our animal companions.
It is bad enough that it is seen as acceptable for greyhounds to be shot in the head for being a poor racer, without thinking about a potential guide dog being PTS because they could not be trained/ended up with an illness.

EdithStourton · 19/04/2022 18:44

@PegsandBags

Only properly trained working dogs and service dogs should be allowed and licensed. That is their job, dogs were not made to be domesticated as pets.

There is hardly room for humans let alone dogs in urban areas now. At least humans use a toilet and flush their poo away.

Dogs have been kept as pets since at least Roman times.

If you look at the fatality stats, it's mostly the same set of breeds. The research indicates that some breeds are more prone be to aggression than others, including Jack Russells (dog aggression). I say that as someone who used to own a JRT.

Badger1970 · 19/04/2022 18:42

I've got 2 exceptionally gentle spaniels. They are NEVER left alone with my grandchildren, because I would never forgive myself if anything happened.

I personally think that anyone who has a dog that attacks a child should get a criminal record, and a custodial sentence. And a lifetime ban on keeping more animals. Instead, they get sad face publicity in local news and end up crowd funding for funerals.

FourChimneys · 19/04/2022 18:38

The only dog I have been bitten by was a West Highland terrier in a totally unprovoked attack on my brother and me.

No dog can be considered safe however much their apologists like to think so.

PegsandBags · 19/04/2022 18:36

Xeno,

What is done with other working and trained animals who no longer make the grade?

Same for working dogs.

PegsandBags · 19/04/2022 18:34

Being shocked and saddened by the suffering of these (mostly) young children is just not enough anymore is it?

XenoBitch · 19/04/2022 18:32

@PegsandBags

Only properly trained working dogs and service dogs should be allowed and licensed. That is their job, dogs were not made to be domesticated as pets.

There is hardly room for humans let alone dogs in urban areas now. At least humans use a toilet and flush their poo away.

What happens to the dogs that don't make the grade as working/service dogs?
Laiste · 19/04/2022 18:31

@Suzi888

And another attack just reported - 3 Rottweilers pts after attack on two year old.
Jesus

:(

Suzi888 · 19/04/2022 18:29

And another attack just reported - 3 Rottweilers pts after attack on two year old.

PegsandBags · 19/04/2022 18:24

Only properly trained working dogs and service dogs should be allowed and licensed. That is their job, dogs were not made to be domesticated as pets.

There is hardly room for humans let alone dogs in urban areas now. At least humans use a toilet and flush their poo away.

Laiste · 19/04/2022 18:16

I'm sure i read somewhere that Labs are right up there near the top when it comes to bites. Not fatal maulings but incidents of biting in the home.

But then you have to set that statistic against the fact that Labs are one of the most common breeds kept as family pets. So even if Labs are one of the breeds least likely to bite, they're going to be up there in the stats. just because there's so many of them!

Personally i think the prevalence of dogs being kept as status symbols and dogs being purchased without any thought to enough exercise or training that is driving up the awful numbers of fatal attacks.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 19/04/2022 17:30

The dog I walk is now fear reactive thanks to numerous bites from little off lead dogs.

My ex lost a significant jewel and was horrendously scarred on his legs from a Jack Russell.

No dog should be left alone with children regardless of size or breed.

Quincythequince · 19/04/2022 17:14

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

Banning breeds doesn't work. We've already banned four breeds of dog in the UK and we still get numerous fatal dog attacks (from perfectly legal breeds) each year.

The law around selling and owning dogs is what needs to change. At the moment, anyone can go online, pick a dog, buy it and take it home with their newborn baby. That's the problem. Not the fact that some people own certain breeds.

Any breed can do damage. There was a 9yo girl in this country who needed 200+ stitches because she was bitten by the family Labrador - yet Labs are constantly rated as being amazing, friendly, biddable family pets. There are also cases where Jack Russells have killed babies.

Yes, size and breed matters to an extent but it's not the sole thing that dogs should be judged by. Temperament, health, breeding and socialisation are all much more important factors than breed.

I hadn’t red your post before mine below, but you illustrate my point perfectly (if very sadly).
Quincythequince · 19/04/2022 17:12

I’ve had rotties and staff, bulldogs and now a lab.

All dogs were properly trained and never left alone with tiny kids regardless.

Quincythequince · 19/04/2022 17:11

A Labrador is a big strong dog and could potentially do untold damage.
Do we ban them too?

Size is the dog is really nothing to do with it.

Personally, I think Jack Russell’s are horrid dogs (never met a nice one, but no doubt there are); snappy and vicious and could do serious damage to your Face if it got close enough.