Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

lighthearted, are you middle class?

178 replies

mrziggycoco · 19/04/2022 11:45

How do you define classes, personally, and are what class are you?

I read a book once that said if you are a professional (in one of the professions; teaching/doctor/engineer/surgeon/lawyer) you are middle class.

Similarly if you are a blue collar worker (you have a uniform for work) this makes you working class.

I wonder if being socially housed makes one automatically working class?

Thoughts? Just for fun.

OP posts:
Santaslittlemelter · 19/04/2022 13:47

Gosh people are very determined not to be middle class.

If class is actually a thing, it’s a bit ‘interesting’ that people fight tooth and nail to insist they are working class. Is it that their now success is all the sweeter because of their perceived ‘tougher’ start?

Maybe we need a new class called wealthy working class who have everything and more than middle class.

XingMing · 19/04/2022 13:47

As a PP pointed out upthread, a large and thriving middle class is a definite sign of a healthy economy and society. Some of it is financial status, but it also involves education and cultural expectations and aspirations. Ambition also comes into it.

desiringonlychild2022 · 19/04/2022 13:47

@Laiste you can pay for an agent to manage the property for you which cuts down on profits but you may not have a choice if you are overseas/faraway. Maybe what you mean is professional landlords who actually have a portfolio. But yes that is still work, my dad is a full time professional landlord with a portfolio of 14 offices and 1 retail spaces. He says it's a lot of work to keep the tenants happy but necessary as he managed to retain them even when everyone was WFH during the pandemic..He could outsource it though which is not the case for most conventional job but chooses not to.

But a landlord who owns hundreds of properties is a far cry from the waiter who was my landlord, I rented a room in an ex council flat in my university days in Camden. He acquired the property through right to buy. The former might be middle class, the latter is a very lucky man!

mrziggycoco · 19/04/2022 13:45

@oldwhyno

In my opinion there isn't really a clear class system in this country any more. There are way too many strata to make classification simple or worthwhile. There aren't many useful clear definitions.

One I do like is that anyone who will be working out of necessity to earn a wage/salary from somebody else, for their whole working life until a nominal retirement age no earlier than 60, is part of a modern "working class".

I think you've summed it up perfectly.
OP posts:
mrziggycoco · 19/04/2022 13:42

@Aimee1987

My partner is a manager in a high street bank, I would consider that middle class but he wears a uniform so I think the uniform thing is weird.

I'm Irish so we dont have the same interest in classes as britian but I think there irrelevant. I'm a teacher but a plumber or electrician would comfortably out earn me.

That was the blue collar/white collar distinction that I grew up hearing about. I don't think it is said at all now.
OP posts:
mudgetastic · 19/04/2022 13:39

[quote Laiste]**@desiringonlychild2022 - So are all BTL landlords middle class then?

I dunno Grin I was asking myself the same question even as i typed that out!

If you work for your money you're working class in my book, and if you don't have to work then i say Middle. Managing property is still working isn't it. So no. I retract that - and caringcarer is still working class.

But her kids might not be eventually ...[/quote]
So you move from working to middle class on retirement?

oldwhyno · 19/04/2022 13:37

In my opinion there isn't really a clear class system in this country any more. There are way too many strata to make classification simple or worthwhile. There aren't many useful clear definitions.

One I do like is that anyone who will be working out of necessity to earn a wage/salary from somebody else, for their whole working life until a nominal retirement age no earlier than 60, is part of a modern "working class".

LaurieFairyCake · 19/04/2022 13:36

When I did that BBC survey 8 years ago it said I was in the metropolitan elite because I went to the opera/plays HmmHmm

Which is ridiculous

Laiste · 19/04/2022 13:31

@desiringonlychild2022 - So are all BTL landlords middle class then?

I dunno Grin I was asking myself the same question even as i typed that out!

If you work for your money you're working class in my book, and if you don't have to work then i say Middle. Managing property is still working isn't it. So no. I retract that - and caringcarer is still working class.

But her kids might not be eventually ...

Schhhteeevie · 19/04/2022 13:26

Cressida Dick wears a uniform

Prince Phillip sometimes wore a uniform

Pilots wear uniforms

desiringonlychild2022 · 19/04/2022 13:25

If they were still relying on their wage/s and hadn't got the btl houses i'd have said they were still working class despite the finance manager/home in france stuff.

So are all BTL landlords middle class then? I know plenty of people from modest backgrounds who are BTL landlords. Considering you can buy a house for 100k in parts of the north, I would say most homeowners in the south could probably afford to be BTL landlords if they remortgaged their homes...

Aimee1987 · 19/04/2022 13:23

My partner is a manager in a high street bank, I would consider that middle class but he wears a uniform so I think the uniform thing is weird.

I'm Irish so we dont have the same interest in classes as britian but I think there irrelevant. I'm a teacher but a plumber or electrician would comfortably out earn me.

Laiste · 19/04/2022 13:23

The question of state of mind vs finances is very interesting.

Mostly i think Working and Middle are completely linked to finances, and upper is not linked to money at all.

Laiste · 19/04/2022 13:20

@Waxonwaxoff0

Like if you're born and raised in a working class household I don't think you suddenly turn middle class when you get a high paying career. Your kids would be middle class though if you bring them up in that environment.
I would have said the same -

but then caringcarer says ''I suppose DH and I are middle class now, an accountant/Finance Manager and early retired teacher. We both went to uni, own our home and 8 btl houses and a holiday home in France. We both grew up poor and both our Dads worked in a factory.''

If they were still relying on their wage/s and hadn't got the btl houses i'd have said they were still working class despite the finance manager/home in france stuff. The fact they have invested their money (BTL) and it's working for them, i say they have jumped class.

desiringonlychild2022 · 19/04/2022 13:20

Unless you are a billionaire. Then the next 10 generations don't need to work. But most titled nobility are far from that. And most billionaires are self made

Lunar27 · 19/04/2022 13:20

What class are you when you attack people?

Under? Or possibly below that in a new sub category.

But what do I know. Born scummy and slightly less no nowadays. Couldn't care less about class TBH.

desiringonlychild2022 · 19/04/2022 13:18

@mrziggycoco his father had 4 kids and Boris is terrible with money apparently. It's why he had a donor to pay for the gold wallpaper

Some have investments, others have to get jobs (even if it's jobs through the old boys network i.e. consultant). Mixture of the two. Contrary to popular opinion, most fortunes are squandered which is why most billionaires are unwilling to let their heirs get their hands on it. Wealth is good for things like buying an expensive house for a 25 year old/paying for school fees but it would not feed a rich family for a lifetime. It is not enough. Passive income can help but that also depends on how well it is managed.

It's why the wealthy find their way into politics.

SW1amp · 19/04/2022 13:16

All these threads ever show is that class is as much a state of mind as a state of finances

Some people identify strongly with the concept and lean in to it
Others couldn’t care less and don’t let it influence their life or decisions

Both are fine

mrziggycoco · 19/04/2022 13:12

[quote desiringonlychild2022]@mrziggycoco I would argue Boris Johnson has to work as he has to support X number of children including two young ones. And I don't think Carrie's income can support a nanny and 2
sets of private school fees.

But a lot of titled nobility have lots of kids and their kids all need to go to private school and have fancy weddings and gifted homes! And they are far from Bezos rich...[/quote]
I think it's about investments for the latter and they have a lot of passive income so don't have to work.

I also think Boris/Alexander comes from generational wealth? Is his father not extremely wealthy?

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 19/04/2022 13:08

Like if you're born and raised in a working class household I don't think you suddenly turn middle class when you get a high paying career. Your kids would be middle class though if you bring them up in that environment.

DialSquare · 19/04/2022 13:08

Sent too soon!
Grew up in the East End of London, was a teenage single parent and many of my peers have died from drug overdoses over the years. I didn't ho to university and ended up in financial services at 16 and have worked my way up. So I'm going with Mickey Flanagan and say that I'm working class with middle class trappings!

caringcarer · 19/04/2022 13:06

I suppose DH and I are middle class now, an accountant/Finance Manager and early retired teacher. We both went to uni, own our home and 8 btl houses and a holiday home in France. We both grew up poor and both our Dads worked in a factory. My Mum was a cleaner and DH Mum a cook in a care home. I would say growing up we were definately both working class but once careers established and buying our home and got btl's at some point we moved to middle class.

unname · 19/04/2022 13:06

I thought it was all based on the fluffy-ness of your towels?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 19/04/2022 13:06

I don't think you can change what class you are. I wouldn't say Wayne Rooney is now middle class just because he's wealthy. Class is so much more than money.

I'm working class anyway.

TheGlitterati · 19/04/2022 13:05

I did a quiz once. Apparently I am middle class, but I grew up 100% working class so I don’t feel any different to that.