Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keep your fear away from my children

166 replies

washingmachines4 · 19/04/2022 11:29

I am so sick of adults talking about their fears in front of my kids. I think it is so detrimental.
Another Mum, family member etc. would say: 'I have to go to the dentist this week so it'll be a terrible week, I am frightened', screaming at spiders, saying how frightened they are to go swimming, get on a bike, get on a plane, go into London, walk home at dusk. (Live in a really safe area by the way and this isn't about kids walking home, these are fully grown adults just talking about how frightened they are by life).
It is not that I don't have empathy for people with anxiety, who have to live with fear everyday but, sincerely - KEEP YOUR FEAR AWAY FROM MY KIDS! It is detrimental to them. You want to talk to me about your fears - fine - call me after the kids are in bed and I will be calm, empathetic and either be the listening ear or assist with solutions, whatever you want. But leave these growing little impressionable brains out of it!
I don't like spiders - pre kids I would scream if there was a big one, now we name them, trap them and put them outside - why? Because it is the RIGHT THING TO DO. I still hate the things (although confess since feeling obliged to be nice to them for my children the 'fear' has diminished, although not gone) . We don't live in Australia, we live in the UK and there isn't a rational reason to be frightened. In Australia they don't promote fear - they promote education and I have yet to meet an Aussie who shits themselves even when presented with a big bite capable spider!
Sorry for the rant. I just fell across a complete stranger yesterday who decided to try and put whatever fears were in her head into my child's and I have seen red a bit. I'll go and have a cup of tea now.

OP posts:
Whetheryouthinkyoucan · 19/04/2022 13:03

@CarmenThePanda

Tbh the level of irrational fear on MN gets to me sometimes. Of course people should be able to talk about fears, but the constant assertion that London / dusk / hiking alone / spiders / answering the door really are things which are too risky to undertake is wearing. Because you do need emotional energy to keep it at bay, even to ignore it. Same for our kids

I completely agree. The level of background paranoia and anxiety on here genuinely concerns me.

MzHz · 19/04/2022 13:00

My oh daughter had a dog jump up at her. ONCE.

Both parents fostered this bs oh she’s frightened of dogs for YEARS!

Neither of them helped her - it really annoyed me as it was utterly needless.

Mind you, in their family fear means drama and attention. I don’t put up with it.

Bit of reassurance, support and encouragement about how to be around dogs and she was sorted in a couple of months.

Notsurenotquiteright · 19/04/2022 13:00

Children take on the negatives as it is key to their survival. How else did they learn what animals to avoid, what food not to eat.
I agree that fears should not be put into children unless there is a need for it.
Like road safety etc.

I’m also going to be careful to not talk about my body negatively and instead focus on what it can do so that hopefully my daughter grows up liking her body and what it can do.

Womeninblack · 19/04/2022 12:59

Actually, I change my mind. Yanbu 🤓

Girlwhowearsglasses · 19/04/2022 12:59

Oh I'm with you!
My DM can't even say or hear the word Spider. We weren't allowed to say it - we had to say 'there's a 'thing' on the ceiling'. She cant even have a conversation about phobias!. She now lives with us but I now refuse to not say spider. Hmm

As for all the other things she 'doesn't like' - TBH I don't know how I stayed sane (bananas, music, sport.. )

Cocobeau · 19/04/2022 12:56

I remember sitting outside a pub last year with my husband and a bee taking an interest in our table. I don't like buzzy thing, but I'm a grown up who understands flapping around doesn't help, so I sat and waited for it to bugger off. It then flew to the next table which was occupied by two adults - mother and grandmother I assume - plus two children. The instant hysteria that was started by the women was ridiculous. Jumping up and screeching, pull the kids away. Then the older one said something like "some people are allergic to bees and they die if they get stung".
It was utterly pathetic and I imagine those two kids will now spend their lives needlessly terrified and probably trying to kill any passing bees.

Lavapalaver · 19/04/2022 12:55

Nah you have to teach your kids that people have all sorts of weird ideas that have nothing to do with reality. It makes them resilient but also.. compassionate. You can try to shelter your children from other peoples fears for a while but ultimately it’s impossible. All you can do is educate your own children.

maltravers · 19/04/2022 12:53

My mother is terrified of spiders so as a smallish kid I used to have to catch any scuttling around the house if my dad wasn’t about and then release them in the garden. So I’m quite cool about spiders.

Opaljewel · 19/04/2022 12:52

Good luck policing then from fears as they get older. It's normal to talk and compare things.

You can't keep in a little box forever. They will be exposed to the outside world eventually.

CarmenThePanda · 19/04/2022 12:51

It’s such a negative way to support kids.

When mine were small I used to stand in the playground amongst meaningless pleas of ‘be careful’. What does that mean to a 3 year old?

I’m not saying my heart wasn’t in my mouth as mine went to the top of the spider web climbing frame thingy, it was, but I used to say ‘good climbing! To be a good climber always just move one hand or foot at a time and keep the others where they are’. Give them practical tips to stay safe rather than fret and fuss anxiously at the bottom.

Same for everything. How to risk assess and problem solve rather than dithering in fear. Going into central London alone for the first time? What to do if you accidentally get the wrong bus. What you could do if the behaviour of a member of the public makes you uncomfortable. Etc.

Tbh the level of irrational fear on MN gets to me sometimes. Of course people should be able to talk about fears, but the constant assertion that London / dusk / hiking alone / spiders / answering the door really are things which are too risky to undertake is wearing. Because you do need emotional energy to keep it at bay, even to ignore it. Same for our kids.

Onlyforcake · 19/04/2022 12:49

My eldest has definitely taken on her grandma's fear of dogs. Which is very frustrating. I try to use things as teachable moments and suggest how to tackle feelings of surprise or alarm (which I definitely feel when I see an fecking goose, vicious hissing bastards). I do use other descriptors rather than fear, so I WAS surprised there, rather than I AM afraid. So much children get that fear is just a reaction, that passes, it doesnt stop you acting. I know phobia is real, and hugely controlling for some, like my exMIL, so I try to explain it as other than fear.

DuinrellCalling · 19/04/2022 12:46

YANBU.

I have a theory that this is exactly why so many people are scared of spiders (as evidenced in this thread) - it's a learnt response that is passed from parent to child/sibling to sibling/friend to friend to the extent that the fear is so commonplace it is now generally accepted that 'spider = scary'. Which is totally irrational (in this country).

MoiraNotRuby · 19/04/2022 12:45

Totally agree. One of my parents has a fear of train journeys, they kept it secret from me and I grew up oblivious to this. They are now scared whenever I take a train journey but they didn't tell me until I was about 30!

Sirzy · 19/04/2022 12:45

People shouldn’t be over the top about it but I don’t think hiding fears from children is sensible either. There is nothing wrong with being a bit scared sometimes and nothing wrong with normalising that. I am scared of bridges, Ds has been aware of this for ages but he has no issue with them - infact he makes sure he holds my hand when we cross one to be kind!

merryhouse · 19/04/2022 12:45

I'm still pissed off about the Tweenies.

I'd spent TWO YEARS patiently building the tools to persuade tiny son that being in the dark is great. It was working!

Then he watched an episode of the Tweenies which was explaining how you don't need to be afraid of the dark, and from that point on he was aware that Afraid Of The Dark was a thing...

washingmachines4 · 19/04/2022 12:43

@Womeninblack - why?
Do we not want our kids to be resilient? We can get them to rationalise that everyone is different after a certain age - before that age you can do a lot of damage exposing them to irrational fear

OP posts:
Eesha · 19/04/2022 12:43

I'm terrified of flying but I put on a brave face with everything as I believe its mind over matter so I want my children to feel like anything is possible.

FairyPolkadot · 19/04/2022 12:41

I notice this everywhere nowadays. I don’t understand why. When I was younger having adventures, travelling, back packing across Europe at 18 were things people aspired to do. I don’t seem to meet people who enjoy or desire these things anymore. Maybe it’s just the people I’m surrounded by right now in life. They’re so full of fears (won’t drive anywhere but within the local town, won’t walk home alone after work, overthink everything, afraid of … everything, really). I do have fears and have definitely experienced periods of anxiety (still do sometimes) but mostly the things I fear are very different things. My loved ones being happy and healthy is really all that matters to me.

I don’t know if the frustration I feel about this is down to how I was raised (my dad in particular taught me to be fearless, resilient and independent. My mum was a worrier but hid it from me because she wanted me to be independent).

I think that something in our culture has altered. I do wonder if I’m alone with this thought.

Womeninblack · 19/04/2022 12:40

I think you’re being a little silly.

ClaudiusTheGod · 19/04/2022 12:34

Yes OP you’re totally right, and can we include similar comments like ‘I was rubbish at maths at school, numbers frighten me, and as for all those x’s and y’s….’ . Angry

Babadook76 · 19/04/2022 12:34

I’ve got a friend who not only has her 2yo completely hysterically afraid of spiders, but actually uses it as a way to get him to do what he wants. Like ‘OMG DONT GO NEAR THERE/DO THAT, THERES A SPIDER OVER THERE’!!! 🙄

Kissifer · 19/04/2022 12:34

I’m inclined to agree, OP. I have a terrible fear of flying (more the being trapped in the metal tube than the height thing, am also claustrophobic as well)
I made sure not to pass my fears on to DS, and by 14 he had been on 2 school trips involving flying - one to Spain & one to America, and several ferry trips all without fear. Bizarrely, he avoids travel now as has become prone to travel sickness!!🤷‍♀️
It’s not fair to pass your fears on, particularly to young children, it can hamper them in life, imo.

Branleuse · 19/04/2022 12:29

At nursery my children went from being fine with spiders to screaming about them. One of them is still frightened now ( although not phobia levels anymore) and im pretty sure its because of the way nurseryworkers reacted to them in front of the children

10HailMarys · 19/04/2022 12:27

I think I'm inclined to agree, OP.

I do think children should be taught to understand that different people are scared of different things, and that they should be empathetic and kind about that (eg if Grandpa has a phobia about deep water, be nice about it and don't laugh at him when he doesn't want to go swimming, etc). But it's perfectly possible to help children understand that without passing that on to them or suggesting that being scared of that stuff is the default, if you see what I mean.

For instance, when I was little I knew that my mum was very claustrophobic and that my dad was scared of heights, but neither of them talked about that in a way that made me scared of those things - my mum hates lifts because of her claustrophobia and sometimes my dad and I would get the lift somewhere and she'd take the stairs, but it was more like 'Mummy is a bit scared of lifts - isn't that silly? I know they're perfectly safe and you and Daddy love them but I'm going to use the stairs this time and I'll see you two at the top.' It was never 'Arrrgh, lifts! Oh my god, terrifying. So claustrophobic! How can you bear to get in one of those? Horrible things, crammed into a little box and not knowing if it'll get stuck.'

I was the zoo once and looking round the reptile house and there was a woman with her young child and she kept saying 'Ewwww, snakes! Snakes are so scary, aren't they? All slimy and horrible! Nasty. I'm glad they can't get out, aren't you?' and I thought 'Why on earth would you carry on like that in front of a four-year-old?' Confused

My SIL is fussy with food and every time anyone eats anything she disapproves of (which is most things, as far as I can tell) she makes a massive deal of it and says things like 'Ugh, gross! How can you eat that? It smells horrible / looks disgusting / has a horrible texture' and she says that in front of her kids, who have absolutely picked up on this and do/say all the same things

Bagadverts · 19/04/2022 12:25

You can hide your own fears and I agree about conversations about the future are completely unnecessary (friend saying how frightened they are of the dentist that they are going tomorrow).

However if it is immediate then I think your children need to learn that some people are afraid of different things. Depending on age and if you know it could be explained - Aunt Sarah was bitten by a dog so she is afraid of them, most dogs are really nice though as long as you are very careful.

Also important if for example need to explain that your dog needs to stay in the kitchen because Aunt Sarah is visiting (if you are doing that.)