Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keep your fear away from my children

166 replies

washingmachines4 · 19/04/2022 11:29

I am so sick of adults talking about their fears in front of my kids. I think it is so detrimental.
Another Mum, family member etc. would say: 'I have to go to the dentist this week so it'll be a terrible week, I am frightened', screaming at spiders, saying how frightened they are to go swimming, get on a bike, get on a plane, go into London, walk home at dusk. (Live in a really safe area by the way and this isn't about kids walking home, these are fully grown adults just talking about how frightened they are by life).
It is not that I don't have empathy for people with anxiety, who have to live with fear everyday but, sincerely - KEEP YOUR FEAR AWAY FROM MY KIDS! It is detrimental to them. You want to talk to me about your fears - fine - call me after the kids are in bed and I will be calm, empathetic and either be the listening ear or assist with solutions, whatever you want. But leave these growing little impressionable brains out of it!
I don't like spiders - pre kids I would scream if there was a big one, now we name them, trap them and put them outside - why? Because it is the RIGHT THING TO DO. I still hate the things (although confess since feeling obliged to be nice to them for my children the 'fear' has diminished, although not gone) . We don't live in Australia, we live in the UK and there isn't a rational reason to be frightened. In Australia they don't promote fear - they promote education and I have yet to meet an Aussie who shits themselves even when presented with a big bite capable spider!
Sorry for the rant. I just fell across a complete stranger yesterday who decided to try and put whatever fears were in her head into my child's and I have seen red a bit. I'll go and have a cup of tea now.

OP posts:
washingmachines4 · 19/04/2022 14:47

@PlasticineMeg - why? Genuine question, really curious.

It wouldn't ever occur to me to not do anything about it, if I found myself with a fear I would seek to overcome it. I have had 'fears' in the past - but I have gone straight with my version of exposure therapy and moved past it very quickly - in hindsight I don't see them as fears as they seem trivial now although they didn't at the time.

OP posts:
Dontfuckingsaycheese · 19/04/2022 14:42

I was absolutely terrified of spiders. Real sobbing, asking strangers into house to remove, ringing people to remove terror. I always had to watch them put it out to prove they’d actually done it! I did get a bit better as I lived alone. I learned to be able to kill them (sorry) with a thick magazine so I couldn’t feel it, loud music so I couldn’t hear it…
Then I had a ds. I was determined not to share my phobia. I pretended they were not scary. I moved them on when required. Even got to stage I could grab them in my hand. Even without tissue!! The funny thing was I managed to conquer my fear by pretending not to be afraid.
And do you know what - despite ds never seeing me panic, flail about, sweat or anything- he is terrified of the buggers!! Makes an absolute fuss. Just like I used to!

PlasticineMeg · 19/04/2022 14:42

I also think it’s fine to do nothing about your fears sometimes

Swayingpalmtrees · 19/04/2022 14:41

What help have you had for that galacting? That sounds very extreme, and it is having a big impact on you and your family. Summer is a wonderful time to be outside, but it must be stressful dealing with that level of fear every time you have a picnic or an outing.

GalactatingGoddess · 19/04/2022 14:38

Also what @Llamapolice said

GalactatingGoddess · 19/04/2022 14:37

Unfortunately not everyone can control certain fears. You can control talking about them, but when faced with them it's a lot harder.

I am incredibly scared of bees , wasps and spiders. I will involuntarily flinch and scream if I so much as hear them and during summer I am on high alert! I try not to talk about them unless it's in a positive way but my DD is going to see my reaction! Fortunately DH is not scared so there is a balance.

Parents are human, and fallible, and I don't think this is the worst flaw that you can present as a parent. Not ideal though, don't get me wrong.

Swayingpalmtrees · 19/04/2022 14:36

Personally I think an astonishing lack of empathy is MUCH more damaging to kids than having to understand that sometimes other people have phobias, but there you go

Absolutely! I would expect my children to be compassionate about bereavement, serious illness, loss etc and be able to support others with empathy. Would I want them to sit there and listen to someone whinge on relentlessly about their neurosis, no, I would not. I would think I have failed them if they become happy to sit there as an unpaid therapists as people dump their negativity on them. That is not empathy, it is doormat behaviour. I would hope they would say 'have you thought about getting some help with that fear' and signposting others to get professional help. I do find the type of person op describes as being blood suckers, they just drain everyone around them.

MedusasBadHairDay · 19/04/2022 14:36

I have raised perfectly happy kids without having to avoid people who are scared of stuff. None of their fears affected my kids

That's great for you, but obviously not all kids are the same, and it depends on the context (is it a trusted adult they spend a lot of time round?)

I know pre-school my DD was fine with all sorts of bugs and beasties, loads of photos of her handling them without a care in the world.

She starts school and within a few months she's screaming and crying every time she spots an insect. She also tells us the TA is scared of them.

Either it's a real coincidence, or she's learnt that behaviour.

Greensleeves · 19/04/2022 14:34

I agree to an extent, in that adults should be mindful of not instilling unnecessary fears and hang-ups in children. It's thoughtless to bang on about how awful injections or dentists are when they're unavoidable, and it might not otherwise occur to children to be afraid.

I have a couple of caveats though:

  1. By having a performatively no-nonsense attitude towards fears - which we all have - you run the risk of belittling children's own fears, or giving them the message that fears and phobias are silly and that you will be disappointed in them if they express them. That isn't healthy either.

  2. Parent-hild relationships are human relationships above all, and I dislike the tendency towards pursuing a "parenting approach" at the expense of real, honest relationships. Our children live with us and are in our lives on an intimate basis, so they will know about some of our fears and pecadilloes. That doesn't have to be a bad thing, as long as fears are talked about and children know that they're individual and not always rational. I used to take DS1 on rides with me when he was little, because I was scared and he wasn't. He loved being Mummy's helper and talking soothingly to me as the umbrella ride got going Grin

washingmachines4 · 19/04/2022 14:33

@robotvalkyrie - I am not afraid of people and their emotions. I am cross with the oversharing of irrelevant and unhelpful emotions which is so widespread I should think many people (let alone just children) are unhappier for it. Ripples in a pond and all that - put out something good.
And yes, my OP was my rant because I am cross because of the old biddy that filled my kids head with shit yesterday while my child was actively trying to overcome something she finds hard. She was set back and it took a good few hours to overcome.
I know I can't protect them from it, not now and not in the future. I am equipping them as best as I can to deal with negative irrational people - yes I am still cross, don't worry if you meet me in real life I come across as much nicer and more understanding. But this is AIBU and I was having a rant. And if one person thinks about not sharing their food phobias, spider phobias, etc. with their kids and grandkids then I'll be pleased.

On the plus side, I am feeling much calmer now seeing all the lovely responses. Cheers! I'll keep plodding on and doing my best and make the kids understanding but hopefully resilient so they don't take on these fears themselves.

OP posts:
ThatsBullshirt · 19/04/2022 14:33

I'm scared of spiders and DH is absolutely terrified of bees (neither of us like wasps!). He deals with the spiders for me and I deal with any bees/wasps in the house. We don't hide the fact that we have these fears from DC but we aren't outwardly dramatic about them, like we won't scream or get in a flap. I think it's fine to show that fears are a normal thing in life, even the irrational ones, but also to make sure that kids know being frightened of something like a spider or swimming or flying is "a bit silly" and they don't have to be worried about them just because someone else is.

I don't love the big outward displays of dramatics from people when you are trying to teach your kids that they don't need to be afraid of something though.

VeneziaGiulia45 · 19/04/2022 14:33

How can you hope to police the behaviour of the people your kids will encounter? As a small child I encountered relatives and acquaintances with a range of mental health problems and idiosyncrasies, from the severe - paranoia, schizophrenia, etc - to the minor, like anxiety, ticks, strange quirks, or just things they were needlessly fretful about. It was never expected of other adults to modify their issues to make me more comfortable. I think it's more important that children learn to be gracious towards others than to have the behaviour around them sanitised to keep them in a bubble where everyone accommodates them (and before people jump on me, I'm not talking about abusive/inappropriate behaviour. Of course children should be protected from people who might harm them.) We live in a broken world full of troubled people. It's good for kids to learn to be sensitive to other people's issues.

BiBabbles · 19/04/2022 14:33

I get the frustration on those who go on about how scary/yucky whatever is to young kids, because yeah, they're impressionable and if you don't show any coping skills beyond avoidance, it's not doing much good. Similar those who go on about how horrible the world is with stories in front of young kids and putting a lot of fear and pressure on young shoulders with nothing to help them deal with that.

I don't think it's unreasonable to discuss fears or dislikes though. I think showing your emotions and how to deal with it is important and I think kids often notice even if they're isn't discussion. My kids' father is afraid of heights, they've seen him not go on a ferris wheel or shake while on a ladder.

I think it's better we talk about it than try to brush it under the carpet. It's possible some of the discussion rubbed off on my youngest who was wary about a walkway after we'd discussed their father not liking it, but my youngest knew he could hold someone's hand and we'd help him through it and after a few times he was fine. I want my kids to know we support each other through our fears and fears are a natural sensory information and just like all of our senses, it isn't perfect in showing us how the world is, but together we can figure it out.

Natty13 · 19/04/2022 14:29

My mother is fearless. She tackles everything in life with drive and confidence and was my absolute best role model. Your kids will learn from you...mum is your constant in life as a child, your rock and where you get your reassurance that, even if you fall, she will be there to catch you. I'm so grateful to her because adulthood is a lot more fun without fear and anxiety.

PlasticineMeg · 19/04/2022 14:29

Personally I think an astonishing lack of empathy is MUCH more damaging to kids than having to understand that sometimes other people have phobias, but there you go 🤷‍♀️

C25kBecky · 19/04/2022 14:27

Absolutely not unreasonable at all. If kids I'd raised turned out like a lot of people today, I'd feel I'd failed them.

Rosehugger · 19/04/2022 14:26

When I used to go on climbing frames, my DM would be like "Don't go too high!" Whereas I'd praise DDs for getting to the top, hovering with my heart in my mouth underneath of course but not saying anything.

Swayingpalmtrees · 19/04/2022 14:25

And most of these fears are complete rot.

Spiders and snakes can't hurt you here in the UK and should be approached with curiosity and care, tenderness even. Bugs and animals - it is the same for all fears without exception. It is mostly entirely irrational anyway. Why teach your children to be irrational?!

Surely simply celebrating wildlife, and showing your children how important the role of the spider, rat, snake is in the eco system is the main aim and celebrate the lives of all insects etc. We are at risk of making them neurotic.

Rosehugger · 19/04/2022 14:24

I really didn't want to pass on my vertigo to DDs and it seems I haven't. I'm sure mine came from my mum going on and on about being frightened of heights and DP's general over-protectiveness and over-awareness of danger to the point of being wet blankets about it. Mine appears only when I might be faced with climbing down somewhere steep/narrow and there is an actual potential to fall and at least hurt yourself (obviously I avoid this most of the time). Occasionally it appears on stairs or escalators.

Bpdqueen · 19/04/2022 14:24

Agree 100% babies are born with 2 fears loud noises and falling every other fear that develops through life is a learned behaviour

Swayingpalmtrees · 19/04/2022 14:21

I have raised perfectly happy kids without having to avoid people who are scared of stuff. None of their fears affected my kids

Your kids may or may not be fine with all the negative drama, but I am not sure why you would want this around them? Fears are for adults to deal with, it is not something you should be putting on a child. I am not talking about putting a protective bubble around them where nothing bad ever happens, but there is something said for children enjoying peace of mind, feeling secure and content. We don't need to introduce a ton of fear mongering into their young lives.

The world at the moment is quite challenging and we are not short on stressful and negative news, it is okay to ensure this isn't rubbing off on your children and ruining their mental health. They have a life time to learn this stuff, let them be happy and carefree. If nothing else most children deserve not to worry about stuff that won't hurt or bother them personally. Young minds can absorb this stuff very quickly.

HTruffle · 19/04/2022 14:20

Also agreed. My mum recently rushed my four year old in from the garden because there was an ‘angry bee which was going for them’ grrrr

ClaudiusTheGod · 19/04/2022 14:13

Then we talk about which bugs and which snakes are actually dangerous, and the ridiculously low odds of ever facing them.

This is a good point. Most people don’t understand odds and probability at all, as evidenced on this site repeatedly.

SagaN4 · 19/04/2022 14:13

Oh I totally agree. Currently with on holiday with family and they are so nervous about everything. It's rubbing off on DD as she's normally so active and fearless when it comes to the outdoors but would now rather 'stay in with Granny'. I guess we don't see them that often but they are so young and impressionable you really have to watch what you are saying.
I see my mum's fears/dislikes as irrational and she constantly talks about food she doesn't like. I try to tell DC that it's ok to fear things but try not to let it have too much impact on our lives. I for one, am petrified of wasps (irrational) and as much as I try and stay calm around them some of that fear comes out!

nopuppiesallowed · 19/04/2022 14:11

I think that a proportion of the rise of mental health issues in young people is that some adults forget they are children and that fears can easily take root in their developing brains. We can't protect our kids from the realities of this world but we can try to diminish them. My 6 year old grandson was obviously scared about the war in Ukraine (no idea where he'd picked it up from as TV is strictly curtailed in their house) so I gave him the world's shortest explanation and then told him that our country is a safe place for us to live. He then changed the subject, but if he brings it up again I'll approach it on an age appropriate way. As a child during the Cuban crisis and then the cold war, I was never afraid of what would happen. Partly because of the lack of social media but also because I never remember the adults around me even discussing it in my hearing. Let's be willing to let children be children - to help and comfort them when they are afraid of something. But let's not weigh them down with fears too heavy for their narrow shoulders.