Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this portion too small (pic)??? Should I complain?

143 replies

TeachyTeacher · 19/04/2022 09:45

OK, a little 1st world problem-ish but we're really trying to budget and eat out rarely, as a treat. Went out over the weekend and ordered this pasta dish from a well known chain restaurant, costs around £15. Is it just me who thinks it's a kiddy portion? I took it up with the waitress who said it's the portion size and thats that... should I email a complaint?

OP posts:
BinBandit · 19/04/2022 12:43

How much (or little) do people think a restaurant should change for a main pasta dish? I mean bearing in mind they need to do X amount of covers at an average spend of Y to cover their costs and turn a profit.

It depends what type of sauce. I'd pay that for something with a decent serving of seafood or chicken and full bowl of pasta. If it was tomato and Basil or similar/cheap veggies then I think £10-£12 is the most.

Lets face it, they could have chucked in a bit more pasta with the same amount of sauce and cost themselves pennies but the customers would be so much happier.

Honestly, unless it's like a little fixed price lunch menu then I rarely eat in an Italian anymore. I think a smaller portion for a lunch menu or fixed price 3 course is fair. I have been out and people have had a decent plateful of pasta with a nice sauce and chicken or sausage etc and it's been fine in the grand scheme of things but I'd not order pasta without knowing in advance what was likely to arrive.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 19/04/2022 12:42

The majority of people I know who go out for meals do so because it is either a celebration of some type or a catch up with friends. A few go for a date night or pre theatre, very few because they are foodies. The meal tends to be secondary on these occasions and therefore plenty are happy to order the pasta however cheaply they could do it at home, because all they want is a pleasant tasting meal to enjoy whilst in the company of friends. I think we may see a move towards more home entertaining as the cost of living increases bite so all those who are saying they can cook far superior quality food for a fraction of the cost are going to be very popular hosts. Not sure how they will feel about producing 8 different starters, mains and desserts though.

Soffit · 19/04/2022 12:38

I think they are going to have to start offering a free small plate in the form of the remainder of your pasta dish served up alongside the reduced size main.
I expect a big portion of carbs because I expect to NOT cook for the rest of that day. Pre-2022, this worked out fine every time. If they reduce sizes and I end up having to cook later on anyway then as far as I am concerned, it's not worth going at all. I will not order the rip off starters, sides and deserts.
I was in the City last week and I noticed that a well known small pizza chain (which is known for being cheap) was absolutely heaving. However, the usual clientele (students) had been replaced by City workers who had never been seen there before (well, the odd one, but not tables full of them). The pizzas may have been a tiny bit smaller but compared to elsewhere, it was still a bargain as ordering two at a fiver each was not going to be ruinous. Everybody seems to be gravitating towards the bargain lunches and I reckon that the chains will fall in a dramatic way.

Herejustforthisone · 19/04/2022 12:38

So the OP hasn’t uploaded a pic?

Indicatrice · 19/04/2022 12:37

@oakleaffy you should have complained, that's not a slice!

oakleaffy · 19/04/2022 12:35

Can’t see your pasta, but I received this tiny, mean sliver of cake at a Bristol park.
Cost £2.95 ish and I paid before seeing it.
I had asked slice size, too and was shown a mimed triangle.

Stall said “” It’s homemade”

Meanest slice ever.

Is this portion too small (pic)??? Should I complain?
Onionpatch · 19/04/2022 12:33

The cost of eating out has risen. My instinct is £15 is too much but I am thinking pre-covid /brexit world.

My local pub (expensive south east) charges about £9 for a tuna sandwich.

Cocomarine · 19/04/2022 12:32

I keep checking back hoping the photo has surfaced!

WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow · 19/04/2022 12:30

I just don’t understand people going for pasta and then complaining that it’s not good value for money tbh. Everybody knows that the main ingredient is very, very cheap. Whether the dish cost a tenner or the OP had got double the amount for her £15, it’s still never going to be good value if you’re basing “value” on how cheaply or easily you could make it at home.

That doesn’t mean restaurant’s are ripping people off. Clearly people are willing to pay a huge markup for a pasta dish otherwise Italian restaurants wouldn’t last long given these are probably 50% of their menu! The OP ordered it knowing it was pasta for £15 and you can be guaranteed plenty of others do too because if it wasn’t selling it wouldn’t be on the menu in a chain restaurant.

How much (or little) do people think a restaurant should change for a main pasta dish? I mean bearing in mind they need to do X amount of covers at an average spend of Y to cover their costs and turn a profit.

Indicatrice · 19/04/2022 12:29

I once had a work meal in a Soho restaurant, ordered the ravioli as my main and got 3 medium ravioli. It was delish but I could have had about 10 more. Had to fill up on bread.

YANBU.

IncessantNameChanger · 19/04/2022 12:27

Even if inflation rises are added to a cheap dish theres going to be a tipping point where the vast majority of people dont want to pay it.

We dont eat out as much as we did pre covid and even before inflation rises it was up due to cleaning / spacing etc costs.

We have been to Zizzi twice this year and with the increase in costs I would rather go less and use my clubcard points.

Thing is the customers have less money too. I do wonder how they will all survive. We walked into Zizzi on the seafront on mothers day with no booking so I dont think they are beating customers away right now

Finallylostit · 19/04/2022 12:25

Thanks for the insult - momjin - not all English people like bland food but feel free to insult the English!

Oysterbabe · 19/04/2022 12:22

I never order pasta in a restaurant as I have found that every single time I feel ripped off because I could have made better at home for about £1.

user1497207191 · 19/04/2022 12:21

@Longdistance

£15 for pasta? It’s pennies for a pack of pasta. Did it have gold leaf added?
£2.50 of that is VAT, leaving just £12.50, of which the raw food ingredients will be averaging £4. The rest of the cost is for the staffing, building costs, power, water, waste disposal, administration, crockery, cutlery, cleaning, equipment, and owner's profit/wages.
99point6 · 19/04/2022 12:18

Pizza Express lasange is sadness on a plate. The only time I had it they didn't even decant it from its black plastic ready meal container.
Which chain was it OP? Can't be that identifying.

justasking111 · 19/04/2022 12:10

OH had a plate of seafood tagliatelle the other week. It was crab sticks for £17 he was a bit taken aback

RedMake88 · 19/04/2022 12:06

I can post a pic of a £19.50 dish of seafood pasta I had at a Riva Italian Restaurant if that helps? It was delicious!!

justasking111 · 19/04/2022 11:55

Staffing costs have risen here £10 per hour for waitress. If you're in the kitchen chefing around 32k now. Chefs don't do long hours any more so you need more staff in the kitchen if you want to serve lunch through to dinner. So split shifts 10 - 4 or 4 - 9. That's five days a week . It's the same with other staff

ChampagneJustBecause · 19/04/2022 11:55

I’m invested now and need the photo !

But it wouldn’t surprise me tbh. I had ravioli recently- 3 ravioli to be exact.

Momijin · 19/04/2022 11:51

I remember a few years ago going to Piccolino in sheffield and had the blandest plate of pasta ever. Probably around £15 mark. My friends like their food but I am a keen cook and I'm not english so am used to more flavour. Even the most basic of bars in Spain for example serve delicious meals better than most restaurants around here anyway.

Had lunch in Tampopo in the trafford last week. £40 for 2 of us and left half of it as it was inedible. The rice was tasteless (like I imagine some frozen ready meal to be like). The coconut prawns were dry. The sticky chicken wings were sickly and salty and the only delicious thing were the mushroom gyozas because I imagine they were ready made. My 11 year cooks better.

Covetthee · 19/04/2022 11:48

Ah shame you can’t post a picture as I would have loved to see the usual comments of ‘thats a massive portion OP, I would eat that all week.. whats wrong with just having a lettuce leaf and water!?’

Either way, i do think eating italian food is always disappointing as i too find most portions very small for what they actually serve…

nearlyspringyay · 19/04/2022 11:45

We went to Cote recently, not sure if they are national but def a chain. I had a duck confit cassoulet main, for £19 and it was TINY. For a duck leg and beans. DH had fish and ended up with a bag of chips on the way home.

I just don't think it's worth it anymore. Paid £170 for 2 adults and two kids at our local family Italian recently, two starters, four adult mains (pasta), water, a beer and two glasses of wine. I understand why they have to do it but I can cook pasta just as well at home. Ditto steak, and sunday roasts. New pub has just opened and it £21 for a roast, £84 for 4 without drinks / desert / service. I'd rather spend the money in the local butcher and do it myself.

BinBandit · 19/04/2022 11:35

I rarely order pasta out either. I do appreciate that they are cooking it etc but unless it has a decent amount of an expensive ingredient, then It's usually much more of a rip off than other meals. Even lovely fresh made pasta in a restaurant costs buttons to make and cook.

if you compare it to something like a steak for example. You might get that on a menu in a gastro pub with all the trimmings and sauce for £25ish. The steak bought by yourself will be over £10 and then add in all the rest, usually some nice vine tomatoes, chips, onion rings, maybe salad or mushrooms and a peppercorn or other sauce, all cooked and served etc with ingredients probably about £15. Pasta will have cost them about 50p tops and the sauce could be a couple of quid at most. No more skill or time to cook than making the steak dish. In fact in a pub type situation you might pay the same for a burger with all the trimmings as you'd pay for pasta and that probably won't even be fresh pasta.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 11:25

@DesidaCrick

It's not just the cost of the pasta!! It's staffing, energy, rent, business rates, water and all the other costs that seem to spiral only upwards...
People are aware of that.

But there's only a certain amount you can charge for a relatively plain pasta dish without people feeling like you're ripping them off.

There's no way I would pay £15 for pasta with pesto and a piece of chicken - I could make it at home for probably less than a fifth of that price.

And yes, I know you're paying for the "experience" and that staff and utility costs need to be paid for, but if you're at the stage where you need to charge £15 for a really basic bowl of pasta, maybe you need to re-jig your menu or think about whether your business is actually viable long-term.

BarbaraofSeville · 19/04/2022 11:23

@DesidaCrick

It's not just the cost of the pasta!! It's staffing, energy, rent, business rates, water and all the other costs that seem to spiral only upwards...
We know that!! But it doesn't stop £15 for a small bowl of food that doesn't involve time, skill, unusual or expensive ingredients or following a recipe being considered poor value for money by most people.