Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being told to choose between partner and my family

63 replies

StephMum92 · 19/04/2022 09:16

Quite a long one so I'm sorry I'm advance. My partner and my mum haven't got along for most of our relationship. He's a recovering alcoholic and does relapse from time to time, the last one being when our little girl was only 4 weeks old. Anyway last night I had a seizure and had to go to hospital. My mum and grandad came down and wouldn't leave our daughter with my partner (he's just had major knee surgery) but when he asked they were just shouting because he's a piss head. My partner has now asked me to choose either him or my family. AIBU to not choose any? He said it's for his mental health but it doesn't seem anyones bothered about mine

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lizziekisss · 20/04/2022 07:17

He’s an alcoholic, will always be an alcoholic, he may if really willing be able to control or suppress it, but he will always be an alcoholic. You will always have deal with it, and so will your Dd. Anyone asking you to choose between them and your support network, isn’t the person you should be choosing. You certainly don’t need his drama when you are unwell.

LIZS · 19/04/2022 16:36

He's not recovering if he has relapses. You cannot leave your baby in his sole care, your family recognise this as do you if you called them. He is not a partner in your relationship and you are best off away from him . You need to put your dd's needs first. Whether that means moving in with family or throwing him out is down to you.

IncompleteSenten · 19/04/2022 16:29

Had he had a drink when your family came round?
Why were they yelling at him that he was a piss head if he hadn't been drinking?

Ilady · 19/04/2022 16:23

You think he loves you. Meanwhile you will probably tell your family to get lost because he has told you to do this.
He is annoyed that your family came to mind your daughter but they know he an alcoholic who relapsed a few weeks after you had your baby. She was and is not safe with him.
So what happens if you cut off your family and your left with no support.

What happens when he goes off on his next bender and you have no idea where he is. Wait until he is arrested for drink driving. Wait until he loses his job and sits at home spending his universal credit on drink.
What happens when you can't pay the rent? What happens when he comes home some night drunk and you say something that makes him bet you up in front of your daughter?
You have to realise that he will put his drinking before you and your daughter. He has already gone on a bender since she was born. My advice at this stage is to leave him and move back in with your mother where you and your daughter can have a far better life without him.

SleepingStandingUp · 19/04/2022 15:55

How long ago was his latest relapse and how often does he relapse?
If he's been sober for years then your family were out of order and you need to be talking to them about that but no, don't choose. Tell him you are not choosing and let him decide what to do about that.

Thinkingblonde · 19/04/2022 15:55

Choose your daughter. Not him or your parents.

FOJN · 19/04/2022 15:53

The change is not up to him if he is frequently relapsing and has a newborn.

Of course the OP can end the relationship at any time. I responding to your assertion he shouldn't be in a relationship, no one advising him on recovery would suggest HE end the relationship. They have no say over what the OP does.

pointythings · 19/04/2022 15:32

@FOJN

he needs to be a year sober at least before even thinking of being in a relationship.

This is good advice if someone is single at the point they try to get sober but they would also be advised not to make any big changes in early recovery, which would include not ending a long term relationship.

The change is not up to him if he is frequently relapsing and has a newborn. The safety of OP and the baby has to come first, and alcoholics cannot be trusted. With anything.
Whenyougonnalearn · 19/04/2022 15:08

@FOJN

And thread confirms 5 weeks ago

I can't see a second post or a name change where the OP confirms this. I can see a couple of posters stating the relapse was recent but not where that information came from.

No name change Just search
Orangenet · 19/04/2022 15:06

I agree with pp who said you choose the person/people who are not asking you to choose. If my husband wanted nothing to do with my family, fine, but he can’t demand that of me.

HowIsItMarchAlready · 19/04/2022 14:55

@Missey85

Tell him to choose alcohol or you? Sounds like your parents were right not to leave your daughter with him
agreed
FOJN · 19/04/2022 14:55

And thread confirms 5 weeks ago

I can't see a second post or a name change where the OP confirms this. I can see a couple of posters stating the relapse was recent but not where that information came from.

peachgreen · 19/04/2022 14:47

Your partner is not a recovering alcoholic. He is just an alcoholic. Do not cut ties with your family.

FOJN · 19/04/2022 14:47

he needs to be a year sober at least before even thinking of being in a relationship.

This is good advice if someone is single at the point they try to get sober but they would also be advised not to make any big changes in early recovery, which would include not ending a long term relationship.

Whenyougonnalearn · 19/04/2022 14:45

@FOJN

You said your partner had his last relapse when your daughter was 4 weeks old but don't say how long ago that was. I would not indulge an ultimatum from anyone but if your daughter is now 10 years old my attitude would be very different to if she were 10 weeks old.
And thread confirms 5 weeks ago
FOJN · 19/04/2022 14:43

You said your partner had his last relapse when your daughter was 4 weeks old but don't say how long ago that was. I would not indulge an ultimatum from anyone but if your daughter is now 10 years old my attitude would be very different to if she were 10 weeks old.

caringcarer · 19/04/2022 14:33

You sound like you can't see the real danger for your dd is in living in a house with an alcoholic. Your parents and family can see it. They were absolutely correct not to hand your dd over to an alcoholic. Wake up and get your dd to safety. Never leave him alone with her, ever.

Herejustforthisone · 19/04/2022 14:16

Choose your tiny daughter and get away from the alcoholic man who last binged 4/5 weeks ago when your daughter was one month old.

One month.

pointythings · 19/04/2022 12:34

Your partner shouldn't be in a relationship. He should be focusing on his recovery. You shouldn't be in a relationship with an alcoholic who isn't fully in recovery - he needs to be a year sober at least before even thinking of being in a relationship.

Your family are right and you should be putting them and your DD first.

recoveringyoungalco · 19/04/2022 12:00

How long ago was his relapse? I don't think it was very fair what your family said to him if he is trying. It is not easy. But he also should never be asking you to make those sorts of choices between him and your family.

Is he getting any help? A huge problem with many alcoholics is they fall into the 'poor me' that is why he isn't seeing that he is not supporting you. He is being self centred. Most alcoholics I know are genuinely good people. Something I have head often is 'we are sick people trying to get well, not bad people trying to become good'. But and a big BUT all the alcoholics I know are in active recovery, slips or not they are seeking help.

Do not cut ties with your family what ever the answers to the above questions are.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 19/04/2022 11:51

Cutting off your family with a young baby and an alcoholic partner would be very unwise. He has forced your hand. Chose your family. Give your daughter a chance to grow up free from the trauma of alcoholism.

Fulmine · 19/04/2022 11:32

Although your parents sound pretty awful too

Why? All they have done is come to look after their granddaughter in an emergency, and to refuse to leave her in the sole care of an alcoholic recovering from knee surgery who relapsed 5 weeks ago. That sounds the reverse of awful to me. Ideally they shouldn't have shouted, but something tells me that they weren't the only ones shouting and maybe it was the only way to get through to OP's partner.

oliviastwisted · 19/04/2022 11:24

Because he continues to choose alcohol over you and your DD you should choose your family. It is the only wise decision when a man who behaved as your husband does asks you to choose. He is a complete bellend OP. His precious sensitive ego couldn’t cope with other people calling out his really shitty behaviour so instead of facing up to his behaviour, looking out for his wife and DD who badly need family support because of his shitty behaviour, he asks you to choose. Gosh he is awful.

AngelaRayner4PM · 19/04/2022 11:20

If your husband is capable of looking after your daughter on his own then why did your mum and grandad come in the first place? It sounds like he not really fulfilling his role as a partner and father if you felt like your mum and grandad needed to travel from out of area to help out because you were in hospital. He should have been the one stepping up.

CheshireCats · 19/04/2022 11:18

Choose your daughter- not growing up with an alcoholic.