Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be frustrated about NI increase?

109 replies

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 19/04/2022 09:02

I understand why NI is important, but at a time when gas, energy etc is going up this on top has royally pissed me off today.

My husband is 26 pounds a month down and I'm 10 pounds down from NI going up, so nearly 40 quid a month we are now paying into NI on top of everything else.
I don't know what we are going to do at the end of the month, we are just barely making ends meet at the moment. I'm even working condensed hours to relieve some of the burden of childcare.

OP posts:
Fedupnurse2022 · 20/04/2022 14:53

YANBU, I just posted about this very same thing. I am a nurse and am down £25/month. I don’t have any more corners to cut but all of my outgoings are going up.

I saw my SIL on the weekend and spent £60 on her and her two DCs for her birthday—she is leaving a manipulative and toxic relationship and thought it would be nice to have a nice day out with her and the LOs…but now I’m regretting it and feeling guilty for regretting, but thinking I should have saved it for myself and my own DCs. Absolutely rotten situation.

I’d vote labour 100% but I’m not a UK citizen so don’t have a political voice here, unfortunately 😢

LampLighter414 · 20/04/2022 14:49

Tory Britain

Make the people who work hard for their money and therefore are subject to NICs pay to subsidise wealthy pensioners rights to pass on their homes and assets to their spawn

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/04/2022 14:46

SlashBeef · 20/04/2022 14:44

How?

The threshold at which NI starts is raised in July.

SlashBeef · 20/04/2022 14:44

ArnoldBee · 19/04/2022 19:32

On the plus side its only until July.

How?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/04/2022 14:42

Guessing that the rest of the post was wasted on you. Not surprised that you can’t hold a conversation. Enjoy continuing the argument with yourself, by yourself.
I can hold a conversation just fine thanks - although I generally find being pompous about others isn't a good way to engage in debate - I prefer to stick to debating the actual issues rather than sneering at others who disagree and trying to present myself as morally superior in some way. But suit yourself.

sst1234 · 20/04/2022 14:11

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/04/2022 12:21

Ranting and swearing doesn’t give your argument more weight. It just makes you look immature and petulant.

Thanks for the lecture Hyacinth.

Guessing that the rest of the post was wasted on you. Not surprised that you can’t hold a conversation. Enjoy continuing the argument with yourself, by yourself.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/04/2022 12:21

Ranting and swearing doesn’t give your argument more weight. It just makes you look immature and petulant.

Thanks for the lecture Hyacinth.

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 20/04/2022 11:38

Yes, there are costs. There are often costs to earning an income, such as commuting costs or home costs if you wfh, so in my example it's not a straight £100k profit for that person earning a wage, either. Plus, it's not automatic that the owner is paying council tax - everywhere I rented, before I bought, I paid the council tax, not the owner.

Travellor · 20/04/2022 11:25

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 20/04/2022 10:18

If 20% if the right tax to pay on income between approx. £12k and 50k and 40% is the right amount of tax to pay on income over approx. £50k then it is also the right tax to pay on assets that make or gain more than £50k.

If you earn £100k a year then you will pay about £27k in tax on that money.

If a property (not main residence) is bought for £100k and sells for £200k then it will have made £100k and you should pay £27k in tax on it. But you won't. You'll pay approx £20k on it - less than someone who worked for their income.

imo that's shitty.

Your property argument fails in that there are costs of owning the asset. In the time the property takes to double in value, the owner will at current rates have likely paid far more than £7k in council tax plus maintenance and insurance. The gain isn't £100k in your example.

safetyfreak · 20/04/2022 11:10

Your wage will rise again in July as they are lowering the threshold.

ReadyToMoveIt · 20/04/2022 11:06

Kick the Tories out at the first opportunity.

Sadly I don’t have that power.
I am objecting to the idea on this thread that those saying ‘it had to be paid for somehow’ are somehow brainwashed, obedient Conservatives. I’ve never voted Tory in my life. Never will. I knew we’d end up paying, it was inevitable. That doesn’t mean I agree with it, or that I’m brainwashed.

Blossomtoes · 20/04/2022 11:02

ReadyToMoveIt · 19/04/2022 20:27

@GreenLunchBox

All these "it has to be paid for somehow" race-to-the-bottom people on this thread infuriate me. Why do the rich not have to pay? Why is it the little people who are already scraping a living having to have tax rises? Angry
It’s not that we don’t want the rich people to pay. It’s that we knew that was never an option, especially under his government. What can we do to make the rich people pay?

Kick the Tories out at the first opportunity.

sst1234 · 20/04/2022 10:58

You could just as people to pay more and more tax, or you could question how what’s paid is spent. Government spending is a bottomless pit. The more you put in, the more they will ask for. Because public sector, by definition, fails to take care of other people’s money like it’s their own. Not like businesses, which are answerable to shareholders and have to account for how they spend and invest.

A novel idea would be to increase minimum wage and stop subsidizing low wages through welfare. Actually have people earn more and keep more. Rather than pay them low wages, too up with handouts and tax others more for the privilege of keeping incompetent government departments in work through pointless re arranging deck chairs.

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 20/04/2022 10:18

If 20% if the right tax to pay on income between approx. £12k and 50k and 40% is the right amount of tax to pay on income over approx. £50k then it is also the right tax to pay on assets that make or gain more than £50k.

If you earn £100k a year then you will pay about £27k in tax on that money.

If a property (not main residence) is bought for £100k and sells for £200k then it will have made £100k and you should pay £27k in tax on it. But you won't. You'll pay approx £20k on it - less than someone who worked for their income.

imo that's shitty.

sst1234 · 20/04/2022 10:13

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/04/2022 09:44

Telling the highest net contributors to F off is nothing short of idiocy. How do you suppose government spending will be funded? Fresh air, or printing money perhaps? You may have noticed the catastrophic rise in the cost living recently due to two years of relentless money printing.

They've really done a number on you haven't they?

This net contributor shit is relentless and ignores the massive increases in regressive consumption taxes (VAT etc) which have fallen once again disproportionately on the poor.

Why can't rich people pay a similar proportion of their income to the rest of us?

If they don't want to do that they are quite welcome to fuck off and try their luck somewhere else.

Ranting and swearing doesn’t give your argument more weight. It just makes you look immature and petulant.

Anyway, factually speaking income tax and NIC generates 42% of treasury revenue, VAT is 15%. Of the income tax contribution, top 1% contribute around 28%. You don’t have to live the rich (not that those on PAYE are particularly rich compared to other types of income). Nor do you need to be an ‘eat the rich’ type socialist.

The facts show that that if you want to generate higher tax take, you have to incentivize people. Telling them to F off does the exact opposite. As Francoise Holland in France found to his peril in 2010s, when the ‘rich’ fled the London to avoid 75% income tax rate. At the same time due to the wealth tax, France lost 16000 millionaires and 7bn Euros. Macron abolished both saying that these turned France into ‘Cuba without the sun’.

Higher income and wealth taxes rarely work. No point in going ‘yeah but, no but, yeah but’. You can hate the rich or incentivize to pay them more through policy which is mutually beneficial.

Subbaxeo · 20/04/2022 10:00

We tax too much on income and not enough on assets. According to the IFS, the imbalance has grown. We have to pay somehow for our society but the burden is increasingly falling to people earning modest amounts rather than wealth. Some people hate socialism but they all like socialism for them-otherwise why all the resentment about selling one’s house to pay for care? And CGT is only a tax on gains made-to hear people talk you’d think they were paying tax twice with CGT.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/04/2022 09:44

Telling the highest net contributors to F off is nothing short of idiocy. How do you suppose government spending will be funded? Fresh air, or printing money perhaps? You may have noticed the catastrophic rise in the cost living recently due to two years of relentless money printing.

They've really done a number on you haven't they?

This net contributor shit is relentless and ignores the massive increases in regressive consumption taxes (VAT etc) which have fallen once again disproportionately on the poor.

Why can't rich people pay a similar proportion of their income to the rest of us?

If they don't want to do that they are quite welcome to fuck off and try their luck somewhere else.

Getoff · 20/04/2022 09:08

bellfrint · 19/04/2022 20:19

NI really is, a tax on the poor,

absolutely

Well, yes, that is/was the point of it. The idea was that NI was not a tax, it's an insurance premium that pays for the state pension and NHS. So once you've paid enough to cover your benefit, you don't have to pay more. But you do have to pay higher rate tax instead. So the rich aren't better off, it's just that their tax goes into the general pot instead of covering what they get back from the state.

Getoff · 20/04/2022 08:48

Kendodd · 19/04/2022 20:07

Plus, did you know NI contributions as a percentage of earnings FALL once you earn above £4,189. NI really is, a tax on the poor, it's the Tory way.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/rates-and-allowances-national-insurance-contributions/rates-and-allowances-national-insurance-contributions

They fall at exactly the same place that income tax doubles, so it's not that people are paying less tax above that.

NI does hide from lower earners that they aren't paying as much less than higher rate taxpayers as they think they are.

TheBatKeeper · 20/04/2022 08:24

For the first time in our married lives, everything is aligned for us.

DH retires in September with a FSP and state it brings us just under the 40p in the £ bracket for what feels like the first time in forever, coupled with no NI for him from August. Woohoo

We are aware that we are fortunate, and plan to divert a percentage of the surplus to the the local food bank.

TheBatKeeper · 20/04/2022 08:17

Kendodd · 19/04/2022 20:57

Has anyone mentioned that we shouldn't need this anyway, what with the NHS being awash with money from the Brexit £350 million.

Thank you , that made me laugh.

applesandoranges221 · 20/04/2022 08:08

Absolutely not being unreasonable! What annoys me most about it is that the boomers will benefit from the care cap, but there's no way there'll be either a state pension or a care cap by the time I retire, so £50 down a month to give yet more to the older generation and get nothing in return, and to pay for endless lockdowns that I vehemently opposed.

But remember how much money the Tories have - they literally don't care if people can't afford basic bills, because it will never happen to them.

Lunar27 · 20/04/2022 08:04

Stabbitystabstab · 20/04/2022 07:33

Yes. Tax the rich so they all fuck off elsewhere and we delay the inevitable rises.
Great plan.
Furlough was absused, yes. Mumsnet seems to generally think that benefit fraud is such a teeny tiny problem that we should just ignore it. Are the two not similar?
It's shit, but covid needs paying for.

Yes, but we'd have to pay less if the government didn't piss a lot of our hard earned money away.

Furlough fraud is said to have cost us £7 billion.
Bounce back loan fraud is said to have cost us £3.3-5 billion.

Then there are the millions wasted on dodgy contracts for mates and other crap.

I don't think anyone here is so unreasonable that they wouldn't pay for covid itself but pissing away money is unforgivable. I don't throw money away in my household and wouldn't expect the public the bankroll me if they did.

The NI and dividend tax increases are set to raise £11 billion, which is roughly what they wasted. It doesn't take a genius to work out what we're paying for 🙄🤦

sst1234 · 20/04/2022 07:53

And businesses.