Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STOP FEEDING HORSES THAT ARE NOT YOURS

956 replies

Pineapplechickenpizza · 18/04/2022 21:25

Unbelievable that this is still a problem after all the hype on social media and the news but unfortunately it is.

Why do people think it’s acceptable to feed an animal that isn’t there’s? I don’t care if it’s an apple or carrot or just a few blades of grass. They’re not your horses- DONT FEED THEM ANYTHING.

If you feed horses in fields that are not yours, honestly, why do you do it?? Do you realise how your ignorance could make someones horse unwell?

Dreading summer holidays when more people are out for walks and think it’s acceptable to feed the horses in the fieldsSad

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 21/04/2022 05:38

ArcheryAnnie · 20/04/2022 22:40

Just because we can't solve all the problems of the world, Plantstrees, doesn't mean we shouldn't solve some of them.

I don't know what the answer is re Dartmoor, etc. Maybe we just live with the current situation. But that's separate to all the cases we do have an answer for, where horses are kept in perfectly ordinary fields, not on moors. When that's the case, the perfectly ordinary fields they ate kept in should not be fields crossed by a right of way.

Well you can maintain that stance all you want, the law says differently. The onus is on you as the human being to keep yourself safe, the horses live there, your rights are those of a visitor.

lameasahorse · 20/04/2022 23:17

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

fUNNYfACE36 · 20/04/2022 23:17

I have the opposite problem. Horse owners/livery allowing their bloody horses to lean over my gardem fence and eat my plants. Twats.

ArcheryAnnie · 20/04/2022 22:40

Just because we can't solve all the problems of the world, Plantstrees, doesn't mean we shouldn't solve some of them.

I don't know what the answer is re Dartmoor, etc. Maybe we just live with the current situation. But that's separate to all the cases we do have an answer for, where horses are kept in perfectly ordinary fields, not on moors. When that's the case, the perfectly ordinary fields they ate kept in should not be fields crossed by a right of way.

Plantstrees · 20/04/2022 22:18

ArcheryAnnie · 20/04/2022 20:40

If your right of way crosses a field of cows and calves, that are blocking your path, then turn back. Or if you're with a dog and the field is full of newborn lambs, turn back

In this thread we aren't talking about cows, or lambs, or crops. We are talking about horses, which although we tend to think of as livestock, in reality serve the same function in society as pets. Massive, beautiful, dangerous pets, but pets nonetheless.

If I climb over several barbed wire fences, and past signs saying "beware of the dog", into an enclosure full of rottweilers, then I am clearly a fool and its my fault, not the dogs' fault or the owner's fault, if I am bit.

If I walk along a legal right of way and am mobbed by rottweilers, then it's the owner's fault if either I or the dogs come to harm as a result.

I've learned a lot in this thread, and have already passed it onto my DS, and would not any more dream of feeding someone else's horse, but I maintain that it is irresponsible to put horses into fields across which the general public will walk.

Yet again you are ignoring the fact that thousands, yes I do mean thousands of horses in England are not pets. They are kept for conservation purposes and live in areas of great beauty where they have to encounter walkers every day. It is not possible to not keep horses where the general public will walk without euthanazing all of them as they have nowhere else to go as they live in free roaming herds right across our countryside!

5000 horses roam free in the New Forest
1500 on Dartmoor
600 on Exmoor plus lots of Exmoor ponies living in herds in AONBs right across the country
A few hundred in the Welsh mountains
Another few hundred in the Cumbrian Fells
Plenty in the islands of Scotland (Eriskay and Shetland ponies)
Other breeds living on common land and plenty of free roaming ponies on National Trust sites including the South Downs and Ashdown Forest, all kept for conservation reasons. I am aware of herds of Highland ponies and Konicks (Dutch ancient breed) on other conservation sites and I am sure there are thousands more I don't know about across the country.

These ponies are part of the ecology of our English landscapes. Take them away and the moorlands and other places of great scenic beauty will not be the same without them. The fields you walk through, without animals grazing would be a different landscape - much of it would become impassable as the gorse, bracken and bramble would take over. If farmers just grazed sheep on the land it would become a totally barren grassland as they eat the grass down until it is too short for many wildflowers to flourish and we would loose many valuable butterfly and bird habitats. Horses have unique grazing patterns and re-introducing them into areas such as the South Downs has led to an increase in biodiversity - flowers like orchids have started to increase in number since the sheep have been replaced by ponies. An increase in wildflowers leads to an increase in bees, butterflies and other beneficial insects. Ground-nesting birds return to these areas and visiting birds come to feast on the seeds and insects that biodiverse grasslands provide.

Horses are indigenous to this country as wild animals and we should respect the part they have played in creating our landscapes. To remove them all from areas the public have access to would be an environmental disaster on an unprecedented scale!

Do you personally still think that we should remove all horses from areas open to the general public?

ArcheryAnnie · 20/04/2022 20:40

If your right of way crosses a field of cows and calves, that are blocking your path, then turn back. Or if you're with a dog and the field is full of newborn lambs, turn back

In this thread we aren't talking about cows, or lambs, or crops. We are talking about horses, which although we tend to think of as livestock, in reality serve the same function in society as pets. Massive, beautiful, dangerous pets, but pets nonetheless.

If I climb over several barbed wire fences, and past signs saying "beware of the dog", into an enclosure full of rottweilers, then I am clearly a fool and its my fault, not the dogs' fault or the owner's fault, if I am bit.

If I walk along a legal right of way and am mobbed by rottweilers, then it's the owner's fault if either I or the dogs come to harm as a result.

I've learned a lot in this thread, and have already passed it onto my DS, and would not any more dream of feeding someone else's horse, but I maintain that it is irresponsible to put horses into fields across which the general public will walk.

Lineofconcepcion · 20/04/2022 20:17

vivainsomnia · 20/04/2022 16:44

Ha the drama of mumnetters, where all dogs are vicious, jump on strangers, frighten their kids, and now we have the horses who are regularly attacked and dying from all the horrible ignorant wildlife lovers!

I live in the countryside, and walk amongst the sheep, cows and horses, with my dog, and never experienced an angry farmer or owner. I wouldn't feed a horse or any other animal (including ducks) but will certainly pet them if they appear friendly? Why? Because its nice to do and feel confident with my careful approach to it. One time last year, we passed about 50 young cows on the path. They came to us and got very close and to our surprised, loved being petted, so much they all followed us for about 10mns. It was a lovely experience, all about being in the country. We passed the farmer and he laughed with us.

Oh realise is so much more friendly, relaxed and welcoming and oh surprise, accident free, than mumsnet!

Extremely stupid . . .
www.google.com/amp/s/www.farminguk.com/news/amp/third-walker-killed-by-cows-within-space-of-one-month_56660.html

Giraffesandbottoms · 20/04/2022 20:15

@SoftSheen

thank you so much - that’s excellent and incredibly useful information for me!

@ZerotwoZero
if this is about duck rape, unfortunately I know about it 😆🤦🏻‍♀️

ZerotwoZero · 20/04/2022 20:13

@Giraffesandbottoms if you really want to know about ducks. look up zefrank1 "True Facts About The Duck" Very educational and very short, we were shown many of his series at university as ice breakers as part ecology degree`s they are all true, but you will never ever look at ducks the same again 😂 (PS Not child safe).

SoftSheen · 20/04/2022 20:06

Giraffesandbottoms · 20/04/2022 20:04

@SoftSheen

like porridge oats?! And peas like garden peas?!

oats would be very helpful actually - I’ve been going to the pet shop to get seeds but my son has a bit of a duck obsession so it would be nice to not have to go daily 😃

Yes, just plain porridge oats and defrosted peas :)

Giraffesandbottoms · 20/04/2022 20:04

@SoftSheen

like porridge oats?! And peas like garden peas?!

oats would be very helpful actually - I’ve been going to the pet shop to get seeds but my son has a bit of a duck obsession so it would be nice to not have to go daily 😃

SoftSheen · 20/04/2022 20:02

Giraffesandbottoms · 20/04/2022 18:38

i would like to say I didn’t know about ducks and bread until embarrassingly recently!

You can feed ducks oats or peas though (according to RSPB)

Giraffesandbottoms · 20/04/2022 18:38

i would like to say I didn’t know about ducks and bread until embarrassingly recently!

Maverickess · 20/04/2022 18:22

To those complaining about the aggression, shouting, swearing etc and saying that it's not the best way to educate people - well I agree, however many of the people we're dealing with don't actually want to be educated, they want to feed the horse.
I've faced this more than a few times - on private land, with people having scaled a locked gate or the fence and walked through the yard (past the farmers house) to the field, ignoring the signs on the way.
When caught and asked not to, the inevitable answer is "Why?" - but they don't really want to know why, they don't want to be educated on equine behaviour, on colic, on laminitis and I've been told I'm talking bollocks more than once, they want to have a moment in the sunshine with the pretty pony, take a selfie or two and then not think about any concequences.
I've even been told that they're not interested in horses when I've tried explaining why it's a bad idea to climb into a field with horses you don't know, and electric fence, kept on private land, and feed them - so 'not interested' that a glimpse of them from the road has brought you all the way up to the paddocks and here you are then?!

Some people have listened and engaged with it, but by and large they're just pissed off they got caught and get arsey and aggressive when asked not to, the 'why' is deflection from most at being caught, not a genuine request for the information.

steppemum · 20/04/2022 17:49

I know and understand about not feeding horses.

But I do think that you need to understand that this is not what used to be taught.

I am 54. All my childhood we were taught the countryside code (far more than I've ever seen it in the last 30 years) and at the same time, taught that the way to feed a horse was with a handful of grass and a flat hand etc so it didn't catch your fingers.
I would not think twice about giving handfulls of grass on a flat hand, or stroking a horse, until I was well into adulthood. I did riding lessons at school, and one school friend had a horse and I occasionally rode with her, and still didn't know you shouldn't give a handful of grass. She fed her horse polos, so I thought they were OK to feed too.

In fact I only really got it when I was staying with my parents aged 30+ and her neighbour rented the field across the road for her horse, and my mum's garage as a stable. My kids were little and we spent many happy hours standing on the gate chatting to her as she sorted the horses out. She used to knock on the door and ask if my kids wanted to give her horse his hay etc etc.
Through that contact I then learnt about laminitis and the danger of even handfuls of grass. I then taught my kids to never give them anything.

So I think that 'feeding the horses' is an embedding in our culture as 'feeding the ducks' You try telling people not to give bread to ducks and you are met with fury etc.

So I am not surprised that people still try and feed the horses handfuls of grass.
I think we probably need a lot more publicity around it. Especially as since lockdown people are coming into the countryside who have not been there for years if at all.

I understand the frustration, and the bloody barefaced cheek of people ignoring signs. In just think there are some deeper ingrained cultural things to unpick.

Grumpsy · 20/04/2022 17:44

alloalloallo · 20/04/2022 16:54

Depends where you are in the country, but a quick Google brings up dozens and dozens of local newspaper articles.

including this one www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/gran-who-kept-feeding-neighbours-22220277.amp about a woman who was given a restraining order after she continued feeding horses when she’d been explicitly told not to.

It was all over our local press and judging by the news stories I’ve just found, lots of local news papers ran with stories.

@alloalloallo that’s the same woman who was charged with assault for throwing rhubarb at her brother/brother in law and hit him in the eye 🙈

alloalloallo · 20/04/2022 17:08

TheOriginalEmu · 20/04/2022 16:06

I know. I absolutely know that. I just think people are human and only have so much patience. I don’t shout but I’ll not polite anymore because I’m so over it. I do agree with you that calling people names doesn’t help anyone. But you can see by the minority who refuse to just leave things alone that aren’t theirs that some people won’t ever learn.

Yes. I agree. I’m all out of patience.

These people I catch feeding my horses have trespassed in the first place and are somewhere they shouldn’t be, have usually climbed over a locked gate, are ignoring perfectly polite and clear signs - and more often than not have been asked to pack it in more than once.

I don’t shout, swear or fling insults. I’m just not that polite anymore.

Especially when randomers end up arguing with me as to why I don’t want them to feed my horses -because they think they know better, or because they think it’s a nice thing to do, or because my horse “looked sad”, or because I’m just snobby and stuck up and will make their child cry - they clearly don’t give a fuck about making my child cry when her pony is being treated for colic again because, someone has fed them something they’ve been asked not to several times already.

I honestly don’t care about people making a fuss of them, my oldie has a little repertoire of tricks she likes to show off if she thinks she’ll get something out of it. The only thing that worries me about it is that if one thinks the other is getting something good, then they’ll kick the crap out of each other. An arthritic OAP with injuries that require lengthy box resting would mean I have to seriously consider putting her to sleep.

PupInAPram · 20/04/2022 16:56

Uppercase thread titles should be reserved for, 'WE'RE ALL ABOUT TO DIE IN AN ASTEROID STRIKE!' or 'TSUNAMI COMING!' not overfeeding a bleeding horse 🤣

alloalloallo · 20/04/2022 16:54

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/04/2022 10:19

@TheOrigRights

I'm still waiting to find out where all the media hype and news about not feeding horses is.
Yeah. I have to say I've never seen a single thing on social media or the news about feeding horses. And there are certainly no signs anywhere.

The only thing I see on SM is to pick dog shit up and not hang it from trees in bags as it kills horses. Nothing else.

Depends where you are in the country, but a quick Google brings up dozens and dozens of local newspaper articles.

including this one www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/gran-who-kept-feeding-neighbours-22220277.amp about a woman who was given a restraining order after she continued feeding horses when she’d been explicitly told not to.

It was all over our local press and judging by the news stories I’ve just found, lots of local news papers ran with stories.

vivainsomnia · 20/04/2022 16:44

Ha the drama of mumnetters, where all dogs are vicious, jump on strangers, frighten their kids, and now we have the horses who are regularly attacked and dying from all the horrible ignorant wildlife lovers!

I live in the countryside, and walk amongst the sheep, cows and horses, with my dog, and never experienced an angry farmer or owner. I wouldn't feed a horse or any other animal (including ducks) but will certainly pet them if they appear friendly? Why? Because its nice to do and feel confident with my careful approach to it. One time last year, we passed about 50 young cows on the path. They came to us and got very close and to our surprised, loved being petted, so much they all followed us for about 10mns. It was a lovely experience, all about being in the country. We passed the farmer and he laughed with us.

Oh realise is so much more friendly, relaxed and welcoming and oh surprise, accident free, than mumsnet!

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 20/04/2022 16:23

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/04/2022 10:19

@TheOrigRights

I'm still waiting to find out where all the media hype and news about not feeding horses is.
Yeah. I have to say I've never seen a single thing on social media or the news about feeding horses. And there are certainly no signs anywhere.

The only thing I see on SM is to pick dog shit up and not hang it from trees in bags as it kills horses. Nothing else.

www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/oldham-horse-pony-dead-sign-19650592

This was all over various media sites, and a few threads here last year.

There are always lambing threads here, facebook pages full of distraught farmers.

Giraffesandbottoms · 20/04/2022 16:18

The countryside code is abundantly clear about leaving horses and other animals the fuck alone! I don’t see what else there is to say 🤷🏻‍♀️ hadn’t seen that before but now I have I think all discussion here is moot.

@TheOriginalEmu
we have similar re our driveway and I fully understand. We’ve done signs etc; everything. I don’t have disabled children but one was extremely ill
for a period. Lots of doctors appts and chance of a and e trips. Used to get extreme rage about selfish bastards blocking me in but then I am probably just entitled, expecting no one to use my dropped kerb…

TheOriginalEmu · 20/04/2022 16:06

Marynotsocontrary · 20/04/2022 13:58

@TheOriginalEmu
I do understand how frustrating that must be, but still don't think it's okay to shout at people really. Particularly at those who have made a genuine mistake but with no bad intentions. And it's counterproductive anyway. People get flustered, angry and upset when shouted at, and are much less likely to think logically as a rule.

Look, I agree with everything that horse owners have said on here about the dangers of feeding, petting etc. The OP has said that people are claiming she is entitled and rude for saying it. No. Saying, informing, educating, that's all fine. But the OP and others on here slating people who were raised in different circumstances and just don't know everything they do (even if it seems abundantly obvious to OP and co)...well, that's the entitled bit. I mean...'village idiots'...it's not okay to talk about people like this.

People on here can shout all they want, but a much more effective approach is to educate people. There was some really good advice upthread on the type of signs that are particularly effective. Campaign, get the message into schools. Most people would hate to think they are risking an animal's health or their family's safety. They are feeding, petting etc because they don't realise the potential consequences.

There is always a minority who think they're above the law of course. But most people are okay. Let them know what you need them to do without the yelling and name-calling. It should cut down on your problems a lot.

I know. I absolutely know that. I just think people are human and only have so much patience. I don’t shout but I’ll not polite anymore because I’m so over it. I do agree with you that calling people names doesn’t help anyone. But you can see by the minority who refuse to just leave things alone that aren’t theirs that some people won’t ever learn.

LovePoppy · 20/04/2022 16:04

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/04/2022 09:24

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist

Yes but then the owners can't get arsey if someone strokes their horse when their horse is head butting them for a fuss can they

Seriously? You can't just leave someone elses horse alone?

Do you struggle with comprehension? What part of "head butting them for a fuss" did you not understand?

The part where you can’t Ignore the horse?

Member869894 · 20/04/2022 16:01

Well I've just asked my colleagues at work if they knew that fresh grass cuttings, apples or polos were bad for horses. They had no idea...

Swipe left for the next trending thread