Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STOP FEEDING HORSES THAT ARE NOT YOURS

956 replies

Pineapplechickenpizza · 18/04/2022 21:25

Unbelievable that this is still a problem after all the hype on social media and the news but unfortunately it is.

Why do people think it’s acceptable to feed an animal that isn’t there’s? I don’t care if it’s an apple or carrot or just a few blades of grass. They’re not your horses- DONT FEED THEM ANYTHING.

If you feed horses in fields that are not yours, honestly, why do you do it?? Do you realise how your ignorance could make someones horse unwell?

Dreading summer holidays when more people are out for walks and think it’s acceptable to feed the horses in the fieldsSad

OP posts:
Pineapplechickenpizza · 19/04/2022 01:19

@Marynotsocontrary

Absolutely no problem with your message, OP, but I dislike the way you're saying it. I appreciate you're trying to be protective, but you're coming across as quite aggressive and arrogant. Not everyone knows about horses and they're simply trying to be friendly by feeding them. It's well-intentioned even while it's inappropriate and sometimes dangerous. I'm guessing we move in different circles because I haven't seen any hype about horses on social media as mentioned in your OP.

To protect your horse you need to act using signs and double fences if they are in a field near a public area. It's your responsibility to look after your animal, not anyone else's. And yes, I've seen you say these precautions (signs etc) happen already. I have to say, I live in the countryside and I think I've seen a sign once ever, double-fencing (for horses) never. So it's not as common as you say, and certainly doesn't happen everywhere.

Education is another tool and I guess it's what you're trying to achieve here? Again I agree it's your responsibility as the animal's owner, but if you could lose the attitude please! Work with people instead of the scolding and the scorn.

Jesus wept.

It’s not an attitude, it’s sheer frustration at the ignorance of people. Just look at some of the replies in this thread! In the first page someone is suggesting children should be allowed to feed handfuls of grass to other peoples horses because it might be the only interaction their children get with horses. It’s unbelievable entitlement like that which causes accidents and illnesses in horses. If you’ve ever seen a death from colic or a horse chronically ill with laminitis, you’d understand the frustration. It’s horrific

And like I said, I’ve taken responsibility for my horse thank you very much. We had double fencing, CCTV, electric fencing, hundreds of signs. We STILL found food in the field. We STILL caught people in the field. So seriously, what do you expect me to do in this situation?

I don’t know what other people near you do, but you directly told me what I need to do to keep my horse safe. So I’m telling you, I’ve done all those things already, what do you suggest I do now?

You summed up the problem in your first paragraph- ‘they’re trying to be friendly by feeding them’. Not everyone knows what horses can/can’t eat and that’s ok, I wouldn’t expect people to know that! But nobody should be feeding other peoples horses ANYTHING. AT ALL. Whether they innocently think the horse can eat it or not is irrelevant. I know dogs like chicken but I wouldn’t approach someone’s dog in a garden and feed it chicken through the fence. I know children like chocolate but that doesn’t mean it’s ok to feed other peoples children chocolate purely because they like it. Could you imagine if someone started randomly feeding your children sweets and said they thought it was ok because children like sweets? It would be completely unacceptable.

It’s sheer entitlement to think you have the right to feed someone else’s animal, at all. If believing that makes me arrogant then I’m happy being arrogant

OP posts:
Pallisers · 19/04/2022 01:14

@Namechangenumber1

I'm glad most people don't mind if I give their horse a pet. I have actually been bitten by a grumpy donkey once for petting his nose, I didn't get annoyed or kick off with the owner, as it was my own bloody stupid fault. I'd give up a finger to pet his nose again though. Maybe I'm just daft, I got bitten by a wild hare a few years ago that I fussed, foolishly assuming because it hadn't ran away that it was fine with me being there. I was also in the (very) local papers for fussing an animal at the zoo that very nearly took a finger or two off. Reading this back, I think maybe I'm just a liability.
you may or may not be a liability but you sound like you love animals so maybe you should rethink how you react to them,

You are presuming that animals respond to human gestures the same way humans do. the animal in the zoo that nearly took your fingers off did it because it was terrified and stressed by what you thought was a gesture of love. Ditto the wild hare - you stressed him out of his mind by presuming he would love to be stroked like a human baby.

I think dealing with animals properly really stretches us out of our usual way of thinking "everyone needs a hug" kind of thing. Actually most animals really don't need anything that feeds our narrative.

OP well done for raising this. the replies have been extraordinary. In the face of evidence that horses will suffer and even die, still there is an expectation that they are there for the delight of the public however it manifests. it has been an eye-opener.

Pixiedust1234 · 19/04/2022 01:10

Well, I have learnt a couple of things so thank you to certain posters. I was taught how to feed grass to horses by the owners, it wasn't a big thing back when I was a young lass. Has grass changed that much over the past 40 years or just horse knowledge improved?

Always knew not to feed anything apart from grass (now I won't do that either).
Always knew that laminitis was foot and grass related but couldn't work it out. Someone said it was insulin (equine diabetes) and the penny dropped.
Never heard/read about starvation paddocks, not even from horse owners. Always thought it was down to crap owners. Now I know they exist.
Never realised about the pecking order at the gates, never experienced it personally but seen it at riding schools etc, but it does make sense.

Once again, thank you to the posters who are explaining it clearly.

WhoKnowsProbsNotMe · 19/04/2022 01:08

I genuinely didn’t know how dangerous it was to feed horses grass from the side of the gate (not that it’s something I’ve ever made a habit of as in the back of my mind there is something about a horse can’t eat lots of long grass: this is more than likely a load of sh#t I’ve picked up wrong and ran with). Also I’ve never fed a horse apples etc. do people go out their way to bring apples?

I would however be much more likely to pet a horse when walking the dog if it was at the fence looking interested in me saying hi (as I do with all animals which I’m sure makes me look crazy😂) if a horse did ever bite me then it would be no one’s fault other than my own. It never crossed my mind people might take issue with that until I seen this post so going forward I might just stick to the hi and keep it moving

Marynotsocontrary · 19/04/2022 01:00

Absolutely no problem with your message, OP, but I dislike the way you're saying it. I appreciate you're trying to be protective, but you're coming across as quite aggressive and arrogant. Not everyone knows about horses and they're simply trying to be friendly by feeding them. It's well-intentioned even while it's inappropriate and sometimes dangerous. I'm guessing we move in different circles because I haven't seen any hype about horses on social media as mentioned in your OP.

To protect your horse you need to act using signs and double fences if they are in a field near a public area. It's your responsibility to look after your animal, not anyone else's. And yes, I've seen you say these precautions (signs etc) happen already. I have to say, I live in the countryside and I think I've seen a sign once ever, double-fencing (for horses) never. So it's not as common as you say, and certainly doesn't happen everywhere.

Education is another tool and I guess it's what you're trying to achieve here? Again I agree it's your responsibility as the animal's owner, but if you could lose the attitude please! Work with people instead of the scolding and the scorn.

AuntTwacky · 19/04/2022 00:51

No need to shout

ForeverLooking · 19/04/2022 00:50

Here is one of the BHS posters we had -I ended up changing it for one saying that the horses bite as some people were still ignoring!

STOP FEEDING HORSES THAT ARE NOT YOURS
ForeverLooking · 19/04/2022 00:47

@Gagaandgag

This tread opens up a whole can of worms about how people should interact with animals/pets in general! Respect and responsible behaviour should always be key but sadly it won’t always be that way. So I can see why horse owners will get defensive.

It’s also about education (I grew up with my parents ripping handfuls of grass and encouraging me to feed horses! But only as an adult with my own children did I assess if this was the right thing to do)

I have worked with dogs and cats myself so I feel confident being around them and teaching my children how to behave with them. I have sadly seen many children approach/behave around them unsafely.

Someone further up said that you shouldn’t feed ducks/birds but our local nature reserve which is run by the wildlife trust sells food for ducks/birds and actively encourages people to feed them.

My children just gently throw the food at a respectable distance. However we have seen people hand feeding birds including huge swans! (With their children right there in pushchairs at face pecking level 🤦🏼‍♀️)
Then these swans terrify other children because they have got over confident and don’t understand boundaries.

I think this thread has revealed that with regard to horses and appropriate behaviour around them too much is put on the owners who are stressed about it - there really should be a public campaign (like the hedgehog and milk etc) to educate the general public! And then a generic poster which can be downloaded and if people see the same one regularly they might respect it a bit more?

www.bhs.org.uk/our-work/welfare/our-campaigns/be-horse-aware The BHS do have signs to download for free. Sadly they do tend to go ignored by some!
Gagaandgag · 19/04/2022 00:45

Thread

Gagaandgag · 19/04/2022 00:44

This tread opens up a whole can of worms about how people should interact with animals/pets in general! Respect and responsible behaviour should always be key but sadly it won’t always be that way. So I can see why horse owners will get defensive.

It’s also about education (I grew up with my parents ripping handfuls of grass and encouraging me to feed horses! But only as an adult with my own children did I assess if this was the right thing to do)

I have worked with dogs and cats myself so I feel confident being around them and teaching my children how to behave with them. I have sadly seen many children approach/behave around them unsafely.

Someone further up said that you shouldn’t feed ducks/birds but our local nature reserve which is run by the wildlife trust sells food for ducks/birds and actively encourages people to feed them.

My children just gently throw the food at a respectable distance. However we have seen people hand feeding birds including huge swans! (With their children right there in pushchairs at face pecking level 🤦🏼‍♀️)
Then these swans terrify other children because they have got over confident and don’t understand boundaries.

I think this thread has revealed that with regard to horses and appropriate behaviour around them too much is put on the owners who are stressed about it - there really should be a public campaign (like the hedgehog and milk etc) to educate the general public! And then a generic poster which can be downloaded and if people see the same one regularly they might respect it a bit more?

Sometimeswinning · 19/04/2022 00:36

Ffs you shouldn’t be sharing a moment WITH SOMEONE ELSE’S PET. Honestly wtf

Sorry, unless you can keep said pet far enough away from public right of ways you need to be more present. I agree no feeding, but you maybe need to think if it's fair to own a pet you can't protect. (I agree that's impossible but the comment re sharing a moment was just ridiculous and slightly self important)

QuestionableMouse · 19/04/2022 00:34

Grass from outside of the fence may also have something nasty on it- weedkiller, for example. I saw someone cross the road to pick big handfuls of the long grass there only the council had been round a bit earlier and sprayed it!

ForeverLooking · 19/04/2022 00:33

[quote Winegumsarewine]@Jenasaurus I was about to ask this. I was always taught by my parents (who had horses) to feed horses Polo mints. Is that a bad thing? Please be kind I am ignorant and wish to know.[/quote]
On the yard we don't "treat" over stable doors and gates as it causes bad manners. We avoid polo's as they have no nutritional value. The odd one isn't going to be a disaster, but we don't as habit. I'm sure you will find owners who are happy to do otherwise, but most I know keep treats to a minimum (like you do with kids!) and try to stick to a nutritionally balanced diet. Its fine not to know as long as you don't just feed horses without asking first! I completely understand not knowing, it just frustrates owners when you put up signs and they are ignored -even ones with explanations on diet and disease.

MaryAndHerNet · 19/04/2022 00:33

Seems that any horse enclosure that borders a public path, the landowner should take steps to keep their animals safe and away from the public.

They've paid thousands for the land, thousands for the animal, a few hundred on a secondary inner fence along the public border seems the best option.

expat101 · 19/04/2022 00:32

It's the same thing with grass clippings for cows too. It needs to be spread right out (if you have permission to do it at all) and not dumped in a pile.

I'm currently dealing with this issue on a lease block where the Gent mowing the grass has no idea the landowner doesn't own the cattle.

And the landowner wasn't too keen on being told that I didn't appreciate not being consulted to begin with.

LazyJayne · 19/04/2022 00:28

Actually, I take that last comment back, there have been some very patient and insightful comments from horse owners.

ForeverLooking · 19/04/2022 00:28

That was a very quick and basic explanation, any horse owner will tell you feeding is complex, laminitis is a bugger to figure out and debated frequently (with issues like frost and spring grass and grass that's too short etc etc).

Winegumsarewine · 19/04/2022 00:27

@Jenasaurus I was about to ask this. I was always taught by my parents (who had horses) to feed horses Polo mints. Is that a bad thing? Please be kind I am ignorant and wish to know.

LazyJayne · 19/04/2022 00:27

I didn’t know that it wasn’t good to feed a horse some grass before reading a thread on here a few years ago.

My experience of horses is very limited, and when I was taken into the countryside as a little girl my parents showed me how to feed a horse some grass with my hand flat.

I always thought it was a nice experience for all involved, and the horse in question would enjoy the friendly attention.

Now I know it can be harmful, I won’t do it again.

But Jesus Christ, some of the comments from you ‘horsey’ people on this thread are beyond ridiculous. Just because something is obvious to you, it isn’t obvious to everyone else. It doesn’t make you clever and the other people stupid.

The ‘hope you get your fingers bitten off, just kidding (but not really)’ woman is the worst, but the rest of you aren’t far behind.

expat101 · 19/04/2022 00:27

We had a foal running with it's mum and uncles in a paddock for a while and had people allow very small children to run into the paddock to try to pat the foal. I have raced up there to ask the kids to leave, explaining the not so small foal will kick out when she gets excited. There isn't much coming back to normal from a kick to the head.

I have had the same children enter a paddock where we kept our bull. No parent in sight, she was too busy entertaining the latest BF. Had to telephone her to get the kids out quickly.

Far out!

ForeverLooking · 19/04/2022 00:26

@HeArInGhandsgirl11

We have horses in the field that boarders our garden. Genuine question, why does feeding them make them ill?
Horses, despite appearances, are actually quite delicate creatures that can suffer with numerous digestive issues and diseases relating to too much sugar in both grass and other feeds. Lots of horses and ponies are kept on restricted diets and grazing, some on starvation paddocks which have no grass (these horses are fed soaked or steamed hay in managed amounts and sometimes hard feed to balance the lack of grazing). Laminitis and EMS are some of the more common conditions that will need a carefully managed diet, also gastric ulcers. If you ever saw a horse suffering acute laminitis or colic you would understand - both horrifically agonising. Horses cannot vomit so anything that goes down stays down. Feeding over the fence or gate can also cause bad behaviour such as biting, nipping and barging and can cause issues with field dynamics and the pecking order. Choke is also a thing, a pony on the livery yard died from a wodge of food stuck in his windpipe. Its really best to just admire them and leave the food well alone and for the owner to manage. It may seem kind and I'm sure always well intentioned, but it's never a good idea or well received.
plominoagain · 19/04/2022 00:24

@HeArInGhandsgirl11

We have horses in the field that boarders our garden. Genuine question, why does feeding them make them ill?
Genuine answer - several reasons .
  1. Horses don’t vomit . They are physically unable to do so . So if you feed them something like bread / potatoes/ or even carrots or apples , if they get stuck , they stay there until the animal chokes to death, or it moves . It’s terrifying for horse and owners .
  1. Some horses have a lifelong condition where they cannot have much sugar , or protein , or rich food , because of the way it affects their metabolism. It can cause a disease called laminitis , related to insulin levels , which can cause the membrane inside the hoof to become separated from the inner wall of the hoof . It can cause small bones inside the foot to rotate , sometimes to a degree where it comes out through the sole . Imagine that happening to your feet . It’s irreversible , and in its worst scenarios , it’s a death sentence . Carrots and apples ? Full of sugar . It can be started by the minutest amount , and requires constant and careful supervision , often costing no small amount of money .
  1. If you feed grass cuttings , there’s a real risk of botulism , caused when the cuttings heat up when in a pile , and then some well meaning soul feeds them .

They’re actually not as robust creatures as you would think .

blinder · 19/04/2022 00:19

I have to say, the thing that infuriated me is when people don’t keep their dogs on leads and let the dogs approach the ponies. Bloody dangerous for everyone, especially the dog.

Momijin · 19/04/2022 00:18

We didn't know a few years ago and I guess Lee lockdown wasn't such an issue as very few people walked by the fields where the horses near my house are. But during lockdown they put signs up and since then we haven't fed the horses. Genuinely didn't know before (well it wasn't me, it was my daughter who went horse riding so I thought she would know).

blinder · 19/04/2022 00:17

Our local Welsh cob breeder allows people to walk their dogs (on leads) in his fields. There are often horses in the fields. They usually ignore us but sometimes do follow us en masse and have got quite nudgy at times. Now I’m wondering if people are feeding them and teaching them bad habits!

Swipe left for the next trending thread