Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STOP FEEDING HORSES THAT ARE NOT YOURS

956 replies

Pineapplechickenpizza · 18/04/2022 21:25

Unbelievable that this is still a problem after all the hype on social media and the news but unfortunately it is.

Why do people think it’s acceptable to feed an animal that isn’t there’s? I don’t care if it’s an apple or carrot or just a few blades of grass. They’re not your horses- DONT FEED THEM ANYTHING.

If you feed horses in fields that are not yours, honestly, why do you do it?? Do you realise how your ignorance could make someones horse unwell?

Dreading summer holidays when more people are out for walks and think it’s acceptable to feed the horses in the fieldsSad

OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 21/04/2022 16:11

I live in the countryside, and I would never walk through the middle of grazing animals, whether that be horses, cattle or even sheep. I'd give goats a wide berth as well

Unless you want to make a huge detour (often miles) you don't have a choice in many areas, though.

Seriously though, I was always taught to stick to the field edge. You not only avoid treading growing crops, but if its a grazing field, the idea is you have a fence to climb over (or through) to escape if necessary. I'd climb the fence if cattle or horses surrounded me. I'd go back the way I came if it wasn't possible or simply not go that way.

A right of way doesn't mean you can go wherever you like in a field, though. You have to (by law) stick to the path, and very often, that path is diagonally through the centre of a field as that's the quickest route to get you from A to B. It's actually illegal to ignore the footpath and skirt round the edge of the field like you describe.

There are a surprisingly high number of deaths and horrible, serious injuries caused by grazing cattle to people walking through their field. And don't act confrontationally - confrontational to grazing animals generally means facing them straight on and looking into their eyes.

According to this article in the guardian: "Between March 2000 and March 2020, 98 people were killed by cattle in the UK, according to the HSE. Of those, 22 were members of the public, with the rest being either farmers or farm workers."

So 22 members of the public in 20 years - barely one person per year. Considering there are over 9 MILLION cows in this country, that's a TINY percentage. Dogs kill more people than that in a year.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/sep/23/farmers-union-issues-warning-after-teacher-trampled-to-death-by-cows

lameasahorse · 21/04/2022 16:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

WisherWood · 21/04/2022 16:01

@ArcheryAnnie whatever you do, don't run. The average small pony can outstrip Usain Bolt without raising a sweat so you're just going to get into a race you cannot win. I would keep interaction to an absolute minimum. Keep walking where you want to go, as quietly and calmly as you can. A horse might cross your path in front of you - it's common behaviour in horses to try to push each other in a desired direction. Just pause, veer slightly, but ultimately keep heading for where you want to go. Generally I would head towards the nearest climbable point in the field. Unless the next field contains cows.

Any flapping or shooing is likely to wind animals up. I trust most of the horses I know, but find other people's horses can be a bit dubious, for whatever reason. Calmly walking where you want to go whilst ignoring them is your best bet.

SucculentChalice · 21/04/2022 15:57

I live in the countryside, and I would never walk through the middle of grazing animals, whether that be horses, cattle or even sheep. I'd give goats a wide berth as well Grin.

Seriously though, I was always taught to stick to the field edge. You not only avoid treading growing crops, but if its a grazing field, the idea is you have a fence to climb over (or through) to escape if necessary. I'd climb the fence if cattle or horses surrounded me. I'd go back the way I came if it wasn't possible or simply not go that way.

There are a surprisingly high number of deaths and horrible, serious injuries caused by grazing cattle to people walking through their field. And don't act confrontationally - confrontational to grazing animals generally means facing them straight on and looking into their eyes.

I would far rather do all of that than walk through the middle of a field and I don't think that many public footpaths were quite designed for leisure use by the size of towns that often now surround them!

ArcheryAnnie · 21/04/2022 15:49

People do have a choice to interact and mess with them.

I think there's a real disconnect between horsey people and non-horsey people, which isn't fully understood even by the horsey people on here who think all of us non-horsey people are idiots.

We've already established that many (most?) non horsey people have no idea what to do with a horse if it comes up to them. I have learned on this thread that I shouldn't feed them, probably shouldn't pat them, but if a strange horse is following me and nudging me in a field am trying to cross, I'd be terrified and have no bloody idea what to do. Should I run? Climb over the nearest hedge? Stand still and let it sniff me? Make loud "shoo" noises and wave my arms? Lay down and play dead? Smack it on the nose to make it leave me alone? I'd probably try to climb over the nearest fence to get away from it. I rally don't know what I'd do if a horse came up to me while I had a leashed dog with me Other equally ignorant townies might see that as a cue to pat and fuss and maybe do more. But in both cases we wouldn't have initiated the interactions, and may not want to "mess" with then at all. Sometimes we don't have a choice on interaction, but the interaction is forced on us from the horse - or, strictly speaking, through the horse by the owner.

TheOriginalEmu · 21/04/2022 13:36

ArcheryAnnie · 21/04/2022 08:13

TheOriginalEmu this thread is about preventing harm to horses, no? Plenty of horsey people here have said that many (most?) people don't know how to interact with horses, and a smaller number don't care to learn. Some horsey people here have said that other people shouldn't interact at all, in any way, other than admiring the horses from afar. They have also said that plenty of horses have learned bad habits from interactions with ignorant members of the public, and those bad habits lead to more interactions, as horses beg for treats, etc.

Given that - whatever your personal wishes - hikers, picnickers, dog walkers and other members of the general public will continue to use rights of way over fields, doesn't it make sense to keep them apart, from horses, to prevent harm to both the horses and the people?

If you want to prevent harm to horses (or anyone else), it's not enough to be correct, you also have to be effective. You are currently not effective. Perhaps - if preventing harm to horses is really your first priority - being effective should be your goal.

Of course preventing harm to my animals is my priority. However, that also means my horses need to graze. Grazing land is in decline across the U.K. and finding grazing that is away from people and rights of way is really difficult.
my own yard is mostly away from the public, but it’s the exception rather than the norm in my area.
so, I can’t not graze horses, they literally need it to survive. There would be no issue with the horses being dangerous or aggressive if people just left them alone.
i don’t have a choice to put horses to graze. People do have a choice to interact and mess with them.
🤷🏼‍♀️

Polkadotties · 21/04/2022 12:48

HelenRose1111 · 21/04/2022 10:10

Please watch, if you can't /won't believe that horses should NOT be fed ANYTHING by anyone other than their owner/carer...

fb.watch/cwS32bd62c/

I agree. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE watch this.

alloalloallo · 21/04/2022 12:19

Plantstrees · 21/04/2022 10:53

Exactly, but that is precisely what @ArcheryAnnie and others are suggesting we do to protect our animals. It ia also be the best protection from dogs. I have triple fenced my field and planted a hedge to screen my horses and sheep from the public. Unfortunately it also means that walkers will loose the beautiful views from the footpath, but the wildlife and livestock living on my land take priority over walkers..

Yes.

I know someone who has done exactly that across a field he owns. Put up fences and created a corridor across the field after he was having problems with people trashing his field, leaving gates open, straying from the ROW, leaving litter and generally being a nuisance.

Now everyone is complaining about it - it spoils the beautiful views across the countryside for walkers, it’s unsightly, it’s horrible to walk through, etc as if it wasn’t entirely as a result of their own actions.

Be careful what you wish for.

WisherWood · 21/04/2022 12:19

Thanks @ArcheryAnnie I was just mulling over why some of the analogies given, although they seem reasonable to me, weren't actually working for others.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 21/04/2022 12:15

In my experience, paths that CAN be fenced off, are fenced off, but there are so many fields where it just isn't possible to do that, and so landowners and farmers have no choice but to hope the public will use their common sense.

I walk rurally a lot and lots of paths are fenced or divided by hedges and dry stone walls, but in many cases you just can't do that, due to farmers needing access to the whole field (due to where tracks and roads are located), or because the "right of way" goes right through the middle of the field, so installing a path and fence would reduce the field to a size where it's too small to keep livestock safely.

ArcheryAnnie · 21/04/2022 11:37

WisherWood what you say makes a lot of sense.

ArcheryAnnie · 21/04/2022 11:36

FWIW I think fencing off public footpaths, where easily done, is actually quite a good idea. Obviously, you can't fence acres of moorland or massive pasture fields but where its easily done I think I'd rather for peace of mind. Some people are just so stupid, they cannot be trusted out in the countryside and its better to encourage them to be restrained by fencing in some way

Agree with this entirely. It would provide peace of mind both for the owners, and for the people using the paths.

dontshootthepianist · 21/04/2022 11:03

Billy Congo - your post made me smile. We have one a bit like that. No-one should feed other peoples horses without permission as stated a hundred times on this thread. I have been known to offer the odd friendly stroke in a duly cautious manner though - please dont shoot me! (see user name!).

TableSetting · 21/04/2022 11:03

@WisherWood well said.

Hearts and minds.

WisherWood · 21/04/2022 10:55

Although I appreciate your frustration OP I think it might be useful to ask why people assume they can feed horses but not do the other things you mentioned. Now I'm all but certain that some people were trolling and being wilfully obtuse. But there is also something different about horses. They are kept on publicly accessible land, whereas dogs generally aren't. They are left unsupervised for extended periods, often in publicly accessibly areas, whereas dogs and young children aren't.

I suspect these things contribute to the idea that horses are in the public realm and that therefore some of the normal barriers don't apply. Plus horses are very, very good at directing humans to do what they want them to do. Scientists have studied this. Horses are amongst a small group of animals who will point to things that they want. This establishes a communication and connection that's quite rare. Added to which, you only have to go back to my grandparents' generation to find a time when horses were all around us and it was much more common to feed them. They worked incredibly hard and died younger, so laminitis and other metabolic disturbances were less prevalent and less known about.

Yes, people are annoying. But if you start by assuming they're stupid you're not going to win them over.

Plantstrees · 21/04/2022 10:53

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Exactly, but that is precisely what @ArcheryAnnie and others are suggesting we do to protect our animals. It ia also be the best protection from dogs. I have triple fenced my field and planted a hedge to screen my horses and sheep from the public. Unfortunately it also means that walkers will loose the beautiful views from the footpath, but the wildlife and livestock living on my land take priority over walkers..

Pineapplechickenpizza · 21/04/2022 10:35

over 800 comments later and some people are still suggesting this post is rude because I didn’t ask nicely for people to stop feeding horses because apparently they didn’t know it’s wrong.

I’m actually concerned at the idea that grown adults don’t understand not to feed another animal they don’t own (whether they think horses can eat grass or not) and think they have to be told that it’s wrong to feed another animal? Do you have to be told not to break into peoples houses? Or told not to feed chocolate to random children at the park? Or told that it’s unacceptable to feed chicken to random dogs in random gardens. No I’m sure you don’t have to be told not to do that, because it’s called common sense and basic manners.

Honestly this thread is baffling. How much hand holding do adults need?

just in case anyone needs to be told, it’s not acceptable to break the law in any way. Apparently we need to tell people this now because they might not know it!

OP posts:
lameasahorse · 21/04/2022 10:27

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

SucculentChalice · 21/04/2022 10:27

ArcheryAnnie And I also think that on the (very probably rare) occasions when a walker is prosecuted after using a right of way and behaving badly (maliciously or through ignorance) towards horses, that won't ease the distress of having a hurt or dead horse, either for the horse or the owner. Better to set up to avoid these situations when at all possible

And, predictably, its onto the "I think I'm likely to get away with it" excuse...

I'm thinking more of walkers with dogs. The local (rural) police really crack down on it around here. But they also crack down on any reports of strangers wandering around looking suspicious, particularly if they have parked a vehicle nearby that can identify them, or in general are acting as if they are trying to see if there is anything worth stealing or someone living alone. They're actually brilliant at responding to such complaints...

FWIW I think fencing off public footpaths, where easily done, is actually quite a good idea. Obviously, you can't fence acres of moorland or massive pasture fields but where its easily done I think I'd rather for peace of mind. Some people are just so stupid, they cannot be trusted out in the countryside and its better to encourage them to be restrained by fencing in some way.

HelenRose1111 · 21/04/2022 10:10

Please watch, if you can't /won't believe that horses should NOT be fed ANYTHING by anyone other than their owner/carer...

fb.watch/cwS32bd62c/

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 21/04/2022 09:56

And I also think that on the (very probably rare) occasions when a walker is prosecuted after using a right of way and behaving badly (maliciously or through ignorance) towards horses, that won't ease the distress of having a hurt or dead horse, either for the horse or the owner.

Of course it won't ease the distress, but maybe it will make the offender think twice and serve as a lesson to others.

Better to set up to avoid these situations when at all possible.

Well, yes, of course.

But generally that's not possible (or owners would do so) so the public need to take some responsibility too.

ArcheryAnnie · 21/04/2022 09:50

And I also think that on the (very probably rare) occasions when a walker is prosecuted after using a right of way and behaving badly (maliciously or through ignorance) towards horses, that won't ease the distress of having a hurt or dead horse, either for the horse or the owner. Better to set up to avoid these situations when at all possible.

ArcheryAnnie · 21/04/2022 09:44

I think this really is a situation in which the perfect is the enemy of the good.

Plantstrees · 21/04/2022 09:20

One of the biggest problems is that rights of way are historic - the route children took to school, or old families used to get to Church on a Sunday. Often they are not practical in modern terms for walkers with their dogs - they may cross through the middle of an open field for example. In the days when these rights of way were created, the people using them were locals, familiar with the livestock and wildlife in the area and if they knew there were calves or lambs in a field, they would take a diversion. Unfortunately these same paths are now entrenched as footpaths and are being used for a different purpose by people who are unfamiliar with the livestock and wildlife inhabiting them.

It is very difficult, if not impossible for a farmer or landowner to move a footpath to a more suitable route - say round a field so it can be fenced. This needs changing. If footpaths all went between fields, rather than diagonally across them (taking the shortest route possible was logical when you were using it to go to school daily) it may help landowners keep their stock away from walkers. I think a new approach to rights of way is required to serve the best interests of everyone.

SucculentChalice · 21/04/2022 09:16

ArcheryAnnie They you have to accept that things will occasionally go wrong, and that both horses and humans may come to harm.

In that case, you have to accept that you might be criminally liable, or be sued for causing damage to property.

I'm not joking. I work with criminals, and this is an attitude that many if not most of them share. The failure to abide my rules and to take responsibility for their own actions, instead blaming others for failure to prevent their actions.

I think with that attitude, you also have to accept that some owners are more on the ball with others at pursuing those who cannot respect private property, whether that be in getting the police involved or in civil law, and your luck may not hold out. Although many with that attitude do already have a criminal record, usually of fairly petty crimes.