Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STOP FEEDING HORSES THAT ARE NOT YOURS

956 replies

Pineapplechickenpizza · 18/04/2022 21:25

Unbelievable that this is still a problem after all the hype on social media and the news but unfortunately it is.

Why do people think it’s acceptable to feed an animal that isn’t there’s? I don’t care if it’s an apple or carrot or just a few blades of grass. They’re not your horses- DONT FEED THEM ANYTHING.

If you feed horses in fields that are not yours, honestly, why do you do it?? Do you realise how your ignorance could make someones horse unwell?

Dreading summer holidays when more people are out for walks and think it’s acceptable to feed the horses in the fieldsSad

OP posts:
CaliforniaDrumming · 19/04/2022 09:18

Security to keep people out, I meant.

CaliforniaDrumming · 19/04/2022 09:18

This thread is mad. I don't care if horse owners are rich as Rishi Sunak . I like to respect other people's property no matter what their bank balance is. And the horse's health of course!

They have explained in great detail why feeding horses is wrong, and you still have entitled posters arguing that they will continue to feed horses. They should not have to corral their horses away from public paths and put up Fort Knox level security to keep horses out. I didn't realise the public were so stupid as to actually scale fences to feed horses. Now I know.

XelaM · 19/04/2022 09:17

@BettyBag It's not. I care about my horse much more than I care about other people's kids so it's definitely not an equivalent. If you think it's ok to continue feeding other people's animals just because the owners of those animals are in a "middle class bubble" I guess there is no reasoning with stupid.

MadameHeisenberg · 19/04/2022 09:16

@XelaM

Nope, nowhere have I said that. You give the impression of being a bit hard of comprehension - are you sure you should be responsible for such a demanding pet?

It’s also no different to cat and dog owners who worry about their animals being injured on the road by people driving carelessly. You cannot prevent the existence of a small minority of idiots, whether they be speeding drivers or determined horse-feeders.

Soubriquet · 19/04/2022 09:16

[quote AProperStinging]@ForeverLooking

"My horses don't exist to bring joy to someone else's kid at the expense of their own health and my vet bills.

"I paid for them, pay for them and look after them every day, spent the money and time breeding them and keep them healthy and happy. They have a happy and healthy life and I don't want them to suffer from colic, laminitis, choke or poisoning from people feeding them shite over the fence which would cause them terrible pain and possible death. I didn't buy them to entertain the neighbourhood kids. They are on private land and I'm not a zoo. You want to feed and look after a horse, invest and buy your own, or at the very least ask. Or pay and visit a farm park where the animals ARE there for your entertainment."

It's so, so weird and very telling to frame it like this rather than simply saying, "don't do it because it is bad for the horse, makes them ill and could kill them".[/quote]
I paid for my dogs.

I pay for their food, toys and vet treatment.

I still don’t want you giving my dogs any sort of food whether they can eat it or not.

They are not there for the public happiness. They are here for mine.

You want a dog to entertain you? Buy one.

Polkadotties · 19/04/2022 09:15

I don’t really have an issue with people petting my horse. He is a gentle giant 700kg lump. However, one of his field mates is a very anxious horse, previously abused in Spain. He will come over and investigate people but if you raise a hand to touch his nose or worse rub his ears he will spin and run, normally with a massive buck. That buck could catch you if you are hanging over the fence

RHOShitVille · 19/04/2022 09:13

@aurynne

If this is such a dangerous and frequent issue, then why on earth do horse owners not keep them away from pathways where people could contact and feed them? Isn't this a much simpler solution?
At our yard there is a field down a private track. No houses up there, all private land. People still drive up to feed the horses.

Another field has two locked gates. People go through both.

People traipse on private footpaths and land. No-one at our yard cared until lockdown, but the sheer extra volume of people who walk there now means that approach has changed.

GetOffTheTableMabel · 19/04/2022 09:12

I have found this thread genuinely educative. Feeding horses is not something I do but it’s also not something I knew that I must never do.

And I haven’t told my DDs never to do it either. So now I will. Thanks all.

XelaM · 19/04/2022 09:10

@MadameHeisenberg So it's ok yo make a living creature suffer in agony so long as the owners can afford the vet (who may or may not be able to save it)?! Excellent insight

BettyBag · 19/04/2022 09:10

[quote XelaM]@aurynne Of course there's so much free land in England...

Some people on this thread are just purposely being awkward. I might start going around public playgrounds giving random kids junk to eat. I'm sure parents would be cool with that.[/quote]
Your horse is not the equivalent to a child.

Try an internalise this.

ForeverLooking · 19/04/2022 09:10

Anyway, that was my last say. Funnily enough the most scathing judgements and assumptions seem to be from those about horse owners and not the other way around

XelaM · 19/04/2022 09:08

@aurynne Of course there's so much free land in England...

Some people on this thread are just purposely being awkward. I might start going around public playgrounds giving random kids junk to eat. I'm sure parents would be cool with that.

suckingonchillidogs · 19/04/2022 09:08

I've genuinely learned not to feed horses now (I don't think I ever have but still). The people getting touchy about people stroking a velvety nose though? I don't suppose carrying an extra 9/10/11 stone of person on its back is what any horse would actively choose to do - must put extra strain on the knees so let's stop that business.

MadameHeisenberg · 19/04/2022 09:07

@XelaM

What a moronic post. Of course the cost of veterinary treatment is relevant to this topic. Literally, if you can’t afford to treat your animal when it’s sick (however it got sick), then you can’t afford to keep the animal. That’s it. The comparison with strangers ‘feeding’ random human children is irrelevant and pointless as it isn’t an issue.

BettyBag · 19/04/2022 09:05

Ahh a horse thread. I love these because they always firmly answer the question "is MN a middle class bubble?".

Anyway, I often feed friendly horses who come close to me a bit of grass. If you don't like it keep you horse somewhere else.

ForeverLooking · 19/04/2022 09:05

[quote AProperStinging]@ForeverLooking

"My horses don't exist to bring joy to someone else's kid at the expense of their own health and my vet bills.

"I paid for them, pay for them and look after them every day, spent the money and time breeding them and keep them healthy and happy. They have a happy and healthy life and I don't want them to suffer from colic, laminitis, choke or poisoning from people feeding them shite over the fence which would cause them terrible pain and possible death. I didn't buy them to entertain the neighbourhood kids. They are on private land and I'm not a zoo. You want to feed and look after a horse, invest and buy your own, or at the very least ask. Or pay and visit a farm park where the animals ARE there for your entertainment."

It's so, so weird and very telling to frame it like this rather than simply saying, "don't do it because it is bad for the horse, makes them ill and could kill them".[/quote]
I've literally said that in the same post, multiple posts since and it's true. I do pay for them and care about their wellbeing and health -which costs money. Money I work for. Why is that weird? Should I pretend they don't cost money? The first line which I've noticed you glossed over to suit your narrative says FOR THEIR HEALTH. I love my horses. I don't want them to suffer any illnesses. I want them all to live long happy lives. I have retired ones living the good life who owe me nothing. Why should I pretend that this is all free?

Patchbatch · 19/04/2022 09:05

@aurynne

If this is such a dangerous and frequent issue, then why on earth do horse owners not keep them away from pathways where people could contact and feed them? Isn't this a much simpler solution?
But then how would they fulfil their desire to have a large mammal as a pet?
AvDemeisen · 19/04/2022 09:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 19/04/2022 09:04

@aurynne

If this is such a dangerous and frequent issue, then why on earth do horse owners not keep them away from pathways where people could contact and feed them? Isn't this a much simpler solution?

It's not difficult to learn and abide by rules for rural living. We have to compromise between people accessing and enjoying the countryside and people keeping animals - horses, sheep, cows etc.

It's the same principle as not letting your dog off the lead in a field of sheep.

Patchbatch · 19/04/2022 09:03

[quote AProperStinging]@ForeverLooking

"My horses don't exist to bring joy to someone else's kid at the expense of their own health and my vet bills.

"I paid for them, pay for them and look after them every day, spent the money and time breeding them and keep them healthy and happy. They have a happy and healthy life and I don't want them to suffer from colic, laminitis, choke or poisoning from people feeding them shite over the fence which would cause them terrible pain and possible death. I didn't buy them to entertain the neighbourhood kids. They are on private land and I'm not a zoo. You want to feed and look after a horse, invest and buy your own, or at the very least ask. Or pay and visit a farm park where the animals ARE there for your entertainment."

It's so, so weird and very telling to frame it like this rather than simply saying, "don't do it because it is bad for the horse, makes them ill and could kill them".[/quote]
Right? It sort of implies the horse is there for their entertainment which is weird- as if their sole purpose is to fulfil a humans wants and hobbies. Ew.

XelaM · 19/04/2022 09:03

@AProperStinging 🙄 Because horse owners are not allowed to talk about money- God forbid. They should just pretend that keeping horses is free.

aurynne · 19/04/2022 09:02

If this is such a dangerous and frequent issue, then why on earth do horse owners not keep them away from pathways where people could contact and feed them? Isn't this a much simpler solution?

MadameHeisenberg · 19/04/2022 09:01

@ForeverLooking

Well that puts you on a par with most other pet owners then, doesn’t it? I’m sure most people would rather their cat not suffer an agonising broken pelvis or fractured skull because of idiots who drive too fast/carelessly. But unfortunately, idiots are part and parcel of life - an environmental hazard, in this instance.

frostyfingers · 19/04/2022 09:01

Where does it stop though? I have proper fencing to keep my horses in, I put signs up that people wilfully ignore, I have insurance, I live on site, we have no public footpaths nearby and yet still people take it upon themselves to trespass and potentially cause harm.

Can we all wander about doing exactly what we like and not be responsible for our actions? Telling me I can’t do something because I can’t afford the consequences of other people’s behaviour is pretty unkind - “an enclosure away from a public footpath” is a lovely idea but maybe that’s the only field that someone has; “remedial veterinary treatment…too expensive” I have insurance, I factor in costs as best I can but expecting me to put aside hundreds of pounds because people might want to feed a horse is madness.

I get that some people are totally unaware and think it’s a nice thing to do and assume/hope that when they see a sign or double fencing or whatever think maybe they shouldn’t and then don’t. It’s the ones, and there are plenty of them, who carry on regardless and that is where it’s so frustrating.

There has been plenty of publicity about dogs killing sheep yet it’s still happening so we can’t rely on publicity stopping people feeding horses, ignorance can’t always be an excuse.

AProperStinging · 19/04/2022 08:57

@ForeverLooking

"My horses don't exist to bring joy to someone else's kid at the expense of their own health and my vet bills.

"I paid for them, pay for them and look after them every day, spent the money and time breeding them and keep them healthy and happy. They have a happy and healthy life and I don't want them to suffer from colic, laminitis, choke or poisoning from people feeding them shite over the fence which would cause them terrible pain and possible death. I didn't buy them to entertain the neighbourhood kids. They are on private land and I'm not a zoo. You want to feed and look after a horse, invest and buy your own, or at the very least ask. Or pay and visit a farm park where the animals ARE there for your entertainment."

It's so, so weird and very telling to frame it like this rather than simply saying, "don't do it because it is bad for the horse, makes them ill and could kill them".

Swipe left for the next trending thread