Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STOP FEEDING HORSES THAT ARE NOT YOURS

956 replies

Pineapplechickenpizza · 18/04/2022 21:25

Unbelievable that this is still a problem after all the hype on social media and the news but unfortunately it is.

Why do people think it’s acceptable to feed an animal that isn’t there’s? I don’t care if it’s an apple or carrot or just a few blades of grass. They’re not your horses- DONT FEED THEM ANYTHING.

If you feed horses in fields that are not yours, honestly, why do you do it?? Do you realise how your ignorance could make someones horse unwell?

Dreading summer holidays when more people are out for walks and think it’s acceptable to feed the horses in the fieldsSad

OP posts:
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/04/2022 16:13

[quote MadameHeisenberg]@SamphirethePogoingStickerist

It’s relevant here because if you want to persuade people to do something/not to do something, then asking them politely is far more likely to get you your desired outcome, than screaming at them with contempt. I would have thought this was fairly obvious.[/quote]
Yes, the intent is obvious, just how it could be accomplished in real life is, seemingly, not possible. Given the number of those determined not to care enough to read a poster.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/04/2022 16:12

It's different because you want to own a horse. A horse isn't a cow, it's a pet. You don't need it, you want it. You want it even if you can't look after it. Tough, be responsible.

Motivation for ownership is irrelevant. Horse owners don't need to justify their reasons for ownership to anyone (that's aside from the cruelty ethics surrounding steeplechase racing, with which, FWIW, I do have a problem). This thread relates to the behaviour of the public and feeding of horses which are not their own. The onus for that is on those people, not the owners.

It's not the same situation as foxes in the hen coop. The onus there is entirely on owners to protect their animals. This problem is caused by humans: supposedly sentient beings endowed with some level of skill in communication. It's hardly beyond human wit, or basic good manners, to comply with owners' requests not to feed their horses.

This thread shows an enlightening divide in the tone of the responses. People can't be blamed for what they don't know. Those unused to horses likely won't be aware horses can't vomit, or know that every horse-lover dreads colic, a relatively harmless condition in humans but frequently fatal in horses. Some posters genuinely haven't known why feeding horses grass is dangerous, have asked, been enlightened and resolved not to do it again. This is how decent people react, and every kudos to them.

It's the others, the kind of idiot who can't take even the mildest criticism, who won't be told what to do and thinks they know better, who gets on the defensive and insists they'll continue their unwanted behaviour, who are the menace to these animals' wellbeing. There are plenty on this thread who've been warned of danger to the animal and potentially to the child but are determined to continue 'because it's nice', or because they think their little darlings have the absolute right to do exactly as they please and fuck the consequences to others.

In that mindset of course it's the owners who are to blame, for daring to own the animals in the first place. Or their motivation is to blame, for owning them simply because they 'want' to. Why else take on the care of an animal; why have children? Here's betting those people don't ask the same question of those with cats, dogs or kids.

Fekinell.

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 16:11

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

alloalloallo · 19/04/2022 16:08

@Worldwide2

I have to say reading this thread I find it baffling so many people are arguing about feeding someone else's animal. Can you imagine people feeing other people's dogs, there would be outrage and quite rightly so. Didn't realise so many people were like this.
I know. It’s baffling.

It’s not a big deal - please don’t feed animals that don’t belong to you. It’s really not a difficult thing to do.

I’ve never understood what it is about horses especially that make random people think they have the right to feed them.

At our yard other liveries have had people removing grazing muzzles or fly masks. Someone came into our field and took down all the track system that we’d put up in an attempt to keep my arthritic retiree at a reasonable weight. People on the actual yard going into stables

I don't think horses, or any other potentially dangerous animal, should be kept in fields where there is a right of way running through it. There's just too much chance of something going wrong.

In an ideal world, I do agree. When we were looking for yards for my horses, I discounted a couple as the grazing had footpaths running across the middle and I just don’t like it. Too many things can go wrong. But then, bulls and cows are kept in fields with foot paths running through them too so 🤷‍♀️

However, fields that are suitable for grazing horses are few and far between - new housing estates, new roads, etc are being built so there’s just not the grazing available to be fussy.

We’ve got a couple of fields beside foot paths at our yard and we tend use them in the winter when there are less people around. It’s usually summer when the problems start - so we then turn out overnight

And I just don’t think it’s unreasonable or entitled to expect grown adults to leave something that doesn’t belong to them alone to be honest.

OnlyTheTitosaurusOfTheIceberg · 19/04/2022 16:06

If fewer people fed or fussed horses that weren’t their own, then fewer horses would follow walkers or runners in their field.

It’s a vicious circle. Every person who feeds a horse treats is teaching it that strange humans in the field / at the fence = treats. So it’s hardly surprising that they then start trying to mug people for treats, and you end up with situations of people who just want to follow a footpath being surrounded by pushy, greedy, bad-mannered horses thinking the human will have some Polos. And none of that is the fault of the owner; it’s the fault of the entitled people who think that any animal in a field is fair game to feed on a whim, because they are the ones who have effectively “trained” the horse to act that way.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 15:59

@ArcheryAnnie

I'd argue that if it has a right of way running through it, then it isn't a suitable field, fairylightsandwaxmelts.
Yes, but that's my point - where are all these animals supposed to go if they can't go in fields with a right of way?

I mean, in Scotland, the public has the right to go anywhere lol. There's no such thing as a "right of way" - they can go in whatever field they like, pretty much.

"The Land Reform Act 2003 gives everyone rights of access over land and inland water throughout Scotland, subject to specific exclusions set out in the Act and as long as they behave responsibly. These rights are sometimes referred to as 'freedom to roam'."

www.apidura.com/journal/freedom-to-roam-in-scotland-everything-you-need-to-know/

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 19/04/2022 15:56

@ArcheryAnnie

I'd argue that if it has a right of way running through it, then it isn't a suitable field, fairylightsandwaxmelts.
This
TheOrigRights · 19/04/2022 15:56

@ArcheryAnnie

I don't think horses, or any other potentially dangerous animal, should be kept in fields where there is a right of way running through it. There's just too much chance of something going wrong.
and this situation maybe explains why the public behave as they do. I'm not talking about feeding, but interacting with them.

Whether it's right or wrong I don't know, but I think you can understand why people might stroke a horse in a field that they are freely allowed to walk through. I assume that if a horse is in a field that I'm allowed to run through then it's one that the owners are confident is of a predictable nature.

ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 15:50

I'd argue that if it has a right of way running through it, then it isn't a suitable field, fairylightsandwaxmelts.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 15:49

@ArcheryAnnie

I don't think horses, or any other potentially dangerous animal, should be kept in fields where there is a right of way running through it. There's just too much chance of something going wrong.
In an ideal world, I'd agree.

But farmers aren't allowed to block rights of way and there aren't enough suitable fields without rights of way where livestock and horses can be kept.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 19/04/2022 15:49

@derxa

The message is simple. Leave other people's livestock alone. And shut the fucking gate.
But a horse sometimes doesn't give you that option.
ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 15:47

I don't think horses, or any other potentially dangerous animal, should be kept in fields where there is a right of way running through it. There's just too much chance of something going wrong.

Polkadotties · 19/04/2022 15:45

Leave gates open if you found it open

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 15:42

@derxa

The message is simple. Leave other people's livestock alone. And shut the fucking gate.
Absolutely.

But it's not always possible to ignore them completely when they actively approach you, nudge against you and solicit attention.

TheOrigRights · 19/04/2022 15:36

@derxa

The message is simple. Leave other people's livestock alone. And shut the fucking gate.
I try to (leave them alone I mean, I always shut gates), but sometimes they approach me as I run through the fields (with public right of way) where they are living (stored? grazing?...dunno the right word).

I'm a bit nervous of horses tbh (big heads) so I try to just keep myself to myself.

derxa · 19/04/2022 15:31

The message is simple. Leave other people's livestock alone. And shut the fucking gate.

LuckySantangelo35 · 19/04/2022 15:28

@AProperStinging

When previous posters said that their horses don’t exist to bring joy to random children who want to feed them you questioned that - asking what do they exist for, and can they only bring joy to their owners etc. Which suggests to me that you think that children and others should have access to these animals even if they don’t want them, if feeling them would bring some joy to the person doing it

AProperStinging · 19/04/2022 15:22

[quote LuckySantangelo35]@AProperStinging

Well no, you were on about how some children don’t have the luxury of having pets and being near horses so therefore they should be allowed to feed them[/quote]
No, I wasn't.

I don't think that, and I didn't say that, or anything even remotely resembling that.

I don't think that children should be allowed to feed animals. I don't even know why anyone would want their children to stick their hands into animals' mouths. I didn't say that some children don't have the luxury of having pets.

You have clearly mixed me up with another poster.

It would be quite nice of you to acknowledge that and apologise for deliberately specifically calling me out for something I never said.

IamaBluebird · 19/04/2022 15:10

I know nothing about horses so when walking through fields , I just admire them from a distance. This seems the best idea to me, if they approach I just keep moving.
I once saw a family have a picnic, then pop the picnic blanket over the pony for their child to sit on. I assumed it was their pony till the owner appeared and told them how much of a risk they were taking and never to do it again.

alphabetsoup1980 · 19/04/2022 15:08

[quote AProperStinging]@ForeverLooking

i paid for them, pay for them and look after them every day, spent the money and time breeding them and keep them healthy and happy. They have a happy and healthy life and I don't want them to suffer from colic, laminitis, choke or poisoning from people feeding them shite over the fence which would cause them terrible pain and possible death. I didn't buy them to entertain the neighbourhood kids. They are on private land and I'm not a zoo. You want to feed and look after a horse, invest and buy your own, or at the very least ask. Or pay and visit a farm park where the animals ARE there for your entertainment.
I wouldn't stroll into your garden because my kids thought it looked nice and I fancied a look round or a pick of your flowers because some kids don't get to see flowers often. Look by all means. Don't feed other people's animals.

I could not be less interested in feeding or looking at any horses.

I don't treat large, intelligent mammals as playthings for my own amusement, and I don't think that having lots of money makes it ok to do so either.

It's very telling how many financial references you made in just that one post.[/quote]
Spot on!!!

AllOfUsAreDead · 19/04/2022 15:07

@DoraSpenlow

It's different because you want to own a horse. A horse isn't a cow, it's a pet. You don't need it, you want it. You want it even if you can't look after it. Tough, be responsible

You really, really don't get it do you @BettyBag.

The OP is trying to be responsible - asking strangers not to feed her horses - but the public just ignore because they want to feed/talk to the nice horsey.

She is trying to get the message across to those who no nothing about horses that it is not a good idea. Several here have said they now understand the reasons why.

Don't waste your time, she'll never get it. It's too complex. Smile Just another one that will wail and scream at being told no.
lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 15:03

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Worldwide2 · 19/04/2022 14:59

I have to say reading this thread I find it baffling so many people are arguing about feeding someone else's animal. Can you imagine people feeing other people's dogs, there would be outrage and quite rightly so. Didn't realise so many people were like this.

Maverickess · 19/04/2022 14:55

[quote lameasahorse]@Maverickess there still is danger as I am sure you know if the mud gets too deep, even if it is a small part of the field. Farmers do what they can to reduce muddy gateways. There is lots of advice out there.[/quote]
I'm not sure I understand the relevance to this comment, but for my horse the piles of his shit I pick up are deeper should he stand in one than any gateway/hard standing areas of high traffic that happen when it rains. That and the fact he's unshod now and I manage the land appropriately and it's well drained - though it was still described as a 'sea of mud' by a 'concerned' member of the public I can only assume because it didn't resemble a bowling green.

DoraSpenlow · 19/04/2022 14:44

*know.