Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STOP FEEDING HORSES THAT ARE NOT YOURS

956 replies

Pineapplechickenpizza · 18/04/2022 21:25

Unbelievable that this is still a problem after all the hype on social media and the news but unfortunately it is.

Why do people think it’s acceptable to feed an animal that isn’t there’s? I don’t care if it’s an apple or carrot or just a few blades of grass. They’re not your horses- DONT FEED THEM ANYTHING.

If you feed horses in fields that are not yours, honestly, why do you do it?? Do you realise how your ignorance could make someones horse unwell?

Dreading summer holidays when more people are out for walks and think it’s acceptable to feed the horses in the fieldsSad

OP posts:
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/04/2022 16:52

- there aren't all that many rights of way, compared to the number of fields. Its not as if this applies to every field, ffs, just a very few.

Yes, so what's the fuss then?

- people who work in the countryside also live in the countryside. It's not just annoying townies who need to get around - unless you want to drive absolutely everyone into a car for every journey, and extinguish ancient rights. (And some people living in the countryside will also have dogs - leashed, or course, if they aren't working dogs)

I don't care. Anyone who uses a facility has the responsibility to know what they are doing before they get there. Countryside Code films are needed again, it seems. Good old Howard and Petunia!

- sometimes the leisure opportunities are part of what makes the countryside a working landscape. Tourism is an essential part of many rural areas. There will be people hiking and using rights of way, whether you like it or not. Some of them will have (leashed) dogs, too.

Again, if you can know your 'rights' you can also learn your responsibilities. Which is what many horse, sheep, other livestock owners ask for year in year out!

These all-or-nothing declarations help nobody. It remains silly to suggest that keeping large dangerous animals away from the general public is to kill all of the large dangerous animals.

As silly as it is to suggest that animals should be kept off grazing fields, or asking for fenced corridors?

So much of these 25 pages of comments have emphasised how dangerous horses can be if interacted with. I believe you all! That's why I was asking questions on what the solutions are. My solution - as many of you also seem keen on - is not to have horses and the general public share a field, without a fence or two between them.

And the law is otherwise for simple reasons. The practical solution for you is not to walk over a right of way of it contains an animal you don't like the look of. Same for anyone else using a right of way. If it is an onconvenience then that is sad. But better that than harm to you or the livestock.

It really does boil down to the fact that the countryside is a workplace. One where leisure pursuits come into close contact with farming. And whilst farmers make as many concessions as they deem fit, practical. necessary, cost effective, there will always be times when a hiker, walker, stroller through the fields doesn't undertsand what is actually happening. That's when the problems start. It's an empty field of grass - have a picnic in the middle, walk your dogs, play with your kids? I've seen that happen too often. That's one farmer's winter feed fucked. Thousands of pounds worth of grass destroyed, flattened, contaminated.

The balance between leisure tourism and farming economics is not for the leisure industry/individual users to decide., It is for the farmer to make their cost benefit analysis and accommodate what they can. Including statutory rights of way!

So when someone using agricultural land for agircultral purposes says "Stop doing that" just stop!

ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 16:49

@VeryLongBeeeeep

There are far fewer instances of walkers being killed or injured by horses in the field they're crossing than there are of horses being killed or enduring life-altering colic surgery by people feeding them crap that makes them seriously ill.
Eh? Did I just read that right?

Horses and the general public shouldn't mix without supervision, which is what we all seem to agree on. There isn't a number of "acceptable" deaths or serious injuries amongst humans, and keeping the two groups apart would lower - as this whole thread argues - the number of painful illnesses and deaths amongst horses, too.

VeryLongBeeeeep · 19/04/2022 16:44

There are far fewer instances of walkers being killed or injured by horses in the field they're crossing than there are of horses being killed or enduring life-altering colic surgery by people feeding them crap that makes them seriously ill.

ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 16:40

The problem is that "the countryside" is a woking place, not a leisure opportunity

A number of things:

  • there aren't all that many rights of way, compared to the number of fields. Its not as if this applies to every field, ffs, just a very few.
  • people who work in the countryside also live in the countryside. It's not just annoying townies who need to get around - unless you want to drive absolutely everyone into a car for every journey, and extinguish ancient rights. (And some people living in the countryside will also have dogs - leashed, or course, if they aren't working dogs)
  • sometimes the leisure opportunities are part of what makes the countryside a working landscape. Tourism is an essential part of many rural areas. There will be people hiking and using rights of way, whether you like it or not. Some of them will have (leashed) dogs, too.

These all-or-nothing declarations help nobody. It remains silly to suggest that keeping large dangerous animals away from the general public is to kill all of the large dangerous animals.

So much of these 25 pages of comments have emphasised how dangerous horses can be if interacted with. I believe you all! That's why I was asking questions on what the solutions are. My solution - as many of you also seem keen on - is not to have horses and the general public share a field, without a fence or two between them.

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 16:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 16:40

[quote lameasahorse]@fairylightsandwaxmelts ah apologies[/quote]
No worries :) it's a very fast-moving thread!

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 16:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

VeryLongBeeeeep · 19/04/2022 16:38

Many people want the right to enjoy the countryside, and that's fair enough.

But with rights come responsibilities. There's a responsibility to be sensible, to assess risk, to shut gates that you open, not to leave litter...and not to interfere with livestock for your own amusement, which includes not feeding other people's horses.

Heartening to see several people on here saying "I didn't know why I shouldn't feed horses, now I do, I'll change my behaviour so I don't inadvertently make a horse ill".

Disheartening to see a small number who seem to want the right but aren't prepared to take any personal responsibility. Why, when you have two courses of action open to you, one of which involves enjoying the countryside responsibly and one of which involves being reckless. careless and endangering the lives of animals, would you be such a dick as to choose the second one?

Yes, there are lots of people out there who are truly ignorant (in the 'not knowing' sense of the word) of the risks to horses of feeding them randomly...but no one on this thread has that excuse now. Yet still people insist on arguing that it's not their responsibility to act like an intelligent adult and it's all on the horse owner. Why??

Chaoslatte · 19/04/2022 16:38

The only time I’ve ever fed someone else’s horse anything was when it was blocking a public footpath eating some grass and couldn’t be coaxed vocally to move and wasn’t moving any time soon of its own accord, so used an apple. So I would counsel horse owners who leave their horses loose around farms to ensure that the horse isn’t going to be blocking the public right of way.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 16:34

[quote lameasahorse]@fairylightsandwaxmelts fencing is expensive. No one is going to fence public pathways so you can avoid some cows.
Sheep are most at risk of people who let dogs run about. Lots of sheep abort their lambs when chased by a dog.[/quote]
Yes...I know.

I didn't suggest fencing, I was responding to someone else who did.

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 16:31

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 16:30

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist

Not to mention bisecting fields, making corners of them inaccessible.

or the cost, c£10/metre as a minimum!

Exactly!

But as long as people can enjoy a nice, safe, sanitised version of the countryside, who cares?!

lameasahorse · 19/04/2022 16:30

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/04/2022 16:28

Not to mention bisecting fields, making corners of them inaccessible.

or the cost, c£10/metre as a minimum!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 16:26

@ArcheryAnnie

So what's your solution? Just kill all the animals?

This is a very silly comment. There's alternatives. Fence the pathways away from livestock, if you intend to put horses or cows in there. (Sheep aren't an issue, generally.)

Not a silly comment at all - I genuinely don't know what other solutions you think are viable?

You can't always fence of pathways as doing so can mean the fields are then too small to legally keep livestock or animals in and many rights of way are directly through the middle of fields.

DameHelena · 19/04/2022 16:25

@SoftSheen

Pineapplechickenpizza I remember seeing a pony get laminitis as a child and it was horrific

Laminitis is horrific, but most often caused by overfeeding/underworking, not by someone saying hello over a fence.

Stop being deliberately stupid and trying to backtrack. Do you not realise your earlier posts are still here.

YOU said 'A pony will not get laminitis from a child feeding it a couple of handfuls of grass.' You brought in 'saying hello over a fence' later, to try to argue your way out of what you'd said.
Just own it, for heaven's sake.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/04/2022 16:25

@ArcheryAnnie

But then, bulls and cows are kept in fields with foot paths running through them too so.

I'd say the same about bulls, and cows in calving season. (Though I am bloody terrified of cows in any season.) My nana lived in a tied cottage accessible only through fields, and I remember once being stuck inside for three days because there was a bull in the field!

The problem is that "the countryside" is a woking place, not a leisure opportunity.

Rughts of way exist, historically, as footpaths to work, church and the market. Nowadays they exist in the same places, but are used mor for leisure pursuits. It is the livestock that have the prior claim not the walker. When you get to a right of way that has livestock in it then you, the walker, are supposed to assess the situation and decide whether or not YOU are in the right situation to cross - dogs on leads, kids coralled, sensible heads on. The framer, horse woner ewct, has already assessed the situation and, assuming each walker is sane and sensible, then there is, 99 times out a hundred, 999 of 1000, no problem.

Yes, sometimes cows get lairy, that's fucking frightening, but thankfully those times are few and far between.

If you nana lived in such a cottage then, presumably, she was used to cows, bulls etc. Her fear kept her indoors rather than the bull. Though I must admit I would have been loath to move! Nonetheless, one person's experience doesn't change how the law actually stands,

And yes, in Scotland there are no rights of way, open access means all walkers have to make sensible decisions all the time!

derxa · 19/04/2022 16:23

Fence the pathways away from livestock, if you intend to put horses or cows in there. (Sheep aren't an issue, generally.) Angry

Marvellousmadness · 19/04/2022 16:23

Put a double fence
Problem solved

But dont tell me I can't stroke a horse bahahaha. Youwould stroke a cat if it came to you in the street... no difference

mamabr · 19/04/2022 16:21

@userxx

Not a chance l'm putting my fingers near those oversized gnashers.
Lol same
ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 16:19

So what's your solution? Just kill all the animals?

This is a very silly comment. There's alternatives. Fence the pathways away from livestock, if you intend to put horses or cows in there. (Sheep aren't an issue, generally.)

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 16:19

@lameasahorse

Bulls can only be kept in fields with a right of way under certain conditions. Cows and sheep of course can be kept in any field.
I remember once happily walking through a field with a public right of way with my dogs - I got to the other side and closed the gate behind me, only to see a sign saying "Warning, Bull in field" Grin
ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 16:17

But then, bulls and cows are kept in fields with foot paths running through them too so.

I'd say the same about bulls, and cows in calving season. (Though I am bloody terrified of cows in any season.) My nana lived in a tied cottage accessible only through fields, and I remember once being stuck inside for three days because there was a bull in the field!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/04/2022 16:17

@ArcheryAnnie

fairylightsandwaxmelts that's not the case in England, though. Sometimes going for a walk in the English countryside (including to get somewhere else) is a choice between walking on a right of way through a field, or walking along a road with no pavement and terrible blind spots. They aren't a luxury - they are a necessity.

Just because there are no other suitable fields available does not turn a field with a right of way in it into a suitable field for horses.

So what's your solution? Just kill all the animals?

I'm a huge advocate for our rights of way being maintained - I dog walk for a living and live rurally and use paths like this day in, day out.

But the countryside is also a place of work and people need to respect that. Too many people want to see a sanitised version of the countryside with no animal poo, no animals, no mud, no risk - it's just not viable for that to happen.

A huge part of our economy comes from farming - both arable and livestock. Where are all the herds of dairy cows going to live if they can't live in fields with rights of way? What about all the sheep, lambs, bulls, meat cows, pigs and chickens etc?

ArcheryAnnie · 19/04/2022 16:14

fairylightsandwaxmelts that's not the case in England, though. Sometimes going for a walk in the English countryside (including to get somewhere else) is a choice between walking on a right of way through a field, or walking along a road with no pavement and terrible blind spots. They aren't a luxury - they are a necessity.

Just because there are no other suitable fields available does not turn a field with a right of way in it into a suitable field for horses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread