Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have felt irritated by my friend’s children today?

319 replies

Chickalick · 18/04/2022 18:41

Not sure if I’m being unreasonable or not to be be honest.

DH and I (who for context don’t have children) went for lunch today with friends of ours and their two DC. Youngest is 5, eldest is 11.

I just didn’t enjoy it and have come home feeling really frazzled due to their DC’s behaviour. I should probably preface it by saying they weren’t being horrendous but neither of them would stay seated for more than 5 mins at a time, constantly bouncing around on their seats, up and down around the table. Youngest kept ear piercingly shrieking every 5 mins and then giggling as they thought it was hilarious, it was like nails on a chalkboard. Eldest kept shouting when they talked (they have a tendency to do this in general) and it was deafening. Youngest kept stabbing their fork repeatedly into the table and eldest started chucking their chips at the youngest which then encouraged youngest to do the same.

I just felt like it was chaos and could feel the diners next to us getting annoyed. It was the noise, just constant really LOUD shouting instead of talking from the eldest or shrieking and silly wailing noises from the youngest. Youngest constantly wanting to get up and run round the restaurant. Us adults could barely hear each other and I just wanted to eat and get out of there ASAP.

To add, parents did tell them to stop each time they shrieked, started chucking food etc but they would stop for about 30 seconds then start again and I think they got fed up of telling them in the end so just kinda gave up. They whipped out an iPad in the end and gave it to them but then they put some game on with the volume on loud and both started shrieking and baying each other when the other was beating them etc.

We’ve just got home and I said to DH that I just didn’t enjoy the meal and won’t be in a hurry to do it with them again. I said it’s like they were feral and had never been taught to sit at the table and eat. He thinks I’m being unreasonable and said that’s just eating out with children, they’re noisy and hyper and there’s not much you can do.

Is he right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Heliotropium · 22/04/2022 13:54

Looking at the voting I think most people agree with you rather than your dh op.

Pottedpalm · 22/04/2022 13:45

I donget this eating from a plate/ tray on your lap. For many children this must mean they are eating with their fingers all the time instead of learning to use cutlery.
was once given a full roast dinner, gravy and all, to eat on my lap. I knew how that would turn out so asked to sit at the table, which was a few feet away.

ClaudiusTheGod · 22/04/2022 13:34

But you can't then bash the parents for taking steps to make improvements.

The bashing was for not having done it before now.

I don’t understand why people don’t make their kids sit at the table to eat. Are their sofas and floors covered in food? Yuck

HumunaHey · 21/04/2022 20:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Bit harsh.

I agree the behaviour of the kids (especially the 11yo!) was not on at all. But you can't then bash the parents for taking steps to make improvements.

Ionlydomassiveones · 21/04/2022 20:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Chickalick · 21/04/2022 18:59

Are you STILL coming back to this thread @HipsterMum?! what is your obsession with someone else’s thread?! So weird!!

No, I’m not two faced, I’ve spoken to my friend since Monday as they’ve suggested we all meet up and do go ape and lunch out in May. I was honest and said Go Ape sounds great but should we make it a picnic after or something as it seemed her DC weren’t enjoying being in a restaurant the other day and it was a bit stressful. She apologised and said it’s because they never sit at the table at home except at Christmas, they allow the DC to sit with trays on their laps and watch TV whilst they eat so they’re not used to sitting at tables. Her DH said apparently when they got home that they need to start eating at the table a few nights a week so they get used to it.

OP posts:
HipsterMum · 21/04/2022 09:43

ExcitedRabbit · 21/04/2022 07:56

YANBU. My three year old niece knows how to behave better than that at dinner. She knows to be quiet and she knows she isn’t allowed to run around. Last meal we went for she sat at the table and coloured in pictures of peppa pig and looked at some
books and waited even though the food took ages.

That being said children do need to be taught how to behave in public spaces. For her faults SIL has always been very good with both her children and teaching them how to behave in restaurants and takes them both out on “dates” to Costa etc. so the rules are clear.

This was the fault of the parents and they should have taken them out. Not fair on you or other diners.

Its fantastic that your 3 years old niece behaves better than that. Mine has nonstop mood swings which makes it really hard to predict how he is going to behave (absolute norm for 2/3 year old by the way). However, I am certain that you only see your niece on certain occasions and not when she is having a bad day, teething, coming up with a cold, refusing to go to sleep, wants another chocolate in the middle of supermarket. Its very easy to like and compliment children when they are on their best behaviour, it doesn't take too much. However, to support them through the challenging moments is just as important. What OP is describing is one occasion, yet the comments are coming up with this whole picture of some lazy awful parenting and some horrible children that the OP had to encounter for one lunch in her entire left. They should have taken their kids out of the restaurant and left? They probably should have, as the OP judges her own friend and her children behind their backs and then meets up with them for lunches probably saying 'awww aren't you 2 lovely'.

ExcitedRabbit · 21/04/2022 07:56

YANBU. My three year old niece knows how to behave better than that at dinner. She knows to be quiet and she knows she isn’t allowed to run around. Last meal we went for she sat at the table and coloured in pictures of peppa pig and looked at some
books and waited even though the food took ages.

That being said children do need to be taught how to behave in public spaces. For her faults SIL has always been very good with both her children and teaching them how to behave in restaurants and takes them both out on “dates” to Costa etc. so the rules are clear.

This was the fault of the parents and they should have taken them out. Not fair on you or other diners.

Owwlie · 20/04/2022 19:34

I can’t believe people have defended this and said it’s normal. My 4 year old knows better than this, she can cope for about an hour at a restaurant before getting restless, although I do take toys/colouring books to entertain her. DC2 has just turned 2 and last time we took her out for a meal (a couple of months ago) she wanted to run around the place, we just distracted her at the table.

Theres no way I would allow shrieking or throwing food or the stabbing the table at 5, let alone 11! That’s secondary school age, more than capable of sitting for an hour, no matter how bored.

Wnkingawalrus · 20/04/2022 19:13

I don't like the attitude in this country that is so anti kids, in Italy they would be swung the kiddies around in the garden and enjoyed them, what is it about this country that expect children to be so prim and proper with Victorian values of being seen but not heard?!

The kids in Italy would have known how to behave.

LoisLane66 · 20/04/2022 19:00

I find it odd as my children never acted like that at all, in fact they were always welcomed and praised for their manners by the staff at our usual restaurants.
Maybe it's because I taught them proper table manners which were the same for eating at home and outside.
It's all about not having two sorts of behaviour.

Swayingpalmtrees · 20/04/2022 15:25

I am chilled, some of my friends children are very loud and boisterous, others are more laid back and gentle. I don't judge everyone I come across, perhaps thats where we differ. I tend to roll with it, and let families do their thing and keep my expectations to a minimum. Don't go to family lunches if you don't like children.

MzHz · 20/04/2022 15:21

And did you miss the part where op said no SEN?

this isn’t typical 5yo behaviour but seeing as the 11yo was exactly the same clearly the ‘rot’ was set in some time ago

there is a world away from ‘children should be seen but not heard’ and the behaviour described on this thread.

my ds at 5, 2 even didn’t behave like this, neither did he aged 11z none of his friends behaved like that either

Swayingpalmtrees · 20/04/2022 14:53

And did you miss the part where op said the youngest is 5 and the eldest is 11?Perhaps read the op properly next time havering

HaveringWavering · 20/04/2022 14:49

Did you miss that the other child was ELEVEN?

And having iPads play with the sound on is unacceptable outside the home.

Swayingpalmtrees · 20/04/2022 14:42

What op has described to me sounds like normal five year old behaviour Mz. Being silly and messing around and not wanting to sit down for boring extended adult lunches is quite normal!
I raised my dc to be polite, engage with adults and sit for as long as they can, but we have no idea if the children have SEN or ADHD or other issues undisclosed, nor do we know that they were 'screeching'. If you are unused to children it can seem loud and too much if you are own house is silent and you can hear a pin drop most of the time.

If you go to lunch with a young family you have to factor in that 'adult' conversations will be limited, it won't be the most quiet affair and you take it or leave it depending on your tolerance. I don't like the attitude in this country that is so anti kids, in Italy they would be swung the kiddies around in the garden and enjoyed them, what is it about this country that expect children to be so prim and proper with Victorian values of being seen but not heard?!

See them out for dinner, in the evening sans children op, if a civilised event is what you are looking for.

MzHz · 20/04/2022 14:24

In other words..

NEWSFLASH - if your kids behave like this in public for no other reason than because you aren’t setting any boundaries or expectations on them… you will be judged by everyone in the unfortunate position of having their lunch/dinner/movie/holiday/whatever ruined by them.

and of course ultimately them means YOU because you didn’t do the basics to help them navigate life with others

MzHz · 20/04/2022 14:21

Swayingpalmtrees · 20/04/2022 12:45

I am not sure I would invite you again, how stressful for your friends that you were judging their children just being children. The dc were probably bored with the adult conversation and took it upon themselves to entertain themselves. It would be better to go out just with adults going forward you are obviously not into children and don't really understand them properly.

Yet post after post of “this isn’t kids being kids/usual/normal/acceptable behaviour doesn’t tell you that your post is just plain WRONG?

mind boggling

Wnkingawalrus · 20/04/2022 14:03

Swayingpalmtrees · 20/04/2022 12:45

I am not sure I would invite you again, how stressful for your friends that you were judging their children just being children. The dc were probably bored with the adult conversation and took it upon themselves to entertain themselves. It would be better to go out just with adults going forward you are obviously not into children and don't really understand them properly.

I’m sure OP would be gutted to miss out…

Swayingpalmtrees · 20/04/2022 12:45

I am not sure I would invite you again, how stressful for your friends that you were judging their children just being children. The dc were probably bored with the adult conversation and took it upon themselves to entertain themselves. It would be better to go out just with adults going forward you are obviously not into children and don't really understand them properly.

Celendine · 20/04/2022 12:15

You're not being unreasonable, some kids are like this in restaurants. Some are great though. We avoided going out with some families with kids when my kids were young. On the other hand I am of a generation where most restaurants did not have kids in them unless they were holiday cafés when I was a child. Luckily I had my kids young before I was shocked by some behaviour of other people's kids.

Stilsmiling · 20/04/2022 12:10

I think you’ve just learned what doesn’t work for meeting with those friends.

We all know kids make noise, need to move, aren’t aware of social etiquette when young. However, our kids needs aren’t more important than anyone else’s desire to expect to eat without food being thrown, excessive noise etc, life is about equal respect. If kids are tired then rearrange something more suitable where they can move about a bit without disturbing others. I have four kids and if we can’t rearrange then we would have taken whatever kid was struggling to stay sitting out for a short walk for a distraction.
Colouring or drawing pads, puzzle books or similar are what we would have taken from a very young age so they had something to do.

All kids have days when they are tired, unsettled, needing to move more. Meeting kids needs isn’t about allowing them to do whatever they need wherever they are at the expense of all those around them. It’s about not trying to achieve the impossible ie. being quiet for an hour while adults have a conversation.

You are not being unreasonable. You can’t change your friends’ parenting so put it down to experience. If they offer the same again then suggest something different, say that it’s too long for the kids to sit and you didn’t get to chat much.

HumunaHey · 20/04/2022 11:41

HipsterMum · 20/04/2022 08:28

I can easily imagine a similar post if the family in question actually decided to parent these kids in the extreme manner adviced by so many in here . If these parents just stood up in the middle of conversation with the OP and went 'nah this is not working with our kids, we got to teach them a lesson right now, so we are leaving'. Then everyone would be saying how bloody rude this family is and why had they arranged the lunch in the first place then. They wouldn't be labelled lazy but rude. Or if they would have opened up a box of Monopoly or Uno because that's what they do to stop their kids from playing up instead of evil iPads and phones which seem to annoy people just as much as any noise coming out of children. I rarely arrange formal meetings in restaurants with friends but if I happen to stop in a cafe and my kids are not behaving their best (which happens because kids cannot be trained to be robots) I just apologise to people sitting next to us and explain that they are overtired. I never repeatedly tell my kids to 'stop it' in front of other people or threaten them outloudly just so others don't think I am a lazy parent. I do it in private when we are outside so they know I don't intend to humiliate them in front of others but to teach them all the same things and how to be considerate of others but in private. This approach is very common in Scandinavia where crying or bisbehaving children in public is considered a part of life and people just get on with it.

How old are your kids? Explaining away an 11 year olds poor behavior as being 'overtired' wouldn't cut it for me.

You're conflating the notion of teaching kids good manners and how to behave as turning them into robots. This is absolutely not the case.

notanothertakeaway · 20/04/2022 10:08

Children of that age should be able to sit quietly and eg read or draw at the table

I wonder if they eat family meals together at home? That's a great opportunity to model good behaviour

bringincrazyback · 20/04/2022 10:02

HipsterMum · 20/04/2022 08:28

I can easily imagine a similar post if the family in question actually decided to parent these kids in the extreme manner adviced by so many in here . If these parents just stood up in the middle of conversation with the OP and went 'nah this is not working with our kids, we got to teach them a lesson right now, so we are leaving'. Then everyone would be saying how bloody rude this family is and why had they arranged the lunch in the first place then. They wouldn't be labelled lazy but rude. Or if they would have opened up a box of Monopoly or Uno because that's what they do to stop their kids from playing up instead of evil iPads and phones which seem to annoy people just as much as any noise coming out of children. I rarely arrange formal meetings in restaurants with friends but if I happen to stop in a cafe and my kids are not behaving their best (which happens because kids cannot be trained to be robots) I just apologise to people sitting next to us and explain that they are overtired. I never repeatedly tell my kids to 'stop it' in front of other people or threaten them outloudly just so others don't think I am a lazy parent. I do it in private when we are outside so they know I don't intend to humiliate them in front of others but to teach them all the same things and how to be considerate of others but in private. This approach is very common in Scandinavia where crying or bisbehaving children in public is considered a part of life and people just get on with it.

And this is really what you think parenting should look like?

Why should some people's inability/unwillingness to control their children trump the rights of other people to enjoy a meal in peace?

Oh, and iPads/phones can be muted, btw, a fact of which many people seem oblivious when letting their kids play on them in restaurants.