Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just tried to watch the new Death on the Nile

170 replies

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 18/04/2022 17:55

What the fuck have they done to it?!

I really really wanted to enjoy it, huge fan of Agatha Christie, love French and Saunders.

From the start it's just too....... Sexy?.... For a Poirot?

None of it felt right.

I'm gonna try again later because I had to turn it off after about half an hour......but jesus.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 18/04/2022 18:55

I enjoyed the scenery, but that was about it. The bit that is absolutely missing from KBs Poirot is the humanity and light heartedness of the David Suchet version.
In the series Poirot is such a warm character- vain and proud - but staunchly loyal to his friends and seemed to get a lot of enjoyment from life.
Here Poirot is dour and pernickety, someone you'd pay money to avoid sitting at the same table with.
KB was a bad choice to play him and whilst I get he wants to do a different Poirot to DS, it's not very enjoyable for the audience.

CaliforniaDrumming · 18/04/2022 18:54

Why Didn't They Ask Evans is my least favourite Christie along with Mystery of the Blue Train, so feeling a bit wary of it.

WimpoleHat · 18/04/2022 18:52

The problem is - in my opinion at least - that David Suchet and Joan Hickson were so good as Poirot and Miss Marple that there’s no room for improvement. And there’s little room in Agatha Christie for modernisation or sexing it up; the stories often don’t fully make sense outside their context. Branagh would surely have been better to take on some of the lesser known Christie books which don’t feature Poirot and make something his own?

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 18/04/2022 18:52

@Greensleeves

Oh bugger, I was planning on putting this on for my aged relatives tonight, it's the only thing I could think of that we would all enjoy (19yo dc1 loves Christie)

Those who hated this, what did you think of the new Why Didn't They Ask Evans?

They might like it, and if not you can all play “well it’s not as good as Suchet is it?” And pick holes in it.
Waitwhat23 · 18/04/2022 18:51

@Greensleeves I rather liked Orient Express but really wasn't a big fan of the changes to Death on the Nile (what on earth was the point of Bouc and Poirot would never have done what he did!). Was pleasantly surprised by Russell Brand though.

Have just finished watching 'Why Didn't they Ask Evans' and really enjoyed it. Will Poulter was a great (if a bit intense) Bobby, Lady Frances (can't remember the actress' name) was just on the right side of arch and any changes to the story were well done.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 18/04/2022 18:49

The back story! If he had had such a traumatic injury to his face that ‘tache wouldn’t have covered it and then where was the scarring when he shaved it off? Branagh wasn’t foppish and pernickty enough.

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 18/04/2022 18:44

Anyone who's into Poirot even a "leetle" bit (see what I did there!) knows his backstory, absolute bollocks and unnecessary!

OP posts:
APurpleSquirrel · 18/04/2022 18:42

It was awful!! We managed about 20mins but it was dire. The dancing scene at the beginning was just wtaf???

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 18/04/2022 18:42

Oh and hello all fellow Christie nerds!!
Nothing better than a great but calming crime drama!

OP posts:
Catkitkat · 18/04/2022 18:40

And the Poirot backstory. Ugh. Nobody asked for it. So wrong

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 18/04/2022 18:40

Tbf it was made before the Hammer shit came out, so I'll give them that at least.

But whoever said it was like they made a completely different thing was right really.

"Loosely based on" might have been better

OP posts:
Catkitkat · 18/04/2022 18:39

Agree with OP. Why change the story? Why not make something else instead of a poor remake of this

CaliforniaDrumming · 18/04/2022 18:39

I did like some of the dresses.

I need to stop watching adaptations of mu fave books. Drives DH mad. Me constantly shouting " You have got it wrong.".

WimpoleHat · 18/04/2022 18:38

Branagh can’t help but put his ego front and centre, it’s like he’s SO CLOSE to being brilliant if he could just get himself out of frame.

That’s a really interesting take, @meloncolic. He’s one of those actors who always “plays himself” in my book and I’ve never been able to get over that. (That said, I did see him get stage doored by a couple of very loud and very enthusiastic American ladies at about 11 o’clock one morning as I was walking down St Martin’s Lane. No crowds or press around and I’m sure he could’ve lived without it. But he was very gracious and pleasant, so I’ve always thought well of him after that!)

Eeksteek · 18/04/2022 18:37

Christie is a warm hug of nostalgic-ness for me too. So thank you for saving me from it! I generally don’t enjoy watching things I’ve read anyway, so I’d probably have given it a miss, but I do like glam costumes, especially 40s/50s so I might have been seduced. Sounds like it’s not worth it.

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 18/04/2022 18:35

For some reason can't quote people anymoreHmm so apparently there is a quota of quotes! Grin

But the moustache thing pissed me off again, the whole backstory of Poirot has pissed me off.

STOP FUCKING WITH GOOD THINGS!!

OP posts:
VeryMuchFlaggingMinty · 18/04/2022 18:33

17yo DD and I enjoyed it...and she's very hard to please when it comes to films, but we're fairly clueless on the Christie front.

Was absolutely gobsmacked at Russell Brand in it...never in a million year thought I'd find him attractive.

CaliforniaDrumming · 18/04/2022 18:33

@meloncolic

Was just ranting at DH that the WHOLE POINT was that Christie invented him based on some Belgian refugees she met in the war so he was never actually serving! Branagh can’t help but put his ego front and centre, it’s like he’s SO CLOSE to being brilliant if he could just get himself out of frame. Haven’t watched past the dance scene yet as was horrified that the Sex Education girl started talking about shagging and I had it on with a 9 year old child as had assumed from having read it it would be fine! Had to turn it off!

BUT Hugh Laurie is producing Why Didn’t They Ask Evans which should be good!

Yes Poirot served as a police officer in the Surete. Never as a soldier! And that bit with him waving a gun around. Come on. He only ever used his little grey cells.

Can you tell I am an annoying Christie nerd?

TheCraicDealer · 18/04/2022 18:33

I saw it in the cinema when it came out. I actually liked the sexy dancing as it suited those two characters and explained some of the motivations there (being SO consumed by someone) but disliked all the changes to the story. As far as I'm concerned Christie was a bloody genius- some small tweaks to suit a modern audience I can accept but why mess with perfection for the sake of it?!

It was filmed before the stuff came out about Arnie Hammer- they've just kicked the van down the road before releasing it in the hope the scandal would die down.

Greensleeves · 18/04/2022 18:33

Oh bugger, I was planning on putting this on for my aged relatives tonight, it's the only thing I could think of that we would all enjoy (19yo dc1 loves Christie)

Those who hated this, what did you think of the new Why Didn't They Ask Evans?

WimpoleHat · 18/04/2022 18:32

The massive Tiffany product placement was also bloody ridiculous. (The cinema should that Tiffany “Moon River” trailer at least twice beforehand and then the same necklace was in the film.) In the book, it was pearls. This was a) much more “U”, b) much more believable because she wore them all the time and c) was a crucial part of the storyline (was she murdered for them, were they fake, the kleptomaniac Mrs van Schyler (sp?) etc.

Sharrowgirl · 18/04/2022 18:30

Did it come out before Armie Hammers sexual assault allegations? Surprised to see him in something quite recent.

It was made before the allegations but the release was delayed for a few years because of Covid. I think it was difficult for the studio to know what to do because of it, and watching it, I think they edited as much of him out as they could. Which did not help with the plot and character development.

meloncolic · 18/04/2022 18:28

Was just ranting at DH that the WHOLE POINT was that Christie invented him based on some Belgian refugees she met in the war so he was never actually serving! Branagh can’t help but put his ego front and centre, it’s like he’s SO CLOSE to being brilliant if he could just get himself out of frame. Haven’t watched past the dance scene yet as was horrified that the Sex Education girl started talking about shagging and I had it on with a 9 year old child as had assumed from having read it it would be fine! Had to turn it off!

BUT Hugh Laurie is producing Why Didn’t They Ask Evans which should be good!

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 18/04/2022 18:27

@WimpoleHat

I was so disappointed I immediately cleansed myself by watching the Peter Ustinov version

@Ionlydomassiveones We did the same. But I love, love, love the idea of “cleansing”!

Might have to "cleanse" as well!!

I really wanted to enjoy it, French and Saunders being in it really appealed to me, but bloody hell!

OP posts:
RonObvious · 18/04/2022 18:26

And there was me trying to avoid any spoilers. Grin