Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking someone to move seats on a flight? Aibu ?

816 replies

wearejustfriends · 18/04/2022 14:31

Last week I was travelling to Gran Canaria with TUI.
I had booked mine and boyfriends seats when we booked and paid £22 for both.
I had the window and he had the middle.

A lady sat on the end and her daughter was in front.
She asked could they have our two seats and we have hers /daughters or my boyfriend switch with her daughter.
I politely said no.
Which she wasn't happy about.
We got "what difference does it make"
"Your adults,my daughter is sacred of flying and is a minor"

Anyway we wouldn't move.

Was I in the wrong ?
Surely if she was that bothered she could have paid like us.

OP posts:
Oatsandstuff · 18/04/2022 16:05

It ALL depends on the age of the minor!

3 yes I’d not move
12 no

MrsAmber · 18/04/2022 16:05

YANBU we’ve had this on the last two flights we went on. In one case DH moved as a Dad asked if he could sit by his DD, thoroughly expecting a child but would guess she was 17/18! DH then ended up with complete behind him, playing a game similar to Bejewelled Blitz so DH’s headrest was being put to the test!

We were then asked if one of us could move so that a young male could sit next to his girlfriend who was afraid of flying. They were told no and ended up sitting together anyway, spare seats I believe!

If you don’t secure your seat by paying extra then you shouldn’t be the CF who expects others to accommodate you!

CorsicaDreaming · 18/04/2022 16:04

@Antarcticant

I can understand 'de-bundling' when it comes to not paying for food etc, that you don't want, but choosing your own seats doesn't have an inherent cost to the airline so I agree with pp that the airline is at fault for using this as an excuse to winkle more money out of passengers.

Yes I agree @Antarcticant - totally reasonable to charge extra for hold luggage and to limit hand luggage, due to the weight - but the additional cost to allocate a seat is just blatantly there to get more money out of people.

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 18/04/2022 16:04

@Tagliatellme

I think it's unreasonable to ask: what's reasonable about 'I want you to give me what you've paid for, and I won't be paying you for it'?
But she may not know if someone had paid for it. So I don't think it's unreasonable to ask. But if found out someone had paid, keep going on like she did is definitely unreasonable.
NobleYeats1 · 18/04/2022 16:03

Ah I see the ‘be kind’ brigade are joining the thread! Never has a phrase set women back so much. Who cares if op is a nervous flyer and paid extra to sit near her partner to help her. Her feelings and situation and money are irrelevant. She should ‘be kind’ and do as she is told. @Genevie82 @Hawkins001 Biscuit

Opaljewel · 18/04/2022 16:03

She isn't petty at all. She paid extra for the seats. If the woman wanted to sit with her child then she should have paid.

Honestly the entitlement of some people.

NewBlueGoo · 18/04/2022 16:03

You weren’t wrong to say no, but if that had been me I’d have let them have the seats.

newname12345 · 18/04/2022 16:03

@KosherDill Not likely at all as its not allowed. No passengers under the age of 15 are allowed to sit in the emergency row.

Simonjt · 18/04/2022 16:03

[quote Mrsherdwick]@Simonjt - we need the full story!! Please.[/quote]
Very boring (sorry!), it was economy plus so two seats together rather than three, so we had four booked on the same side of the plane, including one booked and paid for for our baby. She thought our baby didn’t need a seat so she should be allowed to sit there instead. Premium was about £90 more (short flight) and there were some empty premium seats, so I’m sure she could have paid for one if she wished.

wearejustfriends · 18/04/2022 16:03

Also I told her I had paid for seats.
Her response was "what difference does it make"

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 18/04/2022 16:02

@Genevie82

..I’m going against the grain here but think the decent thing to do would have been to swap the seat with her child.. you sound petty tbh.. I expect what happened here is that she had been unable to book seats next to each other as they were all booked out already - it’s happened very recently on a flight I did so you have to sit like this with your child and rely on the kindness of strangers - or not in your case! I could not have sat through that flight knowing the child infront of me might be feeling nervous not being with their mum, regardless of what I though of them and then post on MN to try and make myself feel justified!
No one knows why she hadn't booked seats with her child. You might think that the OP sounds petty but most people don't throw away money on reserved seats they've paid for for their own reasons. The woman's reaction to the refusal was unpleasant too.
Tagliatellme · 18/04/2022 16:02

I think it's unreasonable to ask: what's reasonable about 'I want you to give me what you've paid for, and I won't be paying you for it'?

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 18/04/2022 16:02

You are not unreasonable not to move. She was not unreasonable to ask. But she was unreasonable not to just accept your answer, and made you fell bad.

Tigofigo · 18/04/2022 16:02

We once booked a flight thinking they automatically seated DC with parents. Our children were 2 and 5 and they sat them on different rows to us! No one offered to move. It wasn't ideal but it was a short flight.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 18/04/2022 16:02

I've been asked this before when flying solo. In these circumstances, as long as the exchange is for another aisle seat, I have no objection to exchanging to enable fellow-travellers to sit together.

In the circumstances you outline, booking fee or no booking fee, the answer would be 'no, we prefer to keep our checked-in seats'. No apology or explanation. This dilemma is for cabin crew to address in any case, not the responsibility of fellow passengers.

And yes, I'll willingly own my choices. I'm not going to feel awkward because a stranger had the cheek to make a demand of me that I've declined to fulfil. Judging and tutting would have precisely zero effect.

wearejustfriends · 18/04/2022 16:02

@Genevie82 I'm not petty.
I'm a nervous flyer hence paying for seats together
It's not my problem the woman didn't book any seats so she wouldn't have this issue.
I actually don't feel guilty in the slightest and why should I

OP posts:
KosherDill · 18/04/2022 16:01

@Genevie82

..I’m going against the grain here but think the decent thing to do would have been to swap the seat with her child.. you sound petty tbh.. I expect what happened here is that she had been unable to book seats next to each other as they were all booked out already - it’s happened very recently on a flight I did so you have to sit like this with your child and rely on the kindness of strangers - or not in your case! I could not have sat through that flight knowing the child infront of me might be feeling nervous not being with their mum, regardless of what I though of them and then post on MN to try and make myself feel justified!
The child could look over her shoulder and see her mother, and speak to her, it's not as though she were in the cargo hold, or 15 rows away.

That's hardly an emergency worth disturbing strangers over.

When I fly with a partner we enjoy chatting, having a drink, looking at cloud formations, watching a film together. That's why we pay the premium.

Had the mother offered substantial payment as in, more than it cost the OP to book her choice of seats that's still rude but at least shows some effort on her part. But expecting a freebie is unbelievably entitled.

Cryingintherain99 · 18/04/2022 16:01

I would have moved to let her sit next to her mum, but that doesn't mean you should have done. We all see things differently.
I would have just been thinking of how the child must be feeling being afraid of flying and needing her mum for comfort. I wouldn't have thought beyond that.

Nanny0gg · 18/04/2022 15:59

@RobotValkyrie

Not unreasonable. Just uncharitable. You're allowed to be mean. People are allowed to judge you for it.

Personally I would have swapped for the sake of a child. My partner is an adult and can survive a whole flight without me holding his hand.
You value money and the entitlements it gives you more than a stranger's child's feelings. The privilege is all yours. Own it.

This should go in Classics as one of THE most ridiculous posts on MN ever.
Blossomtoes · 18/04/2022 15:59

It’s just possible she didn’t realise OP had paid - as I just pointed out, we haven’t paid for ours.

newname12345 · 18/04/2022 15:59

@Antarcticant

I can understand 'de-bundling' when it comes to not paying for food etc, that you don't want, but choosing your own seats doesn't have an inherent cost to the airline so I agree with pp that the airline is at fault for using this as an excuse to winkle more money out of passengers.
De-bundling seat selection allows the airlines to be able to advertise a lower basic cost for tickets, though obviously they know they will be able to upsell. Also though it does remove a 'cost' - it should reduce the amount of effort dealing with customers complaints about their allocated seats.
JustLyra · 18/04/2022 15:58

I think it’s really rude.

The only time I’ve ever asked was when I had to book last minute when DD was offered a last minute cancellation hospital appointment (meant flying the next morning, but cut her waiting time by months). On the plane I asked the cabin crew to ask generally if anyone would swap and I would pay the fee. I had the cash with me, I would have paid but when we booked and checked in there was only single seats left.

Two teens from a family offered as it was only Ashley flight and they hadn’t actually paid to book seats all together anyway.

KosherDill · 18/04/2022 15:56

Some years ago while the plane was still on the ground, a couple behind me had one child in the middle seat and each had a lap child. The kids were shrill, shrieking and kicking the seat back. I asked the parent to stop the kicking and received a surly remark.

As the flight attendant went by, I gave her a beseeching look and jerked my head backward. After everyone was seated but before the plane pushed back, she told me to get my belongings and come with her. She led me to a completely empty emergency row. I had all three seats to myself plus about an extra foot of legroom!

I spent the entire flight lounging across all three seats, reading, with my back to the window and a glass (or three) of wine at hand. Each time those parents trudged past with one of their offspring to the lavatory, I gave them a wide smile.

If they hadn't been such entitled, inconsiderate jerks, it's likely that the extra seats would have been allocated to them. Instead they sat with their lap children, five people to three seats, the entire five hours. And my former seatmates got to spread out and enjoy the space I vacated.

Oatsandstuff · 18/04/2022 15:56

And seeing as it’s a business and not a charity…

Nanny0gg · 18/04/2022 15:56

@apricotlane

I would have quite happily moved. This thread is making me think I'm nicer than I thought I was, and that's saying something!
Or you can afford to throw away £44