Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking someone to move seats on a flight? Aibu ?

816 replies

wearejustfriends · 18/04/2022 14:31

Last week I was travelling to Gran Canaria with TUI.
I had booked mine and boyfriends seats when we booked and paid £22 for both.
I had the window and he had the middle.

A lady sat on the end and her daughter was in front.
She asked could they have our two seats and we have hers /daughters or my boyfriend switch with her daughter.
I politely said no.
Which she wasn't happy about.
We got "what difference does it make"
"Your adults,my daughter is sacred of flying and is a minor"

Anyway we wouldn't move.

Was I in the wrong ?
Surely if she was that bothered she could have paid like us.

OP posts:
Runnerduck34 · 18/04/2022 20:57

I have an anxious teen, I always pay to select seats to ensure we are together.
If its Tui policy to sit parents and children together she should have raised it with airline staff. Having said that if reason was genuine she wasn't unreasonable to ask you but I completely understand why you said no. I really don't like it when airline's split families up. Wish they'd just charge a fair price in the first place.

SoggyPaper · 18/04/2022 20:57

That sounds like a shit user interface.

Tbh, the horse has long bolted on being pissed off at the airlines for this shit. People could have refused to do it at the start and it wouldn’t have taken off (like charging for all ATM withdrawals which is totally standard in the USA, but UK bank customers were not up for it).

Thing is, the alternative is just that all the tickets will be £25 more expensive. It’s really just a system where those who don’t care can save some money. Personally, I’d prefer a more transparent pricing policy for holiday bookings. I find websites like tui unbelievably frustrating to use because they are so busy trying to pretend everything is cheap by standardising the most basic options. You have to go through several pages to figure out how much it actually costs to book what you want - and that makes comparison really difficult.

But clearly other people think that’s great. They do lots of user research about this shit, so it must be based on what customers want.

friendlycat · 18/04/2022 20:54

The problem nowadays is that airlines offer the base price and then you have to add on the extras of hold luggage plus seats. All of these significantly can increase the cost of the flight per person.

I’ve booked flights with Easy Jet for Christmas and my partner needs his work laptop as do I for our holiday and we’ve paid £32.99 each, each way for the seats that includes overhead locker for a small carry on bag plus paid additional hold luggage charge. This is due to EJ changing their policy on what you can take on board. We always put our suitcases in the hold but the policy has changed on what constitutes a carry on bag.

I would be miffed at paying £66 x 2 ways for seat allocation that includes the option of selecting the seat and putting a laptop overhead to then be asked to move and accommodate someone else who has not paid an additional £132. I actually wouldn’t object if my laptop stayed in the overhead and I was given a refund on the seat selection cost. But without the refund why should we move from what we’ve paid for?

I’ve seen families who haven’t paid for seats who then kick up a stink that a family of 4 or 5 aren’t allocated seats together. I get that it adds to the cost of their holiday but that’s how it works.

Changemaname1 · 18/04/2022 20:53

No you weren’t wrong , I recently travelled and my kids sat couple of rows apart from me , it was a last min hol so by time we booked not many seats left together . Wouldn’t dream of acting as thought people who had paid for their seats should swap with us .

Qazwsxefv · 18/04/2022 20:49

The real unreasonable people are the airlines.

Booked flights to the states. Used Expedia. Suggested basic economy. Husband was going to book, it’s only because of threads on here I asked - can we select seats DD is 5 and not flown since she was a lap baby. Husband said - they won’t sit a five year old alone don’t be silly. Next half hour spend reading fine print - no we can’t but don’t worry they sit minors next to parents . Another half hour to find the airlines minor seating policy - next to adult means across aisle or infront/behind so not getting those tickets then. Couldn’t figure out how to pay for seat choice so flying a different airline for £200 more per person. It shouldn’t be this hard to sit next to your kid. I have no need to sit next to dp or have any particular seat but I do need dp or I to sit next to dd5. It shouldn’t be so much more money and effort to sort that.

LibbyL92 · 18/04/2022 20:49

To add.

I’m flying long haul in a few weeks and TUI are charging for seats. I’m well aware we will be split up. We’re not worried. If I was I would pay.

sonjadog · 18/04/2022 20:48

I have no problem with people asking, but the answer is "no" most of the time. I have mild fear of flying and I book aisle seats because those are the ones that work best for me. I do not want to sit at a window or in the middle. I have moved to another aisle seat occasionally but only if it is one or two rows away because otherwise it is a pain when you arrive trying to retrieve your stuff from another part of the plane.

Sometimes people are taken aback by getting a "no" as an answer, but I honestly don't care if the person I am sitting beside for a few hours and will never see again is in a mood with me, and other people's children/partners are not my problem.

SoggyPaper · 18/04/2022 20:47

Well if there's no reason not to move other than the slight inconvenience of your bag being further away so that a young child can be by their parents, of course you should move.

But it’s a complete pain in the arse - often for everyone - if your bag is 5 rows back and you can’t disembark without it. And it’s harder to go and get something out of (especially if you’ve moved to a bloody middle seat).

I just don’t think it’s an ‘of course you should put yourself out for the people who knew this was a risk and decided not to pay anyway’.

It’s now pretty standard that you have to pay to ensure you sit together in planes. It’s not a surprise. Or even close to a new thing. Everyone knows it.

And when they see a family of chancers inconveniencing everyone around them, they know they’re chancers who chose not to pay.

LibbyL92 · 18/04/2022 20:47

There’s been occasions where I’ve moved seats.

There was one occasion where I had paid for my seat (broken ankle so wanted second row (had larger leg room like the front)

Someone asked me to swap and I kindly said I had paid for my seat then saw the ankle. It wasn’t awkward and was totally understood.

If the mother is that worried she should of paid.

DrBunsen · 18/04/2022 20:45

Along a slightly different vein, but 8 years ago I flew to New York for a cancer conference that started later the same day (I had a young child and wanted to minimise the number of nights I was away). I deliberately booked a bulkhead window seat (no extra fee with this airline) to enable me to get some sleep (I can’t sleep in the middle or on the aisle) because the evening session ended at 11pm (4am UK time). The plane configuration was 2-3-2 and upon boarding it became apparent that the passenger next to me was one half of a couple, the other half of which was across the aisle and one row back. They immediately asked me to switch seats with him so they could be together and I politely refused, explaining why. Cue passive-aggressive comments throughout the flight, including gems such as “I hope your air sickness doesn’t kick in, darling” from him to her! I didn’t rise to it then but I am much more feisty now after years of sleep deprivation and wouldn’t stand for those comments now - kick myself that I didn’t 🤣 CFs.

Bread121bread · 18/04/2022 20:44

I personally would have switched the seats and have done it few times before. However, you didn't want to, which fair enough you didn't have to do anything.

Next time, I would tell a flight attendant this woman would like to sit next to her daughter can you help her? This improves the flight environment. Well it would for me.

SoggyPaper · 18/04/2022 20:41

@Gwenhwyfar

When I was asked to move seats, I did so VERY reluctantly. I was travelling alone and hadn't paid for my own booked seats, but moving was a hassle because if you're one of the last people there's often no room in the overhead locker and your bag has to not be right next to you. I had just presumed I'd be picked on by the other passengers if I said no to the parents of small children though so I moved. I'd be interested to know, how I should deal with it next time.
I think what you can take from this thread is that, actually, most people are not impressed when parents pull this shit and would have been on your side. Why should you have to play musical chairs on a plane because some parents can’t be bothered to organise (and pay for) seats together.

Holidays are expensive anyway. The money to sit together is a cost you can totally anticipate and budget for.

girlmom21 · 18/04/2022 20:41

@Gwenhwyfar

When I was asked to move seats, I did so VERY reluctantly. I was travelling alone and hadn't paid for my own booked seats, but moving was a hassle because if you're one of the last people there's often no room in the overhead locker and your bag has to not be right next to you. I had just presumed I'd be picked on by the other passengers if I said no to the parents of small children though so I moved. I'd be interested to know, how I should deal with it next time.
Well if there's no reason not to move other than the slight inconvenience of your bag being further away so that a young child can be by their parents, of course you should move.
Gwenhwyfar · 18/04/2022 20:36

When I was asked to move seats, I did so VERY reluctantly.
I was travelling alone and hadn't paid for my own booked seats, but moving was a hassle because if you're one of the last people there's often no room in the overhead locker and your bag has to not be right next to you.
I had just presumed I'd be picked on by the other passengers if I said no to the parents of small children though so I moved.
I'd be interested to know, how I should deal with it next time.

Mrsmch123 · 18/04/2022 20:13

Nope I wouldn't have moved either. Want to sit together then pay simple! Likewise if it's someone with a thousands kids who wants the whole plane to move to accommodate them.....it's a no from me!

grapewines · 18/04/2022 20:07

You value money and the entitlements it gives you more than a stranger's child's feelings

I can't get over the fact that someone said this in all seriousness. Of course I do. If her parent can't be bothered about her feelings, then why the hell should strangers on a flight? Staggering entitlement from the parent.

bctf123 · 18/04/2022 20:04

I was in a hotel a while back and my roommate decided his friend could kip on the floor for the final night. Hed booked the flights and kipped on other peoples till theyd left. Cant stand it even if the mgmt were too polite to say no. Take ownership for your costs and dont expect others to. You dont know their sit. She was unr.

HerbertChops · 18/04/2022 20:04

YANBU I wouldn’t have moved either. Every single time my DH gets on a plane there’s someone already sitting in his seat. We always tell them to move to their own seat. There can be a single person on the whole plane and they’ll be in his seat. He’s really unlucky!!

Last time it was a woman sitting in his aisle seat, we had the 3 seats across the aisle and that one, so four in a row. She wanted him to sit in her middle seat. I said no, we were a group, we booked those seats so I was with the kids and he was on the other aisle to help out and take kids when they needed the loo. She said she wanted to sit there as it was easier for her to get to the loo. I told her she should have booked it then. She did move to her middle seat then. DH misheard and thought she needed the loo so kept telling her to go as the loos were open, he even got a passing stewardess to take her. I think she regretted sitting in his seat.

jimmyjammy001 · 18/04/2022 20:00

She would of had the same option as you to pay for pre booked seats when booking, it's 100% her fault for not booking and very cheeky to ask you

cherish123 · 18/04/2022 20:00

YANBU

Kitkat151 · 18/04/2022 19:59

@Fruby

Really surprised about peoples feeling on this. I would have swapped and wouldn’t have minded in the slightest. Just doesn’t seem that much of an inconvenience or that much expense.

Maybe the mum doesn’t travel often and didn’t realise you could pay for seats together, or didn’t realise some people has paid for seats. As a frequent traveller even I have missed that page when booking flights before.

I will definitely think twice before asking someone if they’re happy to switch seats again, never occurred to me people would have such strong feelings. If there is a more practical arrangement for all travellers as a group I’d always be happy to switch it up.

I think it’s extremely rude to ask another passenger to switch…it’s not like being on the train where all reservations are free….I always pay for my seats…I am extremely particular about where I sit….I imagine many other People are too and have paid to ensure they sit where they want to….then some CF asked to swap?? 🙄 …..absolutely no way
SecretVictoria · 18/04/2022 19:55

So pay the charge then @Crimesean.

Kitkat151 · 18/04/2022 19:54

@Mamamia7962

I wouldn't have moved either.
Neither would I….I don’t like flying and panic if not next to my DP so always book seats
SecretVictoria · 18/04/2022 19:54

YANBU, no way would I ever move. Unless the person requesting offered me treble what I’d paid in cash. My SIL on DH’s side is like this, moans about paying - so doesn’t and then moans when her party are seated separately 🙄.

We pay a lot for our flights and accept that paying for being seated together is part of the cost.

Crimesean · 18/04/2022 19:48

@Phos

YANBU. Tui clearly state that a child may be placed in front of, behind or across the aisle from their parent.
Yes, which as a parent I'd not be happy with - what it there was severe turbulence? I'd hate to have my child scared and alone on a flight - a crash is incredibly unlikely, but turbulence is pretty common.
Swipe left for the next trending thread