Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking someone to move seats on a flight? Aibu ?

816 replies

wearejustfriends · 18/04/2022 14:31

Last week I was travelling to Gran Canaria with TUI.
I had booked mine and boyfriends seats when we booked and paid £22 for both.
I had the window and he had the middle.

A lady sat on the end and her daughter was in front.
She asked could they have our two seats and we have hers /daughters or my boyfriend switch with her daughter.
I politely said no.
Which she wasn't happy about.
We got "what difference does it make"
"Your adults,my daughter is sacred of flying and is a minor"

Anyway we wouldn't move.

Was I in the wrong ?
Surely if she was that bothered she could have paid like us.

OP posts:
SoggyPaper · 19/04/2022 07:29

@HoppingPavlova

This really is the fault of scummy airlines who could easily change their seat allocation algorithm so no child is left to sit alone. Regardless of how cheap/useless their parents are, this sort of situation is not fair on kids and not fair on the unrelated passengers who end up next to them for hours on end.

I think what would be more feasible is them just increasing the base cost and this including seat selection. If you can’t get seats to your liking then get on another flight that hasn’t filled up and has lots of options.

People need to shift their mindset. Instead of thinking (for example), ‘my ticket is 200 and seat selection is 20 so I won’t bother with seat selection’, it needs to be ‘my ticket is 220 and as part of that I get to pick a flight/seat I’m happy with’.

It would be increasing the base cost. And then people wouldn’t be happy because they couldn’t opt out and ‘save’ money.
SoggyPaper · 19/04/2022 07:27

@whumpthereitis

The fact you think a young child should be left of their own because a parent doesn't have an extra £20pp or doesn't even know there's a seat-choosing service available is weird AF. Train companies manage to allocate everyone a seat when they book all by themselves.

Ah, ‘think of the children’. No. That’s one’s on the parents.

It’s weirder to think that your problems are anyone else’s to solve. If I’ve paid to select a seat then I’m not moving because someone else has failed to do so. Complainers are more than welcome to sit, seethe, and cope with it.

There’s also the issue that, if your budget cannot stretch to an extra £100 to ensure you are sitting with your scared of flying child there and back, then you probably can’t afford the holiday in the first place.

An Easter holiday in Gran Canaria isn’t a basic human need. Just because a family has decided to cut corners in flight bookings, doesn’t mean other people have a responsibility to ensure they get what they wanted anyway.

This is not charity territory. It’s always already in the luxury lifestyle choices category - however ‘cheap and cheerful’ the package booked.

I couldn’t afford to go on holiday for years. So I didn’t go on holiday. We visited family instead or did loc things. Neither me nor my kids are scarred from the experience. Foreign holidays aren’t a human right or even a need.

TwoShades1 · 19/04/2022 07:02

I can be a bit nervous and I always pay to choose my seat as it helps me feel a bit better. Totally fine to not move of you have paid and she hasn’t. If specific seats were a priority she would have budgeted for that in her holiday planning.

SD1978 · 19/04/2022 06:39

I'f you're not willing to pay the extra amount, you can't, even with kids, expect everyone else to accomodate you- you did nothing wrong. You paid extra to ensure sitting together- she assumed that everyone would juts roll over because she had a child with her. Not your fault and I wouldn't have moved either if id paid ti sit with someone.

BeerLoas · 19/04/2022 06:37

You’d have to be living under a rock or have not read ANY details on the web or gazillion emails you get sent before a flight to not know how seating works these days. Very much doubt they booked on the phone and no one told them, upselling opportunity missed and frankly they’d be the only people alive to speak to a real TUI member of staff - it’s like the Wonky Factory.

HoppingPavlova · 19/04/2022 06:34

This really is the fault of scummy airlines who could easily change their seat allocation algorithm so no child is left to sit alone. Regardless of how cheap/useless their parents are, this sort of situation is not fair on kids and not fair on the unrelated passengers who end up next to them for hours on end.

I think what would be more feasible is them just increasing the base cost and this including seat selection. If you can’t get seats to your liking then get on another flight that hasn’t filled up and has lots of options.

People need to shift their mindset. Instead of thinking (for example), ‘my ticket is 200 and seat selection is 20 so I won’t bother with seat selection’, it needs to be ‘my ticket is 220 and as part of that I get to pick a flight/seat I’m happy with’.

newname12345 · 19/04/2022 06:27

@DailySheetWasher

This really is the fault of scummy airlines who could easily change their seat allocation algorithm so no child is left to sit alone. Regardless of how cheap/useless their parents are, this sort of situation is not fair on kids and not fair on the unrelated passengers who end up next to them for hours on end.
In general their seat allocations algorithm will put children next to their accompanying adults. We haven't always paid and DS has never not been next to at least one of us.

But its not always possible - if large numbers of passengers pay to reserve seats there might not be enough pairs of seats next to each other available for those who did not pay. Definitely looked the case on the TUI flights we did last week. Do you suggest the airlines start moving the customers who did pay? Its possible that customers have selected seats to sit near people on separate bookings.

pictish · 19/04/2022 05:29

She can ask and you can say no. The problem here is that she wasn’t prepared to accept a no. She thought it was a case of she can ask and you’ll do as you’re told.

I wouldn’t have moved.

NurseBernard · 19/04/2022 05:29

@wearejustfriends

Also I told her I had paid for seats. Her response was "what difference does it make"
Obviously a lot of difference, otherwise she’d have paid.

Also, does she really think that line of belligerent, entitled thinking is going to sweet talk you?

Scottishskifun · 19/04/2022 04:40

I wouldn't have moved either!

We did have a random one of a seat generator trying to sit us as a family on 3 separate aisle seats as this considered them close together except my DS was 2! But we spoke to the airline who managed to override and put us together.

DailySheetWasher · 19/04/2022 04:40

This really is the fault of scummy airlines who could easily change their seat allocation algorithm so no child is left to sit alone. Regardless of how cheap/useless their parents are, this sort of situation is not fair on kids and not fair on the unrelated passengers who end up next to them for hours on end.

Maskless · 19/04/2022 04:39

If you and your boyfriend are on a tight budget you could have asked her for £50 to swap. It's only a matter of sitting apart for under 2 hours out of an entire holiday, and you'd have had £50 to spend on your hols.

I doubt she would have paid, though; she was just a chancer.

returntoUK · 19/04/2022 04:38

@girlmom21

The fact you think a young child should be left of their own because a parent doesn't have an extra £20pp or doesn't even know there's a seat-choosing service available is weird AF. Train companies manage to allocate everyone a seat when they book all by themselves.

She was probably a changer, given her crappy response to OP.

WildCoasts · 19/04/2022 04:24

I wouldn't for any reason. I pay extra to select seats so I make sure I am travelling with my companions. If I was asked to move, even for a young child, I would say no. One of my regular companions has special needs and I have to sit next to them. To an outsider it's just two adults travelling together. I don't owe them an explanation as to the reason I need to stay with my companion either. Their medical details are none of anyone's business. I'd say no, nicely. If they can't accept I have my reasons for saying no, their problem. They can be organised like me and book seats together in advance.

whumpthereitis · 19/04/2022 04:24

The fact you think a young child should be left of their own because a parent doesn't have an extra £20pp or doesn't even know there's a seat-choosing service available is weird AF. Train companies manage to allocate everyone a seat when they book all by themselves.

Ah, ‘think of the children’. No. That’s one’s on the parents.

It’s weirder to think that your problems are anyone else’s to solve. If I’ve paid to select a seat then I’m not moving because someone else has failed to do so. Complainers are more than welcome to sit, seethe, and cope with it.

RustyShackleford3 · 19/04/2022 03:56

I don't think it was wrong of her to ask, politely. It certainly wasn't wrong for you to refuse. She should have politely accepted that you didn't want to give up your seats and left it there. She is not entitled to somebody else's seat just because she has a child who is scared of flying.

My children are young and are scared of flying. I wouldn't dream of booking plane tickets without being certain that they could sit with me. I can't believe that someone would be that stupid. I think the only thing that makes sense is that she didn't fancy paying the extra money, and assumed that she could pressure someone else into giving away their seat.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 19/04/2022 03:54

I wouldn't have moved and I wouldn't have felt one bit guilty about it. This 'be kind' bollocks is a load of old toot IMO, they should have paid for their own seats if it was that important to them/

avamiah · 19/04/2022 03:40

@expat101

I don't think you are allowed to swap seats once on board..
As long as the onboard crew have agreed it and everybody is happy then there usually isn’t a problem .
Rainbowqueeen · 19/04/2022 03:36

What kind of parent knows that their child is scared of flying and needs their parent next to them but doesn’t book the appropriate seats. Yes there is a cost but that’s just part of parenting.

You were completely with your rights and she was wrong

expat101 · 19/04/2022 03:26

I don't think you are allowed to swap seats once on board..

avamiah · 19/04/2022 03:10

Yes why would you move seats on a flight to be seated away from the person you are travelling with and have paid extra to be seated together.

I’m sorry but the issue is with the airline only.

Selmaselma · 19/04/2022 03:02

I would have referred them to the crew to deal with their issues. I have moved seats before but only when equivalent to the one i had (e.g. window seat in a different row).

avamiah · 19/04/2022 02:43

@HoppingPavlova

I've always understood that it was a legal requirement for children (under 12?) to sit with a parent / carer, so we never paid for it when our DC were younger. I wasn't willing to pay for something the airlines required to provide

As has been pointed out numerous times, airlines definitions of ‘sitting with’ does not exclusively mean sitting next to each other. It can mean sitting across an aisle from, sitting in front of or sitting behind. If you want to be assured of sitting NEXT to a child/children, you need to pay.

Yes your Right

It’s Ridiculous but they get away with it unless you pay for seats next to each other and know the seat numbers.

HoppingPavlova · 19/04/2022 02:37

I've always understood that it was a legal requirement for children (under 12?) to sit with a parent / carer, so we never paid for it when our DC were younger. I wasn't willing to pay for something the airlines required to provide

As has been pointed out numerous times, airlines definitions of ‘sitting with’ does not exclusively mean sitting next to each other. It can mean sitting across an aisle from, sitting in front of or sitting behind. If you want to be assured of sitting NEXT to a child/children, you need to pay.

avamiah · 19/04/2022 02:06

I hate situations like this to be honest but would always ask the onboard airline staff first if there was anything they could do.

I personally would of said No as I would want to be sat next to my partner if I had paid for us to sit together.

Why should we sit apart?

The complaint is with the airline not OP .

Swipe left for the next trending thread