Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking someone to move seats on a flight? Aibu ?

816 replies

wearejustfriends · 18/04/2022 14:31

Last week I was travelling to Gran Canaria with TUI.
I had booked mine and boyfriends seats when we booked and paid £22 for both.
I had the window and he had the middle.

A lady sat on the end and her daughter was in front.
She asked could they have our two seats and we have hers /daughters or my boyfriend switch with her daughter.
I politely said no.
Which she wasn't happy about.
We got "what difference does it make"
"Your adults,my daughter is sacred of flying and is a minor"

Anyway we wouldn't move.

Was I in the wrong ?
Surely if she was that bothered she could have paid like us.

OP posts:
TrashyPanda · 19/04/2022 11:57

Just doesn’t seem that much of an inconvenience or that much expense

So you can afford to throw away £44 and have no issues doing so, as it’s only a minor inconvenience to you.
Why presume everyone can be as profligate?

mrsmolks · 19/04/2022 11:54

I had this. Paid for two seats - when i got there someone else was sat in them. She said ive got young kids and i said i understand that but i have paid for these seats because i want to sit it them. She called me a cunt

MarshaBradyo · 19/04/2022 11:52

@Blossomtoes

Well I’m going to get on my flights feeling insufferably smug as we settle into our seats side by side and contemplate all those people who have paid for something I got for nothing. 😉
Up to you but yes people can always get this if they take a chance

Others will want to be sure they get seats together

I’d still keep it as it is so people opting out get lower ticket price

Quincythequince · 19/04/2022 11:49

What is the flight never gets full?
What if the day before flying there are still 20 seats left? Do you not allow people to pay for their chosen seat allocation, in case three families book?

Don’t be ridiculous re allocating families first.

Airlines are businesses and there to make money.

Quincythequince · 19/04/2022 11:48

@Blossomtoes

Well I’m going to get on my flights feeling insufferably smug as we settle into our seats side by side and contemplate all those people who have paid for something I got for nothing. 😉
That won’t happen on every flight you are on. Not sure how often you fly, but certain routes, you would need to pre-book to guarantee.

I don’t bother for short local ones, but for long haul I always do.

ilovesooty · 19/04/2022 11:43

I actually told my travelling companion at the time I'd have paid not to be sitting next to them! Grin

Blossomtoes · 19/04/2022 11:40

Well I’m going to get on my flights feeling insufferably smug as we settle into our seats side by side and contemplate all those people who have paid for something I got for nothing. 😉

ilovesooty · 19/04/2022 11:37

I already have to pay single supplement for all sorts of things or have my choices restricted by things only being available to couples or families. I'm not keen on subsidising or being inconvenienced by family seating requirements on planes as well.

ilovesooty · 19/04/2022 11:34

Exactly. The extras are clear. I don't want the requirements of families absorbed into the base cost which would undoubtedly rise for single travellers like me.

MarshaBradyo · 19/04/2022 11:32

@Blossomtoes

Are you suggesting under 12s don’t pay? Yes

Because if you lose that price of the tickets will rise Lots of people don’t pay - ilovesooty and me for a start - are people like us causing a rise in ticket prices? No is the answer. The money you pay for seat selection is pure profit, especially when you can get adjacent seats for nothing.

No that’s not correct

A proportion of people currently do pay and that is reflected in overall price of the tickets

Have you noticed how much ticket prices have decreased over the last number of years?

This is due to the selection model - ie base rate is very low with extras on top

The airline industry is now very price sensitive - ie people use sites to get the cheapest

You could change it back to the old model and include it but prices will go up for everyone.

AryaStarkWolf · 19/04/2022 11:31

@wearejustfriends

Also I told her I had paid for seats. Her response was "what difference does it make"
If it made no difference why didn't she pay so she could sit next to her kid? She didn't pay because she was stingy and thought she'd be able to shame someone into moving seats with her. YANBU and even if you weren't a nervous flyer you wouldn't be
ilovesooty · 19/04/2022 11:29

I didn't pay for seat allocation with a companion on those Jet2 flights.

I usually choose and pay extra for my preferred seat from an almost empty flight as soon as the flight is available. I don't want to book my preferred seat later on after the airline has allocated family blocks. If parents want to sit next to their children and be assured of that then they should pay.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 19/04/2022 11:28

People value different seats differently... aisle vs window vs middle. Front vs back. Near emergency exits. Others just want to sit next to their companions. For some just across an aisle is completely acceptable as together (I've flown on smaller planes where its two seats either side of aisle with my two children. I had to sit across the aisle from one or both of them... I was a foot further away. It wasn't a big deal really!)

You either have prebooking or they let a computer decide with no one expressing a preference to get the best algorithm. Or go back to seats being allocated as you check in and the last few groups being scattered, even if its toddler triplets and a single mother or a group of 80yos.

TheBatKeeper · 19/04/2022 11:26

The fact you think a young child should be left of their own because a parent doesn't have an extra £20pp or doesn't even know there's a seat-choosing service available is weird AF. Train companies manage to allocate everyone a seat when they book all by themselves.

One presumes that when they reached their destination they weren't sleeping on the beach, so a bit extra to ensure seats together is hardly rocket science. Now is it.

Coffeeholix · 19/04/2022 11:24

YANBU. When I’ve flown with young children (my youngest was always anxious on a flight) I’ve always paid to ensure we have seats together, so she should have done that if her daughter was truly scared.

Blossomtoes · 19/04/2022 11:23

Are you suggesting under 12s don’t pay? Yes

Because if you lose that price of the tickets will rise Lots of people don’t pay - ilovesooty and me for a start - are people like us causing a rise in ticket prices? No is the answer. The money you pay for seat selection is pure profit, especially when you can get adjacent seats for nothing.

FairyCakeWings · 19/04/2022 11:20

No, I’m saying don’t open seat selection until the flight is full, then allocate families before it’s open. Then you can choose and pay for your seat. They have data to show which seats are most popular and not allocate those to families.

Why would they allocate the seats that are the least popular to the families that are getting to sit together for free? That would mean that the people who want to pay to choose a decent seat have fewer, shittier options.

Airlines already try and sit families near each other, the only problem is that that isn’t good enough for some families because they want to be right next to each other, so there’s nothing wrong with asking them to pay for that.

Also, what would sitting families together really mean? Would two adults travelling with one child all get to stay together for free because they are a family, or would it be just one adult with the child? What about in larger families with more children? You could end up with one parent and two children at the front of the plane and one parent with one child at the back of the plane, but what if that family would have preferred to pay to all be in one or two rows together?

The airlines do it the way they do it now because it’s what works best for them and their customers.

ilovesooty · 19/04/2022 11:13

I don't think it's necessarily a con. I've flown with a companion on Jet2 and often we've not been allocated seats next to one another - we weren't sufficiently bothered to pay the extra.

MarshaBradyo · 19/04/2022 11:13

Sway - seat

MarshaBradyo · 19/04/2022 11:12

@Blossomtoes

So you penalise those of us without children, great

How are you being penalised because a few seats aren’t available? You’re in the same position as if a few other people got to the seat selection before you.

I think my experience illustrates that paying for seat selection is a con.

Are you suggesting under 12s don’t pay?

Because if you lose that price of the tickets will rise

Plus the extra hassle to everyone to wait and check emails to do sway allocation later - plus extra cost to do this on airline side

Tickets are very cheap atm for some because of the fast booking and selection

If you think it’s a con don’t spend the extra

Blossomtoes · 19/04/2022 11:11

If the airline starts preallocating seats to families no doubt that will cause the base rate to rise

People who refuse to pay to choose their seat hasn’t caused the base to rise.

Blossomtoes · 19/04/2022 11:10

So you penalise those of us without children, great

How are you being penalised because a few seats aren’t available? You’re in the same position as if a few other people got to the seat selection before you.

I think my experience illustrates that paying for seat selection is a con.

ilovesooty · 19/04/2022 11:08

I want to book my seat when the bookings open for the flight.

If it's a very short flight I'm happy to sit wherever I'm allocated.

If people have children and want to be assured of sitting right next to them as opposed to near them they should pay for that assurance. If the airline starts preallocating seats to families no doubt that will cause the base rate to rise. If people want extras they need to pay.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 19/04/2022 11:05

No, I’m saying don’t open seat selection until the flight is full, then allocate families before it’s open. Then you can choose and pay for your seat. They have data to show which seats are most popular and not allocate those to families.

So you penalise those of us without children, great.

I'm a nervous flier and pay to make sure I'm sitting next to DH. If I couldn't guarantee that then I wouldn't fly long haul. What happens then, do I get the cost of my flight refunded?

Blossomtoes · 19/04/2022 11:00

Are you saying that nobody should be able to book a seat ever then

No, I’m saying don’t open seat selection until the flight is full, then allocate families before it’s open. Then you can choose and pay for your seat. They have data to show which seats are most popular and not allocate those to families.

Obviously no passengers who paid to choose their seats wanted 18 E and F on our flight so we got them for nothing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread