Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Conviction

59 replies

Malibooo · 18/04/2022 12:05

Hi everyone. This is my first time posting. I will try and summarise as clearly as I can. I would value your advice.
I left home at 16. I slept in bus stops, empty flats and on people's couches. Some of these people weren't very nice to me.

I eventually got a flat of my own. Again, I was vulnerable to certain people. One night I burnt some letters and photos in my flat. (1985 I was 18) Causing some damage. I don't know what the police gleaned from the people around me but they did not want to prosecute. However, the CPS decided to prosecute. I was given two years probation.

I moved on. When I was 21 my husband died. I was 7 months pregnant. It was a very difficult time.

I remarried and was a victim of domestic abuse. I got divorced and then married my current husband. We have been together for 27 years. We have five children and 13cgrandchildren.

When I was 40 I went to university. Over the years I secured two degrees and a PGCE.
During this period of 24cyears. I worked in 2 schools successfully. Both schools knew of my conviction as did university as I had to explain the circumstances of conviction in front of a panel.

I was offered a job last year at my old school. I had worked there for 11 years. Three of those years with the current head. I only left to complete my PGCE (Biology) in 2018. I also did one of my placements there. I was so happy to be offered the job as a Science teacher.

I took my DBS and identification documents to the school. They were happy to see me. The head was isolating so I didn't get a chance to see him. The next day I received an email to inform me that the job was not going ahead. Too cut a long story short, he said he did not know about my conviction and would feel 'uncomfortable' employing me.
I was devastated. I am 56. I had finally come to terms with my past and had worked really hard. I very stupidly let this affect me and have been depressed and anxious. I barely leave the house. and have lost a lot of weight. His response made me feel so ashamed.
Should I be punished for the rest of my life?

There is a lot more to this in regards to how I was treated during my teenage years. I can't tell you how proud I was at the changes I made and in all I had achieved. I battled dyslexia and my own demons to make a success of my life. I now feel rubbish.
I don't want sympathy. I'm just curious, as to what other people think. Should I continue to have consequences for something that happened 36 years ago?

OP posts:
dropoutdoreen · 18/04/2022 15:24

the head is not a good person. Who is he to judge

Youve done amazingly well. Most schools would be proud to have you

Malibooo · 18/04/2022 15:15

Hi... Thank you for your reply. I always declare the conviction. I had been at that particular school for about 11 years. I had worked with the current head for the last three years of my employment there. I only left there in 2018 to do my PGCE..
I absolutely agree that they have to know about convictions as children's safety is the most important t thing. However, he said I was employed by the previous head and he knew nothing about my conviction.

I did confirm my conviction with his PA as the HT was isolating when I took my documents to the school. Unfortunately, he won't give me a chance to explain and that's his right.

OP posts:
Elleherd · 18/04/2022 15:15

I'm so sorry. I also have a crap childhood that left me with low chances in life and punished for life frankly for being an unwanted abused kid stupid enough to do what I was told and take a conviction for my legal guardian. The past is a foreign country, but some of us are forced to have a foot chained to it.
Please remember there are so many women of that era in similar situations and every so often one of them gets smacked down by it. Today it's you, but it won't always be.

Probably not a route you want to go down, but if he employed you happily enough before, isn't there a question of lack of 'due diligence' somewhere in all this? Is that what's bothering him?

You've done incredibly well to turn your life around so well, and don't need to be ashamed. Your feelings are something about internalized shame but you probably know all that.
Please hold your head high, this is a blip in your adult career, not a cul de sac.
This headmaster has clearly used it to not employ you for whatever reason. But the person who is going to punish you for your past, is yourself if you allow yourself to. Please don't.

Take a deep breathe and move forward. I don't know how exactly you market it, but your lived experiences would make you an excellent form teacher and far better at pastoral care than the majority of 23 to 25 year olds with their freshly printed PGCE's.

mrziggycoco · 18/04/2022 15:01

Wow, what you've achieved in life is absolutely amazing. Well done. You also have got yourself a good education and prospects all on your own despite the discrimination you have faced because of a silly mistake.

Absolutely commendable and brilliant. So impressive.

I'm not sure what remedy you can employ except to keep applying and keep being honest? Do you put a letter alongside your applications explaining your conviction? This is what's advised by penal reform charities and those which help those with convictions secure work.

What a fantastic model you are for your children. And what a survivor you are.

Of course you shouldn't be "double punished".

FOJN · 18/04/2022 13:50

There are certain things that will always show up on enhanced DBS records

There are also some jobs which are exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act which means you will always be required to declare any conviction, no matter how long ago.

Rememberallball · 18/04/2022 13:38

@Realitea

I thought after a certain amount of time it no longer showed on your DBS?
There are certain things that will always show up on enhanced DBS records
BreakinbadBreakineven · 18/04/2022 13:15

It may be worth having a look here www.gov.uk/government/publications/dbs-filtering-guidance/dbs-filtering-guide to see if your conviction could be filtered in which case you may not need to declare it even for an enhanced DBS. When you apply for jobs are you writing a little disclosure letter emphasising the time past since the offence, situation then and situation now? Really sorry this has happened to you.

Malibooo · 18/04/2022 13:13

Hi... Although I had worked at this particular school for 11 years I had only worked with the current head for 3 years. The previous head employed me. I had a meeting with her regarding the conviction.
When I did my PGCE I had a panel meeting with 7 of the university staff to explain my conviction. I have no problem with doing this as the pupils safety is a priority and of course they have to ask. However, this head won't even let me explain. I had a very good working relationship with him before all of this.

OP posts:
65honeybee · 18/04/2022 13:09

I have sympathy with the OP; it sounds like she has very successfully turned her life around and I hope she is able to find a teaching position.

Equally, I really disagree with the posts labelling the head an 'arsehole' 'dickhead' etc. Heading up a school is a damn hard enough job as it is, god knows it's not a job I envy, and it's understandable that on an individual basis, knowing their school, parent body etc, they may decide it's not right to take on someone with a serious conviction (which arson is) as a teacher. As a PP said, imagine the field day if the daily Mail or similar got hold of this information, or if some parents found out. It's not reasonable to expect every employer to be prepared to take that risk.

I know with the local lad I mentioned, his parents were gutted about the potential impact on his future. He's a very normal nice lad and from a nice family and he just did something stupid, setting fire to a few rubbish objects as a bit of a 'laugh.' He's now got a serious conviction but it's understandable in that if the fire hadn't been quickly put out, if it has spread and someone had been injured or worse, everyone would be baying for his blood.

So all in all I wish the best OP and I hope you're successful in getting a teaching job; this isn't the end of the world, just chalk it up to experience and keep applying

catgirl1976 · 18/04/2022 13:02

One big no no for us that really marks people down on a risk assessment is if they haven't declared the conviction so do be upfront about it.

winewolfhowls · 18/04/2022 13:01

I suspect the head had looked at the finances for next year and would rather employ a cheaper teacher,your conviction was the excuse to not employ you

Ridingonthewaves · 18/04/2022 12:58

Arson will never be filtered out, it’s on a list of offences that will not be filtered.

I have every sympathy with the OP - what really is very strange though is that the HT was unaware of the conviction previously, despite her working in the school.

catgirl1976 · 18/04/2022 12:58

I work in HR in education. When things come up on a DBS check we look at a number of things such as how long ago the conviction was, is there a pattern of offending, the nature of the offence, any mitigating circumstances etc. obviously a lot of things will be a flat out refusal to employ but in your case the offence is so long ago, it was a one off, you’ve worked in education since, the nature of the offence isn’t one that necessarily makes you a risk and so on that I think we would still offer you a role. I’d go back and see if you can speak to the Head or ask them to do a risk assessment and hear your mitigation. They may change their minds but even if they don’t a lot of places would have a more sensible approach so try not to get down hearted.

Toasty280 · 18/04/2022 12:54

Most places would put a risk assessment in place with the facts that you haven't set anything on fire for 30+ years, no criminal convictions in that time, have been employed and well thought of since...
Did you put on your application form that you had a criminal conviction?

ChateauMargaux · 18/04/2022 12:54

If it's any consolation OP, at our school, the board is in dispute with some of the teachers on a number of issues and a quite a large number of the parents have come out in support of the teachers, standing squarely by their side. I would stand with you and I would not be alone.

LadyLu55 · 18/04/2022 12:53

This should have been filtered out, which means that it would not appear on an enhanced DBS. Contact an organisation called 'Unlock' for further advice or click on this link. The law changed in 2013, so that certain convictions (depending on factors such as the type of crime, age when convicted, sentence imposed) are not disclosed by an enhanced DBS. Your conviction, unless there is more to it, should not have appeared.

unlock.org.uk/advice/filtering-cautions-convictions/

ChateauMargaux · 18/04/2022 12:52

@SarkyMarky... I hope there would be more outrage at a child who was let down by the systems that are supposed to be there to protect vulnerable people, at the penal system which punishes women more harshly than it punishes men and an employment vetting system that fails to distinguish between people who do pose a risk to society and those who don't.

ChateauMargaux · 18/04/2022 12:49

You were let down by the adults around you and then by the police. I am sorrow. You have managed to rebuild your life from shaky foundations, you are an inspiration. I am sorry that you are now in this situation.

You do not deserve to be punished for the rest of your life. Please reach out for support for your depression and anxiety. These are understandable consequences to the things that have happened to you and the situation you find yourself in now, but you do not need to carry on suffering. Help is available (even if you need to pay for it privately) and I am sure you have friends who would happily support you.

You could write a testimonial to the head teacher and ask him to consider asking the advice of the school board or LEA, taking into account the circumstances surrounding your conviction and your evidence of upstanding character in the intervening time. Perhaps an employment lawyer might help draft something (I might be off base there).

You could also reach out to other people who have worked with you, your university college tutor, placement supervisors and ask for advice on how to approach future job applications. Perhaps, an upfront, post first interview statement with additional character references, giving the background to the conviction before the potential decision maker sees the results of the enhanced DBS might help smooth the way... but do ask for advice about this ... are you in a union? Maybe they could advise?

And again... you are amazing!! Hug your husband, call your kids, facetime your grandchildren. Remember all that you have become and use their love to give you strength to get past this.

Malibooo · 18/04/2022 12:42

Hi Markymark. Do you mean there would be outrage if I got a job in the school?

OP posts:
Sarkymarky · 18/04/2022 12:37

OP no I do not think this should follow you for 37 years. But I can imagine if the parents, pupils, LA the Daily Mail got hold of this there would be public outrage. As pp have said there are other schools good luck OP hope you find a great job xx

Malibooo · 18/04/2022 12:28

Hi.... It will always be on an enhanced DBS. I absolutely understand this.

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 18/04/2022 12:28

That's ridiculous, OP, and says far more about that HT than it does about you. You have done amazingly well despite the difficult start that you had in life.

A part of me wants to say that you should push back on this. Explain the circumstances of your conviction and push them to look beyond it. On the other hand, I wonder if life is just too short to be dealing with narrow-minded fuckwits like that.

Life isn't always neat and smooth and perfect for people, and it takes real courage and character to overcome the many obstacles that you have faced. I for one would be delighted to have someone like you teaching my dd. I'll bet you would be one of the first in line to help those kids who were struggling with difficult stuff going on at home as well.

65honeybee · 18/04/2022 12:27

A lad in our local neighbourhood stupidly set fire to some objects in a garage a while back. It was a thoughtless, reckless action but thankfully there was minimal damage as the fire was quickly extinguished. However, he was charged with 'arson with intent to endanger life' which I gather isn't unusual if a fire is deliberately started where it could spread and endanger others.

So, I wonder whether it's a similar case here. The charge and conviction sounds terrible though I can see from your perspective it was a case of you burning a few items.

It's a tricky one, because inevitably some employers will be reluctant to take someone on when there are factors which could go against them, particularly when all things be equal, they have other candidates with a clear DBS

I think you have to brush it off - that's one employer, there will be others and it's clear that in other roles in school your DBS has not been a barrier.

FieryPitOfMordor · 18/04/2022 12:21

I think it’s the school’s loss. You’ll find a better teaching job.

I think most employers would look past a single, old, non-custodial sentence given to someone who was barely an adult. Most people realise that others grow and mature. If that particular headteacher doesn’t, I’m not sure what kind of a leader he is.

Malbecfan · 18/04/2022 12:18

Hopefully you dodged a bullet. There are loads of dick Heads around - I have worked for some of them. You have done an amazing job and science teachers are always in demand.

Keep applying but perhaps next time you apply for a position, ask to speak to a member of SLT before you put in your application to explain. I know you shouldn't have to, but it is often better to be upfront about things like this. Wishing you the very best of luck with finding the dream job.