Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel despondent about feminism

822 replies

2TheLighthouse · 18/04/2022 09:20

I’m almost envious of those women who confidently state that they’re not feminists, because presumably they don’t see much wrong with the state of male/female equality. I, on the other hand, am furious about so many things affecting girls and women that it can get a bit overwhelming.

For example, I watched that Jimmy Savile documentary the other day. It’s absolutely clear as day to me that what happened is what always happens: powerful rich man gets what he wants. Other men shield him. All the wide-eyed disbelief after the event is just total bullshit. Why were people surprised? This is what powerful men and powerful institutions have done forever . Sometimes men are the victims, but more often than not, it’s girls and women who a) suffer and b) know with a deep certainty that they won’t be believed.

Don’t get me wrong- I know there are lots of good men. But girls and women are still at such a colossal disadvantage after centuries of oppression that I find it hard to believe that some women are ok with the way things are. The only way to combat this is to continue the feminist cause - but society has played an absolute blinder on the word ‘feminist’ so that many women believe it to be some sort of weird extremism.

It would be odd, surely, if hardly more than 100 years after getting the vote, following millennia of being officially second-class citizens, women had successfully climbed up to the same status as men in society. Of course they couldn’t undo all that bullshit in one century. Especially with all the pushback.

Off the top of my head, the things that make me furious on a regular basis, in no particular order:

  • the leaking of sickening violent, misogynistic porn into mainstream society, so that classes of 15 year olds snigger at the word ‘choke’ (Yes, I’m a teacher)
  • the constant unofficial policing of what women and girls can and can’t wear while men can walk around topless as soon as the sun shines because the baseline assumption is that women’s bodies are ‘sexual’ and men’s aren’t
  • the way female characters always have to be attractive (real and cartoon) when their male counterparts can be as ugly as you like
  • the horror show that is female healthcare, with particular reference to the ‘just get on with it’ school of thought in maternity care, when women have had major surgery etc
  • the casual contempt shown by boys towards girls they find unattractive; the assumption that shared space is boys’ space to dominate, either vocally or physically, with the kicking of footballs.
  • incels
  • the persistence of the sex trade and the loud defence of it by otherwise sensible people
  • the bending over backwards to accommodate male sexual kinks

As I said, it’s bonkers to expect millennia of sexism to be undone in a century or so. But what’s disheartening is not that there’s still a way to go, but that so many people literally cannot see that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2022 22:01

On the subject of STEM and that tedious gotcha cartoon, I just listened to this great interview with Gaye Chapman. I knew about AfterEllen and Chapman's campaigning on behalf of women and especially lesbians but I didn't know about her work as an elecrician - she's a Senior Electrical Inspector for City of LA. She describes very well the problems women face in this industry, even at her level.

thedancingbear · 02/05/2022 21:53

No. But you had the energy in your fingers to call out someone for being "nasty". Priorities, innit.

Yes, actually.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 21:48

Did you read that link and comment? Did you speak a word of condemnation?

I'll place it again: female prisoners forced to share showers with intact males

No. But you had the energy in your fingers to call out someone for being "nasty". Priorities, innit.

I am very pro-welfare of trans men, especially that they are not placed in men's prison, so no, not "anti-trans". And especially young female transitioners with autism, because it's a subject I know a lot about. I am insisting on carrying on breathing while being female, so I will be classified as "anti-trans" though. Only some people get to be "who they say they are".

thedancingbear · 02/05/2022 21:40

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 21:32

Strangely, after the "face like a slapped arse" and oh, what was it, all the rape threats from trans activists, and all the activists condoning incarcerated women being raped, that doesn't even register with me as nasty.

If that is "pointless and nasty", I've been entirely desensitised to it. Regrettable. I think the only answer is for trans activists to shift the window of acceptable discourse back, by clamping down on rape threats from their own side and speaking out against women being expected to share space with convicted rapists.

Can you get on that, so I can become a more sensitive person again?

The TRAs you're talking about are scumbags. If I see it, I'll call it out.

I'll also call out transphobia when I see on here. I would expect you to too. Because you're not anti-trans, are you?

And I'm categorically not a trans activist. I agree with 90% of what is posted on here on the subject. But shitty comments aimed at trans people and not the related ideology do no-one favours.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 21:32

thedancingbear · 02/05/2022 19:07

Your faux feminism is as fake as a transwoman.

Pointless and nasty.

Strangely, after the "face like a slapped arse" and oh, what was it, all the rape threats from trans activists, and all the activists condoning incarcerated women being raped, that doesn't even register with me as nasty.

If that is "pointless and nasty", I've been entirely desensitised to it. Regrettable. I think the only answer is for trans activists to shift the window of acceptable discourse back, by clamping down on rape threats from their own side and speaking out against women being expected to share space with convicted rapists.

Can you get on that, so I can become a more sensitive person again?

Helleofabore · 02/05/2022 20:54

To be honest, if my child was unquestioning accepting of this type of belief, I would feel that I failed to teach them to do their own research and evaluation and to critically think it all though. We have taught them to never just take what someone says is a ‘fact’ as a fact without checking. Without going to original sources if possible.

And if they feel uncomfortable in a situation, get the fuck out. Don’t stick around because it is kind, or that that person says they are ‘allowed’ there.

Helleofabore · 02/05/2022 20:49

I took it as his daughters are even more unquestioning of males changing sex and accepting that those males are entitled to be treated as females for everything.

So, I took it that his daughters would accept a transitioned male as their ‘women’s officer’ at uni, or in their organisation, or in their political party and that that male would absolutely represent their best interest. (Despite us seeing the times this has happened, all that has happened is that women’s officer deplatforms women from speaking about or protesting about their needs if it involved their body etc. such as Bergdorf did and at the unis this has happened at). And that males should be included in female sport categories. And that if they are nominated for an award that was meant to acknowledge the effort that females have made to overcome negative sexist discrimination, a male who had at least had the opportunities offered up as a male until they transitioned would deserve to be included and even win that award… despite them having x number of years as a male.

I also took it that lunar and his daughters do not believe that females are still discriminated against from birth. As many of us mothers can attest still happens, despite plenty of effort and investment to prevent it. (Hence when Pp’s post a cartoon about STEM as a gotcha, we roll out eyes. YES! Fuck off. We know in detail why daughters are rejecting STEM. A fucking cartoon about it as some sort of gotcha fails to actually understand just as the poster who seems ignorant of the reasons)

I also guessed that those daughters, from the way he said it, would be very happy to have a male in their rape crisis group, their breastfeeding group, as the person taking their Pap smear, as the person looking after their own daughters (his grand daughters) at school or guide camp (where we know that a transitioned male can ‘check’ on the girls in the showers etc).

That is how I interpreted it. But I could be wrong. I mean, I asked a load of questions as did others, and was told that apparently lunar’s answers were covered in my post where I suggested what the answers ‘could have been’. And was told since the answer was covered, they wouldn’t engage further.

LangClegsInSpace · 02/05/2022 20:27

I don't understand Lunar's last post.

I will neither challenge trans men to share my space any more than I will challenge trans women to share your space.

Does he mean challenge in the sense of a dare? He won't dare trans men to share his space ...

Or does he mean 'who' instead of 'to'? He won't challenge trans men who share his space ...

For the record my daughters are feminists and I would say that my views align more with theirs than theirs with mine.

I've read this a few times now. He agrees with his daughters more than they agree with him?

Confused
VestofAbsurdity · 02/05/2022 20:20

Is feminism a brand then? Like Coca Cola?

Feminism is for and about females all females that's it.

thedancingbear · 02/05/2022 19:07

Your faux feminism is as fake as a transwoman.

Pointless and nasty.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 19:04

It completely alienates people when I tell them their occasional consumption of fish means they're not vegetarians, too.

WhichItAwe · 02/05/2022 18:59

If your daughters believe what you believe they're not really feminists. They're women who subscribe to a watered-down liberal creed that those of us who are older, and are really concerned about changing things for the better (indeed, who changed things for the better for your daughters) don't accept as feminism.

Interesting approach to uniting feminism. Telling a whole section of feminists that they can’t be feminists because they don’t agree with your brand of feminism seems like a sure way to competent alienate them.

Pluvia · 02/05/2022 18:25

Lunar27 · 02/05/2022 16:40

Pretty pointless if you've heard it all before @Helleofabore . All I'm going to say on the matter before signing off is that I will continue to give my respect and dignity to those (men and women) who identify as they have. I will neither challenge trans men to share my space any more than I will challenge trans women to share your space.

For the record my daughters are feminists and I would say that my views align more with theirs than theirs with mine. That might not go down well with you but is really not worthwhile going on about it given you're GC.

If your daughters believe what you believe they're not really feminists. They're women who subscribe to a watered-down liberal creed that those of us who are older, and are really concerned about changing things for the better (indeed, who have changed things for the better for your daughters) don't accept as feminism. They are like a contact of mine who works day-in, day-out, with female victims of violence and DV — and yet still insists that her refuge should be a place where men who self-ID as women can live. This is a kind of be-kind virtue-signalling bastard 'feminism' that centres men and not women. As far as I'm concerned no one who believes this should go unchallenged when they self-ID as feminists. Feminism has women as its focus, full stop. Your faux feminism is as fake as a transwoman.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 18:07

DomesticatedZombie · 02/05/2022 17:58

Oh, I'm sure it's not running away. Lunar was very happy to share lots of info on torque. I'm sure he will be back to explain all about how men's wishes matter more than women's.

Well, that's the crux of it.

That's what broke through the dissonance.

I think there should be zero abuse in prison, and that includes male prisoners. But we can tackle abuse in men's prisons without putting anyone male in women's prisons. We can set up facilities for trans people without compromising women's needs.

It's all very simple. Separate units for trans prisoners, and building regulations for new buildings/buildings undergoing renovation. You can even push to solve the issue without legal means- a major charity could run a Trans Friendly Scheme, in which businesses and public buildings would gain accreditation if they had a separate unisex single-occupancy toilet and changing room.

But for this to be pursued, it was necessary that people believed women's wishes mattered equally. It turns out they did not think that.

Helleofabore · 02/05/2022 18:00

Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky · 02/05/2022 17:39

Well colour me shocked that lunar has exited stage left with an air of saddened martyrdom because we’re all so meeeaann without actually answering any of the difficult questions

It is remarkable eyeballs to see it replay over and over. Like posters think they are so tolerant, so nice, so tolerant and so right. But can never answer the hard questions. Because either those answers would show that those posters are not pure enough or because they have reacted purely on an emotional level and not on an evidenced, fact based, and scientific basis and they understand this when they realise they cannot answer the questions honestly.

just like the English sports council and the IOC have admitted you cannot have fairness ‘and’ inclusion. You cannot have empathy for both males who transition ‘and’ females by ‘fully supporting’ those males unlimited access to female’s right.

It must be hard for people who view themselves as feminists to admit.

I mean, it was hard for the OIC to admit, or easy, they just put the onus on other organisations.

Once you see it though, you cannot unsee it.

DomesticatedZombie · 02/05/2022 17:58

Oh, I'm sure it's not running away. Lunar was very happy to share lots of info on torque. I'm sure he will be back to explain all about how men's wishes matter more than women's.

Theeyeballsinthefuckingsky · 02/05/2022 17:39

Well colour me shocked that lunar has exited stage left with an air of saddened martyrdom because we’re all so meeeaann without actually answering any of the difficult questions

Helleofabore · 02/05/2022 17:34

I know that until I saw the confirmation that was Maya Forstater's employers position of agreeing that Maya had some very valid points that were not 'transphobic', but there was absolutely no way that Maya could express those points that was not considered 'transphobic' that I thought people who 'respected trans people AND females' were able to have conversations.

Seeing this, 'I will continue to give my respect and dignity to those (men and women) who identify as they have. I will neither challenge trans men to share my space any more than I will challenge trans women to share your space.' is just another version of that clanging dissonance. But at least Lunar is honest. They cannot understand the feminist position, and nor can they ever have empathy for the women who suffer under the impacts of what Lunar believes in.

This is just the cherry though....

For the record my daughters are feminists and I would say that my views align more with theirs than theirs with mine. That might not go down well with you but is really not worthwhile going on about it given you're GC.

Because I hold a belief that is different to lunar (and have indicated that I am happy to have a discussion and provided some starter discussion points), I am considered not worthwhile to have that discussion.

Who said 'no debate' had started to disappear?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 17:27

DomesticatedZombie · 02/05/2022 17:21

I can only presume that's what happens, Helle. People shrink from cognitive dissonance. It IS uncomfortable.

Yes. It took me years to fully confront that my support of fashionable trans rights also meant supporting women's prisons to be less safe and supporting the violation of incarcerated women's human rights.

DomesticatedZombie · 02/05/2022 17:21

I can only presume that's what happens, Helle. People shrink from cognitive dissonance. It IS uncomfortable.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 17:17

I'm younger than Owen Jones, Jameela Jamil, Suzi Ruffell (trans activist comedian who got very upset by Nic Williams advocating for single-sex sport) and so on. I checked on wikipedia and everyfink.

Helleofabore · 02/05/2022 17:16

I also notice that lunar disengaged when the real life repercussions of that ‘it is too difficult’ gets posted. Women’s prisons, rape crisis centres and sports.

So, the poster gets to disengage with the knowledge that they personally don’t have to deal directly with it.

Helleofabore · 02/05/2022 17:11

promotion you were ‘in line’ for not online… autocorrect.

Helleofabore · 02/05/2022 17:08

i guess that is all we needed to know then Lunar. You cannot provide anything further than one of the arguments I posed as ones that we have heard, it tells us you are a man who is happy for women to have the words they need to use to describe themselves and activate for their needs redefined by others as a start.

yeah. You know, we also constantly here about the ‘younger generation’.

A) if you continue to listen, the ‘younger generation’ will start to tell you and your daughters that they are not happy with going along with this. Despite having best friends who are trans. Because they have started to see the impacts. Do you honestly think that Lia Thomas and Emily Bridges have not sped up the knowledge of what is at stake?

and B) so many of those type of feminists you disagree with were exactly like your daughters. Until we started to be aware of life’s realities. Like missing out on that promotion you were online for but that went to someone who couldn’t ever be pregnant. Like being terminated under loopholes when you are pregnant. Like finding out that conditions haven’t improved as much as you thought, that now females are now having to ‘budge’ over for males who, you are told, are more marginalised than you. That feeling of being ‘kind’ doesn’t actually last long when the reality starts to hit. Particularly when you have a girl guide and discover that GG now have adopted inclusive policies that ignores proper safeguarding and that women writing letters about it, suddenly get police visits or taken to court.

I am going to be very interested if your daughters all have the same attitudes in the next 10- 20 years.

But thanks for your honesty. What a pity though you didn’t try to answer any of the questions though. It would have been enlightening to see how you dealt with the dissonance of your own position.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 02/05/2022 17:05

While we are talking about beliefs.

Many women have beliefs that mean they cannot undress or wash in the presence of strangers of the opposite sex. Still more simply do not want to, to the point that they will self-exclude from public provision like swimming, NHS care rather than do so. Some of those self-excluding will be doing so because of PTSD from previous sexual abuse, which means they will be experiencing indirect discrimination on the grounds of disability, from state institutions.

I understand there are women who do not care about who undresses with them and that's fine.

But do they actually believe they need to be in proximity with strangers of the opposite sex while changing for swimming? Or need to be housed with a male cellmate in the event they are sentenced to prison? Because it seems to me that it's simply that they don't mind whether male strangers are there or not. So there isn't any conflict of rights at all.

We can have female-only facilities, and these will serve the needs of all women.