Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why marriages end?

115 replies

Dee314 · 18/04/2022 08:57

My DH said that most marriages end because one person in unfaithful? Surely there are other reasons?

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 18/04/2022 11:02

[quote RosesAndHellebores]@cocomarine I'm sorry my post came across that way - it wasn't my intention.[/quote]
Thank you.
In my experience directly of myself and friends, I’ve never come across someone who gave up too easily. Frankly I’ve more often seen the opposite - like a friend trying desperately to persuade her husband to go to counselling to stop him beating her 😢

clpsmum · 18/04/2022 10:59

Because people aren't happy in them

RosesAndHellebores · 18/04/2022 10:57

@cocomarine I'm sorry my post came across that way - it wasn't my intention.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/04/2022 10:56

My 1st marriage ended in my late 20s due to being married to a nice guy but wanted to carry on life as if he was still 21 and we had 2 children. Nights out with mates, going to football most weekends, popping down the pub after his dinner3 nights a week. Making it awkward for me to work in anything that might interfere with his social life. Going to off license /takeaway and never asking me if I wanted anything. None were exactly huge things but added up to enough that I felt like a complete afterthought.

If my current 26 year old marriage goes tits up (and the jury is out ) it will be due to him changing from a very loyal , witty , attractive and trustworthy metrosexual slightly right on guy in his 30s who I loved a great deal to someone who developed an infatuation in his early 40s and documented it- found by me many years later, Daily secretive hard core porn habit , not being interested in sex on my part (the porn habit partly responsible) inability to control temper be it other drivers or something not going as expected and an inability to be satisfied with most aspects of life or were we live etc— I do genuinely get how he feels about many things but it’s a bit knackering (I’ve had so many house moves it’s ridiculous) and it’s a bit joyless to live with and I think he will be an awfully hard work pensioner or if I was really ill . That’s at the back of my mind all the time — it really isn’t always affairs-

caecilius1 · 18/04/2022 10:55

IMO it's initial compatibility (and some men lacking moral fibre Wink).

bubblesbubbles11 · 18/04/2022 10:53

"I don't think people generally have affairs if there are no other relationship issues"

Plenty of people have affairs when (and they will confirm this) they are perfectly happy wtih their marriage and would never want their marriage to end (for so long as their spouse does not know about the affair).

Pickingmyselfup · 18/04/2022 10:51

Yep and no amount of trying hard enough will fix something that is truly broken.

You might be able to patch something up and whilst it doesn't look the same it's good enough. Sooner or later the cracks show and it falls apart again. You patch it up again, it looks a bit worse this time but you ignore it until the cracks show and it falls apart for the second time.

At some point you have to admit that it's broken and throw it away. It might be physically hard and mentally hard throwing it away but eventually after time you realise it was no longer bringing joy to your life, just a whole load of stress.

caecilius1 · 18/04/2022 10:47

@FelicityFlops
That's so incredibly hard; I hope you've managed to make your peace it with it x

Pickingmyselfup · 18/04/2022 10:47

My friends ended because she slept with someone else and realised she didn't want to be with the husband despite him willing to try.

Same situation for my SIL I think.

My parents because of abuse and she was seeing someone else who gave her the courage to leave.

Mine ultimately because we've grown apart but there are a lot of deep seated issues in there which have all come to a head.

I think a lot of marriages do end because there was someone else on the scene but I don't believe that the marriage was happy before that. I don't think someone truly happy would be tempted enough to go through with it. I know there are a lot of people who do it for the thrill but I still think there must be issues in there somewhere for it to happen.

Cocomarine · 18/04/2022 10:39

@RosesAndHellebores

Having been married for 31 years I suspect because even when things are 100% right marriage is hard enough and compromises have to be made. Sprinkle in learning how each other deal with life's traumas such as illness and bereavement the curve can be steeper than the closer bonding they ultimately bring.
Well that sounds suspiciously like telling those of us who are divorced, that we just didn’t try hard enough 🙄
MarriedThreeChildren · 18/04/2022 10:39

@5128gap

Straightforward cost benefit analysis on the part of the person who ends it. If the marriage offers enough to compensate for the issues, be they an affair, disinterest, boredom, inconvenience, restrictions, lack of sex, whatever, people tend to stay. When the scales tip in the other direction, they tend to leave, and the tipping point is different for everyone.
That’s a good point.
MarriedThreeChildren · 18/04/2022 10:37

I’m getting divorced.
There is no one else in the scene, either for me or dh.

I think the ‘mainly getting divorced because one of them has an affair’ is symptomatic if the culture you live in.
So refusing to settle or having grown apart or no sex is not seen as a good enough reason to get divorced (you just have to see the number if threads in MN around that idea) whereas an affair is.
I also think that people stay in relationships for too long, unhappy and then the affair starts (so the affair isn’t the issue as such).

The. Of course, you have the ones who are just unfaithful…
Or abusive etc…

CaptSkippy · 18/04/2022 10:36

It's mostly women who initiate divorces and if I remember correctly it's often due to a dispute over money and/or a partner not pulling his weight around the house and with the kids, leaving her to do all the work.

justanotherremainer · 18/04/2022 10:32

A divorce lawyer friend of mine thought that in most cases there was somebody else, either an actual affair or in the wings / background.

In other cases there will be domestic abuse or addiction.

I think in only a few cases do people divorce because they have ‘ just’ grown apart.

Blossomtoes · 18/04/2022 10:25

Mine ended because we got married way too young and ended up a few years later with nothing in common. We’d have been celebrating our golden wedding in June and remain very good friends. Whoever dies last will attend the other’s funeral and shed genuine tears.

NightAndShiningArmour · 18/04/2022 10:24

The ones in my friend group that have ended:

Grown apart
Grown apart
Grown apart (and some financial issues…)
Grown apart (till both couldn’t bear each other)
Alcoholism and gambling (by him)
Post-kids grown apart
Post-kids grown apart

Maybe that’s an unusual cross section? I’m thinking hard as I can, but no one leaving due to an ow/om that I can think of!

FelicityFlops · 18/04/2022 10:21

My own marriage ended when my husband committed suicide. No third party involvement.

HazelBite · 18/04/2022 10:20

My first marriage ended because I realised that my H didn't like or respect me, he didn't want to have sex with me so obviously didn't find me attractive either, to this day I cannot work out why he married me!

My son and his wife's marriage ended due to them losing a baby, then subsequently a child (different reasons) they both dealt with it differently and it tore them apart.

zingally · 18/04/2022 10:19

I'm trying to think back to maybe the last 5 people I know who have divorced...

Couple 1: Got married after only 6 months knowing each other. Divorced after 18 months when it turned out he had a drug and gambling habit he'd kept hidden, somewhat miraculously, gotta say. (There's family gossip that there's a lot more to the story, but I've never been privy to it)
Couple 2: He cheated.
Couple 3: She cheated.
Couple 4: Nothing really definite, she just called him "a waste of space."
Couple 5: He was emotionally and financially abusive.

FelicityFlops · 18/04/2022 10:15

I only know 5 people who have divorced.
3 had spouses who had affairs.
1 had a spouse who was going bankrupt, so divorced my friend and left the country so as not to "bring her down".
The last couple was incompatible.

5128gap · 18/04/2022 10:12

Straightforward cost benefit analysis on the part of the person who ends it.
If the marriage offers enough to compensate for the issues, be they an affair, disinterest, boredom, inconvenience, restrictions, lack of sex, whatever, people tend to stay. When the scales tip in the other direction, they tend to leave, and the tipping point is different for everyone.

ErinAoife · 18/04/2022 10:11

My marriage end because my ex thought I was fat repulsive and he was bored with me after 25 years together and 3 kids. He did not want the responsibilities of having a family in my opinion as he refused 50 50 he is happy of having the kids one evening a week and one weekend every fortnight and leaves all responsibilities to me.

Sparklesocks · 18/04/2022 10:09

They end for lots of reasons. But the main thing is one person at least doesn’t want to be with the other anymore - whether that be trust lost due to infidelity, or resentment due to one partner not pulling their weight in the marriage, or sometimes quite sadly just falling out of love and unable to rebuild those feelings.

TypicallyTopically · 18/04/2022 10:06

@GoAShum

I think death of a thousand cuts is the most common reason, especially for women.

Same thing happens over and over again, likely related to thoughtlessness or taking someone for granted or not listening. It gets raised 999 times and either is met with dismissal or empty promises and nothing changes.

Then on the 1000th time it doesn’t get mentioned, but he marriage isn’t just over.

The hurt spouse doesn’t necessarily walk out right that minute, but that’s when it reaches the point of no return and their focus switches to exit strategy rather than making it work.

This was me 100 percent.
Cocomarine · 18/04/2022 10:05

@Dee314

Yes it was, we was talking about his parents, his dad had an affair but they are still together. We then went on to discover why etc..sorry should have elaborated
So there’s an example where an affair didn’t end a marriage.

Do you and your husband really lack imagination that much?

Even where an affair is the final straw, it’s often not the real reason.

Last 5 marriages in my social circle (Waitrose shopping teachers and doctors and IT managers sort of group) to breakdown:

  • prostitute use (the man, with women)
  • prostitute use (the man, with men)
  • rape and physical violence (the man)
  • physical violence (the man)
  • financial and verbal abuse (the man)
  • alcoholism (the woman)

I suppose if I were given to sweeping unsubstantiated statements like your husband, I’d say marriages break down because a lot of men are arseholes 🤷🏻‍♀️