Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think husband is a twat for this comment?

245 replies

indiesearcher · 17/04/2022 22:58

DH and I are away for the Easter break with kids. Put them to bed, we're playing a few games of cards to pass the evening. All is fine.

I have beaten him at cards for the tenth time in a row and JOKINGLY (very jovially) said "you can't beat me at rummy, you can't beat me at Uno, you can't beat me at anything!"

To which he replied:

"I can beat you at salary. I double your salary"

I didn't know what to say really. So I sort of let it wash over me, jokingly retorted that he can almost double my age, and then wistfully said, "yes I do wonder where I might be now salary wise if I hadn't taken years out to raise our children, and then move half way around the world having quit my job so we could exploit your earning potential".

Then he basically started sulking and turned the whole thing on me. Various claims of "so you'd rather I hadn't dragged you abroad, so you'd rather we hadn't had the children etc etc". Which is all bullshit obviously - I've been very happy with our life, but it was a shitty comment he made and but else was I supposed to have said? I said I cannot have this conversation with you and he then walked out the room.

AIBU to have asked him to acknowledge it was a shitty comment and not budge until he apologises? He has gone off to sleep in another room.

OP posts:
OLP2019 · 18/04/2022 07:37

Actually @indiesearcher I kind of get where you're coming from
Sounds like our life situation is somewhat similar and a couple of times over many years my DH has said something similar - and it leaves me wondering was that just a retort or is that how you REALLY feel / see us / see the relationship

Dentistlakes · 18/04/2022 07:35

You started it. He responded with another shitty comment. You sound as bad as each other.

Sarkymarky · 18/04/2022 07:35

So you are pleased with the comments that agree with you and have a problem with those that disagree. You come across as you must always be right. You are joking but he is a twat??? You went looking for trouble when he mentioned the salary, maybe he was joking honestly OP you sound like hard work

RedHelenB · 18/04/2022 07:34

@indiesearcher

DH and I are away for the Easter break with kids. Put them to bed, we're playing a few games of cards to pass the evening. All is fine.

I have beaten him at cards for the tenth time in a row and JOKINGLY (very jovially) said "you can't beat me at rummy, you can't beat me at Uno, you can't beat me at anything!"

To which he replied:

"I can beat you at salary. I double your salary"

I didn't know what to say really. So I sort of let it wash over me, jokingly retorted that he can almost double my age, and then wistfully said, "yes I do wonder where I might be now salary wise if I hadn't taken years out to raise our children, and then move half way around the world having quit my job so we could exploit your earning potential".

Then he basically started sulking and turned the whole thing on me. Various claims of "so you'd rather I hadn't dragged you abroad, so you'd rather we hadn't had the children etc etc". Which is all bullshit obviously - I've been very happy with our life, but it was a shitty comment he made and but else was I supposed to have said? I said I cannot have this conversation with you and he then walked out the room.

AIBU to have asked him to acknowledge it was a shitty comment and not budge until he apologises? He has gone off to sleep in another room.

I think you are. And would you really have earned more than him if you hadn't had kids, it seems to be a popular MN argument, but not reality. I don't see how it's worth the row, you seem as petty as he does.
Countdownis35 · 18/04/2022 07:30

@MoiraQueen

Also really shocked at some of the replies here. A bit of teasing rivalry over a card game does not equal that kind of response. It's not OK that he seems to have been harbouring this grudge about salary difference and implying you are not pulling your weight, when you obviously do. I'd be cross too in your place. Please don't grovel this morning, you've made a valid point to him, which hopefully he will have taken on board. I'd give up with the card game if he's one of those sulky losers.
OP. Started it and this has been addressed by herself. It's not a big issue like some are making it.

Perhaps her DH is a witty character and it just rolled off his tongue in his defence. It was a bit low yes... but OP egged him on in the first place. Like others have said... what would you say if someone said to you they can beat you at everything? To me it's gone wrong from that point their. I would expect a harsh comment back! That's what OP got.

No need to drag the fall out for days... I think they BOTH won't say things like that again in a hurry.

ToyahBattersby · 18/04/2022 07:26

You kind of started it by your comment so not sure what you expected…

PaddlingLikeADuck · 18/04/2022 07:23

I think it all got a bit silly.

My husband brings home double than me and it’s always a long running joke in our house. I reduced my hours after having the children so we always laugh about him being the breadwinner and how I’m a lady of leisure. It’s all in total good humour.

We play board games a lot and he wins about 90% of the time and it’s a non-issue. He winds me up about it as he knows I hate losing but we just laugh about it.

If this is the kind of topic that leads to sulking and arguments then I think you need to address any underlying issues but in a calm manner, not by being hurtful towards each other.

Furrydogmum · 18/04/2022 07:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BurglerBill · 18/04/2022 07:09

@Philisophigal

I think his was quite a sharply witted comeback. You were wrong, he can beat you at something! You should have just laughed, said yep and moved on. Don't dish it out if you can't take it.
What's 'sharply witted' about bragging about your salary? That's just crass, and a surefire way to make your wife feel undervalued, unappreciated and 'put her in her place '. Some of the comments on this thread are shocking. He took a joke about something that doesn't matter (a card game) into something that actually does - maybe you have to have actually given up your career and been a SAHM to understand the implications of a comment like this and how insensitive it is?
MoiraQueen · 18/04/2022 07:09

Also really shocked at some of the replies here. A bit of teasing rivalry over a card game does not equal that kind of response. It's not OK that he seems to have been harbouring this grudge about salary difference and implying you are not pulling your weight, when you obviously do. I'd be cross too in your place. Please don't grovel this morning, you've made a valid point to him, which hopefully he will have taken on board. I'd give up with the card game if he's one of those sulky losers.

VeganGod · 18/04/2022 07:08

You were joking about a game that really doesn’t matter. He brought a real life thing into it that does matter. They’re not the same. I like people that can take a joke without getting shitty.

We take the piss of each other a lot about the stuff that doesn’t matter, like if the other takes more attempts to get Wordle that day. All light hearted. We don’t bring the heavier real life stuff into it as we don’t actually feel the need to be better than each other, we both know it’s a joke. Your husband sounds like he can’t take a joke, my dad and brother are like that, very good at giving it out but the slightest joke at their expense and they say something really cutting and personal. Really unpleasant. I wouldn’t be apologising.

Nosetickle · 18/04/2022 07:07

I’m so with you OP that was a really insensitive thing for him to say when the reason his salary is higher than yours is because of the sacrifice of your own career you’ve made in order for him to progress his. I would have been equally upset and even more so at his reaction and the fact that he doesn’t appreciate your contribution to his career progression.

GoFishandChips · 18/04/2022 07:04

You're a bad winner OP and were rather childish and he sank to the same level, guessing your both rather competitive.

DrSbaitso · 18/04/2022 07:04

What did you want him to say?

Penguinevere · 18/04/2022 07:04

Neither of you should dish it out because neither of you can take it!

But I actually kind of agree with you op he made it personal.

Kezzie200 · 18/04/2022 06:59

Some people hate losing! A personality trait.

My husband often messes about too far but his family are like that. He's not as childish as he was and, thankfully, our children aren't like it at all.

When we were younger I ended up being soaked with water, absolutely soaked, following a joke with a hosepipe.

Kezzie200 · 18/04/2022 06:53

He probably didn't like your "losing" comment, which was no doubt in jesr but didn't land like that with him, so he retaliated.

You are being oversensitive.

Patchbatch · 18/04/2022 06:49

Joking about a game and about salary aren't equal, he said it as he knew it would sting and its evidently something he ponders now and then. Either way if he's normally alright and treats you with respect regarding money I'd let it go. If it ties in with a pattern of behaviour would be less inclined to, yes it was a low blow.

RowanAlong · 18/04/2022 06:47

Nah, you were both sparring, and you’ve got a point. You weren’t wrong to have pointed it out. He’ll hopefully see that once he’s sober again.

mustlovegin · 18/04/2022 06:47

And to say you can’t beat me at anything is asking for trouble

This

Butchyrestingface · 18/04/2022 06:42

You made a light-hearted 'joke' (if you say so).
He responded with a below the belt comment.
You then hit back with both barrels with comments about him being twice your age, having to sacrifice your career to look after his kids and leaving your job to move half-way around the world for him.

A game of cards at your house sure sounds like fun. He's a sulker and you just have to win, win, win no matter what.

Philisophigal · 18/04/2022 06:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

AchillesPoirot · 18/04/2022 06:35

@starlingdarling

How it would have gone with my DH

Me: you can't beat me at anything
DH: I beat you at salary. I earn 3 times what you do.
Me: Touché

And then we would have continued our game. If anything it sounds like it hit more of a nerve for you.

I agree with this. I think it stung you more than him.
Faevern · 18/04/2022 06:33

Your providing your own drip feed here OP you clearly like to have the last word and the upper hand (no card pun intended) It was banter until you didn’t like his reply so instead of saying that’s a bit below the belt you then took it to another level of competitiveness.

If you really want to overthink it is there anything else he can beat you at, what would have been an acceptable reply to you can’t beat me at anything? What would your reply have been if he had said the comment to you?

You started it and then escalated it, you were driving this and only you know the real reason why.

AllOverIt · 18/04/2022 06:32

You are both unreasonable. Your initial little playground chant sounds goading and his reaction was over the top and hurtful and is probably quite telling.