Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not bothering with summer holidays- ungrateful kids?

263 replies

Tethersend01 · 17/04/2022 21:15

We have two Kids ages 12 and 15.
To set the scene Myself and DH had horrible childhoods (poverty, abuse etc) and have worked hard in every way to ensure our kids lives are a world away from our own experiences
We have always made an effort with Summer holidays, mainly holidays in the UK ( hotels since they have been older and things like Centreparcs) also driven abroad, France, Eurodisney etc.
I have a huge fear of flying (flew a lot when I was younger) due to two horrific experiences and I have no interest in ‘getting over’ this.
It’s literally the only thing I’m not prepared to do holiday wise.
Now, I will say at this point, holidays are not something I particularly enjoy, they are not relaxing for me and even the fully catered ones are rather stressful overall.
Anyhow, both boys now want to go abroad but only on a plane.
One wants to go to the USA the other wants to go to skiing (we don’t ski).
I suggested a cruise on one of theuxuryvfamily cruise liners one where you stop off at lots of places but they are both refusing to even consider that. They are refusing a UK holiday or to drive to the continent.
I’m at a loss and seriously fed up.
I’m being made the scapegoat as they are blaming my lack of flying and as time goes on its less and less likely we will be anle to book anything at all.
AIBU not to bother this year?

OP posts:
Ionacat · 18/04/2022 08:39

Holidays growing up were strictly UK only. My parents hated flying and as children we never questioned it. Going abroad was simply not on the table. We rarely fly on holiday - only twice in the past 10 years.
I also find holidays stressful, I’m well known for getting a migraine on our return.
I’d give them a deadline for their ideas and if there’s not a consensus then you won’t be going or it will be a last minute holiday probably in the UK. There’s so many options via car, ferry or even train if you wanted an adventure and felt like going a bit further afield - the man in seat 61 website will help there - you could easily get to the Alps which are beautiful in the summer and perhaps the one that wants to ski does a lesson for a day as part of it. (You can ski on some of the glaciers in the summer.)

ItsYabbaDabbaDoTime · 18/04/2022 08:35

This is kindly meant OP ..

They are healthy, self-centred teenagers. They don’t appreciate what you’ve done for them because it’s their norm. Gratitude will emerge when they’re older.

You aren’t prepared to do address your fear of flying. That’s your prerogative. Actually ‘no fly’ is an ethical choice.

So you can :

  • Inter rail through Europe (not affected by Brexit)

-Take ferries to Spain, France, Ireland, the Channel Isles or the Scottish Islands.

  • Take Eurostar and drive to the Alps for skiing
  • Cruise to New York (and hire a car for a road trip to Florida)

Or just wave them off at the airport with their father!

fishonabicycle · 18/04/2022 08:32

I'm really surprised that they are allowed to dictate to you. They are 12 and 15 - they are children and go where you take them.

Hollytreenew · 18/04/2022 08:24

Realised I spelt brakes wrong, whoops! Can tell I wrote it in a hurry this morning!

CounsellorTroi · 18/04/2022 08:22

The usual ill informed misconceptions about cruises on here. The big resort ships are great for teens. Not my cup of tea personally, I prefer smaller quieter ships.

rookiemere · 18/04/2022 08:17

Teenagers by their very nature are ungrateful.

We've just had a scenario where DS16 has dropped out of the school ski trip to Banff because his pal had done so ( even though another pal was due to be going). I mean this is a full expenses paid skiing trip to Canada for goodness sake, which he'll probably never experience again.

You're taking the lack of flying thing too seriously. Teens will just teen and use whatever they can to blame it on.

We're just bringing a pal for DS on holidays and counting the days until we can head off without him ( starting with UK camping breaks soon).

Hollytreenew · 18/04/2022 08:14

I just wanted to put out there that the summer is the wrong time of year for the ski season generally so that does really put the breaks on what one of your children want for the summer. It is possible to perhaps find some snow somewhere but it is going to be costly and isn’t reliable or you going to need to fly further out of Europe.

PlasticineMeg · 18/04/2022 08:04

This thread just proves my point earlier. That no matter what people do for their kids, sometimes they’ll always whinge and criticise no matter what they get.

CounsellorTroi · 18/04/2022 07:47

@Tigofigo

They have TRUSTS, free uni, free homes... OP really has given them everything bar a flight on a plane. And she's said they can do that without her.

Good God she's given them almost everything!

I find it really sad (and telling) that you consider "everything" to be purely financial.

Maybe they'd prefer quality time with their mum to a trust fund.

They can have that without flying.
whiteroseredrose · 18/04/2022 07:06

I'd be clear. They have years ahead to go on holiday, by plane, to wherever they want.

For now, flying holiday with mum is not an option.

Flying with dad or non flying with the whole family, those are the options.

Pick, or no holiday.

malificent7 · 18/04/2022 07:00

They are kids...they don't get to dictate holidays . You are setting a good environmental example! My dd wants to go to NYC, the Maldives etc. Great but I can't afford it...tough!

snazzyshoes · 18/04/2022 06:33

Do you think you didn't get over your poor flying experience because you didn't fly until you were older rather than seeing flying as something you can leave until later? I grew up with a dad in travel so we went everywhere since I was pretty much born.
As a result, despite being on some pretty hair raising flights, having been on so many planes since very little I'm able to see that although those flights were horrendous I can't outweigh the 'brainwashing' I received from a young age about flying being safe.

I think it's fine that your dc don't like the type of holiday you've always been on, are they against holidaying in the U.K. somewhere? Can you send them together on a teen activity camp for a week and see if they'd prefer that?
My parents used to go to Spain every summer and I absolutely hated it. I have been to Spain once in adulthood as a result and that was a business trip! Maybe your dc genuinely are tired of the driving holiday. I think you sacrificing things isn't really relevant when it comes to teens. Do they have to be grateful for a driving holiday just because you like them?

If they won't go with dad alone flying, just say that they can either go on whatever holiday you're offering them or you won't be going but say it kindly as a genuine choice not it's this or else. Times are moving on, even though many people can't afford a driving eu holiday many people can and that may be what your dc are looking at, that many of their friends have been further afield and they're expressing their desire to see these places. And that's ok and you saying one day they will see these places is also ok.
Teens are selfish because they're expressing their desire for independence but usually do it in the most clumsy rude manner humanly possible.

MiddleParking · 18/04/2022 05:25

They have TRUSTS, free uni, free homes... OP really has given them everything bar a flight on a plane. And she's said they can do that without her.

All of that stuff is, at best, a completely abstract concept to younger teens, especially the 12 year old. And if I was a teenage boy whose mum was prone to martyrdom, which OP sounds to be, I would be seriously wary of appearing too enthusiastic about her offer to exclude herself from the main family holiday for my sake.

I find it really unpleasant when posters describe their children as ‘ungrateful’ for the material things they provide. It’s like they’re failing to uphold their end of a contract that they never signed. It’s a tall order to give your children all the trappings of a wealthy middle class lifestyle but then expect them to be cheerfully ‘grateful’ about never being able to fly for a family holiday. I also note that you seem to believe you’ve provided large trust funds for your children through ‘graft’ on your part - that’s simply not the case, otherwise the children of all grafters would have trust funds. You’re discounting what must have been pretty significant good fortune on your part somewhere along the way, so perhaps the ingratitude you see in your kids is in fact a learned behaviour.

Tigofigo · 18/04/2022 04:39

It is not necessary to give children everything they ask for or want and quite often they don't want what we give them and we sometimes have to live with their disappointment. They are entitled to be disappointed.

100% this. They should be allowed to voice their opinions, their preferences and their feelings. That doesn't mean you have to do what they want.

I am curious why you don't like holidays - maybe it would be helpful for you to unpick that a bit regardless?

blubberball · 18/04/2022 04:34

You've made your offers to compromise, and you have a boundary that you won't go on a plane, which is fair enough. They need to respect your boundary, and pick one of the options you've given. They'll be able to travel with their mates in a few years, and maybe there'll be some school trips coming up soon.

It sounds like you have a lovely life at home with your animals.

Tigofigo · 18/04/2022 04:20

They have TRUSTS, free uni, free homes... OP really has given them everything bar a flight on a plane. And she's said they can do that without her.

Good God she's given them almost everything!

I find it really sad (and telling) that you consider "everything" to be purely financial.

Maybe they'd prefer quality time with their mum to a trust fund.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 18/04/2022 04:16

@Branleuse

I think your kids need to be a bit more grateful that they already get a holiday every year. Tell them that when theyre big enough and ugly enough to get good jobs and pay for their own holidays then it will be lovely for them to go on all the fancy longhaul holidays they want, but youve been very clear with what you will and wont consider, so their choices now are like it or lump it. Go with their dad if theyre desperate to fly but you will not be bullied into it by them or anyone
Pretty much this.

YANBU OP.

Ilady · 18/04/2022 04:05

I think a lot of teenagers go through a phase of wanting things especially to be the same as friends.
Most families in a good financial position like yours have gone on family flying holidays abroad. They have photos, video clips, stories and family memories from these times.

You told us you have a fear of flying. I am going to be harsh here but it time for you to get help with overcoming this.

Because of this your limiting the places you can go on a family holiday. Due to your children's ages you won't have many more family holidays.

How would you feel in a few years time if your child got a great chance to study abroad. You won't go and see the college, town/area. You miss their graduation.
What happens if they move abroad and tell you a few years later they are getting married their.
You miss their wedding and if they have a family you won't go to see your grandchildren.

I know a lady like you a long time ago but then her son moved to Europe and got a job their. He made friends and met his wife their. He got married their and had child also.
The lady I know got help and ended up enjoying going to visit her son, going to his wedding and seeing her grandkids before her health declined.

Your giving out about your teenaged kids and teenagers can be hard going at time. But they don't want to go on the same holiday as you which I can understand. They said they like to go to the USA or skiing.
I have been to the USA and it a good place to visit. Why not get help re the flying and then you have far more options on where to visit or see both now in the future.

1forAll74 · 18/04/2022 03:49

I would tell them that they can't have a holiday, dictated by them at this age, when you have done your best with holidays in the past.. There will be plenty of time when they are a bit older, to going on planes to different places. There are lots of lovely places to visit in the UK, especially up North, where children can do do stuff, like climb mountains and go kayaking and horse riding along tracks etc, if they are active outdoor types, Moaning children on holidays are a pain, they should appreciate any holidays.

StrongerOrWeaker · 18/04/2022 03:34

I don't think they sound ungrateful. T hey are just saying they would like to do something different. I personally hate holidays in the UK/ driving to France so can see where they are coming from. I would give them a few alternatives that you are happy with. Absolutely do not compromise on flying.
Eg
Skiing holiday in France (use the Eurostar)
Holiday in Europe where they fly and you drive
Stay at home. The money saved could be used for them traveling when older, or for doing fun things in UK
They go on their own via some sort of holiday camp.

daffodilsareinbloom · 18/04/2022 03:21

@Tethersend01 I read something on burnout & boundaries today and your post reminds me of it. I think sometimes when we've poured and poured into our kids in some ways overdoing it (that's not a criticism at all btw, just an acknowledgement of how much you've done) and then our needs are not considered it really can lead to resentment and anger.

Try to remember 12 is still quite young, the idea of a holiday without Mum may feel too abnormal. If it were me I'd chat to my partner to agree on where to go and then sit down with dc and say you've decided that for summer 2022 the plan is a main holiday with Dad wherever your partner has agreed to go, and a mini break in the UK as a family. No more explanations, just this is what meets everyone's needs. I'd say how nice it was that they wanted you to come on holiday, so this serves both purposes. I wouldn't make it into a debate, keep it a learning opportunity that sometimes people's needs will be conflicting and everyone has to compromise. I'd also reassure them this may not be every summer, but just how things need to be this year.

dipdye · 18/04/2022 02:07

Dh takes them to the States or skiing.

You've done your part.

apricotlane · 18/04/2022 01:53

Not sure I would let my children ever dictate where we went on holiday. This is your first problem. They can beg/ask whatever the eff they like, what matters is you are the boss and you have your reasons. You don't have to justify your decisions to them. If it's that big a deal, let them go with your partner for a few days somewhere.

HollowTalk · 18/04/2022 00:37

@Tethersend01

Bigfatliar thank you. For context, we prioritise our children hugely and have set up trusts so they can buy their own homes, pay for uni and travel the world when they are older, we came from nothing financially so its all been sheer hard graft. They know this but choose to make me feel truly dreadful that I can’t face flying. Its depressing and makes me a bit angry too. I didn’t fly til i was 19 but still managed to see the world.
Be very careful though. It sounds as though they are quite spoiled and if you are providing them with everything in the future then they really don't have any reason to work hard.
Calandor · 18/04/2022 00:35

@Jewel52

Honestly, you’re coming across as a martyr and your posts are designed to illicit sympathy and portray your children as selfish brats with no sympathy for your awful life. Isn’t it equally selfish to make clear to your kids that a holiday is a chore. Why can’t you get help for your fear of flying? I didn’t have a great childhood but I don’t think that’s my kids burden to carry. But I don’t think that’s what you want to hear - you want affirmation that the family holiday should be dictated by your wishes and anything else is callousness
I disagree. They have TRUSTS, free uni, free homes... OP really has given them everything bar a flight on a plane. And she's said they can do that without her.

Good God she's given them almost everything!