Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This government and their direction of travel, frightens me.

455 replies

Kendodd · 17/04/2022 19:32

Teressa May (last government, but same party) with her 'go home immigrants' vans and hostle environment.
Immigration and Borders act.
Transportation to Rwanda.
Bringing laws in trying to limit our right to protest.
Lying to the queen to prorogue parliament.
Lying in the house of commons.
Trying to change the law to get one of your MPs off.
Pretty much ripping up the ministerial code.
Windrush.
Admitting that they're just going to break international law.

I bet they will come after the human rights act and try to get us out of ECHR.

Worse, I think a great many of the public love the fact they've done all the above and would cheer loudly at the ripping up of the human rights act and ECHR membership (wtaf?)

How did we get to this?

OP posts:
feedyourheed · 17/04/2022 22:45

[quote Bunnyfuller]@feedyourheed why is showing compassion to their humans virtue signalling? Wtf is wrong with you?[/quote]
WTF is wrong with you? Can't you read?

Bunnyfuller · 17/04/2022 22:44

@feedyourheed why is showing compassion to their humans virtue signalling? Wtf is wrong with you?

feedyourheed · 17/04/2022 22:43

@Kendodd

The poster doesn't have to leave. I didn't tell them too (unlike someone who told me to fuck off to North Korea earlier int he thread) I just said if their perception of this lovely country is as they described then they know where the door is. They can choose to live in all those wonderful countries that are so much better, with such nice people if we disgust her so much

I think this post shows real ignorance of immigration. If you only have a UK passport, the only foreign country you have a legal right to just move to, is Ireland, everywhere else has strict entry requirements for relocation. The days of just being able to move to Europe for UK passport holders are over.

I guess that means I will have to cancel my plans to 'fuck off to North Korea' as a lovely earlier poster ordered me to do then! Perhaps you could point out their ignorance of immigration laws too?

Or is the condescending strawman just for those who don't agree with your virtue signalling pearl clutching?

jgw1 · 17/04/2022 22:42

@Florenz

There is no shortage of workers, there's a shortage of employers willing to pay decent wages.
But then the bosses would not be able to keep getting richer at everyone else's expense.
Bunnyfuller · 17/04/2022 22:38

The government have done a fabulous job of pointing the finger at immigration as the cause of the tabloid reading public. Whilst they break laws, help mates and basically piss on anyone who isn’t wealthy.

What is terribly sad is that they’ve essentially normalised ingrained racism - not just white on black or brown, but white on anything ‘different’. There are many, many solutions to the problems we all face now, but they are not considered by a government with no appetite to force those with 10 houses to perhaps share their wealth, or tax energy companies, like other countries have, or discourage second home ownership to stop the runaway problems with housing, or making university and going into medicine more attractive, or force home builders to build all green, or tax fast food massively and reduce fruit and veg prices to help stem the obesity tide.

Because somehow, the English person of honour, virtue and courage has vanished, and replaced with people full of hate who lack compassion

#Notinmyname

OuttaBabylon · 17/04/2022 22:37

@KyieveMii

Both my husband and I fit the ‘over 40k’ immigrants label. As do many friends. There’s a fair number of us.
Yes. More than a fair number of us. And some of us were born into families with British passports and had to reapply for citizenship. But this government keeps on drumming the drum . . .
Florenz · 17/04/2022 22:37

There is no shortage of workers, there's a shortage of employers willing to pay decent wages.

Kendodd · 17/04/2022 22:37

The poster doesn't have to leave. I didn't tell them too (unlike someone who told me to fuck off to North Korea earlier int he thread) I just said if their perception of this lovely country is as they described then they know where the door is. They can choose to live in all those wonderful countries that are so much better, with such nice people if we disgust her so much

I think this post shows real ignorance of immigration. If you only have a UK passport, the only foreign country you have a legal right to just move to, is Ireland, everywhere else has strict entry requirements for relocation. The days of just being able to move to Europe for UK passport holders are over.

OP posts:
Timeforausernamechange22 · 17/04/2022 22:35

@Fishwishy

You need to be earning well over £40k to be a net contributer to the tax system. Let's not kid ourselves that these low paid immigrants are the lifeblood of the economy helping to fund our public services.
Well it’s ok I’m happy for my extra tax to pay for someone less fortunate. Hospitals need porters, we need carers, we need fruit pickers and I for one don’t fancy plucking my own Turkey this Christmas. Low paid but essential workers.

Nearly every time I visit the hospital I have an immigrant treating me. But the legal type so that’s ok right? Just the refugees fleeing persecution are the wrong ones who don’t deserve to be here correct?

I’m the child of an immigrant although most people don’t look at the Irish as immigrants for some reason. I bet most people are the descendants of immigrants somehow. As I said, we just got lucky being born here. Stop looking down on asylum seekers like they are unskilled and unimportant. They are not, they are human just like you and me

cakeorwine · 17/04/2022 22:30

I agree, it is funny watching the pro corbyn croud suddenly agreeing with it when it confirms their bias. It still doesnty negate the paid to particpate arghument against a genuine poll though

I didn't say that I agreed with the poll - it's interesting that there are 2 very different polls

I don't think people have enough information about the world refugee situation.

If they had more information - then I guess there might be several camps - those who think "Not my problem, we have enough problems" and those who think we should step up and do our bit.

As I said, Ethiopia has 823,000 refugees. Held in what you would see as camps - with tents and everything.

It's out of our sight - so out of mind.

jgw1 · 17/04/2022 22:27

I have had an idea.

These migrants might have useful skills.

There are a number of people in this country who live at tax payers expense, scroungers one might call them who contribute nothing, but seem to spend their days partying and breaking the law of the land.

Could we ship them to Rwanda instead?

sweetbellyhigh · 17/04/2022 22:27

@Neverendingdust

We’re a small shitty island governed by those with delusions of grandeur, voted for by an easily manipulated, averagely educated electorate. What else did you expect? Utopia?

We overindulged on our misconception of being world leaders with magnificent ideologies that we were a Great Britain. But now he charade is up, the ruse is over, our run has ran and now laid bare for all to see is the reality, Little Britain.

Shit in shit out, it’s the rule of the cosmos. We think we’re better than this and yet we continually prove time and time again, we are simply not.

Exactly this. Nothing Great about Britain, just a mess clinging to notions of grandeur.

cakeorwine · 17/04/2022 22:25

As for the rest of your counter point it's nothing more than 'feel goud' points, and offers nothing to counter the global situation, the emotive languange needs something to back it up, you have shown you can''t actially back it up witjh a serious counter point other than some nebulas feel good factor

A 'nebulous feel good factor'?

Maybe - doing the right thing is important.

Are we an isolationist nation or are we part of the world community stepping up where it counts?

I think we should step up - some people don't think we should step up and are isolationist in their view.

Kendodd · 17/04/2022 22:24

I have said for the last four years that the Tory party will eventually ride to victory, yet again, with reintroducing the death penalty to the U.K.

Yes, I think the death penalty would be very popular. I know Priti Patel has wanted to bring it back, as has the Tory press.

OP posts:
Justanotherlurker · 17/04/2022 22:19

It's funny how You Gov is used when it supports Government policy.

I agree, it is funny watching the pro corbyn croud suddenly agreeing with it when it confirms their bias. It still doesnty negate the paid to particpate arghument against a genuine poll though.

As for the rest of your counter point it's nothing more than 'feel goud' points, and offers nothing to counter the global situation, the emotive languange needs something to back it up, you have shown you can''t actially back it up witjh a serious counter point other than some nebulas feel good factor.

The calling anyone else racists is a lost narrative, it;s time to accept the situation and offer a counter point that is based in reality, it's not uniquly a UK situation as it's happening across the EU and counter tge push back and apparently be left leaning when it is the right wing who want to import chrap labour.

The ugly conversations now are open, it is for a lot on the left to try and justify of it

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 17/04/2022 22:18

Haven’t read the whole thread but the normal people who can’t wait to get rid of ‘human rights’ laws clearly forget they’re human. The words ‘useful idiots’ spring to mind. We are living on a knife edge in this country.

OuttaBabylon · 17/04/2022 22:14

And what did modern-day Britain do to deserve the largesse that our depleted and colonised people and land gave? Nothing. Deal with your history.

cakeorwine · 17/04/2022 22:13

@Fishwishy

You need to be earning well over £40k to be a net contributer to the tax system. Let's not kid ourselves that these low paid immigrants are the lifeblood of the economy helping to fund our public services.
We need people to work in industries and in public services

All people working in an economy help the economy to grow, help industries to expand, provide jobs and those industries pay taxes.

High paid workers can't do their jobs or get by in society without the rest of society working as well.

KyieveMii · 17/04/2022 22:12

Both my husband and I fit the ‘over 40k’ immigrants label. As do many friends. There’s a fair number of us.

OuttaBabylon · 17/04/2022 22:12

I dunno @jgw1. President Kagame has been all over the region this week, on a charm offensive. He's having a much better time than Will + Kate. Wine

Blossomtoes · 17/04/2022 22:09

@Fishwishy

You need to be earning well over £40k to be a net contributer to the tax system. Let's not kid ourselves that these low paid immigrants are the lifeblood of the economy helping to fund our public services.
Surely that depends on all sorts of factors. I very much doubt that a family with a couple of kids in school are anything close to being net contributors. HMRC figures indicate that we benefit financially from immigration.

In the past few years, the government has published data derived from Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC, the government body responsible for collecting taxes and paying certain benefits) and the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) of amounts paid and received by foreign nationals. For example, HMRC data show that in FY2018/19 (the most recent year for which there are data), EEA and Swiss citizens paid £22.4bn more in income tax and National Insurance contributions than they took out in tax credits and child benefit (HMRC, 2022). Non-EEA (and non-Swiss) citizens paid £20bn more in income tax and National Insurance than they received in tax credits and child benefit.

migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/the-fiscal-impact-of-immigration-in-the-uk/

jgw1 · 17/04/2022 22:08

@Fishwishy

You need to be earning well over £40k to be a net contributer to the tax system. Let's not kid ourselves that these low paid immigrants are the lifeblood of the economy helping to fund our public services.
Some of them are now going to get themselves flown to Rwanda at our expense, costing us £30,000 or more each. What have they done to deserve this largesse?
OuttaBabylon · 17/04/2022 22:07

@Fishwishy - So those of us who have been earning well over 40K, by choice in the UK, for the last decade. We don't count. You're right. I'd rather be kidding myself in the Caribbean. Good luck to you.

Fishwishy · 17/04/2022 22:02

You need to be earning well over £40k to be a net contributer to the tax system. Let's not kid ourselves that these low paid immigrants are the lifeblood of the economy helping to fund our public services.

PurpleThursdays · 17/04/2022 21:58

The poster doesn't have to leave. I didn't tell them to (unlike someone who told me to fuck off to North Korea earlier int he thread) I just said if their perception of this lovely country is as they described then they know where the door is. They can choose to live in all those wonderful countries that are so much better, with such nice people if we disgust her so much.

Orrrrrr....... deep breath we could vote in a party that actually gives a shit about people. This country is fucked, but hey, food banks so yay!!